Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other children's snacks are irresponsible?

359 replies

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:18

The official policy at DS's school (Year 2) is for them to bring a fruit or veg snack from home for break time. This seemed to be what happened when DS was in reception and Year 1, but over time DS tells me that his friends are regularly bringing crisps, chocolate bars and sweets in for their snack(s) and that he is one of the only ones who has fruit/veg each time.

Totally get that this needs fact-checking (I have a few reasons to think is is accurate), but if it is AIBU to think this is something I should contact school about? I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack, but as I have no control over this, AIBU to think that school should be enforcing the fruit/veg policy?

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 19/04/2023 18:54

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:34

Thanks for your reply. What if it was another school rule being broken? DS is confused because they know what the policy is (they all got told it when they started school) but DS sees no one following it except for them. I think this must be confusing for a child and makes me seem unfair by following the policy when others are ignoring it. I think it sends an odd message to the children about what rules mean.

I get where you're coming from and why you feel the way you do, however:

  • Schools aren't there to parent children, or indeed parent children's parents
  • They did a reasonable thing by putting a clear policy in place and communicating it. I don't think school's should be spending their money extremely stretched resources doing more than that
  • For many people who value personal freedom more than rules or social contracts even the policy might feel like a big overstep
  • Those people aren't 'wrong' they are just different to you
  • I understand what you mean about teaching DC about rules but honestly what they're learning is much closer to real life. It's rare that everyone sticks to rules...might even say it never, ever happens? That there is not one single rule that everyone in society abides by? So honestly if school made everyone abide to the rules they'd have a real shock when they entered real life...
DiddyHeck · 19/04/2023 18:53

I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack

And also...

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

So you think the parents are irresponsible, it contributes to obesity and puts kids off their school lunch.

Yet you want to know whether or not you can not follow the policy and do exactly the same thing? Confused

Vallmo47 · 19/04/2023 18:53

This is down to the school, not you. Yes the obesity crisis is a fact, yes if everyone changed their habits we’d all be healthier. But leave this to the school, please.

I have such issues with my child’s primary banning unhealthy snacks due to poor behaviour in the children - the blanket rule is absolutely fine and I’m happy. However, they hugely contradict themselves by giving them junk food as rewards without even checking with parents. THAT annoys me.

NeIIie · 19/04/2023 18:53

How do you know how much lunch the kids are earing? Do you police that as well?

Wenfy · 19/04/2023 18:52

I would definitely ask them to check and enforce. If their policy is fruit and veg they should be enforcing it.

Heronwatcher · 19/04/2023 18:52

This is going to come up again and again in other contexts. Computer games, films over their age, mobile phones, nerf guns, playing on play equipment which is fenced off, walking to places on their own etc. You can’t police other people or school. And no it’s not your responsibility to do it either. You need to learn to say to your kids when they ask why x is allowed to do y, “that’s between them and their parents/ the school/ their teacher, it’s nothing to do with us.”

cornflakegeneration · 19/04/2023 18:52

Custardbanana · 19/04/2023 18:37

Your DS is very clever trying to get you to give him crisps and chocolate.

😂 yep this

Pixilicious1 · 19/04/2023 18:51

You need to mind your own business

Happyvalleyfan · 19/04/2023 18:51

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

I’m surprised about some of the comments OP. So much for the saying “it takes a village to raise a child” if we can’t collectively promote healthy eating habits amongst our children. End of the day- it’s upto the school to enforce and unfortunately yours appear to have turned a blind eye towards this. At my DD’s state primary- the kids get offered fruit for a mid morning snack- but this may not continue as she’s only in reception.

Lara45 · 19/04/2023 18:51

Greensleeves · 19/04/2023 18:49

This post is peak MN Grin

Just keep your beak out of other people's business, OP. You'll be happier.

🤣🤣

Oysterbabe · 19/04/2023 18:50

There's no way a little chocolate bar or packet of crisps would stop them eating their lunch. Your child is year 2, he is old enough to understand that different families have different rules. Mind your own business.

PiffleIsTakingThePiss · 19/04/2023 18:50

@NeatCompactSleeper

Grin

Pigs are notoriously irresponsible. You try to guide them in the right direction but they just won't be told.

DaisyDando · 19/04/2023 18:50

It is your business if there is a school rule! If it isn’t and there is a free for all then you can’t worry about what anyone else is doing. But if there is a rule then the class teacher should keep to it. It’s really annoying for the other teachers when one class goes rogue.

PollyThePixie · 19/04/2023 18:50

I think your son is being a fly wee monkey and is trying to persuade you to give him chocolate or crisps in his snack box. It’s just a different version of teenagers saying but everyone else’s mum lets them. Stick to your guns if it’s that important to you and leave the teachers to check the snack boxes. If they are anything like my grandchildrens teachers they’ll be on the ball with it all.

devildeepbluesea · 19/04/2023 18:50

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 19/04/2023 18:42

I actually don’t think it’s a terrible thing to teach children that sometimes rules don’t make sense, and that it’s ok to challenge them. (In this case, does it make sense for those in authority to dictate what others eat? We certainly wouldn’t tolerate it from our employers).

I also think it’s a life lesson. I can see several houses on my street have their bins out (breaking the rules, they shouldn’t be out yet). Sometimes people follow the rules, and sometimes they don’t.

I quite agree but you put it much better than I could have.

SleepyRooster · 19/04/2023 18:50

Some rules can be broken, others can't. Isn't that a useful life lesson? Prioritisation, judgement, knowing what's important?

Greensleeves · 19/04/2023 18:49

This post is peak MN Grin

Just keep your beak out of other people's business, OP. You'll be happier.

TomatoSandwiches · 19/04/2023 18:49

MYOB

cornflakegeneration · 19/04/2023 18:49

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:34

Thanks for your reply. What if it was another school rule being broken? DS is confused because they know what the policy is (they all got told it when they started school) but DS sees no one following it except for them. I think this must be confusing for a child and makes me seem unfair by following the policy when others are ignoring it. I think it sends an odd message to the children about what rules mean.

Welcome to school life - kids and parents break the rules all the time

Topseyt123 · 19/04/2023 18:48

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:34

Thanks for your reply. What if it was another school rule being broken? DS is confused because they know what the policy is (they all got told it when they started school) but DS sees no one following it except for them. I think this must be confusing for a child and makes me seem unfair by following the policy when others are ignoring it. I think it sends an odd message to the children about what rules mean.

In that case I'd stop following it. Problem solved.

Fairislefandango · 19/04/2023 18:48

Do we not have a responsibility as members of the same community to promote healthy eating habits?

No. People are in charge of their own eating habits. It is absolutely in no way your responsibility to promote healthy eating habits to other adults or their children.

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

Well exactly. This isn't about your concern for other people's diet, it's about you being annoyed that your ds is following the rules and other people aren't. If you asked the school for clarity on the policy and they said 'Well we encourage it, but we can't actually enforce it', would you then change your own policy and let your ds have chocolate and crisps? Based on your comments so far, I doubt it! So what would your asking for clarification actually achieve?

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 19/04/2023 18:47

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:34

Thanks for your reply. What if it was another school rule being broken? DS is confused because they know what the policy is (they all got told it when they started school) but DS sees no one following it except for them. I think this must be confusing for a child and makes me seem unfair by following the policy when others are ignoring it. I think it sends an odd message to the children about what rules mean.

So your child is the only one having a healthy snack? Really?

GoodVibesHere · 19/04/2023 18:46

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

Oh so based on the policy you'll then start giving your child crisps and chocolate? Just do what you think is right for your own child policy or not!

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:46

PiffleIsTakingThePiss · 19/04/2023 18:44

If anyone's going to the shop could I please have two packets of pork scratchings. With extra lard if you can please. Ta.

Do pigs have much responsibility?

I'll do a bit of research on the way, but can't promise anything until I've spoken to a pig farmer.

Topseyt123 · 19/04/2023 18:46

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:30

Do we not have a responsibility as members of the same community to promote healthy eating habits? What justification is there for giving a morning snack of chocolate and crisps every day? Especially given the childhood obesity crisis in this country.

No. We have a duty to keep our beaks out and let other people feed their children as they see fit. Some children will eat fruit and vegetables, some won't.

Nothing wrong with the odd KitKat or penguin biscuit as a snack. Nor a packet of crisps.

I'm no fan of the food police, or the school lunchbox police either.

With the exception of enforcing a nut free policy due to allergies, everyone (including schools and other parents) should very much mind their own business.