Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘You’ve upset your mother’

85 replies

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 10:57

I’ll keep it brief.

yesterday it’s 80 something year old granny’s birthday, my parents host her for a small tea and invite my younger brother (age 30, own home etc) to attend.

invite not extended to us (me, husband and children or even just me alone)

I ask why we weren’t included in the invitation. It all kicks off, dad messaging to say ‘you’ve upset your mother saying why weren’t you invited’, etc etc and asking me to apologise for upsetting her.

completely appreciate that I could have seen granny separately, gone to visit her that day alone. reality is that we have three children age 16, 5 and 2, a full time job each and a renovation. Time can be tricky but again, completely appreciate you make time for what’s important etc and it’s not having no time it’s choosing how you spend it.

AIBU to expect

  1. A heads up, ‘granny’s here if you want to pop in and see her we’re doing her a birthday cake’ (particularly seeing as younger brother invited)
  1. when I say I was a bit put out not to be invited, told what was going on, that they just say something like ‘oh yeah sorry, we didn’t think, will give you a heads up if you want to pop by next time’, rather than ‘don’t say that, look at all we do for you (1/2 day a week childcare for 2 year old), you’ve upset us saying that’

this is against a backdrop of younger sister visiting home every so often and the four of them (parents, sis and bro) going out for dinner, trips out etc without invites extended and me asking could we all try and do stuff together a bit more often.

id like to make it clear again that I completely appreciate that these things are two way and we make effort when we can to include granny (invites to the children’s birthdays etc), include our parents, initiating trips out or visits, phone calls, as often as we can with work, school, hobbies, etc. which are not reciprocated.

OP posts:
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 20/04/2023 13:20

DwightShrutesgirlfriend · 20/04/2023 12:31

It's hurtful @mumoftoddlerandteen, I get it. As someone with a similar dynamic, the only advice I would give you is to accept that you won't ever change them. I have spent five decades trying to understand why I am excluded and only now am I coming to terms with the fact that it really isn't about me, it's a about a messed up family situation with my parents and sister. For your own peace of mind, I would advise you step away a little bit and concentrate on your own loving family unit.

This. From a similar kind of background myself. You can't have a normal respectful reasonable conversation in a set up like this. When I (reluctantly) accepted this was the case, things have been better. I stopped banging my head against a brick wall. It's hard, but you are not going to change the weird dynamic by being reasonable, and assuming they will be reasonable back. It's hard. Flowers to you and @DwightShrutesgirlfriend Flowers

pikantna · 20/04/2023 13:14

luckylavender · 20/04/2023 13:08

You don't even seem to know your grannie's age. All about you.

😕

itsmylife7 · 20/04/2023 13:13

I assumed yours are the only children ?
Maybe they just wanted it to be adults?

When young children are around it can be noisy , maybe they just wanted a quieter time but don't know how to tell you.

pikantna · 20/04/2023 13:12

We get a fair bit of "you have upset your mother" in our family too

A few years ago I learned to say "she has upset me" in response and to refuse to apologise and play along with the shite and it has been most freeing

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 13:10

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:55

Yes I am wary of that. So for example last week when they had them they bought the eldest a hot chocolate and wouldn’t let the youngest have one when he’d asked. He was really bothered by it and kept saying to me that grandad wouldn’t let him have one (he’s 5). I asked about it to dad (his grandad) who said that DS5 didn’t really want one, just wanted the marshmallows, didn’t get that upset by it etc. I told my son that I couldn’t understand why grandad had said no, that that would have upset me too, and that I’d speak to him. But dad just couldn’t say ‘oh sorry, I didn’t realise he really wanted one’ next time I’ll make sure I get him one or anything like that. Just made me feel a bit weird, like why wouldn’t you just get him one too. X

I know you’re worried about upsetting their relationship with your kids, but I think you’re making a big mistake.

They're starting the discrepancies in treatment on your children now. You know how shit it feels, you’re conditioned to accept it and blame yourself, but please, please, don’t let them do it to your children too.

They’re failing as parents. This is nothing that you’ve don’t wrong. Their different treatment of you all and choosing to exclude you, before then turning it on you and deflecting it when you find out and are UNDERSTANDABLY upset, is vile.

luckylavender · 20/04/2023 13:08

You don't even seem to know your grannie's age. All about you.

winelove · 20/04/2023 13:06

Strange behaviour my them, there is no two ways about it.

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:55

Yes I am wary of that. So for example last week when they had them they bought the eldest a hot chocolate and wouldn’t let the youngest have one when he’d asked. He was really bothered by it and kept saying to me that grandad wouldn’t let him have one (he’s 5). I asked about it to dad (his grandad) who said that DS5 didn’t really want one, just wanted the marshmallows, didn’t get that upset by it etc. I told my son that I couldn’t understand why grandad had said no, that that would have upset me too, and that I’d speak to him. But dad just couldn’t say ‘oh sorry, I didn’t realise he really wanted one’ next time I’ll make sure I get him one or anything like that. Just made me feel a bit weird, like why wouldn’t you just get him one too. X

OP posts:
BigglyBee · 20/04/2023 12:51

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:29

It’s not that we need them for the childcare we just asked if they wanted to do it so that they had the time with the grandchildren. Sadly I don’t think they’d see them a lot otherwise.

if they wanted it low key they could have just mentioned to me and said come without the kids. They say that granny loves seeing the children though so I can’t get my head round it.

very conscious of rocking the boat and causing an issue with the relationship with the grandchildren.

Be careful with their relationship with the children. I bent over backwards to encourage them to develop a relationship with my kids, but then I realised that they were scapegoating two of my sons in exactly the same way as they had with me. It was the son who is the most like me that got the worst treatment, and then the one who had a mild developmental delay. The oldest was useful and the youngest was quiet and cute, so they were the favourites.

It took me a while to see what was going on, but I found it was really important to speak openly to my sons about their GPs behaviour and how the children had done nothing wrong. My MIL and FIL are both dead and my sons really wanted to have grandparents, but as time has passed and they have realised how badly they were being treated, they stopped asking to see the GP and now don't bother with them at all.

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:51

Yes we spend a lot of time with friends so I know we’re not unlikeable people!! I’m not perfect by any stretch but try my best with people - subject to the juggle that is ‘life’!!

for example we held a party for my son and i was conscious I couldn’t invite all of his friends due to numbers so held a little small thing for a group of friends outside of school.

it’s not so much the not inviting - I’m sort of used to it now and get it if it was an oversight, thinking we were busy, etc.

it’s the ‘it’s not okay to be upset about it’ vibe that I wanted reassurance I wasn’t being unreasonable about.

OP posts:
BigglyBee · 20/04/2023 12:41

Unfortunately, there is no happy ending here. There is nothing you can say or do to make them want to include you. Now you know that, you have the freedom to bother much less with them, and work on things and relationships which will bring joy to your life.I would also find alternative childcare, so that can't be used against you

My family is very similar, without the childcare, and after decades of trying, I have come to the conclusion that they exclude me because they want to. This is how they want to live. That's fine, but I also get to choose how I live, and as such I haven't initiated contact with them for three years now. They seem fine with that (or at least have never bothered to contact me), so we all have what we want, sort of.

It's hard to feel unwanted in your own family, I know that. But I have friends who want to see me and my children, and most of my in-laws are lovely. My husband adores me and my children are wonderful people, so I don't feel that I am missing out on much. Strangely (or maybe not!) the favoured siblings in my family actually can't be bothered with our parents, and visit maybe once every 10 years or so. So my parents lose out all round. I have a theory that they like the idea of having a large family, but don't actually like us (or at least me!) very much. That was certainly the impression they gave when we were children.

You should definitely work on the family relationships you want to have, like your grandmother, maybe siblings, aunts, uncles etc, but do it independent of your parents.

Purplehyena · 20/04/2023 12:39

Had you planned to see/contact your Granny independently knowing it was her birthday? Given you weren’t aware of a wider family thing going on. I can see it’s hurtful not to be included in the family plans, just wondering if it’s some sort of ‘test’ to (unfairly) see if you’d bother unless someone else arranged it.

LaylaLjungberg · 20/04/2023 12:33

’You’ve upset your mother’ gives me hives. They got caught out and are deflecting big time.

HaggisBurger · 20/04/2023 12:33

Nevermind31 · 20/04/2023 11:07

”why has me asking you this upset you? I am upset that I was not invited - it is your right to, but can I ask why I am excluded from family events?”

Yes definitely say this.

DwightShrutesgirlfriend · 20/04/2023 12:31

It's hurtful @mumoftoddlerandteen, I get it. As someone with a similar dynamic, the only advice I would give you is to accept that you won't ever change them. I have spent five decades trying to understand why I am excluded and only now am I coming to terms with the fact that it really isn't about me, it's a about a messed up family situation with my parents and sister. For your own peace of mind, I would advise you step away a little bit and concentrate on your own loving family unit.

Justmemyselfandi999 · 20/04/2023 12:31

Had exactly this myself. Stepped away and went NC with all of them. Liberating. No longer spend my time second guessing what I've done wrong, or why I've been excluded.

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:30

I get that we don’t always do things together. It just feels like when she visits that they spend time altogether every day, without an invite extended to us or me at any point. It’s only when I ask about doing something that we are included.

OP posts:
Devoutspoken · 20/04/2023 12:30

That's so unkind of them

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 12:29

It’s not that we need them for the childcare we just asked if they wanted to do it so that they had the time with the grandchildren. Sadly I don’t think they’d see them a lot otherwise.

if they wanted it low key they could have just mentioned to me and said come without the kids. They say that granny loves seeing the children though so I can’t get my head round it.

very conscious of rocking the boat and causing an issue with the relationship with the grandchildren.

OP posts:
NeIIie · 20/04/2023 12:27

It seems unfair of them.

But I did pick up on what you say further down about younger sister visiting and them going for dinner. I dont see an issue with that, things dont always have to be as a complete unit of everyone! Like surely you could visit and you all say shall we go for dinner without your sis and brother.

I go for dinner with my Mum, I dont ask my brother. He drops into my Mums, might have a takeaway with them but he doesn't have to mention it and include us.

But Granny having a little cake and it being an actual occasion, yes thats out of order of them.

Sceptre86 · 20/04/2023 12:15

You should have responded to your dad that actually your feelings were hurt and are often hurt when they do things like this and deliberately exclude you. I wouldn't use them for childcare and so would no issue calling them out on this type of behaviour. You aren't in a position to rock the boat if you use them for childcare though so the only real option you have is to put up with it or find alternative childcare. Ultimately you can let this carry on or you can raise the issue and stand your ground. They're gaslighting you and that's not OK.

paisley256 · 20/04/2023 12:12

That's really cruel. I'd find different child care and stop reaching out to be included in family stuff. Who knows why they choose to do this, but you could waste your whole life trying to find out why and still be in the same boat. See granny on your own and look after you and your own little family. 💐

Peapodburgundybouquet · 20/04/2023 12:06

I absolutely despise parents who treat their children like this. It’s unbelievably cruel. And they’ve taken your total upset and commandeered it, and made it a stick to beat you with (‘your upset has upset your mother’).

I’m sorry, OP. I’d stop them providing any childcare and I’d stop bothering with them. When they inevitably have a go at you for it, I’d tell them to have a long think about the disparity in the way they’ve treated you compared to your siblings, and to see if they can figure it out.

So cruel.

Sittingonabench · 20/04/2023 12:05

Maybe it feels quite a lot organising whole family events when each one has their own family and they were looking to do a more low key thing. Maybe your DB called at just the right time and so it was easier to invite him along. Extended families can’t do everything together and while it’s nice to be invited it’s often easier for the busier people to lead by saying when they are free rather than get into a conversation of could we change the date, place, activity so that it can be more inclusive for all family and never actually getting to have an easy relaxed catch up. I don’t think either side is unreasonable I think though there does have to be a bit of acceptance that when you prioritise your nuclear family (which is obviously important to do) you may not be prioritised with your extended family at every occasion

mumoftoddlerandteen · 20/04/2023 11:37

Other sister not invited as lives four hours away and will plan visits ie ‘I’m next down on this date’ etc. she’s happy with this arrangement ie appreciates she misses out on things because of this.

we live a six minute drive away.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread