Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other children's snacks are irresponsible?

359 replies

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:18

The official policy at DS's school (Year 2) is for them to bring a fruit or veg snack from home for break time. This seemed to be what happened when DS was in reception and Year 1, but over time DS tells me that his friends are regularly bringing crisps, chocolate bars and sweets in for their snack(s) and that he is one of the only ones who has fruit/veg each time.

Totally get that this needs fact-checking (I have a few reasons to think is is accurate), but if it is AIBU to think this is something I should contact school about? I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack, but as I have no control over this, AIBU to think that school should be enforcing the fruit/veg policy?

OP posts:
Mopscharlotte · 19/04/2023 20:47

Please I would like you to msg me personally , I want to help

RobertaFirmino · 19/04/2023 20:47

Oh come on now, do you seriously believe that ALL the other DC have crisps and chocolate? You need to wise up because you've got years of this ahead of you.
ALL the other DC are allowed to stay up until 9pm
ALL the other DC get more pocket money
ALL the other DC have got Xboxes/phones/whatever
ALL the other DC have parents who let them do what they want
Whatever your parenting policies are, you can bet your bottom dollar that according to your DC, every single other child in the universe has parents who do the opposite!

Having said all that, is there really any harm in the odd bag of Walkers? I don't mean on a daily basis but maybe once a week or something? Do you remember being a child yourself? Did you ever think school was boooooooring? They all do at some point - something to cheer it up a little every now and then might not be such a bad idea.

Irritateandunreasonable · 19/04/2023 20:46

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:30

Do we not have a responsibility as members of the same community to promote healthy eating habits? What justification is there for giving a morning snack of chocolate and crisps every day? Especially given the childhood obesity crisis in this country.

You are not owe justification. No one has to justify their food choices to you.

Aslanplustwo · 19/04/2023 20:40

What other parents give their children for snacks has absolutely NOTHING to do with you. In other words, mind your own business.

redbigbananafeet · 19/04/2023 20:40

cowgirljoey If the policy isn't a policy but merely a suggestion are you going to start sending him in with crisps and chocolate?

Fairislefandango · 19/04/2023 20:39

The fact that 80% think YABU makes me despair. Definitely teaches kids that it's fine not to follow the rules, and further fuels the obesity crisis. Poor kids, god forbid we try to promote healthy eating so they don't have multiple health issues growing up.

It is perfectly possible to recognise that there is an obesity crisis and that people should eat more healthily but still think the OP should mind her own business. Contacting the school will achieve what? Would you go up to someone eating crisps on the streets and lecture them about healthy eating? If not, how do you think individuals should 'promote healthy eating'? The OP quite rightly can't do anything about what the other kids eat.

Jourdain11 · 19/04/2023 20:38

FurAndFeathers · 19/04/2023 20:33

Yep exactly the same. Definitely no vitamins or fibre in fruit. Only sugar and ‘outrage of Mumsnetter’ 😂😂😂

I hope you're not poking fun, it is no laughing matter.

Justalittlebitduckling · 19/04/2023 20:37

I think it’s a helpful lesson for your child that some of his peers are in different circumstances with different options available to them and that life isn’t fair and he still has to have fruit and vegetables even if his friends have something he’d prefer. I don’t think you should be complaining about what other children are eating.

VikingLady · 19/04/2023 20:37

Mopscharlotte · 19/04/2023 19:47

It’s equally worrying for children to be over weight as it is under weight . High sugar levels and salt levels can impact not only on concentration levels but also all round body health. Of cause we all like a children’s party with cake and jelly , but as most of us know we’re peeling them off the ceiling which is fine on occasions. But possibly not the best for a learning environment - often children get labelled with tiredness or undesirable behaviour when all that’s needed is a change of diet- this is for a small minority of children but non the less can impact on a whole classroom . Bananas are currently 18 p 🙀 I know shocking 12 p last month . A bag of crisps 65p …. One a slow releaser of energy the other negative carbs , taste great though . No brainier

Bananas are currently 27p EACH in our local shop.

And the queues for the cheap food reuse scheme go round the block. You do get a carrier bag of fruit per week, some sort of bread product, a milk product or substitute, and a bag of freezer stuff. No choice, but it's at least half the week's food for a family for £7.50

But the fruit bag often had mealy bruised apples and semi liquid bananas. My DD couldn't take those. Couldn't even eat them as fruit (ASD, restricted diet). I turned them into sugarless chocolate muffins using the fruit for sweetness (and I know I'm lucky to be able to) and ok'd that with school.

What else would she eat? Nothing from 8.35 til 3.15.

redbigbananafeet · 19/04/2023 20:36

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:34

Thanks for your reply. What if it was another school rule being broken? DS is confused because they know what the policy is (they all got told it when they started school) but DS sees no one following it except for them. I think this must be confusing for a child and makes me seem unfair by following the policy when others are ignoring it. I think it sends an odd message to the children about what rules mean.

What a fucking sin that you've actually got your young child involved in this too. He's asking about policies and checking other kids snacks. Bloody hell.

redbigbananafeet · 19/04/2023 20:34

Who do you think should enforce it an how? Where does the time for snack inspection come from and who is doing it?

Porkandbeans1 · 19/04/2023 20:33

DC was always under weight and I would send them with junk food type snacks as along with fresh and dried fruit. We couldn't give nuts and I always struggled to get the calories into them. Luckily the school didn't care and sold cake bars at their tuck shop.

FurAndFeathers · 19/04/2023 20:33

Jourdain11 · 19/04/2023 20:28

Fruit shouldn't be allowed - it's basically like giving them a bowl of sugar.

Yep exactly the same. Definitely no vitamins or fibre in fruit. Only sugar and ‘outrage of Mumsnetter’ 😂😂😂

Jourdain11 · 19/04/2023 20:28

Moser85 · 19/04/2023 20:24

But if they will eat fruit and veg they do need a snack? 😂

I didn't stuff mine with junk at all. My daughter loved to bring peppers and carrots to school. My son didn't bring fruit or veg to school but he didn't have junk either. I just don't think it's right to tell kids that unless they eat fruit or veg then they can't have a snack.

Fruit shouldn't be allowed - it's basically like giving them a bowl of sugar.

Moser85 · 19/04/2023 20:24

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 20:11

If a child will not eat fruit or veg as a snack they don’t need a snack. End of discussion. You shouldn’t be stuffing them with junk.

But if they will eat fruit and veg they do need a snack? 😂

I didn't stuff mine with junk at all. My daughter loved to bring peppers and carrots to school. My son didn't bring fruit or veg to school but he didn't have junk either. I just don't think it's right to tell kids that unless they eat fruit or veg then they can't have a snack.

Mopscharlotte · 19/04/2023 20:24

Uniforms ? Park ….. excellent children going to the park , so much fun and time to enjoy the wider environment a brilliant education . And your point about uniforms, excise is ?

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 20:21

edwinbear · 19/04/2023 20:17

DS started taking cereal bars from about Y3. He’s now 13 and currently out on a 20km run, competes for his local athletics club, is running the Junior London Marathon on Saturday, followed by a Kent Rugby 7’s tournament on Sunday. He also swims competitively. Having a cereal bar for snack has not lead to obesity for him. It’s a balance.

My austic DD is now 11 and goes on 20km bike rides, runs crosscountry and plays hockey competitatively. She still doesn’t snack even when I send healthy rule appropriate snacks with her. All children are different but that doesn’t mean parents should get to flaut the rules.

mathanxiety · 19/04/2023 20:21

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

Word of advice - disguise your voice. Otherwise they'll see right through you.

Moser85 · 19/04/2023 20:21

SkyFullOfStars2 · 19/04/2023 20:12

In my opinion, unless there is a SEN, they absolutely should go without. Its a morning snack they're hardly going to starve. And if they're that hungry, they'll eat the healthy snack. There is zero need for chocolate mid morning!

I'm not saying they have to allow chocolate, I'm just saying fruit or veg being the only snacks allowed are restrictive because some children will not eat them and so I think it's pretty shitty to say you can only have a snack if it's fruit or veg, if not then you're not allowed. There are other healthy snacks!

Jourdain11 · 19/04/2023 20:20

allmyliesaretrue · 19/04/2023 20:18

Sooo... let's get this straight. It's ok for your child to eat shite if they're SEN but not otherwise...

There isn't really any need for them to eat at school at all - I mean, they're only there for a poxy 6 and a half hours or so...

allmyliesaretrue · 19/04/2023 20:18

SkyFullOfStars2 · 19/04/2023 20:12

In my opinion, unless there is a SEN, they absolutely should go without. Its a morning snack they're hardly going to starve. And if they're that hungry, they'll eat the healthy snack. There is zero need for chocolate mid morning!

Sooo... let's get this straight. It's ok for your child to eat shite if they're SEN but not otherwise...

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 20:18

SkyFullOfStars2 · 19/04/2023 20:12

In my opinion, unless there is a SEN, they absolutely should go without. Its a morning snack they're hardly going to starve. And if they're that hungry, they'll eat the healthy snack. There is zero need for chocolate mid morning!

My dd has autism. Her primary school had a fruit / veg rule too and for a long time during her aversion to most fruit / veg she did go without. Because her lunch was always prepared specifically to cater for her needs and she managed to drink lots of water in the day it wasn’t a problem. Then when she began to eat crispy things I sent her in with dried black gram (kala chana).

I can understand the need to load up a child with calories if they have an illness or condition that requires it but in most cases they don’t and it won’t harm them to miss a morning snack.

mathanxiety · 19/04/2023 20:17

YABVU

Keep your nose out of other people's business.

There's nothing as lacking in nutrition as fruit and veg that doesn't get eaten.

Have you never heard of the apple that gets sent to school and brought home again every day?

edwinbear · 19/04/2023 20:17

DS started taking cereal bars from about Y3. He’s now 13 and currently out on a 20km run, competes for his local athletics club, is running the Junior London Marathon on Saturday, followed by a Kent Rugby 7’s tournament on Sunday. He also swims competitively. Having a cereal bar for snack has not lead to obesity for him. It’s a balance.

allmyliesaretrue · 19/04/2023 20:17

Climbles · 19/04/2023 20:09

The NHS spends tens of millions every year of full teeth extractions for children. I’ve no idea the long terms cost to society of obesity but it’s likely a lot more. The least we can do as a community is not encourage sugary snacks 24/7. It’s no a parental choice it’s the worst health crisis in the country. I work in schools and the absolute shit kids eat for packed lunch then the parents greet them at the door with more sweets. Unless they are autistic or have a restricted diet for some reason then encouraging a healthy diet is a societal issue.

Dental hygiene education required then. None of my three adult children has ever had an extraction. One has 4 fillings because her teeth came up with decay. The others have no fillings. At primary age, none of mine would have eaten fruit or veg as a snack. Our primary did police what they had though! It's not a teacher's job to tell parents how to feed their children though.

I think what's annoying posters here is the high-handed dictatorial approach of the OP.

@cowgirljoey I suggest you mind your own bloody business and get on with rearing your own child. Holier than though types always get other people's backs up. You can rear your precious as healthily as you wish - good for you! - but you won't always be in control...