Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Negotiating exit from work

115 replies

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 13:17

Can anyone share their experience of going through this? DH is about to go through this as a project winds down and he has nothing else in the pipeline. He has a long notice period (6 months) but I’m guessing they will try to negotiate it down so he will probably get paid for a few months? Any insights appreciated/

OP posts:
yewtrees · 19/04/2023 15:16

I think if he has handed in his notice they are unlikely to take any further steps eg gross misconduct or performance plan.

He just needs to do and see where he ends up with his notice period. He either sits it out with them for six months not doing anything (effectively gardening leave particularly if he can work from home) or they or he may try to negotiate a shorter period. If I have a six month notice period, no job to go to and no client base to lose I would be trying to have the six months and get paid.

Law firms generally don't want claims etc. if they are presented with an underperforming partner willing to leave and not cause them problems then I don't think this will be difficult.

RB68 · 19/04/2023 15:16

It is always easier for someone else to argue your case than do it yourself, you say he has MH issues as well - it would serve him well to hand the negotiations over to another solicitor not in his firm. If its not something he is used to doing in his career and he has lost confidence then he needs the support of someone he trusts.

This also means that the firm will be reluctant to try any shenanigans such as sticking him on a performance review - as a peer outside the firm will be involved, and they won't want to look nasty and vindictive to other respected solicitors. Even in solicitor's firms, solicitors do not follow protocol for HR issues unless you hold them to account, and bullying and harassment is also still prevalent.

Employment law is detailed and nuanced and a family lawyer or probate lawyer for instance wouldn't necessarily be up with latest practice etc

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:16

He’s agreed that I might be right and he will seek some advice. Thank you mumsnetters! I had a feeling he was going to himself short but I didn’t feel confident about it until you confirmed that I could be right.

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:13

@DogInATent I did think off that but the contract is pretty general ie nothing like must bring in x number of clients or y revenue.

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:12

@GreyGoose1980 Should have said non equity partner (ie he receives a salary and does not own the business)

OP posts:
GreyGoose1980 · 19/04/2023 15:08

Just realised he’s a ‘partner’ (owner)OP. He needs to find out if he is actually an ‘employee’ of the firm in the legal sense. As pp have said employment law advice is crucial.

funnelfan · 19/04/2023 15:05

Surely in his profession he can easily find a suitable employment law/partnership law specialist to give home the best advice?

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 19/04/2023 15:01

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:57

@Coffeetree I understand that but if your contractually entitled to 6 months and the company has no use for you, then why not try to get 6 months pay whilst you sit at home trying to find another job?

How can anybody here answer that? You need to be talking to him, not us.

DogInATent · 19/04/2023 14:57

I think 'project' may be misleading here.

He's a partner at the firm. Part of his contractual role as a partner is to bring new work into the business. He's not been successful at bringing in new work. Because he has not found any new work he will have no fee-earning work once the work with his current clients ends. The work with the current client has a defined end point project and will end soon.

He needs to refer to his contract and get professional advice from an employment law specialist familiar with working with legal professionals in partnerships. Your husband may be right to be concerned if he's in breach of contract. This is what he needs a specialist to advise him, not Mumsnet.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:57

@Coffeetree I understand that but if your contractually entitled to 6 months and the company has no use for you, then why not try to get 6 months pay whilst you sit at home trying to find another job?

OP posts:
GreyGoose1980 · 19/04/2023 14:55

Mortimercat · 19/04/2023 13:57

Agree.

@Honeybunchcrunch

A payment in lieu of notice is a contractual payment and it cannot be made tax free. Only ex gratia payments may be tax free (to a limit)

Agree. The actual redundancy pay is tax free but not the pay in lieu of notice or holiday pay. This is a relatively recent change to stop large settlements bring tax free.

furryfrontbottom · 19/04/2023 14:54

Why would a high-level lawyer need advice from random people on the internet, most of whom will have no legal qualifications at all?

Coffeetree · 19/04/2023 14:54

Mortimercat · 19/04/2023 14:12

Dismissal for capability is a fair reason for termination, but it is not gross misconduct. I think your husband just wants to leave sooner to be honest.

I agree with this. Reading between the lines, it sounds like he just wants to get out of there, even if it means losing some income. And likely he's embarrassed to tell you that, hence all the circumlocution.

Just tell him you want him to do what's best for him, never mind the money.

GreyGoose1980 · 19/04/2023 14:45

If he has a six months notice period within his contract even if they dismissed him for performance, they’d need to pay this as it’s his contractual notice as he has over two years service. There’s no way they’d make him work the notice as it wouldn’t be in their interests.

The only dismissal without notice which is legally valid is a gross misconduct dismissal which they’d need to prove. A lot of firms do dismiss those with less than two years service for other reasons though as they can’t claim unfair dismissal.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:45

He’s a partner at a law firm so that’s where the expectation to bring in work comes from.

@OdeToBarney that’s super helpful. I didn’t know he would have to get advice on the settlement agreement. That means that he shouldn’t end up settling for less than the 6 months he is entitled to I hope.

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 19/04/2023 14:43

Motnight · 19/04/2023 14:42

I feel as though posters are being asked to send coal to Newcastle here!

Quite

Motnight · 19/04/2023 14:42

I feel as though posters are being asked to send coal to Newcastle here!

OdeToBarney · 19/04/2023 14:40

If they're having without prejudice discussions, presuming these are fruitful, he will be asked to sign a settlement agreement. It is a legal requirement he receives advice on the contents of the agreement, therefore in 99% of cases, the employer makes a contribution to the employee's legal fees in order for them to obtain that advice. Usually £500 + VAT, especially if employer is a law firm.

Get him to make an appointment with an employment lawyer, they can help steer him in the negotiations. They could do that on or off the record (ie off the record, he would be communicating with his employer but have advice from the solicitor in the background).

Poor performance is not a gross misconduct issue.

Whatever the reason for termination (barring gross misconduct) he will need to either be given 6 months notice to work, or have it as garden leave, or being paid 6 months salary in lieu of notice. This payment will always be taxable. He will also receive any accrued but untaken holiday.

On top of this, I would expect him to receive at least some form of additional ex gratia payments. That is the nature of settlement agreements. The employer is trying to avoid any claims of unfair dismissal. By signing a settlement agreement, your DH agrees to give up any and all claims he may have against the employer, in return for benefits. He is already entitled to the notice and holiday by law - so why would he sign without an ex gratita payment? Unless of course there is something he isn't telling you. I've known of clients on the hook for gross misconduct by sexually harassing colleagues who have kept it from their families! I'm hoping this isn't the case for you.

Go and see a lawyer. It will be worth it. I could give you decent advice in an hour. And you could end up with a lot more money (maximum award for unfair dismissal in the tribunal is 12 months salary or around £90k, whichever is lower. You won't get that much with a settlement agreement, but you could comfortably get 3-6 months salary on top of notice and holiday, depending on the circumstances. More if discrimination is an issue). Ex gratia payments are tax free up to £30k. Notice and holiday always taxable. Don't forget about the value of benefits, especially if taking PILON. Restrictive covenants are a negotiating point.

Greensleevevssnotnose · 19/04/2023 14:39

Sounds like a business development manager finding clients for the lawyers, so not a particularly well paid role. If he's been there two years he has rights but if he is already saying he will fail a pip then that's a will issue rather than a skill one. If he is fired for underperforming or failing the pip it is still not gross misconduct and his notice period counts he needs to check his contract.

Radiatorvalves · 19/04/2023 14:38

The other thing to consider is if this is a potential redundancy situation? He may not be bringing in business because there is none - not because he’s no good at his job. However is he an employee or à partner? That may make a difference to process, but still contractually 6 months is the starting point.

Margarita45 · 19/04/2023 14:38

So it’s either a redundancy situation due to volume of work, for which there are statutory requirements that need ti be met in terms of consultation, notice and payments.

Or it’s a settlement agreement between employer and employee. If it is, then again there’s a requirement to have negotiation discussion and formal offer in writing. This can go round the houses as many times as needed. Usually I’d push for a minimum of full notice period as PILON and stat redundancy payment too. Might be able to negotiate some additional benefit continuations or whatever too. Acas have a good guide on settlement agreements that details the requirements from each part. For info PILON is taxed, severance is tax free up to £30k.

If your worry is that an agreement can’t be reached and they’ll dismiss him, they’d have to have a substantial amount of supporting documentation and evidence for that to stand up. Additionally they have to go through warning proceed - all of which take quite a bit of time. From experience, companies don’t do this unless they know it’s full proof, since they’ll just be forced into a tribunal.

Cordeliathecat · 19/04/2023 14:36

Is he a lawyer? If so, I’m surprised at his lack of knowledge of basic employment law.

I have never heard of an employer negotiating a notice period down. He is in a very strong position if he has never had any official warnings etc.

He needs to speak to an employment lawyer. If they are after a settlement agreement they will likely cover his costs for that anyway.

I know a great employment lawyer that I have used many times in tricky situations, just DM me for their details if you want them.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:32

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves No he’s refusing to get any medical help unfortunately

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:32

@Radiatorvalves Yes I think he needs advice. He’s managed people out of his team before so he thinks he knows what he’s doing but I’m really not so sure.

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 14:31

@FriNightBlues His role requires him to bring in work and he has nothing despite trying for a long time. So once the project ends this week he has nothing left to do.

OP posts: