Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other children's snacks are irresponsible?

359 replies

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:18

The official policy at DS's school (Year 2) is for them to bring a fruit or veg snack from home for break time. This seemed to be what happened when DS was in reception and Year 1, but over time DS tells me that his friends are regularly bringing crisps, chocolate bars and sweets in for their snack(s) and that he is one of the only ones who has fruit/veg each time.

Totally get that this needs fact-checking (I have a few reasons to think is is accurate), but if it is AIBU to think this is something I should contact school about? I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack, but as I have no control over this, AIBU to think that school should be enforcing the fruit/veg policy?

OP posts:
Crazycrazylady · 21/04/2023 13:13

Honestly op. Don't be that nut job. Some kids who have very limited diets can get dispensation , you won't know what's been agreed. Tell your ds that what other parents allow is none of his business . All you will get from the school is a eye roll and a reputation.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 21/04/2023 12:51

Ukrainebaby23 · 21/04/2023 07:06

I agree about the confusing rule thing. If it was a uniform issue and all the others were wearing non regulation stuff when your kids were sticking to the rules I have the same thoughts tbh.

However, the school are either aware and don't care, or just don't care so I'd suggest you give your DC whatever it is you'd like them to eat and not worry about the others or the policy.
Or change schools. Raising it as an issue with school will bring you trouble, I guarantee.

The thing is , it's never everyone bar one, be it snacks,uniform or any other school rule.

You actually have a majority of kids following the rules or as close as possible, a couple of kids that have adjustments ,either permanent or temporary, for whatever reason and a few more where either the kids (if old enough) or the parents are pushing the boundaries. Those few kids (in most cases it's less than a third of the class) that are the focus and suddenly it's translated into the whole class.

Goldbar · 21/04/2023 12:27

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 11:15

which is why it is generally recommended that children have three meals and two snacks a day.

i can bet that's NOT what is recommended in other western European countries which don't have an obesity issue on the same scale as the UK.

Its like pregnancy 'rules' which vary enormously throughout Europe. It's recommended based on not a lot.

Just like the 'five a day'.

It's cultural belief rather than actual science to a much greater extent than we are willing to admit

Regardless, that is what the NHS and nutritionists recommend for young children... 3 meals and 2 snacks per day.

And I get a bit bored of people banging on about the obesity crisis as if it applies to all children and therefore no children need or should have snacks.

Children are individuals.

Your child may or may not be overweight/obese and contributing to the UK's obesity crisis - I have no idea. It may be appropriate for you to send your child to school without a morning snack - if so, you don't need my permission, crack on.

My child is underweight for their height. Their morning snack is a key part of their carb/protein intake and ensures that they learn effective. We also don't have time to make big breakfasts here as I have a baby to feed/get ready as well in the morning

You do what works for your child and I'll do what works for mine.

Outnumberedmummy2022 · 21/04/2023 12:13

I don’t think you should phone school about other peoples children. How do you know that these parents can only afford to buy a pack of 6crisps in Tesco for 82p vs a tub of 6/7 strawberries max for £2.50.
this could be a money issue and aslong as YOUR kids are eating what YOU would like them too, what other children are eating is none of your business.

oldwhyno · 21/04/2023 11:26

There's absolutely nothing wrong with healthy active kids, that don't have a weight problem, eating a couple of biscuits, even chocolate biscuits, or a packet of crisps as a snack. Not every day, and fruit and veg are an important part of a balanced diet. But this idea that all snacks have to be fruit or veg is utterly stupid. Healthy kids can cope with and benefit from a sugar kick!

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 11:15

which is why it is generally recommended that children have three meals and two snacks a day.

i can bet that's NOT what is recommended in other western European countries which don't have an obesity issue on the same scale as the UK.

Its like pregnancy 'rules' which vary enormously throughout Europe. It's recommended based on not a lot.

Just like the 'five a day'.

It's cultural belief rather than actual science to a much greater extent than we are willing to admit

Goldbar · 21/04/2023 10:43

Eating three meals a day is a social construct and there is no reason why our eating should necessarily be structured this way.

Some people will do better on more frequent, but smaller, meals. Some people will be healthier on two, or even one, large meals a day.

Young children are much less likely than adults to eat a sufficient amount in one meal to keep them going to the next without getting hungry, which is why it is generally recommended that children have three meals and two snacks a day. Hungry children cannot learn effectively. Would you really want a reception teacher to have to deal with a whole class of 'hangry' 4 and 5 year olds as lunch time approaches?

There is nothing wrong with snacks and eating between meals, so long as the content is healthy and the overall amount is appropriate.

And while I do think if schools have a "healthy eating" policy, they should enforce it, ultimately it's part of a parent's job to say "no, just because Max/Asa/Arlo has a chocolate bar/haribo/cake for their snack doesn't mean that you can have it too... Yes, it's so unfair. Life's unfair - get over it". Putting up with pestering is part of being a parent - if your kids are the type who pester you, they'll just be pestering you about something else if it's not snacks.

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 09:38

nappysan · 20/04/2023 22:01

As a teacher the snacks children have and how they try new foods at lunch has a huge influence on their learning and development.
Children with painful and stressful dental interventions for rotting teeth, aged 4/5, are a direct result of parents choices of food, drink and hygiene habits. This is so sad and a huge problem in this country.
Childhood obesity is just the tip of the iceberg. When your child is growing you are building a person. Health problems for the future can be avoided or risks lessened by a varied diet. Not providing a balanced range of foods is neglect. If you don’t provide at least 5 fruit and veg a day they cannot possibly eat them.
Children who aren’t able or willing to feed themselves independently and/ or eat well at lunch often struggle in the afternoons with concentration, energy and mood.
Please think about the long term consequences of the easy options…
give your children a great start in life with a fun, balanced range of foods Le

The 'easy' option is to allow snacking at all.

Just give the kids proper meals at lunchtime and understand that some kids aren't being fussy because they are spoilt, they are being fussy because they are ND and in those cases their dietary needs might be less than ideal.

DS will try new food, he's weird like that, but he won't go near fruit (we now think that's related to allergy so he is having a physical reaction to some and that's put him off) and we are struggling with veg. He's getting there, but the harder we push the more avoidant he becomes.

It is pointless to offer five fruit and veg a day as the recommendations (which are actually founded on surprisingly little and pretty bullshit tbh). Variety of food and avoiding processed food is much more preferable in terms of health.

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 09:32

Fercullen · 20/04/2023 19:17

It’s reasonable to be annoyed at a healthy eating policy that’s not being enforced meaning that some children are eating an apple for snack watching others scoff a mars bar. It’s not fair on the kids following the rules and it would be much easier for parents if everyone was having fruit or veg. Unpopular view but I think people are really irresponsible with their kids snacking. I’m all for teaching kids healthy eating. At least they have a chance of that if they are eating healthily at school.

Snacking is unhealthy. It doesn't matter what it is.

Normalising snacking is the problem.

DS won't eat anything in school. So if he has a chocolate bar at school I really don't care.

What boils my piss is him being told that he can't have it at snack time when he's allowed it for lunch, he hasn't eaten it for lunch and then ends up going all day in school without any food at all.

All because of a fucked up 'healthy eating' bullshit which is actually encouraging poor eating patterns and labelling foods as good/bad which can trigger eating disorders when actually 'in moderation' is a much much better message.

Any parents seeing what DS eats / doesn't eat in school might be horrified. Doesn't mean they could get him to eat better in school. Nor does it mean they have a bloody clue what he eats at home, which is probably far far better than most of his peers because he won't touch beige and doesn't eat processed food (tbh I wish he bloody would somedays).

I really wish they'd ditch snack time altogether. The kids don't need it and the parents who profess their child does, are revealing a lot. The only reason you might need a snack is if you have type one diabetes. Otherwise it's just poor training for later in life.

Countries which don't have a snack culture don't have an obesity crisis to anywhere near the same level. Therein lies your issue. Newsflash to the health eater brigade - all food contains calories, the more you eat the bigger the issue, so don't eat when you don't need to and waste your calorie intake.

RoeK · 21/04/2023 09:08

Just to flag that as a child I was rarely allowed unhealthy snacks. I am fat as an adult, I think partly because as a result I grew to see certain foods as "bad" (or junk) and "good" and did not learn to self regulate.

As a result with my now 8 year old I don't restrict stuff- he's got basically unlimited access to chocolate and crisps alongside fruit, veggies, rice cakes etc. With the result that he is totally unbothered by said chocolate and crisps. They're just food to him, not a treat. If I put out a bowl of chocolate buttons he may have one or two or he may not have any - he doesn't feel the need to scoff the lot down because he knows if he feels like having one tomorrow he can.

He's a healthy weight with perfect teeth.

Wonderfulstuff · 21/04/2023 08:43

Imagine for one second that there might be a child who eats maybe 3-4 safe foods and that their parent has agonised over this but has agreed with the school that their child can eat these foods at both snack time and in their lunchbox. Are you really going to cause further distress and pain to this family by pointing out their parental failings and how, in your own words, irresponsible they are?

As you seem so concerned about other people’s welfare then hopefully you’ll have a little more compassion.

Fercullen · 21/04/2023 08:43

FairyUpLiquid · 20/04/2023 21:56

No, we don’t. We’re not the morality police and we all have a duty to mind our own bloody business and our own children. Professionals go through proper channels to help and support parents of children at risk of being overweight or obese. Schools also do a lot to educate about healthy eating including sending leaflets home etc. this is not YOUR job. You seem very controlling and too fixated on other peoples lives. You give your kid veg for a snack, pat on the back for you. Many kids can eat a variety of foods including crisps and chocolate in a day but eat fruit and veg at home and are just fine. Banning junk foods has been shown to create unhealthy relationships with food later on in adult life. Mind your own business.

It’s nothing to do with morality. It’s to do with health!

CoalCraft · 21/04/2023 07:29

When I was a kid my my mum wrote in to excuse me from the "fruit/veg only" rule as I was underweight and needed the calories from the cheese etc. I brought in. Think they eventually compromised with cereal bars.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 21/04/2023 07:22

Well. My elder 2 had a club biscuit for their break every day for about 8 years.
My younger one had an orange and banana cos her school banned biscuits.
Literally cannot see the issue. Except the Club biscuit sometimes got nicked!

WingingItFTM · 21/04/2023 07:10

I remember a post a while back from a mum saying she’d been whatsapped out of the blue by another mum telling her to stop sending her child in with Pringles!
You’re not her are you??

Ukrainebaby23 · 21/04/2023 07:06

I agree about the confusing rule thing. If it was a uniform issue and all the others were wearing non regulation stuff when your kids were sticking to the rules I have the same thoughts tbh.

However, the school are either aware and don't care, or just don't care so I'd suggest you give your DC whatever it is you'd like them to eat and not worry about the others or the policy.
Or change schools. Raising it as an issue with school will bring you trouble, I guarantee.

SarahJane796 · 21/04/2023 06:10

Firstly, all those people saying school shouldn’t be policing what kids eat - keep their noses out. Honestly, schools have to teach about healthy eating. They are not allowed by the government to sell crisps on site. Some parents have incredibly overweight children who do no exercise.
And in addition schools get bashed regularly for not teaching about life skills such as mortgages or how to vote. Some parents expect schools to deliver all aspects of a curriculum except when it calls out unhealthy eating. Make a choice. Parent your kids properly and stop complaining about school or actually listen to the school. They will both have the same outcome.
with regard to crisps and chocolate for a snack. If you are a parent and your child comes home every day and says that you are too strict because every other child eats crap for break and lunch then this causes issues within the relationship even if you are doing the right thing. It’s a fine line between giving in and doing what’s right for the health of your child.

SleepingTilSummer · 21/04/2023 02:15

It doesn’t sound like you would change what you give your child so what does it matter? Tell you child if that if others are having different snacks, they’re not following the school rules, but that you feel school rules should be followed. I’m sure this isn’t the first times he’s seen children breaking rules at school.

Are you going to call the school every time your child tells you someone broke a rule without being caught so you can ‘clarify the rules’? I wouldn’t recommend it. Just concentrate on your own child.

FinnysTail · 21/04/2023 02:01

If you and your child are happy with what he takes for snack time that’s all you need to worry about.

Re the people stating a pkt of crisps is cheaper than an apple or banana - we all know that’s bollox 🙄

“Rubbish snacks are cheaper than healthy snacks” seems to be the go to phrase for the uneducated at the moment. Take no notice.

T1Dmama · 21/04/2023 01:34

Is suggest that your son is probably lying.
snacks are policed and kids aren’t allowed to just eat anything at breaks.
mmaybe he’s seen a kid with a medical condition having a snack at break and doesn’t realise that they are not subject to the rules.
for example my daughter has a condition that means occasionally she ‘NEEDS’ sugar/carbs…. So while we usually give her fruit juice or dextrose tablets, I have friends who treat the same condition with sweets or a chocolate bar.
Either way though I’d keep my nose out, you will look very judgemental if you complain and it’s nots true, or the kid he’s seen does have health reasons.

pollymere · 21/04/2023 00:37

Having been on duty for KS1 at break...some parents send in stuff such as fruit winders or similar fruit disguised as sweets. Things with that annoying bear on (fruit yo-yos?). Chocolate seems to make an appearance via rice cakes. Toddler snacks made with vegetables in the form of crisps are also a popular "cheat". Organix Carrot puffs look like Wotsits. They also make bars of things. Suddenly the playground is full of "sweets" and "crisps". Maybe buy him some as a treat he can have for break sometimes?

This isn't ruling out that some kids seem to hope the teacher won't see a tub of pringles or a KitKat and sometimes it will be ignored but most schools I've worked in would be calling or writing home if it kept happening.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 21/04/2023 00:36

I generally respond to this sort of assertion with “how odd, the rules are very strict on this. Would you like me to write to form teacher/head to ask if they’ve changed the rules and you can have candy floss every day?”
the answer is usually to stall me

RobinaHood · 20/04/2023 23:38

I really hope you're joking. Someone working in a school with high levels of poverty and deprivation should absolutely understand the factors not excuses that lead to certain choices.

LBMBH · 20/04/2023 23:28

I’m so shocked by the comments on here! I’m a primary school teacher and previously worked at was a healthy eating school (which was in an area of high deprivation and poverty). Unfortunately some parents DO need reminding or teaching what is meant by HEALTHY. You wouldn’t believe what some parents and children believe is okay to have for breakfast and lunch. The amount of packed lunches that were left over McDs, multiple bars of chocolate, crisps Etc. With the price of fruit, veg and bread being what it is, there’s really no excuse. Schools are places for children to learn and grow… surely one of the most important things in life is being healthy. Children observe and learn from SO young. Contacting the school is a good idea! I don’t know what’s so unreasonable about replacing a chocolate bar with an apple… surely cheaper too!? YANBU

nappysan · 20/04/2023 22:32

Enough children and families each year that it is worrying.
especially children having to have teeth removed in hospital under general anaesthetic… imagine the stress and pain of that for a little child