Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell my DC's I am adopted?

115 replies

Whatamigoingtodopleasehelp · 20/04/2023 01:11

My mum had me when when she 19. My biological dad is not on on my birth certificate. My mum married my Dad when I was 3 and he adopted me. He is the only dad I have ever known. I did meet my bio dad a few years ago, I do look like him but we are not in touch any more and probably wont be ever again.

I have two DC's 16 year old girl and 10 year old boy. I'm wondering if and when I should tell them? Is it important at this stage? I don't want it to be a big 'thing' but I guess they need to be told at some point. I can't discuss it with my mam and dad, they will take it badly. I don't want a dramatic soap opera reveal. I don't want to keep secrets either. I can't tell 16 year old without telling 10 year old at same time but they are at different stages maturity wise.

OP posts:
DoughnutDreams · 20/04/2023 06:51

I don't understand the big secret, or dramatic framing of being adopted. Most of their friends will have step-parents or blended families and yours just made it more formal. It was obviously a lovely thing to do but no great bombshell.
I wonder whether you might have mixed feelings about your situation that might be helpful to explore though?

PuttingDownRoots · 20/04/2023 06:48

I would tell them before they are old enough to do "fun" DNA tests and it throws up unexpected relatives.

Broadbeachshallow · 20/04/2023 06:45

Yes, tell them now. The longer you leave it, the more it's a big shocking reveal, rather than an everyday fact.

Give your Mum and Dad a heads-up and reassure them (no need to forewarn your bio dad).

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 20/04/2023 06:39

I don't understand why you wouldn't tell them.

My mum is in her sixties now and she was adopted by her aunt and uncle - I've always known about it. It was just normal to me and I never saw it as any kind of big deal.

Handpickled · 20/04/2023 06:37

i would tell. There is nothing to be ashamed of, it may be relevant socially or medically in the future (and could be revealed by bio dads relations) and ethically it is better not to keep secrets.

Weallgottachangesometime · 20/04/2023 06:35

I think you should tell them. It might be relevant if they have any genetic related medical issues. Also I think it would be terrible for them to find out from some other source or by accident somehow (I know lots of people are finding out from doing DNA familial websites etc).

I always think that honesty is the best policy. Giving kids information in an age appropriate manner.

At 10 and 16 you should be able to say “nanny and grampy don’t like to talk about it. So please don’t speak to them about it. But If you have any questions you can ask me at any time”.

Whilst I respect that your parents wouldn’t be happy, it’s not really fair for you to have to hide a part of your life story from your children or for them to not know their family tree. I think you can manage this sensitively. You sound like you are very thoughtful of everyone's needs.

Clymene · 20/04/2023 06:25

I would absolutely tell them. But you don't need to make a big deal about it - just say you thought they should know and the only reason you haven't told them before is because he's your dad to all intents and purposes and you forget he's not related to you.

Keeping it secret makes it seem like a much bigger deal than it is

MayThe4th · 20/04/2023 05:02

Gremlinsateit · 20/04/2023 04:40

Gosh, I would tell them. “Your grandpa is such a wonderful man. He’s my stepdad, you know, and he loved me so much he adopted me as well.”

We told the kids that H is adopted when they were tiny, just as part of family history. I know that this situation is different, but you don’t need to dwell on how much of a tit the fellow is if you don’t want to - just that he and grandma broke up, then grandma met grandpa and he became your dad.

I always remember the story of my uncle finding out as an adult that his older half siblings weren’t full siblings, and how upset he was - everyone else in the extended family knew except him. And H’s aunt, who wasn’t told until after her adoptive parents died. It’s not nice to find this stuff out as an adult.

He’s not OP’s stepdad though, he’s her dad.

Seriously this doesn’t need to be some kind of sit down talk where you confide some dark secret in your children.

I think I was about 7 when I discovered that my dad’s dad wasn’t his real dad. It was just mentioned in discussion, I don’t even think that I was told specifically, someone just made reference to it.

My uncle though was adopted and I wasn’t not told, but i was told not to just blurt it out as he was actually my cousin and my gran had adopted him. He, on the other hand, was told by a child at school when he was five that “your mum’s not your real mum,” presumably from a child who had overheard their parents gossiping.

But this isn’t the same as a child being told by their adoptive parents that they were adopted, people make far too much of this biological link further down the family, and the the almost expectation that extended family should be upset and feel betrayed at being told. Why? While your dad didn’t come into your life until you were three, their grandad has always been their grandad. They absolutely don’t need to know, but there’s nothing wrong with them knowing but it doesn’t need to be made a thing of.

I mean in reality how many of us are interested in our grandparents’ extended families? Depending on the ages likely not that much. Kids don’t have nearly the kind of connection to great aunts and uncles and second cousins as parents have to their aunts and cousins.

Question is, is your dad your dad? Or do you feel some kind of sense of loss and wish he wasn’t? Is he a good father? Because that’s what counts.

Creepyrosemary · 20/04/2023 05:00

If they ever do one of those dna tests from a website they will find out anyway and think that granny cheated on him. Just tell them, it's no big deal unless you make it a big deal.

Ted27 · 20/04/2023 04:51

I really don’t understand why you feel ashamed. Growing up with a stepfather isnt unusual - yours just went a stage further.

I have an adopted son. All the younger kids born since my son’s adoption know about it. We had a big party last year to celebrate 10 years of being adopted.
I also have a stepfather who has been married to my mum for 35 years. My mum has a quite a collection of grandchildren and great grandchildren, they all know that grandad isnt mine or my brothers dad. He is just grandad.
Its not a big deal

Gremlinsateit · 20/04/2023 04:40

Gosh, I would tell them. “Your grandpa is such a wonderful man. He’s my stepdad, you know, and he loved me so much he adopted me as well.”

We told the kids that H is adopted when they were tiny, just as part of family history. I know that this situation is different, but you don’t need to dwell on how much of a tit the fellow is if you don’t want to - just that he and grandma broke up, then grandma met grandpa and he became your dad.

I always remember the story of my uncle finding out as an adult that his older half siblings weren’t full siblings, and how upset he was - everyone else in the extended family knew except him. And H’s aunt, who wasn’t told until after her adoptive parents died. It’s not nice to find this stuff out as an adult.

palelavender · 20/04/2023 04:26

I do think you should tell them - a friend of mine nearly ended up dating her half-brother and was mortified to find out. She was adopted in one area and moved to a bigger city and so did her biological father's family. So it wasn't somebody local as it were and she didn't know she was adopted.

The other thing is health issues. You don't want to be thinking that you have a low risk of heart disease when it might in fact run rampant in your biological grandfather's family. My mother's family has a genetic problem with high cholesterol levels which I didn't seem to inherit but one of my children does seem to have inherited the gene. It is important that he knows about the gene and is ready to take medication and modify his diet in the future. I am sure there are lots of other diseases with a genetic component.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 20/04/2023 03:30

I'm adopted. Ds is adopted. I think secrecy around this is kind of odd. There's nothing to be ashamed of. Your Dad is still your Dad.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 20/04/2023 03:21

greenspaces4peace · 20/04/2023 02:58

@Whatamigoingtodopleasehelp is there a possibility that they may have half siblings in the area? that was my point. you wouldn't want your teen daughter dating her half brother.

It would be a half cousin which is legal and common in some communities. I personally wouldn't choose to and there can be a higher rate of genetic issues. It might though be a good way of broaching it with OP's parents.

memoire · 20/04/2023 03:04

JackiePlace · 20/04/2023 02:12

I wouldn't tell the children. As you said OP, your adoptive Dad was your real father. Why introduce them to the idea of some absent sperm donor who they're never going to meet anyway?
Sometimes 'secrets' should be kept if it's for the good of all involved.

I don't see the point of keeping it a secret? "Grand dad became my stepdad when he married Grandma, and he loved me/us so much he adopted me" is a point of interest, not some huge terrible secret that could destabilise the kids or tear the family apart (like "your dad's not your biological dad").

If you actually keep it a secret unnecessarily though, it could come across as shocking and destabilising to them when they're adults. (They may need to know for health/genetic reasons btw.) It's not going to be a big deal at all when they're kids.

greenspaces4peace · 20/04/2023 02:58

@Whatamigoingtodopleasehelp is there a possibility that they may have half siblings in the area? that was my point. you wouldn't want your teen daughter dating her half brother.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 20/04/2023 02:50

My DH was adopted by his mothers 2nd husband. Our kids have always known this. It's never been a secret. Not sure why you never would have told them

mumofjackandamy · 20/04/2023 02:49

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

DGay · 20/04/2023 02:49

Yes go ahead. My son always knew and I made sure granddaughter knows too. No reason they shouldn't know their family history.

Happyhappyday · 20/04/2023 02:42

In my limited experience, kids tend to roll with stuff like this way better when they are younger. Ex, my dd (4)’s best buddy was conceived via donor sperm, while mum was pregnant she started dating a really nice guy who was on board with pregnancy. 5 years down the line, they are happily together and just had another kid. My DD just knows that she has a daddy but other kid has a “Henry” (not his real name) and a Henry is just like a daddy except other kid wasn’t made with parts of him. Neither kid is phased at all. So I’d just tell them, especially since it’s related to two generations above.

Softsoftsleep · 20/04/2023 02:41

Would it be a secret that would have to keep?

PippaF2 · 20/04/2023 02:37

I found out my Dad was adopted when I was about 8yrs old, sometime around then. Can't 100% remember. But they did hold off telling me until I was of an age where I could understand not to bring it up infront of my Grandparents. That was their key reason for telling me later. I don't think they waited for a specific age but more a specific level of maturity, which is different for each kid.

I had a few questions - but this was the whole truth for my case - Grandma and Grandad couldn't have a baby, so they adopted.

When I asked well what happened to the other people - I was told - the lady couldn't take care of him but must have loved him very much to make sure he went to such lovely people. My Mum was very much like - sometimes we have to put the needs of others ahead of our own and your Grandparents are your Grandparents and they are Daddy's parents. There was some explanation on how we don't talk about it with my Grandparents because they raised him and they love him just like he was their own, so it would upset them to be asked lots of questions.

I was definitely old enough to grasp that as a concept and respect it. I never had a conversation with my Grandparents about it.

I think it helped that everyone in the scenario was painted as an incredibly nice person! Your adoption is different to my Dad's. My Dad's was a social services, he didn't know any of his birth family type of adoption.

So my advice would be to tell them but do so matter of fact and just allow them to ask questions. 16yrs and 10yrs is a different age group to when I found out but I do remember neither of my parents made a big thing out of it, and they told me in a way that wasn't emotional, which meant I was able to explore the topic and ask my own questions, rather than be 'told' alot of stuff.

Like I say, I was a bit younger than your kids, so I understand the reasons my parents took the approach they did. But it really wasn't a big deal.

HoppingPavlova · 20/04/2023 02:35

I wouldn't tell the children. As you said OP, your adoptive Dad was* your real father. Why introduce them to the idea of some absent sperm donor who they're never going to meet anyway?
Sometimes 'secrets' should be kept if it's for the good of all involved.*

Completely agree. There is no need to tell them anything. I also disagree it’s a secret, your dad actually is your dad and that’s the truth, which is likely all you have ever told your kids, that ye is your dad. Why do you need to complicate this and go into a sperm donor? If it was directly relevant to them, in that THEIR dad was not their biological dad then that’s a different matter and you would say they have the right to know. But, this is not about their dad, it’s about your dad, so they have no need or right to know anything other than he is your dad.

Ponderingwindow · 20/04/2023 02:31

I knew about my dad’s adoption under similar circumstances starting around age 4-5. I may have been told earlier, but that is my first distinct memory of it. It was always just a fact.

we Definitely never specifically told our dd. we just would mention it periodically from early on. just like we would mention other semi-interesting tidbits of the family tree to keep them all nice and normal.

Whatamigoingtodopleasehelp · 20/04/2023 02:29

My biological dad hasn’t got any other kids. He is a bit of a tit. But we still live in the same small town and there is a small chance we could bump in to him at some point. He knows I have two kids, last time I bumped in to him I told him but he wasn’t too fussed so I don’t think he will be too upset. The kids certainly aren’t missing out on another grandparent in their lives. I don’t think he cares.

OP posts: