Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Negotiating exit from work

115 replies

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 13:17

Can anyone share their experience of going through this? DH is about to go through this as a project winds down and he has nothing else in the pipeline. He has a long notice period (6 months) but I’m guessing they will try to negotiate it down so he will probably get paid for a few months? Any insights appreciated/

OP posts:
dcadmamagain · 19/04/2023 17:13

I’m confused he’s a lawyer by occupation but doesn’t seem to u set stand the basics of employment law and an employee contract.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 17:12

@SavBlancTonight I’m getting the support I need through this. One of the sad realities I’ve had to accept is that if someone refuses to get help there really isn’t anything you can do for them, unless they are behaving in ways that requires sectioning (which he is not).

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 17:10

@blueshoes Thanks. He has experience in a couple of sectors. Will ask him to look at in house roles again. I think he felt that because his experience is in arbitration and not general commercial litigation that he’s not a good fit. He has spoken to a number of recruiters but nothing has come from those conversations. Maybe once his case is over he can double down on the job hunt. I am worried about how he will make such a huge transition at this stage in his career but I’ve always been a bit of a pessimist and right now I feel I really cannot be one.

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 19/04/2023 17:05

He's a lawyer and your asking on here for legal advice on his behalf?!

SavBlancTonight · 19/04/2023 17:01

If his mental health really is this bad, I think that needs to be addressed asap. Because a partner in a law firm who thinks that he won't get his 6 months is either in an extreme mental health crisis and can't see the wood for the trees or, unfortunately, is lying to you about what's really happening.

As MPs have said, law firms have good employee assistance programmes and he should be accessing it. And if he refuses, you should - most of these programmes cover immediate family as well as the actual employee. I'm not sure what, if anything, they can do to help if he isn't doing it, but it's worth a shot.

blueshoes · 19/04/2023 17:01

Yes, arbitration is not the easiest segue into inhouse. The case that he has been working for years, is that in a particular sector. If that sector is say, oil & gas, he can try to look for inhouse roles in that sector.

Alternatively there are companies that have big inhouse legal teams managing their litigation. His arbitration/contentious work experience will put him in good stead there. GC roles, at least within law firms, often involve handling the company's litigation. Look for a firm/organisation that is always being sued.

I am not sure whether he has spoken to a recruiter (or two) but this requires more exploration and putting his CV out there and speaking to contacts. Appreciate his head may not be in that space yet.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 16:43

@blueshoes Makes sense. His practice area is arbitration so not really the right background for an in-house role from what I understand.

OP posts:
blueshoes · 19/04/2023 16:39

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 16:22

@blueshoes Yeah that’s definitely the problem. His skill set is definitely more in management, strategy and being the public face of a company rather than a traditional lawyer role but finding a senior role where his experience will count and he is paid a decent salary is the challenge.

Unless he joins a start up (that could be an option but obviously risky if the start up fails), his best way of getting into a senior role within a big organisation is via the legal route. Once he is in the company, he can make connections and be on the look out for sideways moves into management. If he likes management and strategy, there is much scope for that inhouse but he needs the sector experience and commercial first.

Might take a few steps to get there since it is a career change.

He could try doing an MBA but I am not sure of the value of that v. trying to get into the organisation first. The opportunity cost will be huge unless it is a pt MBA. But that is hard with young children and if his MH is not good, not the best hurdle to climb.

Is he interested in management consultancy? Again, if we knew what his practice area or skill set is, it will be easier to come up with ideas.

SpecialControlGroup · 19/04/2023 16:25

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 13:42

So he’s saying if they can’t come to an agreement through negotiation, they would put him on a performance improvement plan (say for 3 months) and once he’s not able to deliver what they want they can just get rid off him?

Well this is true, but unless he is fired for gross misconduct they still have to pay him for his notice period

Royalbloo · 19/04/2023 16:22

Once the company put any offer in writing he will be advised to consult a lawyer. They can advise but if his job is to bring in work and he hasn't he should take what he's offered, or try and negotiate for slightly more but if they put him on gardening leave for 6m he can't get another job during that time anyway as he's still "employed", so I'd cut and run! And avoid disciplinary routes.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 16:22

@blueshoes Yeah that’s definitely the problem. His skill set is definitely more in management, strategy and being the public face of a company rather than a traditional lawyer role but finding a senior role where his experience will count and he is paid a decent salary is the challenge.

OP posts:
Sirius3030 · 19/04/2023 16:17

Mortimercat · 19/04/2023 14:01

If you received a PILON tax free, then I would put aside an appropriate amount of tax because you company have done that wrong and HMRC might chase you up. A redundancy payment is tax free up to £30k, this is not the same as PILON.

Thanks. Fine was perhaps slightly different as it involved a discretionary bonus. It was rigorously checked by company accountant and external employment lawyer so I am reasonably confident.

OnTheRunWithMannyMontana · 19/04/2023 16:16

Honeybunchcrunch · 19/04/2023 13:31

Does your DH have a PILON ( payment in lieu of notice) clause? I'd so and if this is a redundancy situation ( you mentioned no work in the pipeline) then he can be paid his notice period up to £30K tax free.

Sorry to be pedantic but just on the tax free point - PILON or anything that can be linked to PILON must be taxable which would include his notice period. It's only a redundancy or ex gratia payment that the £30k tax free applies to.

blueshoes · 19/04/2023 16:16

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 16:01

@blueshoes Thank you for taking the time to share that. We have spoken about going in house, legal tech etc but he doesn’t feel he’s a good fit for any of those and he keeps saying he’s done with the law and wants to do something completely different. The difficulty is that to get something that will pay as well as he is currently paid is going to be challenging. I think he’s really lost and he needs time to figure things out, which is why getting the six months pay is important.

I understand. It sounds like he has considered alternatives already.

The perennial problem, which is the one me and many of my other colleagues faced when wanting to leave fee-earning, is that very few roles pay as well as law. I can only think of Tech or Finance. He needs to clear his head first.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 16:01

@blueshoes Thank you for taking the time to share that. We have spoken about going in house, legal tech etc but he doesn’t feel he’s a good fit for any of those and he keeps saying he’s done with the law and wants to do something completely different. The difficulty is that to get something that will pay as well as he is currently paid is going to be challenging. I think he’s really lost and he needs time to figure things out, which is why getting the six months pay is important.

OP posts:
blueshoes · 19/04/2023 15:54

For his seniority, he is right to seek proper employment law advice about his exit.

If he has no clients to take with him, a good option is to flip sideways and go in house, particularly if he specialises in a certain sector. I would suggest he start searching for roles inhouse asap as that can take a while. If he joins a big organisation, there is a lot of scope for advancement and remuneration. The best way if he is a partner is to parachute in as a GC or close to GC. It will be a steep learning curve but if he enjoys management and does not like client entertaining, he will feel much more at ease and motivated. There is nothing more soul destroying that not having work to do and still have hourly targets. The best thing about inhouse is there are no time sheets!

If he prefers to stay in a law firm, he can also work inhouse as a professional support lawyer or in Risk or the latest buzz Legal Tech. There are senior non-fee-earning COLP and MLRO roles that sometimes go to ex-partners but they are quite rare.

Alternatively, if he wants to stay in practice, he can consider joining a virtual law firm like Gunnercooke or Keystone. There, he eats what he kills and keeps the majority of his billings. But he must have at least some clients of his own to make that work. There is an internal referral network within these firms but he will have to go out and make those contacts (call it internal schmoozing). There are no targets or external pressure on him or management crap, other than finding and doing the work. Some people prefer this freedom to working in a law firm and is equivalent to self-employment.

The downside about stepping down to join another law firm as a fee-earner as Counsel or as Senior Associate is that unless he takes a big pay cut, he will be very expensive and sooner or later, the conversation will come up re: making partner. If he understands the concept of "Finders, Minders and Grinders", the latter 2 don't come up that often to lawyers joining externally unless your dh has a particular niche skill that is difficult to find.

It will be very useful to know which area of law your dh practices in. There are lots of lawyer mntters who can offer advice.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:49

@billy1966 Thanks. Unfortunately, ultimatums won’t work on him. He’s in such a dark place that he’s ready to cut everyone out of his life including me, his parents, his siblings and his friends. The only thing he cares about are his children and they are too young to ask him to get help.

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:46

@MrsPinkCock Thank you, very helpful. I think it really is about not being able to bring in work. We have sort off seen this coming for a while now. Apart from one case which has been ongoing for the last two years and about to end, he hasn’t been able to bring in anything else. He’s been particularly focused on trying to bring in more work over the last 6 months as he knew this case was going to end but has had no luck. I don’t think there is any gross misconduct type issue (but of course I can’t say that with certainty). It’s good to know that in these circumstances he should get at least 6 months.

I agree he should be great at negotiating. In fact when I have been reticent to negotiate things with my employer he has always pushed me on it. I really do think his mental health issues are having an impact here.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 19/04/2023 15:38

Excellent advice from @RB68.

He is clearly not a well man if this has to be pointed out to him.

OP, you need to step up as you are doing and not allow him to be taken advantage of when unwell.

Be very firm with him on this point.
YOU need to protect the family from him, if necessary.

Have you asked for GP advice?

A dear friend of mine whose husband had MH issues and was refusing to be helped, had to be told she was moving out before the penny dropped that he needed help.

He needs protecting from himself and sometimes you have to apply tough love to convey that.

I am so sorry.

potniatheron · 19/04/2023 15:37

Speaking from my own experience, if you are a valued employee with a good track record then you don't get exited just because you're going through a dry spell for new business. Your bosses will support you in finding new opportunities until things get better again. Sorry OP but I do think you are not being given the full picture here and that he is being eased out due to a poor track record which puts him in a less ideal position for a payout. I would suggest you talk to him to find out what's really going on.

I would also add that even the most seemingly cutthroat firms have excellent mental health policies in place (because they have to) and so they wouldn't be easing him out because of poor mental health - he'd be getting lots of support and an action plan to help him return to full capacity. Or has he been through this with them already?

MrsPinkCock · 19/04/2023 15:35

I am an employment lawyer and it really isn’t in his interests to accept a shorter notice period.

If he is made redundant due to a lack of work, he would expect six months notice, plus redundancy pay. It won’t be a lot with him only having two years service though.

If it’s a performance issue then I would expect six months notice plus an additional three to six months pay to reflect the minimum amount of time it would have taken to performance manage him if they hadn’t opted to bypass the process.

And when it comes to notice requirements in a contract - the company cannot simply claim gross misconduct and get out of paying it. It’s not like unfair dismissal which is slightly more subjective - it’s a matter of fact, ie did he ACTUALLY commit gross misconduct (a fundamental breach of contract) which absolves any notice requirement. Assuming that he hasn’t committed GM then they need to give him his notice.

The only obvious reason to accept shorter notice is if there’s a real and genuine risk of instant dismissal (because the employee is guilty of doing something akin to gross misconduct) where the alternative would be dismissal without notice.

As a lawyer he needs to learn to advocate for himself, presumably he does this on behalf of his clients so he should be capable of negotiating a decent deal for himself!

Linio · 19/04/2023 15:34

Ok, it now makes a lot of sense if he’s a non equity partner. Unfortunately they can performance manage him out if he’s not bringing any work in. He’s essentially an employee with targets and if he can’t reach those targets, things become tricky.

Maybe he could look at other firms in a non-partner role. For example, go in as a director or of counsel. Less responsibility than a partner (and therefore less pay) but still a level of seniority.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 19/04/2023 15:32

6 months is plenty of time to look for a new job.

Lostwifehelp · 19/04/2023 15:25

@RB68 Yes confidence is completely shot and his mind isn’t working as it should. I think that’s definitely an issue which is why I felt the need to step in and try to steer him a bit.

OP posts: