Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Automatic car advice please , not drove for years

63 replies

Thedreammuststayalive · 20/04/2023 05:20

Hi hoping this is the right place to post as couldn’t find a car area.
I’m looking for advice please , back story is I passed my test first time around 8 years ago then I pretty much bought a car straight away everything was ok for a few months even drove on motorway to a holiday , then one day I stupidly made a mistake and reversed into a bollard in a car park, causing the back bumper damage. After that incident I panicked a lot and felt sick having to drive so probably driving anxiety.
I spent just over 3k on this car , I didn’t get it fixed as the damage was a scrape of paint off and it bent inwards a little.m so still ok to drive etc . Anyway my long term partner then had an issue with helping pay for the next insurance etc he works I don’t so decided as I wasn’t enjoying driving would sell the car so after approx 8 months of having this car we sold it pretty much got the 3k back so no issues.
Since then I’ve not drove however now our children are older I’d like to drive to go places and make life easier it’s quite a long walk to do shopping etc they get tired and no buses etc where we live.
My partner suggested getting a automatic as he said you can’t stall it etc so I wouldn’t panic as much , is this correct and do you think I’d be ok driving a automatic when I’ve never before ? I did used to panic and stalled a couple of times in the manual.
id be looking at hopefully a Ford fiesta 5 door 13 plate onwards and our budget is around 8k . ( this is alot and most of our savings ) but I struggle to find one under this price because auto is more expensive then manual .
i guess I’m asking if you think I’d be ok driving a automatic after not driving for around 7 years with no auto experience. I spoke to a friend irl who said I’d soon get used to it after a hour or so it’s dead easy.

thanks for any advice

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 20/04/2023 20:09

It might not be true for everyone but many people stuff up there first car. I ruined the gearbox in mine. I had a series I of manual cars after which were fine but I do prefer the automatic I drive now.

A person in my family drove into a HOUSE in their first car...that stuffed the car up pretty conclusively!

OP, automatics are very easy to drive. You can concentrate on the road around you, and not worry about what gear you're in, etc.

RoseBucket · 20/04/2023 20:04

I’ve driven a manual for 30 years, hired a car on holiday and they were all automatic, I’d never driven one! It took about 10 minutes to work out how to drive with a redundant leg and it was fine.

strawberryicecreamice · 20/04/2023 20:04

I paid £7,800 for a 14 plate auto Ford fiesta 5 door. 32k on the clock. Def go auto. Less to worry about. Doesn't stall and most have hill start assist so you don't roll back.

junglejane66 · 20/04/2023 20:03

SmirnoffIceIsNice · 20/04/2023 19:10

I drive an automatic Fiesta. It's a doddle. You put the car into drive and off you go. Only accelerator and brake to worry about. The car changes gear for you and there is no clutch so you won't stall it.

If your budget allows it get one with rear cameras or sensors so you can better judge distance when you're reversing.

All cars have clutches otherwise it would stall, it's just in an auto the gearbox does it for you. The same if it's a torque converter or dual clutch (the clues in the name)

ShandaLear · 20/04/2023 20:00

Automatics are brilliant. I got one almost by mistake - I had my heart set on a particular second hand car at the local dealer and only found out it was automatic when I went to have a proper look at it. Tried it anyway, and fell in love. It’s like driving a dodgem car - go, stop, reverse. It’s much more sensible and intuitive than gears. I can still drive a manual when I have to but a manual is so much better.

hay5689 · 20/04/2023 19:57

@CardinalCopia was just going to say we'll all be driving autos in a few years when everything is electric.

CardinalCopia · 20/04/2023 19:51

Ive just gone full electric, so for the first time in my life I'm not driving manual. I honestly could kick myself for not doing it 30 years ago. I actually enjoy driving now and sitting in traffic is so much nicer than it was.

Notsureonusername · 20/04/2023 19:46

I have had automatics over the years and they are so easy to drive. You cannot stall an automatic. Only 2 pedals, one for go & one for stop. You have a gear stick that just goes back and fore which a basic model will have P - Park, D-Drive (forwards) & R - Reverse. If I remember correctly you could only put it in reverse if you pressed a button on the gear stick so that was another safety feature. The last auto I had was like a little dodgem car it was brilliant. If you have anxiety around driving go for one that has camera’s and parking sensors. Have as many extras as you can afford to help with the driving. Go for it.

Thedreammuststayalive · 20/04/2023 19:31

Yes thank you I will definitely book a couple of automatic lessons locally soon to see how I get on , I will explain there refresher lesson as I’ve been off the road for a few years and looking to get a automatic. I do think my nerves are worry of stalling though so hopefully I after a couple of lessons in a auto I’ll decide if I want to go ahead with it as it would make a huge difference to myself and my children’s lives if I’m able to drive many thanks everyone

OP posts:
amylou8 · 20/04/2023 19:29

Could you find a driving instructor with an automatic who will give you a few refresher lessons and get your confidence up before you commit to buying the car? DD and all her friends have learnt in an automatic, seems really common now..and she can't nick my car!

Comeshinewithme · 20/04/2023 19:20

Despite driving for a long time, I was still a nervous driver. Switching to an automatic has really helped increase my confidence, and I wish I had done it years ago. I hated having to stop on any hills but now they hold no fear for me - and no chance of rolling backwards or stalling 😁

SmirnoffIceIsNice · 20/04/2023 19:10

I drive an automatic Fiesta. It's a doddle. You put the car into drive and off you go. Only accelerator and brake to worry about. The car changes gear for you and there is no clutch so you won't stall it.

If your budget allows it get one with rear cameras or sensors so you can better judge distance when you're reversing.

TheQueenOfOverthinking · 20/04/2023 19:08

After not driving for 7 years I really think you should have some refresher lessons. After 7 years being off the road, when you are a nervous driver already, it would be quite irresponsible to just get behind the wheel and hope for the best.

bellac11 · 20/04/2023 19:02

OliveHenry · 20/04/2023 18:52

Just one thing - not all modern automatics will creep in gear (forward or reverse).

My old Saab does and it's great because it will hold itself without rolling back on pretty steep hills.

My partner's newer Peugeot 3008 doesn't, so would roll back without the handbrake on (or giving it enough revs to hold in place).

However, the Peugeot has an electronic handbrake, so you just put that on, then it takes itself off as you pull away, so it's pretty easy once you get the hang of it though.

I do find his harder to park though, as it doesn't just nudge along when manoeuvring!

Yes my OH's fiat 500 is a nightmare because I forget and end up rolling backwards!

Ive a nissan note, love it

bellac11 · 20/04/2023 19:01

Get yourself some refresher lessons in an automatic and you'll feel more confident to decide whether you should go for it

Then make sure you do a test drive of whatever cars you have your eye on and dont be forced into a decision by the salesperson

OliveHenry · 20/04/2023 18:52

Just one thing - not all modern automatics will creep in gear (forward or reverse).

My old Saab does and it's great because it will hold itself without rolling back on pretty steep hills.

My partner's newer Peugeot 3008 doesn't, so would roll back without the handbrake on (or giving it enough revs to hold in place).

However, the Peugeot has an electronic handbrake, so you just put that on, then it takes itself off as you pull away, so it's pretty easy once you get the hang of it though.

I do find his harder to park though, as it doesn't just nudge along when manoeuvring!

Wenfy · 20/04/2023 18:46

As long as it’s a proper automatic and doesn’t have a gear box that switches to semi / manual you won’t stall it.

MargaretThursday · 20/04/2023 18:41

I've always driven a manual.

However we got an automatic about a month a go. I dreaded it. All these people saying how wonderfully easy it was. I was sure I was going to prove them wrong 🤣

Well within a couple of drives I felt totally comfortable with it, and I'm not sure I would choose a manual over an automatic if I had the choice.

LisaD1 · 20/04/2023 18:13

I passed my test in a manual but I’ve driven automatic for 20+ years now and love it. Recently downsized as I walk most places so only really drive a couple of times a week and some weeks never. I’ve got an older
car that belonged to an elderly gent and only done 50k, picked her up for just over 3k and she’s a dream. My fuel is around £50 a month. Automatics are super easy to drive, good luck :)

Nickersnackersnockers · 20/04/2023 17:59

After so long off the road you should not drive until you have had some refresher lessons with an instructor. They should also include motorway driving.

Good luck though!

EustaceTheMonk · 20/04/2023 17:59

I haven't driven a manual in over 30 years. Autos are wonderful. You'll be fine.

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/04/2023 17:33

I stopped driving for about 10 years a year or so after passing my test, then found I was having difficulty, nervous about stalling like you, so moved to an automatic. Not quite “you’ll be used to it in an hour” but it transformed my driving experience.

You could have 2 or 3 lessons in an automatic to get you started.

GaspingGekko · 20/04/2023 17:32

They are definitely a lot easier to drive. If you're unsure though you could try to rent the car you're thinking of buying - or a similar automatic - from a car hire place for a day to give you a chance to try it.

Thedreammuststayalive · 20/04/2023 17:28

Thank you I am nervous about stalling so I do think an automatic will help.

OP posts:
Snowjokes · 20/04/2023 06:37

Automatics are definitely easier. Especially things like hill starts, parking or crawling in slow traffic - the car moves forward in drive and reverse unless you press the brake, there’s no clutch control (so no stalling). You only ever use your right foot.

I do think you sound particularly anxious, so like others I’d suggest you have a few driving lessons. That way you can test out an automatic with the instructor as back up, and get some support to get your nerve back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread