Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell my DC's I am adopted?

115 replies

Whatamigoingtodopleasehelp · 20/04/2023 01:11

My mum had me when when she 19. My biological dad is not on on my birth certificate. My mum married my Dad when I was 3 and he adopted me. He is the only dad I have ever known. I did meet my bio dad a few years ago, I do look like him but we are not in touch any more and probably wont be ever again.

I have two DC's 16 year old girl and 10 year old boy. I'm wondering if and when I should tell them? Is it important at this stage? I don't want it to be a big 'thing' but I guess they need to be told at some point. I can't discuss it with my mam and dad, they will take it badly. I don't want a dramatic soap opera reveal. I don't want to keep secrets either. I can't tell 16 year old without telling 10 year old at same time but they are at different stages maturity wise.

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 20/04/2023 11:50

Ah. I think you should have told them 14 & 8 years ago so they were brought up 'knowing'. That's the advice for adopted children, and I think grandchildren should be the same.

If your eldest is doing GCSEs I'd now wait until after then and then tell them both, similarly if she has end y12 exams, just in case it causes any wobbles.

I probably should have told you this before, but Granddad isn't my biological dad. Gran had me before she met Granddad and he adopted me when I was 3. I didn't tell you before as it makes no difference to me - he is my Dad - but I have realised you need to know if only because it isn't something that needs to / should be hidden, and it might be relevant if you are ever asked about family medical history.

monsteramunch · 20/04/2023 11:41

@Gremlinsateit

Gosh, I would tell them. “Your grandpa is such a wonderful man. He’s my stepdad, you know, and he loved me so much he adopted me as well.”

She definitely shouldn't say this because it undermines his role completely.

He isn't her stepdad.

He's her dad.

budgiegirl · 20/04/2023 09:51

I was adopted at birth. I grew up always knowing I was adopted, I must have been told when I was very, very young, but I don't remember. It was never a secret, or something to be ashamed about. It was actually made to be something special, I remember someone saying to me once how wonderful it was that someone wanted me so much that they adopted me.

My children have also always known about my family history. Why wouldn't I tell them, it's part of me and therefore part of them. They also don't ever remember being told, as they were young at the time.

Adoption shouldn't be a secret, IMO, unless for very specific reasons. It's a wonderful thing, a true gift.

That said, I was lucky that my mum and dad were very supportive, open and happy for me to tell others. There was no perceived shame. It would be trickier if your parents will take it badly. Talk to them, help them to understand why you would want to tell your children.

LowFlyingDucks · 20/04/2023 09:42

I haven’t rtft. But OP I believe it is best to tell children about this as soon as is possible, to do as gently as you can - do it as an opening, allow them to ask questions and try not to be uptight about it otherwise they will pick it up and think it’s a taboo subject.

Be ready for questIons like ‘have you met your birth parents’? Do you want to find them? Can we meet them? and these questions may come up, whenever. They might ask painful questions. Think about how you’ll manage that without making them feel bad for wanting to know. If you feel you can handle their questions, then you are ready to do it.

In the long run, it will deepen the relationship between you and your children to not feel like you have a secret and for them to know something about you which is important to you.

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 20/04/2023 09:40

I am in my sixties and have a similar background. I can't even remember when I told my DC about it but they grew up knowing that my much loved dad was not my biological dad. It wasn't a big deal to them, just part of our family history.

Tdcp · 20/04/2023 09:30

My mum was adopted by her dad, I always knew, it was just a 'matter of fact' kind of deal. I've never been adversely affected by the knowledge.

PippaF2 · 20/04/2023 09:08

MarciaSaysANumber · 20/04/2023 07:01

These two points are so important, they need repeating.

  1. Encountering blood relatives without knowing you are related to them.

  2. Inherited health issues. I’m amazed so many people have glossed over this. I can scarcely think of a medical appointment (including opticians) where I haven’t been asked whether other members of my family have any of a variety of health concerns. There are potentially really serious implications if those treating you don’t have access to full and accurate information.

