Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend pissing my children off - do I just tell her?

257 replies

Givenupgivingashit · 19/04/2023 21:16

Ok so may be me or my DD's being oversensitive here, but here goes. My shift patterns have changed so I now have to leave 2 youngest DD's (6&7) with a friend 3 days a week so she can take them to school for me. Return favour is that I can pick up her 2 DDs from school on the same days.

I drop them off at 7.30am, they are ready for school and have had breakfast so all they do is play with her DD's until they leave the house at 8.15ish. This has been the routine for the last 2 weeks since the Easter holidays.

This morning, eldest DD seemed to be a bit quiet when they were on the way to friend's house, and was seemingly wanting to tell me something when I dropped them off, but didn't so I didn't think any more about it until this evening when friend had picked up her 2 from me, then DD said that she thought that the friend didn't seem to like them very much and was a bit "strict" with them during their early mornings with her.

When I asked her what she meant, there were a few specific things which my friend seems to impose on my children which she obviously does with hers;

  • making sure that their shoes are clean, and if they've been in the garden and they're a bit muddy then they have to be wiped clean (uppers not just soles)
  • they have to spend 15 minutes doing their reading books (mine do this night before but she makes hers and mine do it too)
  • she fills their water bottles with bottled water, tells them it's better for them than tap water (which I fill them with)
  • makes them do up their ties/top buttons, even though they're more comfortable undone and school isn't bothered

I'm not sure whether this is just me being picky, or I have lax standards, or whether I should just be grateful that she's able to take them at that time in the morning and drop at school etc? Or should I say something?

OP posts:
memoire · 20/04/2023 02:49

Is wearing a tie and doing up the top button really that bad? My DC do it everyday! It is fully enforced at their school, but even if not every teacher at OP's school cares, I'm sure stricter teachers occasionally will anyway.

So I don't see it as changing the uniform, but getting them to follow uniform rules. Yes, she's not a teacher but she is responsible for them, and in her mind she could be obliged to ensure they look okay turning up for school. So as long as my DC weren't very physically uncomfortable, I wouldn't kick up a fuss.

And again, I think looking presentable is a good life skill. Even for students! The invariably well-groomed and presentable children, usually from better backgrounds, used to get lots of peer-voted or adult-selected leadership opportunities back at my school (which straddled 2 very different socioeconomic areas). I'm not super fussed but it's good to at least have that option, no?

That said if she really is criticising and nitpicking as opposed to issuing simple instructions, that's not okay.

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 02:04

memoire · 20/04/2023 01:22

Commenting on appearance (eg fat, or even scruffy if child happens to be the messy kind) is unacceptable, but let's not conflate simple instructions concerning clean shoes and buttons with that... If my child is physically uncomfortable, yes I would politely say something, but framing it as "commenting on their appearance" comes across as exaggeration tbh. Why stir up drama unnecessarily

I would also rather someone filled my child's water bottle than left it empty. I wouldn't take it personally if they preferred bottled water

Yes agreed child minder would be better overall

She had no right to tell a child to do their button up. It doesn’t impact her at all, unlike the mud, which she will end up cleaning up and therefore makes sense. Why stir up drama? How about why make a child change how their uniform is when their own mum doesn’t mind? It’s a weird thing to do.

Topping up or filling the water bottle up because it’s empty is different to pouring the tap water out and refilling. We’ll have to see if OP clarifies which it is.

DahliaRose3 · 20/04/2023 02:04

I wonder too if it’s her manner with the children - the way she talks to them which isn’t nice.

StoneSkipping · 20/04/2023 01:55

memoire · 20/04/2023 01:22

Commenting on appearance (eg fat, or even scruffy if child happens to be the messy kind) is unacceptable, but let's not conflate simple instructions concerning clean shoes and buttons with that... If my child is physically uncomfortable, yes I would politely say something, but framing it as "commenting on their appearance" comes across as exaggeration tbh. Why stir up drama unnecessarily

I would also rather someone filled my child's water bottle than left it empty. I wouldn't take it personally if they preferred bottled water

Yes agreed child minder would be better overall

It is commenting on appearance and shouldn’t be done. It’s unnecessary and not her business. It’s not drama, you just don’t do it. Their parent is aware of it and is ok with it so butt out.

The shoes thing is fine, the mud causes her more work to clean up.

The water bottle thing wouldn’t bother me unless she did actually pour the water I’d provided away, although my daughter wouldn’t drink bottled water so I’d have to say something, if my daughter didn’t.

The reading thing, she’s probably doing to make her life easier to stop her kids moaning. If it was me, I wouldn’t make my friends kids do it, I’d just tell my own kids they’re doing it as they don’t do it in the evenings unlike friends kids.

