Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that sex and gender are the same thing?

319 replies

StNinian · 19/04/2023 20:01

I don't buy into the distinction many people make between the two terms nowadays. "Gender" was never a word used to describe how one feels/identifies behaves until recently. It has long been synonymous with "sex". Just curious to see if anyone else agrees with me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
milafawny · 20/04/2023 10:17

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 10:14

Its easier to see gender as a scale

No it's definitely not!

There are only 2 genders - masculine or feminine!

No. Some females are more feminine that others, some males are more masculine than others. there isnt a definition of feminine/masculine that every one fits in. They are ideals created by a society as to what they are and people will conform to them to different levels. Therefore, its a scale.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 10:15

Why can't people just like what they like and what does it have to do with being male or female, whether that's in sex or fucking gender?

Exactly.

Male or Female. Simple.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 10:14

Its easier to see gender as a scale

No it's definitely not!

There are only 2 genders - masculine or feminine!

Housenoob · 20/04/2023 10:10

Sorry that should be Hollywood to Bollywood, bloody autocorrect

Housenoob · 20/04/2023 10:10

I'm going to really struggle to articulate what I think so bear with.

To me personally I use sex and gender interchangeably although I understand the difference. But I think 'identifying' as a particular gender just because you may like a specific colour or type of clothing is bullshit.

I'm biologically female but when I was younger I loved cars and refused to wear dresses until I was about 14. This does not mean I identified as male in gender, I didn't even think about that because it wasn't a trendy 'thing' at the time.

Why does gender have to be such a 'thing'??? Why can't people just like what they like and what does it have to do with being male or female, whether that's in sex or fucking gender? It's like me saying I'm Indian, but I prefer Hollywood to Hollywood therefore I must identify as Western. Fucks sake.

milafawny · 20/04/2023 10:08

sex is biology, what your DNS states. Gender is the characteristic society associates with that sex as others have said. So sex male/female, gender masculine/feminine.

I do have a hard time with the " there are 72 genders" or whatever number we are currently up to.

Its easier to see gender as a scale. You can have a very feminine biological male who lives their life entirely conforming to feminine traits, and wishes for society to see them as female, and vice versa. We are all on this scale to an extent. Im female, i identify as female fully, but i live my life in jeans vans and gaming hoodies with natural cut twice a year if its lucky hair, unkempt eyebrows and wouldn't know one end of a mascara to the other. I am less feminine that someone who live their life in heels and dresses with daily make up and weekly visits to a beauty therapist and hairdresser. Those traits are, within our society, as to what is feminine and what isnt. We dont have to stick a label on them though, just, as a society, accept that regardless of what a persons DNA states, they are free to conform to the ideals of feminine/masculine as much or as little as they chose.

Its really not complicated, or "woke", its just simple acceptance.

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 09:48

bridgetreilly · 19/04/2023 20:22

Sex = male/female.
Gender = masculine/feminine.

Male/female is universal.
Masculine/feminine changes over time/place/culture.

This is an accurate definition.

Male / Female is a basic biological mammalian definition of sex.
Gender is a social construct which as you correctly point out varies across cultures and how each individual feels / dresses / behaves.

However a feminine male is never going to be female and a masculine female is never going to be male.

The issue is lies with the definition of the words man and woman- do they refer to gender or sex?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/04/2023 09:06

Personally I’m a bit nostalgic for the days when ‘gender’ - at least in my head - was associated with the foreign language nouns I had to learn - M, F, N…

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 08:41

The whole problem has arisen from people accepting that gender is different to biological sex

I cannot see any difference - you're either male or female. Simple.

MargotBamborough · 20/04/2023 08:38

If you believe that sex and gender are two different things, can you name one situation in which someone's gender actually matters? Or any situation in which we need to distinguish between people on the basis of their gender?

HairyKitty · 20/04/2023 08:36

I am a man named Simon. My gender expression is female and I like to wear dresses and lipstick

He is a male
His gender is male
He may or may not wish he was female
He may or may not “identify” as female gendered (although he cannot actually be female gendered)
He exhibits some traits more typical of, or associated with, biological females (in that society).

The whole problem has arisen from people accepting that gender is different to biological sex.

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 23:08

If gender is simply a sociological construct, is it all just meaningless solipsism?

Then we might as well use it as we used to in the past and as other languages still do - to describe someone's biological gender - male or female

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 23:04

Except when it's der Kater!

That's true Grin. Ok how about die Maus?!

HBGKC · 19/04/2023 23:00

StNinian · 19/04/2023 20:01

I don't buy into the distinction many people make between the two terms nowadays. "Gender" was never a word used to describe how one feels/identifies behaves until recently. It has long been synonymous with "sex". Just curious to see if anyone else agrees with me.

One of the most knowledgable people I know agrees with you, OP - says that until fairly recently (which could include the 1990s!), the two terms were synonymous. (My friend's 60 years old.)

TheClitterati · 19/04/2023 22:56

sexandgenderintro.com

You might find this a useful read op.

anon666 · 19/04/2023 22:50

It feels at times like this is "god's way" of telling us we have far too many people coming up with and debating pointless abstract constructs.

If gender is simply a sociological construct, is it all just meaningless solipsism? Why does anyone in the real world outside universities take any bloody notice of it?

I would love to zoom forward three centuries and see what they make of all this.

I thought I was a feminist but if we have inadvertently opened the door to all this nonsense then I regret that.

BadNomad · 19/04/2023 22:42

Seperate to this can anyone explain gender without using words like make-up, toy cars, dolls, climbing, dresses etc.

Simply, gender is what people think is stereotypical of sex. Caring, loving, nurturing, pretty vs strong, dominant, handsome. The issue is people can be caring, loving and strong and dominant. That's when people are described as (acting) feminine/masculine depending on their sex. When the truth is, it's all bullshit because nothing about your sex determines if someone will be caring, loving, strong, dominant etc.

DomPom47 · 19/04/2023 22:41

bridgetreilly · 19/04/2023 20:22

Sex = male/female.
Gender = masculine/feminine.

Male/female is universal.
Masculine/feminine changes over time/place/culture.

This

Conkersinautumn · 19/04/2023 22:38

I was learning about variety of gender expression jn ancient Rome when I was at uni .... and I graduated before the years started 20.

Did you fall under something heavy?

Fairislefandango · 19/04/2023 22:37

Because in German it is Die Katze so a cat is feminine in German.

Except when it's der Kater!

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/04/2023 22:36

MargotBamborough · 19/04/2023 22:25

In French it's the other way around. A cat is masculine and a table is feminine.

In English all common nouns are gender neutral.

The French also don't use the words "male" and "femelle" to refer to biological sex in humans (only other animals). I had my children in France and in the medical notes my son is described as a child of the masculine sex and my daughter is a child of the feminine sex. And absolutely nothing is gender neutral (which is why "non binary people" are struggling to be taken seriously).

Thanks. I couldn't remember what way round they were in French. Google suggested different words for male and female cats, which I don't remember learning at school!

That's interesting about how babies sex is recorded though.

I guess that in English, "male" is the word for "of the masculine sex" and female for "of the feminine sex" despite the fact that masculine and feminine are (imo) based largely on stereotypes. (In English at least. French obviously has different meanings)

WandaWonder · 19/04/2023 22:36

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 22:14

How can a "thing" be male or female if it doesn't have a biological sex?

Because in German it is Die Katze so a cat is feminine in German. A table is masculine

I presume that is the words they are not actually calling those items male or female?

Mind you ships and cars are traditionally female?

Seperate to this can anyone explain gender without using words like make-up, toy cars, dolls, climbing, dresses etc.

Yes I am well aware males and females do a mix of this it is the cliche I am asking

moveoverye · 19/04/2023 22:35

Not sure I explained that very well, but basically I mean that people who feel that their sense of their own gender means they ARE a woman (or a man) are actually saying therefore that gender and sex are the same thing. And they are saying gender should determine sex.
It’s all terribly confusing.

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 22:33

I am a man named Simon. My gender expression is female and I like to wear dresses and lipstick

He's a man. His gender is male. Simple.

Regardless of how he 'expresses' himself

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 19/04/2023 22:32

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 22:26

Just because 'cat' is a feminine word in German doesn't mean cats are all female.
Or that tables are actually male

No of course not Grin

But the word 'gender' refers to whether a word or a person is male or female.

Any official forms and your passport will contain your gender - male or female

Right ok... in German.

But the vast majority of us on here are (I assume) not German. And therefore it's not really relevant what words Germans use, is it?

As I understand it "Gender" (in England at least) was used as a polite word for sex. And to stop twats like my brother writing "yes please" on forms.

But the actual word "sex" refers to biology and "gender" is some kind of made up thing identity which no one can actually explain. I don't think I have one.