Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that sex and gender are the same thing?

319 replies

StNinian · 19/04/2023 20:01

I don't buy into the distinction many people make between the two terms nowadays. "Gender" was never a word used to describe how one feels/identifies behaves until recently. It has long been synonymous with "sex". Just curious to see if anyone else agrees with me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
VestaTilley · 20/04/2023 14:16

YABU. While they may well have been conflated, they do not mean the same thing.

Treating them as though they are the same is what the idiots at Stonewall etc wanted - and it’s been an utter disaster for public policy.

Sex and gender are different.

MarkWithaC · 20/04/2023 14:14

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 21:10

A man can dress as a woman (well, what he thinks a woman should wear 🙄)
His gender is feminine.

No, he is male, regardless of how he dresses

I'm not sure you're understanding. And you've left out the – pertinent – last line of that post, which is 'Whatever label is used he's still and always a man in a frock.'

The poster agrees with you that 'he is male regardless of how he dresses'.
This man's SEX is male. His GENDER may be whatever he says, as that's a socially constructed idea.

Version4needsabitofwork · 20/04/2023 14:12

Sex is real. Gender is made up (so can be whatever you want it to be).

Being made up, it's also nonsense, which is how we got into all this mess in the first place.

Fordian · 20/04/2023 14:08

"If a man is “feminine” or has “feminine traits” or wears a dress, this doesn’t make him have a female gender."

I'd perhaps say "Despite whether a man has a propensity towards more stereotypical feminine traits; he is still a man".

I do like the trans argument that 'gender is a construct'; because it makes it easier to ask 'Then, how can I misgender you?' 🤔

funnelfan · 20/04/2023 14:03

the use of the word sex to primarily mean sexual intercourse is also relatively modern. Eg Jane Austen used the word to mean the male or female class in her novels and no one fainted at Elizabeth Bennett declaring her opinions of the female sex.

Florissante · 20/04/2023 14:00

You are not only being very unreasonable, OP, you are incredibly ill-informed.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 13:58

However a feminine male is never going to be female and a masculine female is never going to be male.

Exactly, males are males and females are females. They can dress up however they like.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 13:56

You can choose to change your gender but it's not possible to change your sex

See, I don't think you can (or need to) change your gender.

What's wrong with male or female? Just be who you are!

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 13:55

The confusion and problem I see is when people refer to man or woman are they talking about sex or gender?

They are the same to me. You can only be 1) male or 2) female.

Why is the need for any more genders anyway?

Verv · 20/04/2023 13:07

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 09:48

This is an accurate definition.

Male / Female is a basic biological mammalian definition of sex.
Gender is a social construct which as you correctly point out varies across cultures and how each individual feels / dresses / behaves.

However a feminine male is never going to be female and a masculine female is never going to be male.

The issue is lies with the definition of the words man and woman- do they refer to gender or sex?

Man/Woman IMO is related to sex.

A man is an adult human male.
A woman is an adult human female.

Verv · 20/04/2023 13:04

No.
Sex is male/female.
Gender is cultural stereotypes associated with sex - masculinity and femininity.

Fordian · 20/04/2023 13:04

KnittingNeedles · 19/04/2023 20:18

People say "gender" because they think it sounds more polite than "sex".

My DH was a biologist for a govt. agency in Queensland.

Banned words in searches in govt. computers included 'sex' (which this just autocorrected to 'sec') 🤷🏻‍♀️. For Biologists

I think people use gender because 'sex' sounds 'crude', but the time is well upon us where we must use words carefully...

Corkcobain · 20/04/2023 13:02

You can choose to change your gender but it's not possible to change your sex

LangClegsInSpace · 20/04/2023 12:58

Sex: Biology - male or female, man or woman, boy or girl.

Gender (1): a polite euphemism for sex

Gender (2): in feminism - masculinity and femininity. A set of different kinds of practices and codified behaviours and systems that ritualise male domination and female subordination.

Gender (3): in queer theory and sexology - the idea that you can 'identify' as a man or woman, both, neither or something else, regardless of biology. Like a sexed soul. They claim it also has nothing to do with sex role stereotypes (Gender (2)) but that's not very convincing from the behaviour I have seen or the history of the term 'gender identity'. Invented by John Money in the 1960's who believed that by forcing a boy to adopt submissive sexual positions with his twin brother he could convince the boy he was a girl.

1dayatatime · 20/04/2023 12:58

@moveoverye

"You can be a masculine woman (“tomboy” if you like) but still be 100% female?"

++++

Correct- you can be a masculine female but you are still female it doesn't make you male.

As a previous poster neatly summarised it:
Sex is biological and is male or female
Gender is a social construct as is masculine/ feminine and varies across cultures.

The confusion and problem I see is when people refer to man or woman are they talking about sex or gender?

moveoverye · 20/04/2023 12:50

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 12:09

No, they’re not the same. Sex is biological and cannot be altered. Gender is essentially femininity and masculinity and is a sliding scale.

I understand what you mean, but I also disagree. You can be a masculine woman (“tomboy” if you like) but still be 100% female?

MargotBamborough · 20/04/2023 12:41

heathspeedwell · 20/04/2023 12:24

Let's be honest, how many of us actually feel like we have an internal sense of gender?

I suspect it is very rare indeed among people who haven't been taught at school that they should have a gender identity.

Not me.

And even if I did have a gender identity it wouldn't be the same one trans women have.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 12:25

I just don't understand why my 'gender' has to change just because I choose to wear masculine looking clothes or cut my hair short or take up football?! I am still a female.

What's wrong with male and female?

heathspeedwell · 20/04/2023 12:24

Let's be honest, how many of us actually feel like we have an internal sense of gender?

I suspect it is very rare indeed among people who haven't been taught at school that they should have a gender identity.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 12:22

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 12:09

No, they’re not the same. Sex is biological and cannot be altered. Gender is essentially femininity and masculinity and is a sliding scale.

How can my female gender be altered? I'm a female, regardless of how I dress or act!

maddening · 20/04/2023 12:20

I agree - until recently (eg until around 2006 which is recent relative to human history) gender was often used to mean sex - eg baby's gender. It also was used in gender roles - which very much related to sex based roles, it was a politer way of saying sex meaning bilogical sex.

In academic circles it was divorced and the rise of Queer studies which also saw a decline in women's studies in academia has accelerated that into society.

HairyKitty · 20/04/2023 12:15

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 12:09

No, they’re not the same. Sex is biological and cannot be altered. Gender is essentially femininity and masculinity and is a sliding scale.

No. If I stop shaving, cut my hair, wear trousers etc, I am still not male gendered, are you? I am exhibiting stereotypical male characteristics but my gender is still female.

Howdoyou · 20/04/2023 12:09

No, they’re not the same. Sex is biological and cannot be altered. Gender is essentially femininity and masculinity and is a sliding scale.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 11:59

Lazy -minded people will assume your baby is a boy, yes

Well, then those lazy minded people will make wrong judgments, that's THEIR problem.

It does not mean that we need to change any definitions of gender!

My dd wore a lot of her brother's baby clothes. She wore blue baby grows, she wore Spider-Man tops etc - I would never be angry if people had assumed she was a boy, I rather feel sorry for their narrow minded way of thinking.

Beowulfa · 20/04/2023 10:26

moveoverye · 19/04/2023 22:00

But surely it isn’t that simple? You are talking about stereotypes?
My baby has a blue baby romper outfit - that doesn’t mean her gender is male?

Lazy -minded people will assume your baby is a boy, yes. I was with a friend whose new baby was wearing a stripey blue babygrow, a woman came over to coo and asked "what's his name"? Then looked angry at the response "her name is Alice" as it revealed her rigid stereotpyed thinking.

Woman and girls will lose our sex-based rights if we do not correct the word gender whenever it's wrongly used instead of sex.