Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that sex and gender are the same thing?

319 replies

StNinian · 19/04/2023 20:01

I don't buy into the distinction many people make between the two terms nowadays. "Gender" was never a word used to describe how one feels/identifies behaves until recently. It has long been synonymous with "sex". Just curious to see if anyone else agrees with me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Proudofitbabe · 20/04/2023 16:43

Sex and gender are of course two different things but I do agree that practically-speaking, those terms were used - and understood - interchangeably by the average person until the trans agenda. I'm very mindful to refer to sex only now.

Verv · 20/04/2023 16:42

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:29

Why lol. My best friend looks like that. Although she isn't 6ft. She's a short ass. But people mistake her for a man (and then a lesbian) all the time based on how she looks. She keeps her hair short because it annoys her and she dresses like that because it's comfortable I suppose. She isn't any less female because of it. Yet people assume she's male.

Men and women have (primary and) secondary sex characteristics that make them identifiable.

I wear jeans and hoodies. I have short hair. I am a lesbian. I am 5'9 and quite muscular. From the back I have been mistaken for a man, but when I turn round and my secondary sex characteristics are observable - the error is instantly corrected and usually just elicits a smile and a "dont worry about it"

The pretence that male and female whether that be a man or a woman or a doe (no antlers unless a reindeer) or a deer (antlers and a cock) by the presence of sex characteristics is either pitiable or deliberately obtuse.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:42

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:35

No, because bar the Adams apple, both men and women can be broad, narrow, high voiced, big/small hands and feet. And then there are variations in the size an Adam's apple can be.

It's stereotypes like that which make one gender think they can become another by changing the way they look.

I don’t think you understand what stereotypes are.

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:40

Florissante · 20/04/2023 16:37

I have read some amazingly ignorant posts on MN but this must be among the top five.

What did I say that is wrong? Women can't have big feet? Men can't have high voices?

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:40

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:37

I know who they are. Find a man and a woman who look the same then ask me.

Ok. Couple of stock photos for you. Can you tell which is which?

To think that sex and gender are the same thing?
To think that sex and gender are the same thing?
Florissante · 20/04/2023 16:37

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:35

No, because bar the Adams apple, both men and women can be broad, narrow, high voiced, big/small hands and feet. And then there are variations in the size an Adam's apple can be.

It's stereotypes like that which make one gender think they can become another by changing the way they look.

I have read some amazingly ignorant posts on MN but this must be among the top five.

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:37

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:34

You can’t see the height in these photos. Are you confused about their sex? Do you find it hard to tell which one is female and which is male without watching them perform gendered (undefined) stereotypes?

I know who they are. Find a man and a woman who look the same then ask me.

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:35

Florissante · 20/04/2023 16:25

You wouldn't have a clue by their voice, size of hands / feet, presence of Adam's apple, breadth of shoulders, narrowness of hips, etc?

No, because bar the Adams apple, both men and women can be broad, narrow, high voiced, big/small hands and feet. And then there are variations in the size an Adam's apple can be.

It's stereotypes like that which make one gender think they can become another by changing the way they look.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:34

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:31

I dont get your point. I never said broad or mentioned muscles. Just tall. Women can be tall too you know.

You can’t see the height in these photos. Are you confused about their sex? Do you find it hard to tell which one is female and which is male without watching them perform gendered (undefined) stereotypes?

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:31

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:27

It’s so hard to tell the difference isn’t it?! 😂

I dont get your point. I never said broad or mentioned muscles. Just tall. Women can be tall too you know.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:29

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:22

I've answered repeatedly. I don't know how they decide to name animals or why only some of them.

Defining gender is the whole issue. People can't agree on it and that's why there is so much conflict. Who gets to decide? Who has the authority to define it? Sex is easy, it can be proven. But gender is a lot of opinion.

I asked you how they decided which animals have a gender, not which animals have names. I’ve clarified this for you twice now.

So if no one can define the woman gender and the man gender, how can it possibly be important?! It’s an undefined idea. Meanwhile, everyone knows what sex is, so let’s just stick to that.

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:29

Verv · 20/04/2023 16:21

Oh mate.
Thats pitiable.

Why lol. My best friend looks like that. Although she isn't 6ft. She's a short ass. But people mistake her for a man (and then a lesbian) all the time based on how she looks. She keeps her hair short because it annoys her and she dresses like that because it's comfortable I suppose. She isn't any less female because of it. Yet people assume she's male.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:27

It’s so hard to tell the difference isn’t it?! 😂

To think that sex and gender are the same thing?
To think that sex and gender are the same thing?
caringcarer · 20/04/2023 16:26

Sex is biological, e.g. chromosomes, internal and external sex organs so only 2 sexes. Gender is how you present yourself to the world so how feminine or masculine you present as.

Florissante · 20/04/2023 16:25

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:13

How would I know she was still a woman? Because if a 6ft adult, with a shaved head, no makeup, wearing a chequered shirt, jeans and trainers comes up to me and says "I'm incognitasensius" I wouldn't have a clue if they were male or female.

You wouldn't have a clue by their voice, size of hands / feet, presence of Adam's apple, breadth of shoulders, narrowness of hips, etc?

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:22

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:14

I’ve never heard David Attenborough talk about how they decided which animals have a gender, funnily enough!

Why are you putting a distance restriction on the question? What gendered behaviours makes a deer a doe? Why is this such a hard question?! If you can’t answer for other animals, answer based on humans. How is the woman gender defined, and how is the man gender defined?

I've answered repeatedly. I don't know how they decide to name animals or why only some of them.

Defining gender is the whole issue. People can't agree on it and that's why there is so much conflict. Who gets to decide? Who has the authority to define it? Sex is easy, it can be proven. But gender is a lot of opinion.

Verv · 20/04/2023 16:21

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:13

How would I know she was still a woman? Because if a 6ft adult, with a shaved head, no makeup, wearing a chequered shirt, jeans and trainers comes up to me and says "I'm incognitasensius" I wouldn't have a clue if they were male or female.

Oh mate.
Thats pitiable.

JackGrealishsLegs · 20/04/2023 16:16

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:13

How would I know she was still a woman? Because if a 6ft adult, with a shaved head, no makeup, wearing a chequered shirt, jeans and trainers comes up to me and says "I'm incognitasensius" I wouldn't have a clue if they were male or female.

Ok, now I know you’re on the wind up.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:15

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:13

How would I know she was still a woman? Because if a 6ft adult, with a shaved head, no makeup, wearing a chequered shirt, jeans and trainers comes up to me and says "I'm incognitasensius" I wouldn't have a clue if they were male or female.

Good point, no one can tell which sex The Rock is…

Naunet · 20/04/2023 16:14

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:08

Eh? I'm not David Attenborough. I imagine they observed the animals.

Yet, from a distance, you can only assume a deer is a doe based on how it looks and behaves based on what they think a doe should look and behave like.

Kinda like how baby boys with long hair and wearing pink are mistaken for being girls. That has nothing to do with sex. It's gender stereotyping.

I’ve never heard David Attenborough talk about how they decided which animals have a gender, funnily enough!

Why are you putting a distance restriction on the question? What gendered behaviours makes a deer a doe? Why is this such a hard question?! If you can’t answer for other animals, answer based on humans. How is the woman gender defined, and how is the man gender defined?

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:13

Verv · 20/04/2023 15:59

A woman is an adult human female and a man is an adult human male.

If a woman told you she was incognitasensius, you would still know that she was a woman.

(Number 89 on the gender list - Incognitasensius: A gender where your true gender feelings are unknown likely non existent but you identify with genders.)

How would I know she was still a woman? Because if a 6ft adult, with a shaved head, no makeup, wearing a chequered shirt, jeans and trainers comes up to me and says "I'm incognitasensius" I wouldn't have a clue if they were male or female.

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 16:08

Naunet · 20/04/2023 15:49

No, that’s not what I asked is it? Don’t be disingenuous. I asked how they knew which animals had a gender and what behaviours a deer should display to be considered a doe. Are you able to answer, or no?

Eh? I'm not David Attenborough. I imagine they observed the animals.

Yet, from a distance, you can only assume a deer is a doe based on how it looks and behaves based on what they think a doe should look and behave like.

Kinda like how baby boys with long hair and wearing pink are mistaken for being girls. That has nothing to do with sex. It's gender stereotyping.

lifeturnsonadime · 20/04/2023 16:01

It doesn't make any sense to say you are a woman but no one needs to know what that means.

PMSL. Do you actually really believe that?

Everyone knows what a woman is, even the ones who pretend to be women.

lifeturnsonadime · 20/04/2023 15:59

Your statement is contradictory. Are you saying gender doesn't matter? Or that it does but it should only mean what you think it should mean i.e. woman = adult female? Because if so, then like I said it is important that we understand what gender means.

No my statement is not contradictory. The ONLY thing that all women have in common is that we are all human females who have survived to adult hood. That is literally what a woman is.

Gender is made up nonsense, based on personality and regressive sex stereotypes.

You have failed to explain what you believe female and male gender actually are despite being asked several times.

Naunet · 20/04/2023 15:59

BadNomad · 20/04/2023 15:55

No we don't. The one thing I share with every other woman on the planet is that I am an adult human female that has lived to adulthood.

Your statement is contradictory. Are you saying gender doesn't matter? Or that it does but it should only mean what you think it should mean i.e. woman = adult female? Because if so, then like I said it is important that we understand what gender means.

It doesn't make any sense to say you are a woman but no one needs to know what that means.

What does it mean then? How is the woman gender defined and how is the man gender defined?