Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to do - dog related

181 replies

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 08:40

my partner and I want to get a dog but cannot decide between trying to get a rescue or a puppy. Pls can people offer advice/opinions?
we have thought long and hard about the pros and cons of each…
Rescue pros

  • helping a dog in need
  • helping a charity
  • Dog may be less needy than a puppy
  • can get clearer idea of dogs character
  • cheaper
Rescue cons
  • don’t know genetic/health/physical history of dog
  • Potentially harder to train than a puppy
  • Would be from abroad so (low) risk of parasitic disease (would be tested for these)
Puppy pros
  • more choice over what we get and when we get it
  • more knowledge of puppies past and parents health etc
  • potentially easier to train as stating from young
Puppy cons
  • not helping a rescue
  • cost is higher
  • potentially more needy at beginning

we have given it a lot of thought, but cannot decide what option is best for us (and the potential dog). We are definitely in favour of rescues but want to make sure we get the right dog for us.

for context, we are first time dog owners who have no children or other pets. We have a large garden and live in a town. We enjoy longer walks, paddle boarding, beer gardens etc. We would want a dog to come out and do things with us. We would want a small dog as our car is small.

if we got a rescue it would be from Romania but from a charity with a UK presence and support system. If we got a puppy it would be from a licensed breeder with lots of research into them etc.

Sorry that’s long but didn’t want to drip feed.
all opinions gladly received!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Parsley1234 · 19/04/2023 10:46

They do have dogs that can be only dogs as well

Parsley1234 · 19/04/2023 10:46

Many tears is the way to go they had 40 dogs arrive in one night 96 last week they have every dog you can imagine some puppies some older I am biased we have a rescue from there and raise money for them. Our rescue has been the most rewarding thing I’ve ever done

To not know what to do - dog related
To not know what to do - dog related
Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 10:41

Thanks everyone for your responses and it’s really helpful to see the range of opinions. It is definitely a minefield!
For context, we have reached out to UK rescues but not had much luck. We live in a flat and the garden is shared access (only with the flat above) which we think may be seen to be an issue. Additionally we have struggled to find a UK dog which fits our brief (small, young, ideally female) which does not have behavioural issues and would not be suitable (eg does not like men, reactive - we live in an area with lots of dogs around where we would walk) so it’s not like we have turned lots of these opportunities down in favour of a dog from abroad.
we have found a charity that has done a home check and approved our flat/garden. While they do rescue from abroad they have a UK base so we would go and meet the dog first, and they offer full back up and support if something goes wrong. We would not be rescuing from one of the charities where you only see the dog online and receive it directly from its travel from abroad.
please keep sending opinions but just wanted to explain that :) Thankyou

OP posts:
xyxygy · 19/04/2023 10:35

ToHellBackAndBeyond · 19/04/2023 08:43

The imported rescues are brought in to order, they're not a kind way to rescue a dog. If you do want to rescue support a dog who is already in this country.
Having seen the way our larger local rescue operate I would never rescue a dog because I couldn't support their way of working with a clear conscience.
At the end of it all only you can decide what to do but whichever way you choose don't buy from pity. Do your research, ask around, check licensing and health tests.
Good luck.

While this might be true of some foreign rescues, it's certainly not true of all. We've just adopted a rescue pup from Romania, and this particular rescue bring the dogs to the UK, get them a good foster home and then worry about adoption; the very opposite of "brought in to order".

In response to the OP...if you're going to get a rescue dog, choosing the right one for you is absolutely the most important part. Look at your own experience of dogs, how confident (realistically) you are in your ability to support them, and also question the rescue themselves on the support they offer. For example, the rescue we've just worked with use double chips and they can't be removed from it - effectively, they've committed to being there for the dog for life. They've been in contact with us daily, sent us medication for his mange infection, and have been invaluable with advice from the foster family.

Equally, though, if you're thinking about a puppy then...how confident (realistically) are you that you can raise and train that puppy to be a confident, safe and happy adult? Don't rely on puppy classes as a cure-all here, they're only a small component of what it takes to properly raise a dog from 8 weeks.

For what it's worth, we've had many rescue dogs over the years, and I still wouldn't be confident that we could properly raise a dog from a puppy; we're just better at helping dogs assimilate and recover from the trauma of rescue (and what put them there in the first place).

Forestdweller11 · 19/04/2023 10:25

We've had three UK rescues. All with their little quirks. All were a risk and needed work, all three were lovely.
We've had two from puppies as well. They are hard work but with care you can end up with a dog that fits with you and is a known quantity. Our latest pup is lovely but he's a terrier and has absolutely no recall despite our best efforts even after three years.

If you want to see a Romania rescue follow
Rory Cellan Jones on twitter- he has a rescue dog - Sophie from Romania
https://twitter.com/ruskin147 and tweets regularly. She was supposedly a known quantity and was okay with her foster family but was obviously tramautised on the journey to the UK and perpetually hides behind the sofa, will only come out on rare occasions, won't tolerate a lead and is a very scared dog. Their life together is not as they imagined it would be. I think they had dreams of long walks, afternoons in the pub with the dog. Not sure it will ever be achievable They've had her since Christmas and progress is very very slow (painfully) even allowing for a couple of months decompression.

https://twitter.com/ruskin147

Naimee87 · 19/04/2023 10:23

My vote is for a rescue as well. And like a PP said, one thats a little more mature in years as well. But whatever dog you choose its paramount to research what the breed needs in terms of a home-life/exercise/diet and what health conditions they are prone to as well. Its also really important to already have the time to dedicate to them and not think you will find it when you get them home. Even the smaller breads need multiple walks, stimulation and human interaction.

We recently were fortunate enough to be able to rehome a dog from a family that were just unable to provide her with a good home. It was awful where she had been, bordering on just pure neglect. Thank god we found her. She is settling in nicely but is far more reactive to other dogs/people than our other dog that we had since she was puppy. I think rehoming a dog is such a nice thing to do as long as you are in it for the long-haul. Theres another poster on here talking about rehoming his dog he has had 4yrs for a 1yr relationship as the gf is allergic... they become part of the family they arent a nice to have or an addition.

Vergeofbreakdown23 · 19/04/2023 10:23

I’ve had both and can hand on heart say rescue Is definitely easier and more beneficial to the whole rescue/charity help etc - we have a 14 week old Puppy at the mo and Lord it’s hard work!
Mainly because we are training but to train a puppy takes time and dedication morning noon and night and cannot be done one day and not the next!
Ive said countless times the past 5 weeks that a newborn baby would be easier - and I still mean it 😂
My rescue dogs were both puppies BUT we had older dogs who showed them the ropes, helped with boundaries and training etc
If your a first time dog owner 100% rescue first and work with your chosen centre to get the best most suited dog for you and your lives (if you work etc)
Hope that helps a little - good luck whatever you decide x

user4750 · 19/04/2023 10:16

I don't understand why people rescue dogs from abroad. It's so sad when there are so many dogs needing a home in this country why would you import more dogs. Please don't do this.

redboxer321 · 19/04/2023 10:14

Just to add, there is so much prejudice about 'rescue' dogs - I prefer to call them rehomers - many of them don't come with all these issues at all.
I saw one the other day whose family were heartbroken to have to give their dog up but their landlord was selling up and they couldn't find a house where the landlord would accept pets.
Obviously that dog is going to need support to get over its heartbreak but it's not a dog that's going to come with a whole host of issues.
Supposing it was true of course but that's just one example.

Try looking on dogsblog @Dogconfused if you haven't already.

redboxer321 · 19/04/2023 10:02

For balance, I have a Rommie rescue and she's a wonderful dog.
As long as you're prepared to learn and potentially work with a behaviourist and have lots of time, patience, and an understanding of what they've been through and are willing to help them overcome it, then a Rommie might work for you.

I've never had a puppy so can't comment on the amount of work they need but I see a lot of posts from people with the puppy blues.

As for the comment upthread: "The imported rescues are brought in to order, they're not a kind way to rescue a dog."
I really don't understand what this means. You see a dog on a website, ask questions, do as much research as you can and they are brought over. It's not ideal but they get a chance of a decent life.
If you go to a UK based organisation, you get to meet the dog of course but you're still just choosing one dog out of however many.

If you do go to a UK rescue, go to a small one. Organisations like Dogs Trust put so many obstacles in people's way they often give up and go to a breeder.

Good luck with it all.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 19/04/2023 09:46

See if you can volunteer at a rescue place as a dog walker for a few months. You might be able to progress to foster once you have experience. This will help you get to know different breeds and you might even find one you fall in love with. If you want a small, sporty dog then Jack Russells are fabulous little dogs. I've always had at least one of some description amongst our pack.

Whichwitchhasanitch · 19/04/2023 09:44

I’ve had both rescue and pup.

Whatever you choose, be prepared for your life to change.
Both are hard work in different ways.
But very rewarding.

bridgetreilly · 19/04/2023 09:43

When I looked into Romanian rescue dogs recently, they were very clear that they would not use first time dog owners, because there can be huge behavioural issues that really need someone who knows what they are doing.

I would look for a UK based rescue that uses fosterers rather than a rescue centre. That way, the fosterer can give you a good idea of the dog before you go ahead. Also, although you don’t always know the medical history, the dog should be thoroughly vet-checked when it’s rescued so you’ll know any current or ongoing issues.

Dogsandchocolaterule · 19/04/2023 09:37

Just look at the gorgeous little faces wanting a cuddle! Breaks my heart!

To not know what to do - dog related
To not know what to do - dog related
To not know what to do - dog related
Dogsandchocolaterule · 19/04/2023 09:35

My friend got a Romanian rescue dog and it was probably the worst thing she ever did. It is 4 now and is terrified if everything, goes for other dogs, won't let you stroke it etc. it had clearly been abused or something before it came to the UK as a vetted puppy at 12 weeks, it's not a normal or happy dog despite the love it's now given.

There are rescue centres in the UK with dogs and puppies that are DESPERATE for homes and they are the most gorgeous dogs, you could visit a few times to see which works for you.

www.manytearsrescue.org/. Is a lovely one they have every type of breed possible, they have a TikTock page where you can see videos of them and they are adorable. 🥰

When my son has moved out I'm going there to adopt a several!!

rumred · 19/04/2023 09:32

Rescue dog every time. For ethical reasons. So many dogs are given up because of the owners 'circumstances' who just need a good home to flourish in. I have rescue dogs and also foster. Never regretted either. And the lifestyle change is massive but great if you have patience and are flexible

TinyKitty · 19/04/2023 09:32

A UK rescue dog from a good rescue where they will take the dog back if it all goes wrong.

I do not include RSPCA in this as I know of examples where they refused to take 2 pets back when the owner became ill.

vivainsomnia · 19/04/2023 09:30

Getting a puppy is a selfish choice. It's the one I made because it was very important to me to train them as I wanted. It's very hard work at the beginning but then much easier for many years.

You can get lucky with a rescue and indeed it's been the case for most of the dog walkers I got to meet but it is also the risk.

It is a very hard decision. I like to feel in control of my life hence going for the puppy choice but yes, I do feel guilty.

If you do go for a puppy, remember that most of the training has to be done in the first 6 months, and the earlier the easier. You don't have to pay a specialist but do your research well before getting your puppy.

Mortimercat · 19/04/2023 09:24

I also cannot fathom why you would take a rescue from overseas, there are plenty of dogs in the UK looking for a new home.

I have only had two dogs, got them both as puppies. I think if we ever get another one, which will be after these two have gone, it would be a rescue. I don’t fancy puppy days again and I think I would like to give at least one dog another home which would be forever.

Bluebells1970 · 19/04/2023 09:23

I would never rescue from abroad, I would rehome from a small breed specific charity that has a good "warts and all" history of the dog.

I would also be a bit wary of the charities that rescue breeding dogs too - most have never lived in a house or been treated kindly by human hand, need a huge amount of input and probably aren't great 1st dogs.

JulieHoney · 19/04/2023 09:23

With only one exception, every rescue dog I’ve known has had significant behavioural issues. They aren’t an easy option.

Babsexxx · 19/04/2023 09:19

I would obdviously rescue a uk dog???? Why from abroad? Puppies are extremely hard work I had my first puppy in years two years ago and I love her to bits but never again if I was to get a dog I’d be looking at ages from 2 and upwards!

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/04/2023 09:17

Uk rescue dog with no previous behavioural issues. I think something like greyhounds are a fab choice for first time owners providing you use your brain and you don't own a cat..!
Taking on a Romanian rescue is a very tricky thing - I know several and none are easy dogs. They need experience. They are often abused street dogs.

Phgty · 19/04/2023 09:15

Isitoknow · 19/04/2023 08:48

You won’t know the true nature of a rescue until they’ve been with you for a year. Dogs that have been through trauma / had difficult lives come with problems. They are not the easier option when compared to a puppy.

I'd say a puppy isn't an easier option compared to a rescue dog. I've had both, and can say with certainty the puppies are much harder work. There's a much bigger impact on your life, and 2 years of them being dickheads.

I've always chosen rescues carefully though, it's worth waiting for the right dog, a good rescue will help match.

For example a retired greyhound is a fantastic first dog, or a lurcher.

BMW6 · 19/04/2023 08:58

I'd suggest, as you a new to dog ownership, getting a UK rescue dog who is getting along in age.
They will be house trained, familiar with a household and the dynamics, less energetic and easier to control on walks.

They would get several years of a loving home to see out their days, and you would gain valuable experience and, of course, unconditional love.

Swipe left for the next trending thread