Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think other children's snacks are irresponsible?

359 replies

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:18

The official policy at DS's school (Year 2) is for them to bring a fruit or veg snack from home for break time. This seemed to be what happened when DS was in reception and Year 1, but over time DS tells me that his friends are regularly bringing crisps, chocolate bars and sweets in for their snack(s) and that he is one of the only ones who has fruit/veg each time.

Totally get that this needs fact-checking (I have a few reasons to think is is accurate), but if it is AIBU to think this is something I should contact school about? I don't think it's fair on the kids to be having junk food as a snack, and I've observed myself that lots of them eat barely any of their school lunch, suggesting that they aren't v. hungry at this point (understandable if they've had choc/crisps an hour beforehand). I think that parent are being irresponsible to be giving chocolate as a daily morning snack, but as I have no control over this, AIBU to think that school should be enforcing the fruit/veg policy?

OP posts:
MissDollyMix · 19/04/2023 19:09

Just wait till your PFB is at secondary school where (judging by our local school at least) a bag of Haribo passes for a morning snack 😂
My DD almost never takes a snack in so when she does I let her take what she wants (so long as no nuts etc) She’s tiny so if they staff want to tell her she can’t eat her snack because Bobby’s mum is worried it might make her fat then THAT would be an issue for me. She does a lot of sport and eats really healthily at home- and that’s the crux, you just don’t know. In our family, we don’t don’t divide food into ‘good’ and ‘bad’, personally don’t think that’s a healthy attitude to have.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/04/2023 19:08

I think it’s fine for you to speak to the school for some clarification on this. Find out whether what ds is saying is right, and if so, what the policy really is? Is it just fruit and veg recommended but they can bring what they like, or is it only fruit and veg allowed?

If it’s the former you can then make an informed choice as to what you want to send ds with. If it’s the latter, you can ask them why it’s not enforced (if that is the case).

PippaF2 · 19/04/2023 19:06

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

But why? You want to follow the policy because you don't agree with kids eating crisps and chocolate. You want your child to eat fruit and veg.

So you do what's right for you and yours, let other families do what's right for them and theirs and stay in your own lane.

Bumdealoftheweek · 19/04/2023 19:04

Choconut Totally agree with you. Mumsnet is such a contradiction sometimes - everybody is allowed to make they're own choices and anyone who questions that is ridiculed. However, once they're overweight you're never allowed to point out that this may be a result of those choices otherwise it's insensitive and rude.

Bellyrumble · 19/04/2023 19:03

Haven’t read all the replies on this thread so someone may have raised it already

firstly it’s none of your business

secondly, some of these kids could be receiving help via food banks. So it’s a case of take what they are given. Sometimes free chocolate and crisps from a good parcel is the only choice they have. We are in a COL crisis after all

wheresmymojo · 19/04/2023 19:03

I'm intrigued as to what some PP would like the school to do to 'enforce' the policy.

Surely everything they can do would be completely ineffective?

The policy was clearly communicated and is being ignored. It's reasonable to think that any 'reminders' of the policy would also be ignored by the same people.

So what then?

Do the children get their snacks confiscated if they fail to meet policy?

Do they steal children's food and leave them with no snack when the child wasn't in control of the decision?

What is it that you'd like the school to do that you believe would actually solve the problem?

Glittertwins · 19/04/2023 19:01

PFB per chance?
Bring up your own child how you wish and leave others to do likewise. There will always be people who go around the rules so it's also an opportunity to teach your own child that they don't have to follow others either

Choconut · 19/04/2023 19:00

I agree with PP and would email the school and ask if the policy for snack is relaxed now the kids are in Yr2 or if it is still fruit and veg only. Schools can't have policies and then not bother to follow them, it just makes a mockery of everything. Either have a policy and follow it or don't bother having a policy.

Unfortunately it's probably a hassle to be constantly checking and taking away kids snacks because parents can't be bothered to follow the rules. Eating crisps and chocolate at break, then probably more in their packed lunch and then probably more junk when they get home for tea. It's no wonder there's an obesity crisis.

UpsyDaisy352 · 19/04/2023 19:00

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:57

My DC brought the same apple home from school so often, I named it Kevin and it became part of the family.

This made me howl with laughter!!! 😂😂😂

Applesonthelawn · 19/04/2023 18:59

I'm surprised at the responses here, you have clearly hit a nerve, bit of a Jamie Oliver/turkey twizzlers moment.
You are absolutely right that schools should uphold healthy eating practices.

Parents are free to feed their kids rubbish at home if they really want to, but not at school.

5128gap · 19/04/2023 18:59

You just need to parent your own child OP. If he thinks you're unfair giving him fruit and veg when other kids have junk, then it's your job to either explain and justify your decision to him, or alternatively tell him 'Tough. You're having a banana because its the rules and I said so'. Whichever best suits your style. What you can't do is expect other parents and the school to sheild you from owning your less than popular decisions. I guarantee that you will have the 'But so and so is allowed to...' conversations multiple times between now and the day he's old enough to do as he pleases, so best get used to it!

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:59

Redebs · 19/04/2023 18:58

🤣🤣🤣 Assistance Snacks!

😂😂😂

Redebs · 19/04/2023 18:58

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:55

Hmmm how about I swap the pork scratchings for guide dog scratchings?

Or police dogs, they're pretty responsible too.

🤣🤣🤣 Assistance Snacks!

Greensleeves · 19/04/2023 18:58

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

With respect, I don't believe you. If the school "clarifies" that the policy is a guideline, and they can't/won't actually stop children from eating the food their parents have provided, are you going to send your DS in with a packet of Monster Munch and a Curly-Wurly? What about the childhood obesity epidemic/collective responsibility/collapse of the social fabric you're so aerated about?

Pull the other one. You want to impose your weird food-restriction morality on other people's children, and you're pissed off that the school isn't being controlling enough.

ShimmeringShirts · 19/04/2023 18:57

DS takes crisps to school for a snack every day, he has ASD and an extremely limited diet to the point me, the school, his paediatrician and dietician all agree he should be given whatever it is that he’ll eat. He’a in a mainstream school, not a lot of people outside those directly involved know he has ASD. I feel a bit sick at the thought of other parents judging me for that

Moorwoodsriver · 19/04/2023 18:57

OP fresh fruit doesn’t stay fresh for long and it gets squished in bags - it’s probably cheaper to buy a multi pack of chocolate and it won’t go off so quick . My 14 year old son has told me not to give him fruit for school .He wants things quick and mess free to eat so he can get on socialising . He is 6ft and sporty and eats loads of good stuff at home .. you would never know ftom
his pack lunch

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:57

MissAmelia · 19/04/2023 18:56

I used to send my son to school with a healthy snack, and it invariably came home with him. So sometimes I'd give him a biscuit or crisps. I'd have ignored any notes home telling me what I was allowed to give him. I'd also have told my son not to worry what everyone else is doing regarding snacks.

My DC brought the same apple home from school so often, I named it Kevin and it became part of the family.

IrregularChoiceFan · 19/04/2023 18:57

Don't make your kid a target. Someone will work out it was you who raised it with the school, they will tell their kids and those kids will tell others and soon your ds will be labelled as 'the kid whose mum stole the snacks'. He will probably end up being teased for this. The teachers will probably be irritated they now have another job to do other than teaching and that could also impact their relationship with you and your son.

Its really not worth it, just keep sending in fruit and tell your son to ignore what others have.

Redebs · 19/04/2023 18:56

You're absolutely right to ask the school if it's enforcing the healthy snacks policy. Most schools don't let kids eat junk food for break because as well as being unhealthy, it affects their behaviour and thus impacts everyone.

Perhaps an email to the Head asking if what your child says is actually happening, or if he's trying his luck. Either way, s/he will probably take notice and hopefully address it if it is an issue, or reassure you if it's not.

It's an Ofsted criteria too

Darkchocolatekitkat · 19/04/2023 18:56

cowgirljoey · 19/04/2023 18:41

Not the approach I was thinking of. I would ask for clarity on the policy, as I want to check if my DS comments are accurate, and if they are, whether we need to follow the policy or not.

Is this really because you want the other kids to stop eating what you regard as unhealthy food then, or is it because you want “permission” to give your own child crisps? Either way, is this really what you want to become known for at school?!

(My children’s school supposedly has a fruit or veg rule. One of my children has special needs and a diet of about five “safe” foods which means he gets a packet of mini cookies. We all, parents and staff, agree it’s better he eats something rather than has a hangry meltdown involving throwing chairs or screaming. If you dared breathe a word of complaint in my direction you’d get extremely short shrift. Other families might have financial problems, disability problems or a whole ream of bigger problems than what snack their kids have. There’s kids coming into my child’s class having had nothing to proper to eat since their school lunch the day before. Mind your own damn business.)

MissAmelia · 19/04/2023 18:56

I used to send my son to school with a healthy snack, and it invariably came home with him. So sometimes I'd give him a biscuit or crisps. I'd have ignored any notes home telling me what I was allowed to give him. I'd also have told my son not to worry what everyone else is doing regarding snacks.

NeatCompactSleeper · 19/04/2023 18:55

PiffleIsTakingThePiss · 19/04/2023 18:50

@NeatCompactSleeper

Grin

Pigs are notoriously irresponsible. You try to guide them in the right direction but they just won't be told.

Hmmm how about I swap the pork scratchings for guide dog scratchings?

Or police dogs, they're pretty responsible too.

UpsyDaisy352 · 19/04/2023 18:54

YABU to make it a full report. Maybe just mention that your little one has asked for chocolate and crisps like his friends and you were wondering if that would be ok/if the policy had changed? See what they say and go from there. Don’t make it a huge deal though because you’ll get shut down very quickly.

The nursery I used to work at got rid of home lunches and would instead provide a snack each day. They got funding for it, and everyday we’d give the kids things like a biscuit/milk/apple or breadstick/cheese/water.

The reason we did away with home lunches was because there were constant arguments between the children and we’d have to confiscate certain things. One child would be sent in everyday with McDonald’s chicken nuggets! In the box!!! You can imagine how that went down - her parents were spoken to

Coyoacan · 19/04/2023 18:54

Personally I think healthy eating rules should be enforced. Like motorcycle helmets they are for the general good

Bumdealoftheweek · 19/04/2023 18:54

bellac11 · 19/04/2023 18:44

Yes, but lots of people are smokers, lots of parents are smokers, people smoke in their homes with their children present, its not advisable but people do it

So who is OP reporting those people to?

Its as nonsensical as reporting the irresponsible snacks

Well no, it's school policy so there are clear guidelines already in place as to what standards are expected. The OP didn't set the rules.

Just because you can smoke indoors with children, doesn't make it right. As with smoking, we are learning more about the detrimental effects of obesity on our health. You'll also see many arguments on here which report that losing weight is not that simple which suggests that it's not just about viewing things at an individual level but more about societal attitudes around food availability and the influence of consumerism on our eating habits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread