Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New team member problem with SM & appearing on the internet

92 replies

SanJayH · 19/04/2023 21:25

I have a new member of my team who’s just started at the company. She flew through the interview and I think she’s going to be great at her job. We were completing the induction process by having pictures taken for her work badge and her profile on the website, but she suddenly announced that she couldn’t appear on any kind of social media or our website due to ‘personal reasons’.

I totally respect she is entitled to her privacy but we work in an industry which it’s kind of expected to appear on various social media platforms and on checking with HR I was informed it’s company policy to appear with a picture and profile on our website.

I’m a bit stuck as to how best proceed so I wondered if anyone else had experience of this?

OP posts:
Reugny · 19/04/2023 22:45

Fulltimetwathead · 19/04/2023 22:39

Ew your company sound like those LinkedIn golf selfie dickheads. LinkedIn used to be about CPD and job opportunities. Now it's just #bossbabe #Imcrying #workhardplayhard and #golfday

Sounds terrible.

😂

Greenfairydust · 19/04/2023 22:44

Your company policy needs to be updated.

You cannot just use someone's picture without their permission. They have stated they do not want their image to be shared and you have to respect that.

As for ''big personalities'', which I assume means gossipy, irritating busybodies, it is none of their business and they should focus on their own work instead.

Baabaa75 · 19/04/2023 22:39

You can't force someone to use social media and have their name/photo on the website, there are all sorts of reasons why someone may not want this. Your HR sounds awful!

Fulltimetwathead · 19/04/2023 22:39

Ew your company sound like those LinkedIn golf selfie dickheads. LinkedIn used to be about CPD and job opportunities. Now it's just #bossbabe #Imcrying #workhardplayhard and #golfday

Sounds terrible.

Justalittlebitduckling · 19/04/2023 22:36

I’m just concerned now as it may cause friction within the team as there are some big and opinionated personalities

If this is the case then the problem is the culture of the workplace and the “big personalities” who may hassle her over this, not the individual in question.

OutDamnedSpot · 19/04/2023 22:25

It’s a shit policy and the ‘big personalities’ are bullies. Go back to HR and fight her corner. Or, better, just don’t expect anything on SM.

Greyarea12 · 19/04/2023 22:22

Well the bullies, sorry, 'big personalities' need to be dealt with accordingly should they decide to bully question anybody about something that is none of their business.

begoneday · 19/04/2023 22:13

What a ridiculous company policy. People are entitled to privacy and boundaries between personal life and work. Because of the rise of documenting every aspect of a persons life on social media, I think these boundaries have become blurred. Good for her, to want to protect her boundaries.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 19/04/2023 22:12

I’m just concerned now as it make cause friction within the team as there are some big and opinionated personalities, I’m concerned some colleagues will find this odd and it may cause unwanted questions and judgement for her.

Then their manager needs to manage that and make sure these “big and opinionated personalities” aren’t actually bullies. She has every right to be protected from their “unwanted questions and judgement”.

edwinbear · 19/04/2023 22:10

I’m one of those ‘big personalities’ at work. If a new member of the team joined and my line manager told me they would not be going on the website for personal reasons, I’d completely respect that and not ask questions - most people (even the opinionated ones) will be perfectly aware that there are many reasons people cannot be visible online.

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 19/04/2023 22:07

Maybe she's in witness protection, you need to back of and respect her wishes

321user123 · 19/04/2023 22:03

She could have religious reasons - Jewish or Muslim or maybe she’s escaped abuse?

what a stupid policy!

SnackSizeRaisin · 19/04/2023 22:01

SanJayH · 19/04/2023 21:47

I agree it’s not legally enforceable and think HR have just brushed it off. I’m just concerned now as it make cause friction within the team as there are some big and opinionated personalities, I’m concerned some colleagues will find this odd and it may cause unwanted questions and judgement for her.

I’ll go back to HR in the morning and inform them her picture won’t be going on the website.

Surely your team can understand there may be good reasons for her not being on public view, unless they are all extremely dim! Personality size is nothing to do with it.

JudgeRudy · 19/04/2023 21:59

Whilst she might have very good reasons for not wanting to be on SM, the point really is that unless the contract explicitly states that photos can be shared, I think her just saying she doesn't want to is a valid reason.
I was asked to consent to this. I made up my own consent form and said that I wanted all pics of me submitting for consideration before I consent. In reality that's kind of what we did anyway, but I wanted to maintain my right to decline. It irritated management that I was awkward and they said that they wouldn't share/publish without my blessing, so I said in that case, these new concent forms weren't needed!

JassyRadlett · 19/04/2023 21:58

SanJayH · 19/04/2023 21:47

I agree it’s not legally enforceable and think HR have just brushed it off. I’m just concerned now as it make cause friction within the team as there are some big and opinionated personalities, I’m concerned some colleagues will find this odd and it may cause unwanted questions and judgement for her.

I’ll go back to HR in the morning and inform them her picture won’t be going on the website.

I have a couple of 'big and opinionated' personalities in my team; I find they need semi-regular very clear and unambiguous reminders that they have zero right to know about what's going on with other people unless other people choose to share it; decisions that have been made about other colleagues will have been made for good reasons but sometimes they don't get to know what those reasons are because they're private to the individual in question, and expressing their opinions on what the colleague should be doing could in some cases constitute harassment against colleagues who may have protected characteristics or other sensitive situations.

I've got one going on at the moment where someone is demanding an accommodation on the basis that 'other people do it'; I have nearly gone hoarse repeating 'remember you don't get to know what's going on with other people.'

Chattycathydoll · 19/04/2023 21:57

@tenbob you sound like a fabulous manager.

UWhatNow · 19/04/2023 21:57

I have no reason to object but I hate it too. The idea that SM is now so ubiquitous that anybody who objects to it is seen as weird. I like my anonymity and don’t want my photo or personal details out there connected with my job of work. It’s presumptuous and intrusive for employers to even make the assumption.

carriedout · 19/04/2023 21:56

Agree the 'big personalities' need to wind their necks in or you will have to have a chat.

Glad you are doing the right thing - no one should have to have their face on a work website except for roles that are expressly promotional or senior leaders i.e. where you would automatically expect it.

tenbob · 19/04/2023 21:55

Unless she is the CEO, there isn’t much need to have her listed on the website and featuring heavily on LinkedIn etc

Ive spent 20 years in comms and marketing roles, where I have been in charge of the company website, LinkedIn, SM, putting people forward for press articles etc and have come across this a few times.

My stock response is ‘ok that’s absolutely fine. If anything changes on the future and you want to be added, please let me know.
There will be some work conferences where the delegate lists and their companies will appear on the event website, so if you are planning on attending any conferences or similar events, please flag this to me so we can make sure you’re not included.

Im not going to pry but I am going to make you aware we have a corporate security manager, an employee support scheme and a supportive management, should you need any of them in the future.

She will have valid reasons, and no business reason will override them

thecatsthecats · 19/04/2023 21:54

SanJayH · 19/04/2023 21:47

I agree it’s not legally enforceable and think HR have just brushed it off. I’m just concerned now as it make cause friction within the team as there are some big and opinionated personalities, I’m concerned some colleagues will find this odd and it may cause unwanted questions and judgement for her.

I’ll go back to HR in the morning and inform them her picture won’t be going on the website.

I dealt with issues like this very firmly within my team. Some people forget that their "big personality" isn't appropriate at work.

If they were raised in public, I would say that it was not a matter up for discussion. If raised in private, then the same, but in much stricter words and tone.

If raised again, then a very serious reminder that any further intrusive questions would become a disciplinary matter.

Paq · 19/04/2023 21:52

Your "big personalities" need to be more sensitive. I think that people are going to be much more careful about an online presence and SM use in the future. My teenaged nephews are both really aware of how SM exploits their data and are withdrawing from it a lot.

If your business model requires people to be on SM as themselves I'd really question it.

C152 · 19/04/2023 21:50

Agree with others - your Company's policy needs immediate revising. There are lots of legitimate reasons people may not wish to publicise their photo - fleeing domestic violence/stalkers springs to mind.

Irissa · 19/04/2023 21:50

Irissa · 19/04/2023 21:48

Your HR are wrong. (We have had similar in our workplace.)

Not only can you not enforce this as a policy, but to have a photo on the website request a consent form, data protection statement and so on.

She has every right to refuse.

Requires, not “request”

Irissa · 19/04/2023 21:48

Your HR are wrong. (We have had similar in our workplace.)

Not only can you not enforce this as a policy, but to have a photo on the website request a consent form, data protection statement and so on.

She has every right to refuse.

Anothnamechang · 19/04/2023 21:47

As someone who never shares where I work or have anything location wise on sm due to an abusive ex I understand!

My ex husband found out where I worked once& he continuously called my work with ‘complaints’. In the end they had to send him a cease and desist!