Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aftermath of brother’s wedding

373 replies

HuxleyDog · 20/04/2023 10:11

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4222570-Am-I-selfish-Brother-s-Wedding?postsby=HuxleyDog

I have tried to post a link to my only ever mumsnet post from 2 years ago.

After I posted my little boy came in early July following a good bit of drama. My brother relented and allowed all of us to come to his wedding however we chose to only go to the ceremony and he did seem pleased about this. On three occasions between birth and wedding my brother had the same conversation about what would happen if the baby cried. It got a bit heated. We decided to sit at the back but my dad insisted we come to sit with family. My boy slept throughout. Family did come to fuss but there was no distractions from wedding.

They now have a lovely five month old baby!

Relationship between us and sister-in-law has changed and we are not as close as we were, but my brother still comes round. I have stopped asking about her as he always seems embarrassed.

My sister-in-law’s father died a month ago very suddenly. My mother and I went round immediately but SiL was out with her mother. When she came in she screamed at us to get out saying it wasn’t about us and we’d ruined her wedding. She claimed that we didn’t care for her father but we should be happy we had saved money on the band. We had no idea what she was talking about.

It turned out my father who is divorced from my mother had withdrawn funding from their wedding when he found out my husband and baby were banned from wedding. When we were invited and my dad tried to pay Sister-in-Law’s dad wouldn’t take the money.
None of us knew this. My mother swears she knew nothing.
I texted my sister-in law apologising and saying that we knew nothing. It’s obvious that I am blocked. There’s nothing I can do is there? My brother just said to leave it. My dad is genuinely upset but still thinks he did nothing wrong especially as baby slept throughout.

Log in | Mumsnet

Mumsnet makes parents' lives easier by pooling knowledge, advice and support on everything from conception to childbirth, from babies to teenagers.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4222570-Am-I-selfish-Brother-s-Wedding?postsby=HuxleyDog

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/04/2023 13:27

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 20/04/2023 13:12

I have family I've not seen in 2 years. I'm not in conflict with them.

Was there a massive row over the wedding of said family members two years ago? Because if not, this isn’t really a relevant comparison.

Noicant · 20/04/2023 13:24

I don’t really get excluding your own nieces and nephews from weddings. If one of my siblings (or DH’s) had a newborn it would never occur to me to ban them. It’s a bit mad tbh. I can’t imagine needing to be the centre of attention so much (or at all) that I would begrudge a baby meeting extended family at my wedding.

They were unreasonable and you should have checked with your DB if she was ok to receive you. I actually understand where your dad was coming from, they were trying to exclude part of his family while still expecting him to cough up. I wouldn’t want to pay up either.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 13:24

Going to her house when her father had just died shows she's right and you do like to make things about yourself. I bet her side of the wedding story would be very different.

Just leave her alone.

Starhead69 · 20/04/2023 13:23

Bridezilla vibes. She sounds jealous

MyAnacondaMight · 20/04/2023 13:20

Your brother and SIL were unreasonable for excluding your husband and baby. But everything since sounds like it’s on you - and your father. You pushed for an invite when you knew that husband and baby weren’t welcome. You then sat at the front to really rub it in, even though that could have caused a distraction. Your father was financially manipulative, which in turn made things awkward with SIL’s parents. And then you turn up for the drama around her father’s death, despite knowing she doesn’t like you or want a relationship?!?

Leave the poor woman alone. She might be weird about your baby (perhaps she has experienced loss that you don’t know about), but she isn’t the drama here.

Calmdown14 · 20/04/2023 13:20

I can't quite understand how on a site called Mumsnet people don't understand that a baby a few days old is rather difficult to leave anywhere so saying no to baby is also saying no to mother. At a few more weeks yes you have probably learned to express, baby might take a bottle etc but in the first few days it's all very unpredictable. Plus when it's a wedding all the people you'd leave it with are there.

But in response to the question today, send her a card or flowers with a nice message and then just leave it. You can't do anything else. Offer an olive branch but don't push anything.

MayThe4th · 20/04/2023 13:20

You or your husband obviously should have sat at the back with the baby in case the baby woke. That's just basic decency at a wedding. Instead after multiple arguments and endless stress about it in the run up to the wedding, the bride, as she's walking up the aisle will have seen you sat there right at the front with the baby. You say the baby slept through it as though that makes it ok, the bride will still have felt a rush of anxiety over whether the baby will wake in the middle of the ceremony and, no doubt, anger that you couldn't do the one basic thing you'd said you'd do - which frankly shouldn't even needed to have been asked for, just when she should have been feeling nothing more than happiness and the normal anxiety at having to stand up in front of a lot of people and say your vows. Your job as the future sil was to try to ease sources of anxiety - not create them. what a load of shite. It’s a day in the scheme of things having a baby at your wedding is entirely irrelevant, as for the poor SIL getting stressed wondering if her (me me me) day might be disrupted by the presence of a baby, she needs to get a fucking grip.

As for the OP going round after the bereavement, if she hadn’t gone round I imagine that would have been wrong as well.

If only people put so much effort into having a decent marriage as they do into the one day which brought them there maybe the divorce rate wouldn’t be so high.

Emigratingimmigrant · 20/04/2023 13:19

Well looking at most posts deflection to past wedding issue and making someone's death about OP's family worked...

Seaweed42 · 20/04/2023 13:16

I think it was a bit presumptous to call around to SIL immediately when she had just lost her Dad.
Would you not text beforehand to arrange a suitable time, rather than just drop around to the house like that? You can't really doorstep people like that, it's not fair and it's controlling to be honest.

Was that your mother's idea?

It sounds like your parents are quite controlling.

Your BIL has found a controlling woman to look after him and tell him what to do.
That tells us something about your mother.

Your Dad had contributed money to his son's wedding. Regardless of any squabbles he shouldn't have messed them about like that playing games with your brother and the money. That's emotional manipulation.

Can you not see how someone might not want a tiny newborn baby, probably the first grandchild or the only child in the church, sitting in pride of place when it's supposed to be the other person's big day? I sort of get where she is coming from.

Does your brother maybe keep trying to keep your Mum happy as well. He probably feels pulled apart at the seams trying to keep everyone happy.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/04/2023 13:14

Ponderingwindow · 20/04/2023 12:58

Parental contributions to weddings are optional. Effectively excluding a sibling from a wedding because of a newborn baby is disgusting behavior. Your father did the right thing by refusing to contribute to a wedding where that was going to happen. There should be no apology.

No one is saying the father HAD to contribute - but if he was going to, it shouldn’t have come with Ts and Cs and a massive dose of emotional blackmail.

SerafinasGoose · 20/04/2023 13:13

We decided to sit at the back but my dad insisted we come to sit with family.

Your father really hasn't helped this situation at all. He flexed a lot of muscle around this wedding - showing everybody who was in charge and this was him - and as ever it's the women who end up carrying the can for that behaviour. (Much the same as when a woman marries into a family, the responsibility for any consternation between her husband and his FOO is usually blamed on her).

If SiL feels really bitter about this situation I can see her perspective. But if anyone needs to be mending fences here, your father needs to be doing this with your brother.

Given DB has just lost his FiL, right now would be bad timing. In the meantime, SiL has made it clear she doesn't want her in-laws around, and has blocked you.

There is nothing you can do but respect her wishes.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 20/04/2023 13:12

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/04/2023 13:10

The OP didn't know she was in conflict with SIL and her brother didn't give a heads up that was the case.

If only she’d had some clue, like her SIL avoiding her for the last two years…

I have family I've not seen in 2 years. I'm not in conflict with them.

OverCCCs · 20/04/2023 13:11

RampantIvy · 20/04/2023 12:25

Why are today's brides so self absorbed that they hate the idea of that a baby (in this case a very tiny baby) might cry out during the wedding? Does it really matter?

I wouldn't have given a fig if my nearly two year old niece had cried at my wedding. Although, I also know that SIL would have done her best to quieten her down.

You answered your own question. Because it’s disruptive, and what bride who has spent months and lots of money planning her wedding wants disruptions? If it wasn’t seen as such, why would your SIL bother quieting your niece for age appropriate behaviour?

Not to mention that during a wedding ceremony, a loud child might make it hard for other guests to hear what’s being said, or get captured on audio and then the happy couple’s official wedding recording has a wailing infant at key moments instead of “I do.”

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 20/04/2023 13:10

The OP didn't know she was in conflict with SIL and her brother didn't give a heads up that was the case.

If only she’d had some clue, like her SIL avoiding her for the last two years…

Bluebells1970 · 20/04/2023 13:09

I think you all need to step a very big step back from the drama. Your DB is completely right in saying to leave it.

Just keep in touch with your DB, and let the dust settle. Having lost my own Dad recently, I can say that nothing about grief is logical - she was probably in shock, and deeply upset so perhaps was very rattled by your presence. Leave her to grieve her Dad, and see what time brings.

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/04/2023 13:09

Spcd · 20/04/2023 11:21

I can't help wondering if you/your Dad have form for making occasions where you should be nothing more than a supportive bystander about you/you're husband, and if that's what precipitated the original decision that your baby wasn't invited.

You or your husband obviously should have sat at the back with the baby in case the baby woke. That's just basic decency at a wedding. Instead after multiple arguments and endless stress about it in the run up to the wedding, the bride, as she's walking up the aisle will have seen you sat there right at the front with the baby. You say the baby slept through it as though that makes it ok, the bride will still have felt a rush of anxiety over whether the baby will wake in the middle of the ceremony and, no doubt, anger that you couldn't do the one basic thing you'd said you'd do - which frankly shouldn't even needed to have been asked for, just when she should have been feeling nothing more than happiness and the normal anxiety at having to stand up in front of a lot of people and say your vows. Your job as the future sil was to try to ease sources of anxiety - not create them.

Then you decide to go round uninvited to the house of someone who clearly doesn't like you the moment they've suffered a major bereavement?! What on earth made you think that was a good idea?

The baby was due just before the wedding and was in the event premature. When op posted 2 years ago she was heavily pregnant and the brother and sil basically expected op to leave her newborn at home and walk 12 minutes alone to the church so that her dh and the baby were nowhere in sight.

Op’s sil is totally unpredictable and volatile. Her brother it appears does his wife’s bidding. Had they stayed away after her mother’s death it would have been unfeeling. It simply isn’t possible to please some people because the person trying to please isn’t at fault.

As for op’s father, that is not her responsibility.

Ducksinthebath · 20/04/2023 13:04

No matter what happened at or around the wedding you were being spectacularly insensitive to turn up at the house of grieving person you know you have a difficult history with. I mean, what did you think would happen? She’d welcome you with open arms and all would be forgiven? Deluded.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 20/04/2023 13:04

Her father died and someone she doesn’t get on with (you) turned up straight away?

I don't particularly get on with my SIL she had the photographer cut me out of all the official wedding photos! but I was really upset and pissed off that she didn't make any effort when my father died. It wasn't just me it affected, it also affected her brother (my husband) and her supposedly much loved nieces. It's normal and arguably expected for family to be present around those sorts of times unless you're already in conflict with them. The OP didn't know she was in conflict with SIL and her brother didn't give a heads up that was the case.

HyacinthBookay · 20/04/2023 13:03

fhillipefloppe · 20/04/2023 10:33

I have read your previous posts. How did it end up that the baby attended the ceremony?

Not inviting your DH was spiteful but the baby is understandable.

Honestly they sound unhinged

The SiL's recent reaction is unhinged, but then grief at the loss of a parent will do that to a person.

ArcticSkewer · 20/04/2023 13:03

Never mind the wedding, it was two years ago, you haven't really seen her since.

What on earth were you thinking to rush straight round after her dad just died??

No wonder she went mad. It really isn't all about you. She doesn't like you. You are not her friends. Her father had just died. It's really nasty to do that, very cruel.

Dithyramb · 20/04/2023 13:01

Everyone involved in this seems to have come straight from a soap opera whose writers are fighting a dip in viewer figures by wringing all possible melodrama out of a minor situation.

De-escalate, OP. Disengage. If there’s any sorting out to be done, it’s on your brother, surely.

Meteormetro · 20/04/2023 12:59

Your dad doesn't sound very nice. I don't know that you've done anything wrong but you should have insisted on sitting at the back, knowing that bride's wishes and the carfuffle if your baby has woken. In your place I would have gone alone to the ceremony. I do feel a little sorry for the bride.

Ponderingwindow · 20/04/2023 12:58

Parental contributions to weddings are optional. Effectively excluding a sibling from a wedding because of a newborn baby is disgusting behavior. Your father did the right thing by refusing to contribute to a wedding where that was going to happen. There should be no apology.

CremeEggQueen · 20/04/2023 12:58

GOW56 · 20/04/2023 12:48

I would just avoid her she doesn't sound like a very pleasant person. None of this is your fault. I can't imagine anyone saying a new born baby can't attend a wedding of a very close family member. But then again I don't understand why people get so precious about weddings.
E it's not your fault your father withdrew his contribution to the wedding but it's perfectly understandable. It's his money to spend as he wishes and after they said your husband couldn't even pop into the reception I don't blame him.
Stay in contact with your brother but don't initiate any contact with your sister in law

Not everyone wants kids at weddings.
Its OP and her family who don't sound pleasant, not the SIL.
The pushing, the manipulation just ugh

CremeEggQueen · 20/04/2023 12:55

ShandaLear · 20/04/2023 12:12

So, your SIL didn’t want the baby at the wedding but the baby came to the wedding. Your dad refused to contribute to the wedding because your DH and baby weren’t invited so they had less money to plan the day they wanted. I can see where she’s coming from, TBH. She’s handled it badly, but the event really did become all about you and what you wanted, so I can understand why she’s upset. The last thing anyone needs when planning a wedding is all that extra conflict and hassle. Regardless of the morality, the ‘children are the best bit about a wedding’, ‘families should be together’ blah blah blah, this was their wedding, so their preferences, their decisions, and they get to make their choices as you made yours. If you don’t like theirs you respectfully decline the invitation. It was up to your brother to sort this out, and he clearly failed to do so. You’ll have to leave it for now. Send a sympathy card and maintain a relationship with your brother and hopefully their child.

This!
They didn't want kids at the wedding, but you all pushed until they relented and finally getting your own way ( with a bit of manipulation of threatening to pull the plug on money, with others on this one, gifts should not come with strings attached, either it's a gift or it's not)
Don't blame them for being fucked off to be honest.

Swipe left for the next trending thread