Goodread1 · 20/04/2023 01:49

I can see why your children may find doing top button slightly uncomfortable
That's it

Goodread1 · 20/04/2023 01:47

I agree She sounds good, and has what you call good standards and runs everything like clockwork

She treated your children like her own, which stands out,

Nothing Weird here, unlike what @Mum2jenny said,

The water bottle thing,

Sounds very much She or her children does not like the taste of water much prefers bottle water instead, is it hard or soft water area place you live at @Givenupgivingashit ?
or dislikes the chemical put into water, to purify the water , or added to water to help with keeping teeth strong for children, what's the chemical called ?
I can't rember

Only thing about bottle water,

I drink bottle water quite often

I have found occasionally once with certain flavored water 💧 bottle,
I could taste the weird flavour of chemical taste of the bottle, which was off putting 🤔,

Are you very or somewhat lakisy daisy @Givenupgivingashit then?
Not organised, dashing here and there ect,?

OctopusComplex · 20/04/2023 01:23

Love the pp post about looking for the note behind the note.

I went to a childminder before school, and nothing she did was mean or difficult, it just felt really alien, and that is a difficult emotion to articulate.

I'm not saying you should keep them home, but acknowledge that it feels unsettling, but that it would be odd for her to apply different rules to her own child.

I suspect she's just not very warm, which can feel even stricter to a child. She doesn't have to be, but completely understand their disquiet.

memoire · 20/04/2023 01:22

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 01:15

I’d say it for my children if necessary rather than them having them upset. It’s not a big issue for someone to just leave a water bottle alone or not comment on their appearance. Just don’t do it. It’s not necessary and it’s bothering the kids. It’s not a power struggle to speak up for your kids, if she takes it as one, it shows she’s a weirdo and I wouldn’t want my kids with her anyway.

Probably better to just get a childminder. This woman can’t be that much of a friend if OP can’t chat honestly about this sort of thing.

Commenting on appearance (eg fat, or even scruffy if child happens to be the messy kind) is unacceptable, but let's not conflate simple instructions concerning clean shoes and buttons with that... If my child is physically uncomfortable, yes I would politely say something, but framing it as "commenting on their appearance" comes across as exaggeration tbh. Why stir up drama unnecessarily

I would also rather someone filled my child's water bottle than left it empty. I wouldn't take it personally if they preferred bottled water

Yes agreed child minder would be better overall

YerArseInParsley · 20/04/2023 01:21

Does the school have a breakfast club as you may not want to rely on your friend long term?

YerArseInParsley · 20/04/2023 01:17

I suspect the kids don't like going because they are being made to do homework before school, no kid likes doing homework so that could be the issue.

The water thing is a bit odd but no major issue.

I think you need to tell your kids it's their routine and they need to fit into that. If you mention all this to your friend you risk losing the childcare as she may start to feel awkward.

Matchymatchylemonscratchy · 20/04/2023 01:15

Having looked at the title of your thread again, compared to what is actually happening, you are being very unreasonable!!

Your kids need to learn that other people do things differently and if you genuinely have an issue with it, start paying for a child minder.

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 01:15

memoire · 20/04/2023 00:58

Yeah but that's coming from a child (your daughter)... I think for an adult (OP) to get involved would be too much of a petty power struggle.

I just don't think clean shoes, buttoned tops and extra reading time are the end of the world?? That's why I read it as a tiny bit of a power struggle

The friend probably can't be arsed about OP's kids, but she has to use the same standards in case her own kids complain

I’d say it for my children if necessary rather than them having them upset. It’s not a big issue for someone to just leave a water bottle alone or not comment on their appearance. Just don’t do it. It’s not necessary and it’s bothering the kids. It’s not a power struggle to speak up for your kids, if she takes it as one, it shows she’s a weirdo and I wouldn’t want my kids with her anyway.

Probably better to just get a childminder. This woman can’t be that much of a friend if OP can’t chat honestly about this sort of thing.

memoire · 20/04/2023 00:58

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 00:53

My daughter would have told her that bottled water in plastic bottles was bad for the planet and would have kept her water bottle in her hand if necessary. 😬 and she’d have refused to have the top button done up no matter what anyone told her.

Not that my friends would have done any of this anyway other than possibly the mud on the shoes thing.

Yeah but that's coming from a child (your daughter)... I think for an adult (OP) to get involved would be too much of a petty power struggle.

I just don't think clean shoes, buttoned tops and extra reading time are the end of the world?? That's why I read it as a tiny bit of a power struggle

The friend probably can't be arsed about OP's kids, but she has to use the same standards in case her own kids complain

SammyScrounge · 20/04/2023 00:53

You have a good thing going here - a friend you can trust
a friend who treats your children the same as her own
the reading practice is good for them
the shoes and button only amount to a different emphasis on appearance.
You are being picky if this is all that disturbs the children. The only problematic thing I can think of is that your daughter is silent when she comes home. Is she fretting? Does your other daughter complain too? What does DD1 mean by 'strict". Is it only the different routine or is your friend shouting at them or somethin?

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 00:53

memoire · 20/04/2023 00:34

She could easily be re-filling the empty/half empty water with bottled water, while saying "bottled water is better than tap water"

While I might speak up if my kids were uncomfortable, I don't think attire standards are controlling. Some parents have higher expectations of their children. I am not one of those parents lol. But neatly presenting yourself is an essential life skill not all children get to learn! Plus she's probably only doing it with OP's kids so her own kids don't ask "how come they can get away with it?"

My daughter would have told her that bottled water in plastic bottles was bad for the planet and would have kept her water bottle in her hand if necessary. 😬 and she’d have refused to have the top button done up no matter what anyone told her.

Not that my friends would have done any of this anyway other than possibly the mud on the shoes thing.

LadyJ2023 · 20/04/2023 00:46

Awww for goodness sake it's the same kindof thing I would do without thinking when I have friends kids over, just dive in and treat them like my own and no harm in it at all. Maybe if you know there going to read at hers then let them off it at yours and do something else. There's no harm meant you need to make sure your kids know that. I would be more than grateful my kids were being well looked after than not.

memoire · 20/04/2023 00:34

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 00:22

If she’s not changing it, why would she make the point of telling the kids it’s healthier?

And the top button thing is controlling too. The kids should just say no.

She could easily be re-filling the empty/half empty water with bottled water, while saying "bottled water is better than tap water"

While I might speak up if my kids were uncomfortable, I don't think attire standards are controlling. Some parents have higher expectations of their children. I am not one of those parents lol. But neatly presenting yourself is an essential life skill not all children get to learn! Plus she's probably only doing it with OP's kids so her own kids don't ask "how come they can get away with it?"

memoire · 20/04/2023 00:31

Clean shoes and extra reading – I'd be glad someone else is instilling bonus good habits in my kids without me putting any effort lol

Tap water – I wouldn't pick a fight over this, so long as my kids are getting water. If your kids are worried/curious, just tell them the bottled vs tap water thing is a myth

Do up ties/top buttons – if my kids were very uncomfortable, I would maybe mention this one to her politely. But if you think it does no harm apart from annoyance, or is a good habit for your kids, leave it

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 20/04/2023 00:22

melj1213 · 20/04/2023 00:02

Where does it say the other mum changes it though?

The OP just says she sends the children to school with tap water in their bottles when she fills them, not necessarily that she sends the children to her friend's with tap water and she pours it out in favour of bottled water.

If she is emptying their water bottles just to refill them with bottled water then I'd agree but I took it to be that the children either take empty bottles in the morning and the other mum fills them up with bottled water just before they leave for school or she refills them with bottled water (as opposed to tap water) before they leave because they've drank the water that was already in the bottle whilst at her house.

If she’s not changing it, why would she make the point of telling the kids it’s healthier?

And the top button thing is controlling too. The kids should just say no.

OrchidsBlooming · 20/04/2023 00:08

I'm willing to bet there are random things you and your DC do in the afternoon that piss her kids off! Could be a different type of snack choice, could be changing out of uniform, could be not doing homework or whatever as soon as you get in and then end up doing stuff later. Different families, different routines.

I'd say your kids just need to get use to theirs, or you run the risk of opening a whole discussion to things she'd like you to change!

melj1213 · 20/04/2023 00:02

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 19/04/2023 23:51

I think it shows she’s weirdly controlling. Their mum has provided a drink, but she thinks she knows better. Yes, it’s just water, but who would actually do what she is and change it? Total freak.

Where does it say the other mum changes it though?

The OP just says she sends the children to school with tap water in their bottles when she fills them, not necessarily that she sends the children to her friend's with tap water and she pours it out in favour of bottled water.

If she is emptying their water bottles just to refill them with bottled water then I'd agree but I took it to be that the children either take empty bottles in the morning and the other mum fills them up with bottled water just before they leave for school or she refills them with bottled water (as opposed to tap water) before they leave because they've drank the water that was already in the bottle whilst at her house.

Titusgroan · 20/04/2023 00:01

It won’t hurt your DD to see how other children live.
As long as she’s not criticising you or hurting your DDs I wouldnt worry.

BadNomad · 19/04/2023 23:59

It's probably just because they're not at home. No other person will treat your children the exact same way you do because they are not you. Even if you change childcare provider, they still won't be you and the children will still feel a difference. You need to help your children to understand that "different" is not bad or wrong.

TheMiddleOfTheMiddle · 19/04/2023 23:55

Id just tell my kids to keep their water bottle in their bag, or would she just go through their bag? 😬

Tell them to say that mum/dad said their top button is ok undone.

QueenSmartypants · 19/04/2023 23:51

I agree with others that these are not hills to die on. She's doing you a huge favour and making sure your dc fit in with her routine - it's a good opportunity to teach your children about respecting other people's household rules and ways of living, and of sucking up minor things because someone is helping you out.

If she wants to waste money on bottled water for your two then fine and they can always undo their top buttons after they've been dropped off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread