Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult son 23 doesn't want to ever move out

109 replies

onlyabitnosy · 20/04/2023 10:37

Son 23 is autistic and ADHD.
He has a job and works very hard but has said that he wouldn't ever want to move out because he doesn't think he would cope on his own and would hate it.
Do we accept that he's always going to live at home or push him to be independent?

He doesn't have any friends and spends a lot of his free time with us.
He doesn't earn a lot of money but he works hard and pays his way.
He seems very unhappy and finds life quite overwhelming at times is often subject to being bullied and can be quite vulnerable which has seen him taken advantage of in the past as he's very trusting.
We'd be reluctant to leave him alone for example if we went on holiday because he is oblivious to what he's doing most of the time, loses his keys often, always seems in a daydream and I'd be worried he'd leave the oven on or not lock up.

We love him dearly and he's a lovely lad but I don't know if we are doing him any favours allowing him to stay at home indefinitely writing off any plans of making a future on his own.

He has a lot of anxiety issues and I don't want him to think this isn't his home or we don't want him here, I'd just like him to be happy and I can't believe he's going to be happy with us forever.

OP posts:
UrsulaBelle · 20/04/2023 14:14

My 23yo DS with ASD still lives at home. He's nominally fairly bright but hasn't managed to get a job. He's very happy at home with few responsibilities. I'm divorced, it's just him and me so he is company, as much as an autistic youngster with special interests but no conversation, can be company! I'm slowly training him up with household tasks so he will be able to do his own washing etc eventually. He can heat up a ready meal and order a takeaway 😉so I can leave him for a few days on his own. I'm building this up to a week so that I can still have the occasional holiday without him.

As PPs have said, he's like someone much younger than his age, 23 going on 14 or so. So I'm not too worried about him moving on as yet. In time, maybe.

InSpainTheRain · 20/04/2023 14:13

If you don't think he'd cope by himself whilst you are on holiday or a week or something how on earth can he be expected to move out to his own place? Could you leave him for a 3-4 days whilst you have a short holiday and see how he goes?

Robinni · 20/04/2023 14:05

@onlyabitnosy I wouldn’t force him to mix only with autistics it will amplify everything he’s going through. Like a smoker trying to quit having only smokers around them to talk to about smoking and the difficulties with smoking. Instead of him learning new ways of being it will just reinforce it all. Personally couldn’t think of anything more awful.

He needs outdoor activity (not team sport, think scouting for grown ups or walking, cycling, swimming) or hobbies with detail like making something, coding, gaming, music. Music is actually very good as he can sit and listen, or play, doesn’t have to say anything and then can talk about the music he likes with people after. Something where his autism won’t matter so much and he can play to his strengths. You or another person he knows could go with him to start, then when he gets established you might not be needed every time. Having one success will then give him confidence for further. It’s all gradual.

MagicSpring · 20/04/2023 13:59

I third the air frier!

MagicSpring · 20/04/2023 13:59

Taptap2 · 20/04/2023 11:15

I’m sure I will face this situation in a few years . We may go down the granny flat route or find him a flat somewhere very close to us but I would be concerned he would be lonely. However, I’m happy to have him at home long term but DH is not. You need to be able to leave him at home at least overnight on his own and build up from there. Air fryer has been a godsend on teaching DS to cook.

Opposite way round here; DH wants DS (also 20s and autistic with ADHD) to know that he can live with us as long as he likes. I’m trying to shove him gently towards greater independence. After all, we won’t be around for his whole life.

My mother has just died and I’m feeling my own mortality.

onlyabitnosy · 20/04/2023 13:54

I have encouraged him to join groups for autistic adults but he's reluctant, I think he's quite happy just being with family he knows, its almost like he doesn't know about friendships so he doesn't miss them.
He works as a drivers mate delivering white goods so he is with one other person during work, but not a lot of opportunity for mixing.
Lots of lifting and shifting and he works long hours but he doesn't find the job too difficult and he's been there several years and enjoys it.

OP posts:
Naunet · 20/04/2023 13:53

My brother is autistic to the point of not being able to work and needs a lot of help with certain tasks so he moved into an assisted living flat. It was great for him, gave him some independence a bit of responsibility etc. Unfortunately he’s now had to move back home because over the last year, the care provided by the agency had declined significantly, but the experience, as well as going off to a special college when he was younger (which he loved) has really helped him develop a degree of independence.

1offnamechange · 20/04/2023 13:46

Thing is the actual decision isn't going to be between him moving out OR staying with you for the rest of his life, is it?
Because, sorry for being blunt, its very unlikely that you or his father will be around for the rest of his life. At some point he will be on his own.

So it's more a question of whether its better for him to live the majority of his life with you as he would prefer BUT with the high likelihood at some point he will end up on his own and struggle to cope with all the skills that he's never needed to use at the exact time he's also coping with a bereavement -or if it's better for him to move out earlier even if its not what he wants while you are still around to support him and provide a safety net.

That doesn't mean he's necessarily ready NOW. But given that he's able to hold down a job it sounds like if you put the effort in to support him develop the skills (and ideally support networks beyond you) he's currently missing he could possibly be ready in a few years, even if it's in a supported living situation or with the support of a social worker or with you still being in contact with him every day.

But I fully appreciate both options are hard. Either way he's lucky to have parents that care about him so much.

HappiDaze · 20/04/2023 13:36

If you're ok with it then I'd let him stay till he's ready to move on

onlyabitnosy · 20/04/2023 13:34

thenightsky · 20/04/2023 13:23

Place marking. I have a 31 year old son still living at home. All the previous posts pretty much describe him. I cry myself to sleep at night worrying what will become of him. Me and DH are retired now and I have visions of him living on the streets, homeless, if anything happens to us. He did actually move out to university at 19, but within a few months he'd become so depressed he attempted suicide and had to come home, where he's been ever since. I cannot get him interested in work at all but we do live very rurally with no public transport.

Sorry I'm not much help OP. I just wanted to let you know there's quite a few of us out here.

So sorry to hear that, it must have been difficult.
I do worry about his future, he's never been suicidal but has often said he'd rather not be here than have autism.
I think a lot of it's the anxiety and bullying that comes with it, has he seen a doctor for his depression?

OP posts:
zurala · 20/04/2023 13:25

OP please join some autistic led groups on Facebook and ask there. Some of the comments here are upsetting to read as an autistic person myself. He doesn't need to get "out of his comfort zone" he is likely far out of it every day just trying to live in neurotypical society. He needs security and to feel safe (I know you know this).
Try this group https://www.facebook.com/groups/AAAandA/?ref=share
There are lots of autistic people on there who will have similar lived experience to your son.

Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/groups/AAAandA?ref=share

thenightsky · 20/04/2023 13:23

Place marking. I have a 31 year old son still living at home. All the previous posts pretty much describe him. I cry myself to sleep at night worrying what will become of him. Me and DH are retired now and I have visions of him living on the streets, homeless, if anything happens to us. He did actually move out to university at 19, but within a few months he'd become so depressed he attempted suicide and had to come home, where he's been ever since. I cannot get him interested in work at all but we do live very rurally with no public transport.

Sorry I'm not much help OP. I just wanted to let you know there's quite a few of us out here.

midnightblue12 · 20/04/2023 13:20

23 is still young.
I agree about building his confidence and social skills etc but also just give him time. Things won't be like this forever

Ffsmakeitstop · 20/04/2023 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wow. What a nasty comment. Op is not asking for a judgement on her life choices.
A bit of support and empathy and hopefully some advice from people who have been in this situation.
I'm not in this position but I do have one son who lives alone with quite severe mental health problems and I also have to deal with all his admin, appts etc. I do his laundry and am going tomorrow to help him clean.
It really worries me how he will cope when I'm not here.

Nanny0gg · 20/04/2023 13:08

onlyabitnosy · 20/04/2023 11:28

We're not looking to push him out by any means, I enjoy his company and we get along great, we are a close family, it's more about him thinking he'll never be able to move out and me wondering if it's healthy for him to think like this or if he just needs to believe he could rather than doubting he'll ever manage without us.
Like any parents we just want to do what's best for him and to see him happy.

So have you looked into supported accommodation? Or groups he could learn to socialise with?

You won't be here forever so you need to start planning how best to get him ready to be away from you

AskMeMore · 20/04/2023 13:06

Also do not expect everything to be perfect. I am NT and when I lived away for the first time sometimes forgot to lock my door or lost my keys. Most young adults have this experience at some time, the difference is their parents dont know about it.

AskMeMore · 20/04/2023 13:05

I also agree that it is easier to learn now than him be forced to learn these things when he is 50 or 60 years old through circumstance. Because you can do it slowly and gradually.
If he did live independently there are plenty of solutions to some of his issues. So don't have kets but install a door code on the front door and an automatically closing door.
The being bullied and taken advantage is off is a real issue though and a hard one to solve.

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 20/04/2023 13:03

Accelerated not delayed! What an odd replacement!

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 20/04/2023 13:02

I would let him stay with you but encourage him to learn some more life skills. It sounds as if he’d be willing to try things such as routines and checklists so that he has a list for when he leaves the house/goes to bed so that he knows everything has been switched off. Often I think you do have to make a potentially dangerous mistake to learn not to do it again.

I’m autistic (Asperger’s) and I’m 50 now. I probably only moved out at 25 because I was in a long term relationship and my exH organised most of the house stuff. I gradually started taking responsibility for that in my mid 30’s and then we broke up and suddenly I had to do everything alone.

I think the autistic brain is very slow to develop though and I’m not sure these things can be rushed. The internet (particularly YouTube) has been very useful to me though for learning about people and my self development has a delayed a lot over the past ten years. Learning about Myers Briggs, neurodiversity, highly sensitive people and then narcissism has been so useful to me because now I know when I’m being lied to and manipulated.

AskMeMore · 20/04/2023 13:00

I would start small and work on his skills so you feel fine leaving him overnight at first.
I would also work on some of his practical skills like being able to cook simple meals if he cant already, and shopping and paying for food. You can do all this in a fun way together at first.
If he says he never wants to love out, I would just say something vague like you are still young, you might change your mind when you are older.

ChickenDhansak82 · 20/04/2023 12:51

My BIL has ASD (aspergers) and lived at home until he was 42! He was quite comfortable there, his mum waiting on him hand and foot, everything paid for...

Eventually he decided he needed to be independent and moved out and has lived on his own for about 8 years. His parents helped him buy a 1 bed house and he lives with his dog and goes to work, plays his guitar and has a playstation. He isn't very sociable, and can be quite odd at times, but sometimes he does try and agree to socialise.

If you contact the National Autistic Society, they have schemes to help those with ASD to be able to live independently either in their purpose build units, or in their own homes with some sort of support.

Robinni · 20/04/2023 12:44

He’s only 23, lots of NT people are still living at home at that point, many well beyond.

I think in future you could look at moving to somewhere with an annexe or potential to built/convert so he has his own space but still has access to support. If financially this isn’t possible, then a flat or smaller house nearby. Supported accom if necessary, but he’s working so probably doesn’t need it.

Work on his life skills (money/bill management), use an organisation app/alarms or a paper planner specific to adhd, and work on responsibility within the household (dishes, washing, cleaning, cooking). Do a rota and visual schedules to help him establish these new routines at set times. This will give him confidence and gradually the idea of semi- independent living will become less scary and more manageable, it’s all about repetition.

GasPanic · 20/04/2023 12:39

The problem is that the older he gets, the more adverse he will become to learning new things. This is like most people. It's better for him to learn slowly at a gentle pace now than suddenly be plummeted into the situation when he is 50.

The best thing is to help him develop skills for independent living, because even if he doesn't leave your house, it will make your life easier when he lives with you and also help him when the eventual time comes when he is on his own.

My feeling is that if he can hold down a job, he is probably capable of doing quite a lot.

LowFlyingDucks · 20/04/2023 12:39

Have you looked into supported housing OP?

sweeneytoddsrazor · 20/04/2023 12:32

Hopefully you can help him become more independent, but you can't help with the loneliness. Even if he can become independent enough to live alone, how will he manage making a few friendships or even a romantic relationship? I think looking for some sort of assisted living type place alongside encouraging independence is worth looking into.