Alot of people don't though. I don't know of health related issues on my Dad's side.

I do know though that when it comes to being asked the question- saying my Dad was adopted so I don't know about his side of the family - Is an honest answer. Medical people collecting that info can risk assess it as they see fit.

Lovesacake · 20/04/2023 08:14

My cousin wasn’t told that her mum was adopted, I felt really bad when she would be saying ‘oh I’ve inherited my physical features/interests etc from my grandad/grandma’ when every other person there knew that she had no biological link to her grandparents. I think it would’ve been far better for her to know the truth as it does feel disrespectful to exclude her from knowledge that everyone else has.

DilemmaDelilah · 20/04/2023 07:35

The concern for me would be the possibility of my children coming across any children of my biological father and developing a sexual relationship. That is why I think it is important to know who your relatives are. I have heard several stories of adopted children of the same parents meeting each other and, not knowing, even getting married. That is why I would ensure that my children knew.

Tigofigo · 20/04/2023 07:31

I'd tell them.

They might be wondering why you don't look like grandad

They might want to know their medical history in the future

They might have half siblings in the area

user1492757084 · 20/04/2023 07:28

Your kids should be told. It is their biological information too.
Your daughter is old enough to be sensitive to the feelings of her grandparents, so I would tell the grandparents then her.

I would plan to tell your son at about 16 or 17 too.
Tell your daughter your plans so she possibly would tell him if you had an accident or sudden death.

The reason I would tell them is out of sheer respect for them knowing about themselves, their family history and health issues. They also then are alerted to family names etc should they date a cousin in future.

RomanticizingHeroine · 20/04/2023 07:26

Some posters are referring to her dad as her "step dad". He's not - an adoptive father is legally the father.

It's still important that the DC know she's adopted. I think it's rather wonderful that he came into her life when she was 3 and she got a daddy. Adoption is not a dirty secret.

Birdsongsinging · 20/04/2023 07:25

I would tell them because it is such a normal, reasonable, thing that there is no reason not to. Not telling them makes it a secret and maybe lying by omission.

I would try and do it casually when talking about relationships although it may be a bit late for that to work as well. Why do you think it would be more difficult for your son to accept? That makes it potentially more important that you think through how best to do it.

Spiderboy · 20/04/2023 07:23

We’re pretty transparent in my family and this would have been a casual conversation a long time ago. No big deal…families come in many different ways and I can’t see any benefit to being hush hush about it. Just tell them both

RomanticizingHeroine · 20/04/2023 07:19

JackiePlace · 20/04/2023 02:12

I wouldn't tell the children. As you said OP, your adoptive Dad was your real father. Why introduce them to the idea of some absent sperm donor who they're never going to meet anyway?
Sometimes 'secrets' should be kept if it's for the good of all involved.

Bad advice.

Your DC will find out. Possibly after you die when going through your papers and they find your birth and adoption certificates and you nor your parents will be there to explain.

Just tell them about it and ask them not to tell your parents as it will upset them. Your dad is still your dad and grandad is still their grandad and that's that.

Rosula · 20/04/2023 07:18

HoppingPavlova · 20/04/2023 02:35

I wouldn't tell the children. As you said OP, your adoptive Dad was* your real father. Why introduce them to the idea of some absent sperm donor who they're never going to meet anyway?
Sometimes 'secrets' should be kept if it's for the good of all involved.*

Completely agree. There is no need to tell them anything. I also disagree it’s a secret, your dad actually is your dad and that’s the truth, which is likely all you have ever told your kids, that ye is your dad. Why do you need to complicate this and go into a sperm donor? If it was directly relevant to them, in that THEIR dad was not their biological dad then that’s a different matter and you would say they have the right to know. But, this is not about their dad, it’s about your dad, so they have no need or right to know anything other than he is your dad.

I'd tell them because it would be better to hear this from their mother rather than via a chance encounter with their biological grandfather in the town, or if they decide to do so ancestry research at some point.

Hillrunning · 20/04/2023 07:17

I think you are over thinking this. You were raised by your biological mother and step father. This is a very normal situation for many many people. Fairly run of the mill really. The fact that he took on parental responsibility formally through adoption isn't particularly relevant for your children and I think focusing on that element could muddy the waters for them and could cause unnecessary worry for them.

Find ways to bring it up organically. There must be photos of you as a baby or wedding photos or friends of theirs who are being raised by step parents and story lines in TV shows.

JMKid · 20/04/2023 07:10

My step dad raised me from the age of 4, never seen biological dad since I was 3. He died this year. I won't tell DC step dad isn't bio dad as I think it's irrelevant. As far as I'm concerned he is my dad and that's all that matters.

StamppotAndGravy · 20/04/2023 07:07

It's fairly likely that several of their friends have step dads, maybe even in the same situation as you. It might be something that could come up naturally one day, where you can just drop in my dad is my dad even though he's my step dad.

helpfulperson · 20/04/2023 07:01

Now DNA testing is something you give as a Christmas present it is vital they know because it will come out as soon as someone in the family does one and the dots don't join up.

We are going to be doing some thinking as a society about what family and ancestors mean in coming years. Obviously he is your father but are his parents your grandparents, his grandparents uour great grandparents etc. Whose family tree would your children follow back. They have a bilogical lineage and a societal one. They need to be prepared for this.

MarciaSaysANumber · 20/04/2023 07:01

palelavender · 20/04/2023 04:26

I do think you should tell them - a friend of mine nearly ended up dating her half-brother and was mortified to find out. She was adopted in one area and moved to a bigger city and so did her biological father's family. So it wasn't somebody local as it were and she didn't know she was adopted.

The other thing is health issues. You don't want to be thinking that you have a low risk of heart disease when it might in fact run rampant in your biological grandfather's family. My mother's family has a genetic problem with high cholesterol levels which I didn't seem to inherit but one of my children does seem to have inherited the gene. It is important that he knows about the gene and is ready to take medication and modify his diet in the future. I am sure there are lots of other diseases with a genetic component.

These two points are so important, they need repeating.

  1. Encountering blood relatives without knowing you are related to them.

  2. Inherited health issues. I’m amazed so many people have glossed over this. I can scarcely think of a medical appointment (including opticians) where I haven’t been asked whether other members of my family have any of a variety of health concerns. There are potentially really serious implications if those treating you don’t have access to full and accurate information.

dittbtdity · 20/04/2023 07:01

Happyhappyday · 20/04/2023 02:42

In my limited experience, kids tend to roll with stuff like this way better when they are younger. Ex, my dd (4)’s best buddy was conceived via donor sperm, while mum was pregnant she started dating a really nice guy who was on board with pregnancy. 5 years down the line, they are happily together and just had another kid. My DD just knows that she has a daddy but other kid has a “Henry” (not his real name) and a Henry is just like a daddy except other kid wasn’t made with parts of him. Neither kid is phased at all. So I’d just tell them, especially since it’s related to two generations above.

Wow this seems complicated, not sure I understand what's going on here......

moonspiral · 20/04/2023 06:59

You need to tell them. If they are asked about family history at the doctors at any point they need to know they don't know that part of the family's genetic history.

FlamingoQueen · 20/04/2023 06:58

You were adopted my a man who (I assume) has been in your life for many years and he is (again, I assume) a kind hearted Dad/ Grandad. It says a lot more about him, that he adopted you and raised you as his own from such a young age.
I’d have thought that was actually worth celebrating.
I don’t think it has to be a big deal - some children that are adopted have no idea at all where they are from - I think you are one of the lucky ones.

BooksAndHooks · 20/04/2023 06:55

I found out when doing the family tree. I found it very strange that they had never told me. Much better to be honest keeping secrets makes it a much bigger deal.