Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to wreck my family like this? (separation)

82 replies

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 10:25

Married for 11y, 2 children. Things have been shit for 2 years at least. Two main themes - not enough sex/affection (him) and unequal household running / mental load (me) on top of that there was covid and a new baby.

The dealbreaker for me was my Dh’s constant need for sex and affection. When we agreed to try and have some time together once a week that soon was’t enough and he would get in bed all expectant and then get huffy with me if I wanted to read my book or go straight to sleep. We would spoon but he would always have to be touching some part of me that I didn't particularly want touched. My libido is so low because I am fucking exhausted. I do all the cooking, cleaning, laundry, childcare (minus one day when I’m at work) house maintenance, car maintenance, all the driving, all the school admin, all the weekend plans and kids parties, all the bill paying. I also work 3 days a week. He works 4 days and he does the bins and empties the dishwasher.

We’ve tried so many things to fix it but I think what it comes down to is he believes he is owed sex from me and if I am not giving him that exactly when and where he wants it he gets huffy, short tempered and will ignore me. It makes for a frosty atmosphere in the home. In the past I have sensed the atmosphere and given in to him but I won’t live like that. It makes me miserable and literally does nothing for me, why should I give him everything.

Anyway you get the picture. Spoke last week and decided separation was the way forward. We haven't spoken logistics yet just been cooling off a bit. We are amicable.

I feel terrible terribly guilty. It was me that decided enough was enough. My children are young and oldest is v sensitive and I worry what affect this will have on him. Its likely we’ll have to move which could mean uprooting school, nursery, friends, neighbours etc. Not to mention financial worries associated with all this. But then theres silly things like we have two holidays booked for summer holidays which we’ll now have to do alone with the kids separately. I think I am sad for the future I had imagined for them.

AIBU here? should we keep trying?

OP posts:
Bluebells1970 · 19/04/2023 14:51

It boils down to respect. He can see these things, but he chooses not to action any of them. Strategic incompetence, whatever, but he feels that he's above doing them. Even when he can see you on your knees with exhaustion.

That's not love. That's fucking cruelty. He will NEVER change, this is the rest of your life if you let it be. It won't always be toddlers, it'll be illness, school issues, teenagers... the stress never leaves, it just changes. You deserve an equal partner to walk through life with, not a millstone to drag along with you.

One lesson I've hammered into my 3 DD's is knowing their own worth Flowers

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 14:39

With the chores, we have literally sat and written up a list and dished out the jobs equally. We have tried apps too. He will give it a go but he will do a lazy job of it, i.e unload the dishwasher and refill it but leave half the clean stuff out on the side rather than in the cupboard because he cba to undo the child locks. Or he will tidy up after tea but leave the sink full of food that should have been scraped in the bin. So I always end up finishing up his tasks.
He will help with all the basics, cooking tea, dishwasher, a bit of laundry here and there but other bigger jobs like oven clean or hoovering never. I dont think hes actually ever used our hoover! Unless i explicitly say “please hoover up” the thought will not even enter his head.

OP posts:
Mochinated · 19/04/2023 14:30

The worst time is when DC are under 3/4. Can you make it absolutely clear than he either pulls his weight or fucks off? Be specific about what chores he must do to equate to pulling his weight.

This is assuming he is clueless rather than abusive. The sulking makes me think abusive but that is hard to tell from the thread.

It is worth one last go to get an equilibrium that can last for the next couple of years while DC are tiny, then revist

Dracuuule · 19/04/2023 14:28

I can't believe men like this won't even try. He's happy to separate when he could shape up, do his fair share so you're not completely wrecked and unhappy which could have a ripple effect of you feeling more supported and loved and then more in the mood for sex and physical contact.

That tells you all you need to know.

WhatToDo2023 · 19/04/2023 14:23

The problem with all the suggestions here is that it's all on him. He's the problem. His laziness. And you cannot change him. Repeat that. YOU CANNOT CHANGE ANOTHER PERSON. This is who he is. You have had the hard discussions already. He has not changed his behaviour. You can only decide what YOU are going to do. You can choose to put up with him, things will get easier as kids get older, but will you be able to let go of the resentment and memory of how much he has let you down at the hardest time in your lives? He's making your life hell and treating you like a prostitute. Your feelings and bodily autonomy mean nothing. It's all about him. You are there to serve him. Some women are ok with that, some aren't.

Cordeliathecat · 19/04/2023 14:22

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 12:55

We have looked into counselling in the past and unfortunately it came down to not being able to afford it. But perhaps we its something we need to do even if it means we buy less food.

Counselling is far cheaper than divorce and running 2 households!

You and said you love each other. These 2 issues seem huge when you are in the thick of it but they are not all that huge in the grand scheme of things.

You are exhausted and resentful of all you do and that impacts your desire for intimacy which frustrates him.

If you love each other and both want your marriage to work you can both fix this with a little support from a counsellor.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/04/2023 14:18

wankerseverywhere · 19/04/2023 13:55

Or perhaps "some people" think that completely upending their children's lives needs to be for a more significant reason than "my husband is lazy."

This family may need to cut their food budget to afford counseling. How do you think running two households is going to go?

I really think on MN there's a lot of "you need to be happy, get a divorce, the kids will be fine" rubbish churned out in some situations that are not ideal but certainly not worth all that upheaval. I think that is the case here.

Her husband isn’t just lazy - he treats the OP like a slave and a a sex pest. His wife being upset and near broken point hasn’t changed him. Not even the prospect of losing his marriage has changed him.

You may be happy to live with that, and for your children to see that as normal, but most of us aren’t.

There’s a big difference between “you need to be perfectly happy” and this…

mogtheexcellent · 19/04/2023 14:18

Dump him and run. The kids will be fine.

If you were worth anything to him he would be bending over backwards to take on some of the chores.

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 14:16

Thanks for all the replies, I do appreciate them all and mulling this all over constantly.

OP posts:
neilyoungismyhero · 19/04/2023 14:04

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 12:55

We have looked into counselling in the past and unfortunately it came down to not being able to afford it. But perhaps we its something we need to do even if it means we buy less food.

Do you really need the cost of counselling when the problem is so obvious?
Can you not have a final council of War? Tell him exactly how you feel and why you feel so knackered and resentful which results in lack of wanting sex with him. If he genuinely can't understand your point of view and is unwilling to do his fair share maybe its time to do the same with sex let him huff and puff. Leaving is of course an option but has all of its own issues when you have young children.

Stratocumulus · 19/04/2023 14:03

I was married to a sex pest. He was also a narc.

I did all the chores and tasks you’ve outlined for all our married life.
He did zilch but even if he had, I had lost the will to repair our marriage so counselling would be wasted on us. In any case he didn’t want to pay for it.

The final straw was him telling me to “eff off and go live in a nunnery!”
I almost did but bought a small house instead.

Such a huge huge relief to get away from the sex pest issues and everything else that wrecked my MH for years. I would rather have slept on the High Street in a cardboard box than spend another day with him.

No loss of libido now. Happy days.

wankerseverywhere · 19/04/2023 13:55

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/04/2023 13:51

This so much.

Not even the ending of his marriage has spurred the man on to stop being a lazy fucker.

but once her kids get more independent life will get easier apparently…

Some people’s standards for men are through the fucking floor!

Or perhaps "some people" think that completely upending their children's lives needs to be for a more significant reason than "my husband is lazy."

This family may need to cut their food budget to afford counseling. How do you think running two households is going to go?

I really think on MN there's a lot of "you need to be happy, get a divorce, the kids will be fine" rubbish churned out in some situations that are not ideal but certainly not worth all that upheaval. I think that is the case here.

Prahdeepx · 19/04/2023 13:54

I have one of those. Before we had kids we got on ok. But when I was pregnant he was an unsupportive dick, and when the baby was born he didn’t do his share. I was begging him for help because I was having a nervous breakdown due to the sheer burden and I was hallucinating due to lack of sleep, but he still made excuses. Then as the baby grew older he insisted his job was more important than my right to work and have a life too, so he just focused on his career and dumped everything else on me without consent.

I don’t think I will ever forgive him for that. It made me realise that he doesn’t love or respect me, and that put me off him. It’s not necessarily to do with looks or hormones or anything else - I simply don’t love him because it’s clear that he doesn’t love or respect me. And then my contempt for him led to me not wanting sex, which led to him sulking as you described. Even though he caused my disinterest himself by his behaviour.

I wish I could leave, but the way he dumped everything on me has left me trapped with no money. I desperately wish that I could be free and possibly have the chance to find someone who loves and respects me, however remote that chance might be. If you have the opportunity to leave then do so.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/04/2023 13:51

KILM · 19/04/2023 13:19

Can't believe people are suggesting try to counselling with a man who treats his wife like a domestic slave and pressures her into sex. You are worth more. Life is too short. Two years is a lot of time to try. The kids will be fine after the initial bit.

This so much.

Not even the ending of his marriage has spurred the man on to stop being a lazy fucker.

but once her kids get more independent life will get easier apparently…

Some people’s standards for men are through the fucking floor!

quietnightmare · 19/04/2023 13:50

Thing is he need to respect boundaries and split household chores and mental load but your going to be even more exhausted if you separate and he doesn't have the children 50/50 and ends up seeing them EOW and you will still do all the household chores and mental load

It's up to you but I'd try everything first

wankerseverywhere · 19/04/2023 13:48

FourTeaFallOut · 19/04/2023 11:18

I think I'm about to give advice that I'd have totally disagreed with only 5yrs ago or so. Just so you know, and you can disregard it from the outset for being inconsistent and changeable, if you like.

But I think it's worth hanging on in there and consider counseling. This is a fairly typical problem that is at its most fierce at this particular point in your children's lives.

You sound knackered. I know that knackered when you think about sex and then decide that actually that's sleep you'd rather not lose or the opportunity to just be quiet and have some of your own space being eroded. That isn't a problem with sex, that's just survival and efficiency.

This point with small children is the very hardest point with regard to this. From here on in, each of your children's steps towards independece has a material difference to the quality and space you have in your life. It gets easier and then it gets so much easier it feels like a breeze in comparison.

He could do a lot more around the house and I see your frustration around it. If he insists on being rubbish on this, could he go to work for five days a week and use the additional income to call in services that will mitigate his lackluster effort - cleaners/ service wash laundry/ babysitting services. Yeah, it might get expensive but not getting divorced and running two households expensive.

I mean, it sounds like you still like each other. Splitting up could be the permanent solution to the temporary problem. It might be the nuclear option which would have huge consequences for your children. I think it's worth exploring options to see if there's a different way to skin this cat.

👏

bibbitybobbityyhat · 19/04/2023 13:48

YABU

wankerseverywhere · 19/04/2023 13:46

To be honest, I would not end a marriage over this. You're really in the weeds right now, and I think the years when you have young kids are the hardest. But you can get through it, or I would be trying my best to. You work 3 days and he works 4...this is about shifting responsibilities rather than having an unmanageable workload that you're crumbling under the weight of. You can't "fix" him but I would be looking at counseling, etc, because divorcing is a permanent "solution" to what could be a temporary problem.

alltoowe · 19/04/2023 13:45

Ahhhhh what a horrible squirming little rat man you have there. No wonder you don't want to shag him behaving like that. What an absolute horror. Get rid.

ConstitutionHill · 19/04/2023 13:40

Many many children experience divorce and do just fine. If you decide to separate then try not to use dramatic terminology like "wreck" their lives etc and aim for collaborative parenting. Sod the guilt as well.

Mycathatesmecuddling · 19/04/2023 13:39

He's buying his energy and headspace to want to have sex with your overworked domestic load and then complaining you aren't seeing to his needs. You do nothing but see to everyones needs. When does anyone see you your needs?

Stop feeling guilty You arent seperating because you aren't trying hard enough. You are seperating because he never even bothered to start trying.

sadsack78 · 19/04/2023 13:33

Your kids will know if they are living with two unhappy people who are not in love. You are doing the right thing by ending things. A lot of people feel like they should stick together for the sake of their children but instead end up modelling an unhealthy partnership.

It will be stressful and emotional but you have to hang onto coming out the other side of the separation much happier, and that you are respecting yourself by not allowing yourself to be treated badly any longer. In time, your kids will respect that and it will help them form healthy relationships in the future.

Blort · 19/04/2023 13:21

Youre with a man who just wants to take every bit from you - your body, your energy, your devotion to the kids, your housekeeping, cleaning, organising, your spirit.

Obviously hugely depressing situation to live in. I wouldn't want my mum to be stuck.

Imagine how much more of yourself you can give the kids if this succubus of a man isn't stealing it from you?

Suzannargh · 19/04/2023 13:20

Newperson4 · 19/04/2023 12:55

We have looked into counselling in the past and unfortunately it came down to not being able to afford it. But perhaps we its something we need to do even if it means we buy less food.

If you can’t afford counselling, how are you going to afford to run two households?

Think about the future and where you’d both be in five or ten years if you separate.

The early years are a drudge but it’s worth persevering, in my opinion.

KILM · 19/04/2023 13:19

Can't believe people are suggesting try to counselling with a man who treats his wife like a domestic slave and pressures her into sex. You are worth more. Life is too short. Two years is a lot of time to try. The kids will be fine after the initial bit.