Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other children's snacks are irresponsible?

359 replies

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:18

The official policy at DS's school (Year 2) is for them to bring a fruit or veg snack from home for break time. This seemed to be what happened when DS was in reception and Year 1, but over time DS tells me that his friends are regularly bringing crisps, chocolate bars and sweets in for their snack(s) and that he is one of the only ones who has fruit/veg each time.

Totally get that this needs fact-checking (I have a few reasons to think is is accurate), but if it is AIBU to think this is something I should contact school about? I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack, but as I have no control over this, AIBU to think that school should be enforcing the fruit/veg policy?

OP posts:
2crazyboysandstillalive · 20/04/2023 16:52

because some parents cant afford to buy fresh fruit and veg - its the same with our school to i used to send fruit bags and snack tubs in but in the end crisps and breakfast bars are easier. also YABU

Itsamission25 · 20/04/2023 16:50

🤣 you would hate my daughters school
in the last term she has come out with sugar rocks her teacher made, Easter muffins and Italian chocolate one of her teachers bring her back everytime she goes home for a week 🤣

EmmaM84 · 20/04/2023 16:38

My daughters school doesn't have such a policy (Scotland) but I really wish it did. My daughter feels really hard done by taking in fruit when other kids have biscuits or crisps but I don't want her eating junk at 10.30am! We don't live in a very affluent area though and whilst we are comfortable and can afford fresh fruit, a lot of kids will be taking in food bank donations and such like so I think schools need to be careful about enforcing such rules sadly. Something is better than nothing and all that

PeskyPenguin · 20/04/2023 16:23

get lost!! are you perfect parent in every way, or just this one?

EarthlyNightshade · 20/04/2023 08:24

I think it's fair enough to ask the school to clarify the policy.
They may well be trying to enforce it behind the scenes (we had similar at my DC primary with bookbags/rucksacks, school were doing their very best with the issue but some parents just won't listen) in which case, there's nothing you can do.
But if they are not trying to enforce it, they might as well ditch it as a policy and used their very overstretched teachers to concentrate on other areas.
Based on this thread, it seems the healthier fitter adults had a chocolate bar every morning, I wonder how well that translates into real life?

QuickNameChangeForMeToday · 20/04/2023 05:34

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

However when I asked earlier what you hope to gain from this you said
cowgirljoey · Yesterday 18:24
That they would enforce the policy. Friend's kids at another local school have same fruit/veg policy and snacks get checked.

You need a clear objective before you contact the school. So far it has been a mix of the above plus social responsibility and the obesity crisis.

Happyvalleyfan · 19/04/2023 23:06

Climbles · 19/04/2023 20:09

The NHS spends tens of millions every year of full teeth extractions for children. I’ve no idea the long terms cost to society of obesity but it’s likely a lot more. The least we can do as a community is not encourage sugary snacks 24/7. It’s no a parental choice it’s the worst health crisis in the country. I work in schools and the absolute shit kids eat for packed lunch then the parents greet them at the door with more sweets. Unless they are autistic or have a restricted diet for some reason then encouraging a healthy diet is a societal issue.

It’s not just teeth extraction, it’s also diabetes - there’s been an increase in rates of type 2 diabetes in children.

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/15/child-diabetes-referrals-england-wales-obesity-crisis

More than a quarter of children are obese by the time they leave primary school 😯

One of the ways the government can support children is through healthy eating messages - which should be supported by schools.

Unless we don’t want the state to promote healthy lifestyle?

Child type 2 diabetes referrals in England and Wales jump 50% amid obesity crisis | Diabetes | The Guardian

Diabetes UK warns cost of living crisis could aggravate problem and accuses government of ‘letting our children down’

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/15/child-diabetes-referrals-england-wales-obesity-crisis

workwithmeaning · 19/04/2023 22:44

I love the word "snack". 😋 I just love it.

Best word in the dictionary

Red0 · 19/04/2023 22:42

Incidentally, I don’t understand why they need a snack an hour before lunch. It’s the same at my DC school. Makes much more sense to me to have an afternoon snack, if one is needed at all. Or just earlier in the day rather than one hour before lunchtime.

Charmatt · 19/04/2023 21:46

It's none of your business what other children have. My son had a bloody good reason why he had to have a carbohydrate based snack every day and it was no other parent's business.

Even those who may not have a reason you feel is valid may not be in the position to afford fruit everyday, or indeed any day.

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 19/04/2023 21:35

The teachers need to confiscate all the irresponsible snacks and then consume them dutifully in the staffroom to avoid waste.
And DS needs to be sent in with a tureen of cabbage soup to feed those poor unfortunates with lax mothers.

Whippetlovely · 19/04/2023 21:34

I don’t think it’s any of your concern what other children are eating. It’s rather judgemental as well, parents know kids are meant to have fruit but it’s a balanced diet, most kids have crisps in their lunchbox, shock horror along with fruit and a sandwich. My children do and they are perfect healthy , they have lots of sports afterschool , walk to and from school and burn off plenty energy. Schools also can not police every childs lunchbox they have hundreds of kids in a lunch hall over the lunch hour and there are only a few staff. There are much more important safeguarding issues for schools to worry about that someone eating a bloody packet of crisp.

msisfine · 19/04/2023 21:26

Keep your neb out of other parent's choices, it's none of your bloody business

IamnotSethRogan · 19/04/2023 21:24

My DS says the same. I send him in with fruit and don't give a shiny shit what other people do. Instead of policing what other people do, use it as an opportunity to explain that just because other people are breaking the rules doesn't mean everyone should. My DS mention it now

RobinaHood · 19/04/2023 21:24

There is no way that OP's DC is the only Yr2 with fruit and veg as snacks. He's obviously trying to convince OP he needs crisps and sweets Grin

NotaCoolMum · 19/04/2023 21:24

Oh my God🤣 how about you can teach your DC to not worry about other people and just concentrate on himself?.. sounds like you need a lesson or two in that as well.

Red0 · 19/04/2023 21:23

Climbles · 19/04/2023 20:09

The NHS spends tens of millions every year of full teeth extractions for children. I’ve no idea the long terms cost to society of obesity but it’s likely a lot more. The least we can do as a community is not encourage sugary snacks 24/7. It’s no a parental choice it’s the worst health crisis in the country. I work in schools and the absolute shit kids eat for packed lunch then the parents greet them at the door with more sweets. Unless they are autistic or have a restricted diet for some reason then encouraging a healthy diet is a societal issue.

Hear hear!
And if the parents aren’t willing to follow health guidelines and school policies, what chance have the children got?!
And it’s true like OP says, that those children who are eating healthily and whose parents are following guidelines, feel they are getting short changed… hopefully they will appreciate it in the long run though.

MagpieSong · 19/04/2023 21:16

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:57

My DC brought the same apple home from school so often, I named it Kevin and it became part of the family.

Love this!

I don’t think it’s so important for children to snack that you give them unhealthy stuff just to make sure they eat it, but that’s just personal opinion. My DS is king of sheer bloody stubbornness and I’d never get anywhere if I didn’t stick to my guns for months on ends. He also has a kidney issue that means he has low sugar, low salt, so we have to be hotter on it than most. When he didn’t want fruit at break, we just said he didn’t have to have it but didn’t replace it. He can ask for it again if he wants (he’s a good fruit eater bar bananas but didn’t like having to waste break sitting still as it took him longer to eat than the others). I feel like a lot of parents worry a lot over children eating enough when most eat plenty, but I’m sure I’m guilty of similar with other issues too. I think if they don’t want the healthy snack that is the child’s choice, really, they won’t starve. Obviously, exceptions to this include children who have autism or other issues and genuinely will not eat more than a few safe foods. I wouldn’t phone the school, but I do think it’s a good time to chat around our own choices and why we choose to do it this way as pp have said.

Hellybelly84 · 19/04/2023 21:10

If the school have a rule, then they should enforce it otherwise no point in having the rule in the first place. I got told off for a fruit bar once instead of fresh fruit so our school do enforce it 😅

But I dont think you should judge the parents giving them that-mine have a little bit of chocolate/biscuits every day and are fit, healthy, perfect weight (probably described as skinny to look at) and eat a totally balanced diet. A small treat every day if they are fit and active kids is fine.

I would just mention to the school that you would rather them enforce the rule if its there.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 19/04/2023 21:01

Not your child, not your concern. 🤷‍♀️

Redebs · 19/04/2023 20:58

Gymrabbit · 19/04/2023 20:04

Yet again another mumsnet thread that reminds me exactly why larger and larger percentages of students seem to be coming into my secondary school thinking rules are for other people and they are far too special to follow the rules like other children. At the OPs school the rule is that it should be fruit or veg - you may think that’s a stupid rule and if parents want to challenge it or need special dispensation then again totally fair enough.

I genuinely don’t care what the rules are but if they have the rule it should be enforced. I bet there’s a few teachers or TAs reminding students of what they are supposed to have and getting ignored or rudeness back because others can’t be bothered.

Yes, exactly so

sadsack78 · 19/04/2023 20:55

I understand your good intentions but you alone sending a complaint is not going to magically provide easy to eat fruit and veg for these kids and turn back the tide of the country's health crisis.

All you can do is feed your own kids well and donate good healthy food where you can.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/04/2023 20:53

Whatever your parenting policies are, you can bet your bottom dollar that according to your DC, every single other child in the universe has parents who do the opposite!

Its funny isn’t it how it’s never that everyone else has an earlier curfew / less screen time / less pocket money… 😅

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/04/2023 20:52

Mopscharlotte · 19/04/2023 20:24

Uniforms ? Park ….. excellent children going to the park , so much fun and time to enjoy the wider environment a brilliant education . And your point about uniforms, excise is ?

My point, assuming that’s aimed at me as I don’t see any other posts about uniforms, was pretty clear.

My DDs claim that everyone is allowed to go to the park (that I can see from the garden, as well as the school gate) before getting changed is as accurate as most of the other everyone else is allowed claims children make and likely as accurate as the Op’s DS’s insistence that everyone has chocolate and crisps instead of fruit…

sadsack78 · 19/04/2023 20:52

I would stay in your own lane and take care of your own kids.

I think it's a privilege thing, too. Some kids come from homes where parents are too time-poor to make balanced meals, and can't introduce them to fruit and veg the way you have been able to with your kids.

And some families are reliant on food banks where it might be difficult for them to keep a steady supply of fresh produce.

These families might have tried giving their kids a banana or carrot sticks but have maybe found they always got chucked away or left in their schoolbag, so it ended up being less of a waste of money to just give them things they will actually eat.

It is frustrating when you feel like no one else is making an effort but trust that most parents wish they could give their kids more and feel bad when they can't provide it. Count your blessings and focus on yourself.