Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband's brother not invited his step-child

409 replies

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:23

I got married 4 years ago and my husband became my child's stepfather. My child is 13, and doesn't see their father. My husband has nieces and nephews either side of this age.

My child is sadly my husband's only chance of parenting.

His brother is getting married in a late afternoon early evening wedding in a world famous hotel. They are having 60 people there. Apparently this has been planned for the last two years but we only found out about this a month ago just days before the invitations went out. He told my husband after a night out (he had told their sister that afternoon).

The invitation stated just our names with no mention of my child.

I got it, it's a world class venue and a reasonably small wedding. I totally get child free weddings especially given the time of it. I found out yesterday that husband's sister's kids are invited. Mine clearly hasn't because they are a step-child. I feel quite heartbroken.

My husband asked yesterday if my child could be extended an invitation but was refused. A kicker came a minute later when brother was asked if there was a drop out could they come and brother said if there were drop outs relatively new work colleagues would be invited.

No idea if this is relevant but I want to put my cards on the table so any advice I get will be informed by the facts. My first wedding was massive and as my dad later told my cousin it cost a grand for every month it lasted. My wedding to my husband was in a registry office with just our parents so the sibling who has invited us wasn't invited to ours.

OP posts:
JackSheepskin · 20/04/2023 17:48

So you didn’t invite his own brother, who he’s clearly
known his entire life and grew up with, to your wedding. But you want him to invite your child, who he isn’t related to, has only had in in his life for a few years, and realistically clearly doesn’t see as his nephew, to his?

ittakes2 · 20/04/2023 17:45

I am sorry but I think we need to know the ages of the children involved. We know your son's age but not the cousins ages - are the cousins in the wedding party? This could also make a difference.

Clarabell77 · 20/04/2023 17:42

treespouse · 20/04/2023 12:47

In fact the more I think about it the cheekier it is that your husband is so annoyed about it when he didn't even invite his own brother to his wedding?! A small registry office wedding would still be appropriate for siblings if you had a good relationship and if you don't have a good relationship then why get upset he's not inviting the step child??!

These are not comparable situations. No siblings were invited to the registry office wedding whereas nieces and nephews are invited to this one. Just not OPs child because they’re a step niece/nephew.

It’s nasty and I wouldn’t be going OP.

TheCrystalPalace · 20/04/2023 17:41

I'm not sure I completely follow the "their wedding, their rules" line when it can end up with Bride/Groom/Zilla behaviour with no care. So, when if comes to inviting work colleagues over and above family members (leaving aside the argument as to whether a step-nephew counts as family), I would just ask this question to those of us who've been married many years: how many of the people you invited to your wedding (more normal-sized celebrations - not elopements or "just two witnesses off the street" affairs) are you still in regular contact with?
We recently looked through our wedding album (from 28 years ago) and there were a couple of people there (plus ones, probably) who we had NO IDEA about. It took us two days to work out one guy. Never saw him again afterwards as I guess they split up. Now we had quite a large wedding (120+) and all the extended family came but I would have been upset to think that virtual strangers (subsequently, in the grand scheme of things) took precedence over family.
Sometimes you have to look at the bigger, longer-term picture.

DangerNoodles · 20/04/2023 17:37

I don't think you can expect extended family to treat a step child the same as biological nieces and nephews, especially given the distance and how late your DS came in to your DH's life. Your DH threatening to get your parents involved when it is his brother's wedding just makes him sound silly, especially given that you didn't invite any family other than parents to your wedding.

Ladderback · 20/04/2023 17:35

I'm dying to know what the world class venue is. Hopefully it's somewhere not nearly as nice as the wedding couple think it is.

DarkDarkNight · 20/04/2023 17:31

That’s unacceptable. A child free wedding is fine. But inviting nieces/nephews but not a step-nephew isn’t nice and I wouldn’t want to celebrate the wedding of someone so mean minded.

Ladderback · 20/04/2023 17:29

It's not a mistake, the wedding couple have dug their heels in and refused to allow the stepchild to attend even if there are cancellations.

But I'm sure the brother wouldn't care if the OP doesn't attend either. Another work friend he can invite instead. Some people just don't see in-laws as family.

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2023 17:29

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2023 17:17

@redroseflyer on another thread a stepmum is complaining that her DH is asking her to do childcare for an afternoon. Many other stepmums will be saying she is right to complain, she didn’t marry her DH to do that, not her children, not her responsibility, she doesn’t have to do anything with them, not same as bio children. But if this stepmum’s brother was getting married it would appear from this thread that the brother should invite the stepchildren as they should be treated as family

To be fair I don't think it's the same people saying that.

I'm one of the often mentioned step parents of the step parenting board and personally I don't think step parents should have to do the drudgery or that their family should have to treat them the same as bio kids, entirely depending on circumstances.

A SC that has their own other family and visits EOW is very different from one you've taken on as your own from a young age.

RabbitSocks · 20/04/2023 17:20

This is a really tricky one! Personally, I think what you did for your wedding is irrelevant because you were consistent.

I think that his brother has been very unreasonable and is signalling that he doesn’t really regard your child as his nephew. Which I think is pretty outrageous seeing as you’re married! But in doing so he’s put you in a really hard position because although it’s him who has been a dick, It’s you or your husband who are potentially going to have to choose to take a stand, and that makes it look like you who is generated the drama when actually it’s his brother.

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2023 17:17

@redroseflyer on another thread a stepmum is complaining that her DH is asking her to do childcare for an afternoon. Many other stepmums will be saying she is right to complain, she didn’t marry her DH to do that, not her children, not her responsibility, she doesn’t have to do anything with them, not same as bio children. But if this stepmum’s brother was getting married it would appear from this thread that the brother should invite the stepchildren as they should be treated as family

ImAvingOops · 20/04/2023 17:15

Honestly I don't think either side is wholly right or wholly wrong.
I totally get that your dh sees your child as his child now and that the kind, generous thing to do would be for bil to recognise this and invite your child. But from bil's pov, your child isn't the same as his actual nieces. People decide to blend their families but their parents and siblings don't get to choose and maybe don't always have the bonds that develop naturally with children they are biologically related to.

And it's a small wedding, they want people they actively choose and you chose not to include them in your wedding - you can't legitimately complain about this. At the same time, it's still hurtful - you want them to love your kid or at least respect your husband's bond.

If your dh talks to him and makes it clear that your child is family to him, as important as his biological child would be and bil doesn't respect that, then I'd decline the invitation. Hopefully bil cares enough about your dh to have a rethink.

I do think your extreme reaction is ott though - from their pov they are having a wedding with limited places snd just want guests that mean something to them. You can't force feelings.

TheCrystalPalace · 20/04/2023 17:14

If the OP's own wedding was the issue and this is tit-for-tat, then presumably she and her DH wouldn't be invited either?
No one attended her wedding apart from parents. It wasn't some siblings/kids but exclusion of others.

Thegoodbadandugly · 20/04/2023 17:11

I wonder if this is because you did not invite him to your wedding?

redroseflyer · 20/04/2023 17:06

At the centre of this is a 13 year old being ostracised from a family wedding, and that's cruel. You are a family unit and the brother seems to be forgetting this.
If your child was all grown up, flown the nest and off doing their own thing this would be different. But he/she is a child cared for by your DH and that seems to mean nothing to the brother/family.

I'd refuse to go, let DH go and do his bit. But they've made their position clear and I wouldn't give them the time of day from now on.

Soontobe60 · 20/04/2023 17:02

JaynesSmalls · 20/04/2023 12:51

@treespouse I know Karma has come to bite me.

Honestly I don't think our not extending an invitation to siblings has anything to do with their not inviting my child.

My husband didn't want a big wedding and given my history neither did I. None of our siblings have ever expressed hurt over it.

Any his brother doesn’t want a wedding involving step children. Maybe they were as fuming as you are about not being invited to your wedding but kept their feelings to themselves?

toomuchlaundry · 20/04/2023 17:00

It does seem that where it involves usual family life and drudgery step parents should be able to avoid interaction with step children but when it comes to gifts and celebrations step children should be treated the same as bio children in the extended family

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2023 16:59

Op can go and read the threads for herself to see how step parents talk about their step children and the responses that are given about how involved a step parent should be.

Yes, and will see that you are talking about your arse. Very rarely is it said that you should not do any of those things. It IS often said that you should not HAVE to do all those things.

44PumpLane · 20/04/2023 16:57

I think if it's a child free wedding other than nieces and nephews then it's fine.

Your child is not their nephew, although you've been together for 4 years your child wasn't a tiny, he was 9.

Yes it would be lovely of them to invite him but the wedding is probably £££ per head with limited numbers and they want their friends and loved ones there, and your child isn't their nephew so they probably like him well enough, but not to bump someone else from the wedding which is fair enough.

Whatsthefrequencykenny · 20/04/2023 16:56

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2023 16:53

Oh give over. You are talking about people who think you shouldn't be obliged or pushed to do those things, not that you shouldn't do them full stop. If you want to do them that's your choice.

Stop lurking on threads and then totally misrepresenting what is said on them.

Op can go and read the threads for herself to see how step parents talk about their step children and the responses that are given about how involved a step parent should be.

RedToothBrush · 20/04/2023 16:55

thecatsthecats · 20/04/2023 16:51

Given the husband is co-best man, then it would appear that they are close.

This is kind of where I land, depending on how much the OP and her husband have made the brother part of their lives, including the children.

I mostly invited partners to my wedding, for example, but one woman was very cagey about her boyfriend, never introduced us, never made a token gesture of friendship. Since she came solo often to events, it seemed that she should be happy enough coming to the wedding alone.

If the OP's husband has never so much as said, "hey, let's have a siblings and kids pub lunch", his brother might not even feel like they've become a family in that way.

To me it looks like the brother is trying to make a situation where he asks brother to choose between him or his new family tbh.

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 16:54

If I were your DH I’d be declining the invitation. If you had only just met DH I’d understand but he has been a stepfather to your child for a few years and your DC is obviously a big part of his life. I’d be hurt by this and wouldn’t be going.

dittbtdity · 20/04/2023 16:54

Irritateandunreasonable · 20/04/2023 16:41

ITS NOT RELEVANT!!!!!!

Jesus this is CHILDREN we are talking about what’s wrong with you all!!!!!!

what a way to say ‘you’re not welcome in our family, you’re not blood’

Children. Yes they are children.

I wouldn't waste £200 + a head at a world class venue on my own spotty teenager let alone someone else's who I have no meaningful relationship with.

RedToothBrush · 20/04/2023 16:54

Ok, so you live 300miles from your brother and they don't know your biological son. He's not invited. But they do know their sister's daughter so they invite her.

Are we saying that ok?

Of course this is a great opportunity for family members who don't know each other to get to know each other, but hell why bother.

Add in that's it's step child who has been in a situation where they feel rejected by their biological father. Step dad is great. Only for them to be rejected by his family as 'not good enough' as he's not biological and cos brother has a chip on his shoulder about your wedding.

Is this ok? To take out the petty vendetta between adults on an already rejected child and to not value the opportunity to bring him into the family and get to know them?

It 100% is about the lack of consistency and the vindictive nature of this using A VULNERABLE CHILD as a pawn in his adult drama and chip on shoulder.

Piss off. I'd be unhappy if husband went to the wedding but I wouldn't stop it, but I definitely wouldnt attend because he doesn't want to try and make a relationship.

The registry office wedding was about formality not a big celebration. The OP didn't want that for whatever reason and that's ok. There wasn't a personal element to not inviting siblings. This is very much personal.

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2023 16:53

Whatsthefrequencykenny · 20/04/2023 16:46

The answers here are very different from the step parent board. On there most step parents don't even consider their own step children to be part of their family, let alone their brother's wife's child. Go read a few threads on that board. Most think the idea of doing anything for a step child means the bio parent is a lazy, useless, worseless parent. They do not believe a step parent should ever put a single dollar or moment of time towards step children - that is them being taken advantage of. That board gives very good insights into how negatively and critcally many feel about step children and why the brother might not be inviting a child that is his brother's step child.

Oh give over. You are talking about people who think you shouldn't be obliged or pushed to do those things, not that you shouldn't do them full stop. If you want to do them that's your choice.

Stop lurking on threads and then totally misrepresenting what is said on them.