Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Thinking of going to XR Big One in London on Sat...but will it be very full-on?

218 replies

Noteverythingisasitseems · 20/04/2023 08:25

Want to go, and take DC. I'm not amazing with big crowds, but can handle it if it doesn't get too pushy/shove-like and full on. Never been to an XR gathering before - if you have, what should I expect, please?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Devoutspoken · 22/04/2023 09:01

Yes, but is that 'normal' enough?

SquirmOfEels · 22/04/2023 08:49

Devoutspoken · 22/04/2023 08:46

But are these people 'normal'?

As "normal" as any community in social housing. Mixed bunch of all sorts.

Devoutspoken · 22/04/2023 08:46

But are these people 'normal'?

SquirmOfEels · 22/04/2023 08:41

Devoutspoken · 21/04/2023 22:45

There are still working class areas in those places

Yes, just as there are in Westminster (Peabody), Pimlico (Peabody and others) and Chelsea (ditto)
Plus others in Kennington if you cross the river.

First two places mentioned are within 15-20 mins walk, other two within 30 mins.

I think perhaps some posters have a very cliched view of London demographics. People may not be able to afford to buy/private rent, and a lot of the council stock was taken by "right to buy" decades ago. But the big HA estates survived (and Peabody is expanding).

And being redeveloped now, the utterly notorious Heygate is a mere 2 miles from Parliament Square.

TodayInahurry · 22/04/2023 08:30

Demonstrations like this do not make a difference, 1 million people demonstrated against Blair’s foreign wars. That worked well!

AuntieStella · 22/04/2023 08:29

limitedperiodonly · 22/04/2023 00:17

@AuntieStella do think I'm unaware of how big the London Marathon is? I live at the end of it. Lots of runners stay in the hotels round here from Saturday. It's a bit of a pain in the arse if you want to walk for lunch north of St James's Park but it's just one day so I'm not going to spoil anyone's fun. I always like to see the people coming back with their medals. I think the weather will be perfect on Sunday. Not rainy and not too hot.

No, of course I wasn't thinking of any particular individual when I wrote about the size. Just posting what I thought was meant by disruption.

And then adding some thoughts of my own, about the sheer scale of crowds on Sunday.

Because I do think that some posters, in posts scattered across the thread, have not fully grasped how enormously busy the finish area always is. Nor how far round you'll need to walk to reach places that are usually only minutes apart. I noticed a couple of posts saying to bring a map. That's good advice, as phone signal always struggles around the finish, and you may need to navigate round closures and choke points.

Cnidarian · 22/04/2023 08:28

I'm so pleased to read that people are going with church groups! The church has such an important role it can play, the messages of hope and faith are so important in the face of the reality of the suffering that is to come and the anxiety that comes with that knowledge. There are many dismissers here, and it's ok we understand it is hard to accept what is happening. The scale and gravity of it is really hard to come to terms with.

Devoutspoken · 22/04/2023 08:26

Catscou, if your travel plans in London are disrupted by protests or indeed large scale events if any kind in the future, London has a great network of bike hires

Qilin · 22/04/2023 08:22

Most people will be using public transport that would be running regardless. It's not like they put extra trains and coaches on for it..

Special coaches ARE being put in for it.
There are definitely special coaches being out in specifically for the protests/rally from my northern town. I know people going on it.

AuntieStella · 22/04/2023 08:20

Sausagenbacon · 22/04/2023 07:49

Sausage, I'm guessing they're may be a cross over, some marathon runners may be in favour of the protest
I don't disagree. What I said was that I bet someone in xr protest will take it up upon themselves to disrupt it and xr will disclaim all responsibility

You can be in favour of the protest but still dead against any interference with one of the iconic world races. Especially if you're non-elite, only got your ballot place after umpteen years of trying, and this is your only shot at it.

Organisations such as Home - (thegreenrunners.com) are at the protests

Devoutspoken · 22/04/2023 08:18

Well I guess both runners and protesters have a right to run and protest in london, and people who live there, be it in 'normal' or abnormal neighbourhoods, have a right to not be offended by the disruptions

Qilin · 22/04/2023 08:17

Confrontayshunme · 20/04/2023 14:20

A lot of uninformed posters here. XR are specifically billing this as family friendly and are moving away from resistant tactics that inconvenience people. We are going with a group from our church, and they wouldn't be going if there was even a hint of unrest. It will be fine.

But have chosen a well known very busy event weekend, and haven't ruled out distribution to that event - which raises a lot of money for charities and where people have trained long and hard for.

Is it really family friendly to do that?

Let's face it - are they really going to line the streets holding up,a banner or two whilst cheering in the runners?!

Sausagenbacon · 22/04/2023 07:49

Sausage, I'm guessing they're may be a cross over, some marathon runners may be in favour of the protest
I don't disagree. What I said was that I bet someone in xr protest will take it up upon themselves to disrupt it and xr will disclaim all responsibility

limitedperiodonly · 22/04/2023 00:17

AuntieStella · 21/04/2023 22:09

I read that as not wanting the marathon to be disrupted.

Not that they minded the disruption of the marathon.

There are 40,000 runners, plus their supporters, plus organisers, staff volunteers, plus other spectators. It's a huge number going through Parliament Square, many roads closed (and marshalled crossing points only) and much of St James Park and Green Park closed to the public.

@AuntieStella do think I'm unaware of how big the London Marathon is? I live at the end of it. Lots of runners stay in the hotels round here from Saturday. It's a bit of a pain in the arse if you want to walk for lunch north of St James's Park but it's just one day so I'm not going to spoil anyone's fun. I always like to see the people coming back with their medals. I think the weather will be perfect on Sunday. Not rainy and not too hot.

Satsumastocking · 22/04/2023 00:14

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:05

Yeah, 35 minutes isn't 15 minutes though, is it? 35 minutes you could easily be talking about dodgy bits of islington, hoxton, vauxhall, North Kensington, bermondsey, Euston etc.

i am trying and failing to think of anywhere less than 15 min walk from Westminster that could be described as 'a normal neighbourhood'. I'm assuming they mean Pimlico. Which really isn't 'a normal neighbourhood', even if it does have a Boots and some pubs.

Presumably the children who go to Pimlico school live close by. Admittedly I did just look up the Tachbrook estate and the other Peabody estate on Vauxhall Bridge Road and they're 21 minutes and 18 minutes away respectively according to Citymapper...but despite my short legs I tend to get to places a few minutes faster than Citymapper predicts. :) And there'll be non-Peabody housing there too.

limitedperiodonly · 22/04/2023 00:03

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 22:43

100 years ago my family lived on or just off Brick Lane, Whitechapel Road, the Cut and the Old Kent Road

The fact that these were working class neighbourhoods a century ago says absolutely nothing about what they're like now

There are tourist tours around Brick Lane now. If I moved there (not that I could afford it) it would be laughable bollocks to claim that it was 'an ordinary neighbourhood' because of what it was like a century ago.

Anyway I remember your posts. You grew up in Essex. You living in an expensive area of central London has fuck all to do with where your grandparents lived. Just like if I moved to Brick Lane it would have no link to my grandparents.

Ooh! @Bamboux That's quite creepy, but flattering. Is it just me or there other people on Mumsnet you pay close attention to?

I have no interest in your family history and no need to explain myself to you. I've lived here for a very long time and so has my family.

I'm happy for people to come to Parliament Square, which as I say is 15 minutes walk from my house, for whatever reason they want so long as they are not going to hurt me. No one has ever done so and I don't own the place.

I don't think the people who'll come here tomorrow for the Earth Day or whatever they want to call it or on Sunday for the London Marathon will do that. I didn't mind when the Countryside Alliance people came here or the anti Iraq war protestors or various Stop The City protests or the Black Lives Matter people did.

When the place is shut down for the state opening of Parliament every year or for Kate and William's wedding or Margaret Thatcher's funeral or the Queen's funeral I just walk round it. I don't need to agree with it, which is just as well, because no one asks me.

Like I said, to another poster who doesn't live here but was getting her panties in a bunch about disruption, it's a historic centre of protest and celebration and I don't own the place. If I'm not getting annoyed about it I don't know why she would. And I don't know why you would either.

You can come if you want.

Inkblue · 21/04/2023 23:10

The footage from today looked pretty laid back. It will be busy in central London but not ridiculously so. They are expecting about 50,000 people which is not a lot for London really. I’ve certainly been to bigger events. As OP says, it’s billed as a family day and looking at the order of events, there are lots of smaller events going on for kids.

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:05

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 23:02

I live about 35 minutes' walk away and have done all my life.

Yeah, 35 minutes isn't 15 minutes though, is it? 35 minutes you could easily be talking about dodgy bits of islington, hoxton, vauxhall, North Kensington, bermondsey, Euston etc.

i am trying and failing to think of anywhere less than 15 min walk from Westminster that could be described as 'a normal neighbourhood'. I'm assuming they mean Pimlico. Which really isn't 'a normal neighbourhood', even if it does have a Boots and some pubs.

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 23:02

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:00

There aren't very many of those. At all. How well do you know London?

I live about 35 minutes' walk away and have done all my life.

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:01

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 22:50

Most of us here in central London are working or under class and live in social housing actually.

You live less than 15 minutes walk from Parliament?

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:00

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 22:55

Surely the normal Londoners who live within fifteeninutes' walk are evidence of it?!

There aren't very many of those. At all. How well do you know London?

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 23:00

Devoutspoken · 21/04/2023 22:07

Bamboux, so it's not protests per se, that you are against, just this one ?

Yes . I've been part of loads of marches and protests. Including protests against the Criminal Justice Bill and anti nazi protests, among others. I've taken my own children on several demos.

my dad was arrested in 1968 on a student protest. My mum was at the first ever sit-in in Britain. My grandfather and great uncle were at Cable St (on the right side) and fought respectively in ww2 and the Spanish civil war.

I'm not at all opposed to protests in general. I have massive problems with this one.

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 22:59

Catuscatish · 21/04/2023 22:54

This. It's a jolly. It's virtue signalling but most of all its a massive waste.

I've had travel London disrupted by a bunch of mindless fools from XR. I ended up having to take several ubers to get to places by a specific time, all far more polluting than the mass transit plus walking I had planned to do (I walk a lot especially in cities). So that day because of their planet saving antics, the planet actually ended up a tiny bit worse off.

They're a bunch of thoughtless attention seeking idiots. They don't really care about the environment, all of their 'protests' and the inevitable clean up make things worse by consuming yet more of the earth's finite resources. They care about having their smug hypocritical faces on telly.

But worst of all they rile people up and turn them off of protecting the environment, rather than the opposite. Who can forget the idiot on the train at Canning Town? I don't think he was winning friends and influencing people.

Why don't they do something useful for a change. Clear up an area inundated by rubbish? Plant some trees? Remove plastics from a beach? Boycott businesses they don't approve of environmentally? Nope those things aren't high profile enough, despite actually doing some good, they won't make them feel sufficiently sanctimonious.

It's just Instagram environmentalism done for show. It has no substance.

All the people I know involved in XR do the things you suggest and more. Most work in the field, so are for example research scientists, environmental architects, lecturers, ecologists, people working in environmental education, recycling, etc..

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 22:57

As for the transport questions, yes some use coaches or public transport. Also there are many Londoners who have offered beds or sofas to people coming from outside London so they can travel in advance or stay for all three days of the protests.

Satsumastocking · 21/04/2023 22:55

Bamboux · 21/04/2023 21:16

Yes.

Nowhere that can be reached on foot within 15 mins from parliament Square is even slightly representative of any aspect of the UK, or even London, population.

Feel free to quote the statistics that prove otherwise.

Surely the normal Londoners who live within fifteeninutes' walk are evidence of it?!