Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to do - dog related

181 replies

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 08:40

my partner and I want to get a dog but cannot decide between trying to get a rescue or a puppy. Pls can people offer advice/opinions?
we have thought long and hard about the pros and cons of each…
Rescue pros

  • helping a dog in need
  • helping a charity
  • Dog may be less needy than a puppy
  • can get clearer idea of dogs character
  • cheaper
Rescue cons
  • don’t know genetic/health/physical history of dog
  • Potentially harder to train than a puppy
  • Would be from abroad so (low) risk of parasitic disease (would be tested for these)
Puppy pros
  • more choice over what we get and when we get it
  • more knowledge of puppies past and parents health etc
  • potentially easier to train as stating from young
Puppy cons
  • not helping a rescue
  • cost is higher
  • potentially more needy at beginning

we have given it a lot of thought, but cannot decide what option is best for us (and the potential dog). We are definitely in favour of rescues but want to make sure we get the right dog for us.

for context, we are first time dog owners who have no children or other pets. We have a large garden and live in a town. We enjoy longer walks, paddle boarding, beer gardens etc. We would want a dog to come out and do things with us. We would want a small dog as our car is small.

if we got a rescue it would be from Romania but from a charity with a UK presence and support system. If we got a puppy it would be from a licensed breeder with lots of research into them etc.

Sorry that’s long but didn’t want to drip feed.
all opinions gladly received!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Newuser82 · 19/04/2023 20:30

What is your thinking in getting a Romanian rescue? There are so many dogs in this country needing rehoming.

wheresmymojo · 19/04/2023 20:25

user4750 · 19/04/2023 10:16

I don't understand why people rescue dogs from abroad. It's so sad when there are so many dogs needing a home in this country why would you import more dogs. Please don't do this.

I don't understand why people think dogs who happen to have been born in the UK deserve a home but dogs born outside of the UK don't?

UK rescues are so over zealous with their thoughts on what makes a suitable home that they make it practically impossible to re-home a dog if you have anything remotely different.

For us that was having cats and being first time dog owners.

I stalked about fifteen rescues in the South East trying to adopt a dog but absolutely no chance.

We're a couple with no DC, who grew up with dogs and who are very clued up having spent lots and lots of time researching all aspects of dog ownership, we have a large 4 bed house and fully walled garden in the countryside and both WFH.

If we couldn't adopt in the UK then not sure who can TBH...

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 20:24

Disneygirl37 · 19/04/2023 20:08

What rescue has approved a flat with a shared garden? Most decent rescues wouldn't approve that for good reasons.

I have a Romanian rescue and the rescue we used wouldn't have approved that. There are some good ones but there also are some really dodgy ones!

I’m not going to name names - but to offer context our flat is not in a big block with a big communal garden. It is the ground floor of a house with direct garden access and it’s own entrance from the street, no shared access areas other than the garden. The garden is shared with two people who live in the flat above. It’s rarely used other than by them letting the dog they look after in there every few weeks. We are on friendly terms with them. All this was explained to the rescue centre.

OP posts:
Disneygirl37 · 19/04/2023 20:08

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 10:41

Thanks everyone for your responses and it’s really helpful to see the range of opinions. It is definitely a minefield!
For context, we have reached out to UK rescues but not had much luck. We live in a flat and the garden is shared access (only with the flat above) which we think may be seen to be an issue. Additionally we have struggled to find a UK dog which fits our brief (small, young, ideally female) which does not have behavioural issues and would not be suitable (eg does not like men, reactive - we live in an area with lots of dogs around where we would walk) so it’s not like we have turned lots of these opportunities down in favour of a dog from abroad.
we have found a charity that has done a home check and approved our flat/garden. While they do rescue from abroad they have a UK base so we would go and meet the dog first, and they offer full back up and support if something goes wrong. We would not be rescuing from one of the charities where you only see the dog online and receive it directly from its travel from abroad.
please keep sending opinions but just wanted to explain that :) Thankyou

What rescue has approved a flat with a shared garden? Most decent rescues wouldn't approve that for good reasons.

I have a Romanian rescue and the rescue we used wouldn't have approved that. There are some good ones but there also are some really dodgy ones!

wheresmymojo · 19/04/2023 20:06

Nap1983 · 19/04/2023 08:50

I feel bad saying this but I’d never get a rescue (barring a few circumstances) every one I see when out walking had issues either dog reactive, people reactive, nervous or had separation anxiety. You don’t really know their history especially ones “rescued” from abroad.

I have a rescue and completely agree with this.

Rescues do often come with behavioural issues because they've often gone through some kind of trauma.

Personally that was fine with me, I'm happy to put the work in and in some ways I think I've formed an even tighter bond with my dog because of it.

She's a rescue dog and I'm sort of a 'rescue human' having gone through childhood trauma and having ADHD so we're perfect together and I wouldn't change her or any of the quirks we've worked on together or the ones she still has.

Only you can know whether this is the right set up for you though.

You can get rescues who are trained with no behaviour issues (e.g. their previous owner passed away) but you'd need to be willing to wait for the right dog.

redboxer321 · 19/04/2023 19:57

When I had my first appointment with the vet she called me first to ask me about my Rommie rescue. I'd had her for a few weeks by then but couldn't take her as I needed to get her comfortable in the car before I did. The vet sounded hesitant, agreed to see her but said she'd probably have to muzzle her.
I said that was fine and completely her decision but she probably wouldn't need to.
They went in, came back out (it was Covid times and I wasn't allowed in) and the vet declared: "She's lovely".

I appreciate it is not like that for everyone. I also think the vet further up this thread makes some good points and rehoming from abroad is not something to be taken lightly but it can work out and a dog locked in a hell hole of an existence can get a chance of a good life.

Last thing: Well said @GreekDogRescue

Itiswhatitis21 · 19/04/2023 19:38

I will give the positive side to adopting a dog from Romania
April 2021 we picked up our dog we had adopted from Romania through a UK based rescue.
We didn't know what to expect, but what I can say is she has completed the family
She was 2 years old when we got her, a golden Labrador (cross I think as she is shorter than a lab)
She has 2 downfalls which even 2 years on we are still working on

  1. she's a runner if you leave the front door open, but if we go to a field off lead and we have a ball she will not run off
  2. Greedy, will take food off a plate if left unattended (we just don't leave food around) I still wouldn't change her for the world and I can't believe anyone could give her up, she's cuddly, great with kids, cats and people, has never messed in the house or chewed anything up. She's just beautiful ❤️
LucyLucyAppleJuice · 19/04/2023 19:29

Please do look at Silverfox dog rescue. They specialise in small dogs. I agree with everything @Verv says, they're a wonderful rehoming charity, I have 2 dogs from them.

Stardust32 · 19/04/2023 19:21

My friend has two Romanian rescues and they were utterly traumatised by the journey over here (in a van for a number of days).

They are both reactive dogs and despite lots of training, hundreds spent on behaviourists, they can’t socialise the dogs with other people/dogs so they can’t take them to cafes/beer gardens or walks with friends etc

Unbridezilla · 19/04/2023 19:21

If you have no experience of dogs, and live near a centre, guide dog training dog fostering is a great introduction.

If you live less close, and are able to have a puppy, there is always GD puppy raising. You get given training all the way through on how to train a pup, which is a great opportunity to learn and can be applied to a future pup.of your own

GreekDogRescue · 19/04/2023 19:17

@ToHellBackAndBeyond When you have spent time in Romanian and Greek dog pounds come back and tell me that rescuing a dog from one of these places isn’t ‘kind’.
The latest wheeze in Romania is to
lace cat food with pins to feed to stray cats.
it’s another world.

NewtonsCradle · 19/04/2023 19:16

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 08:40

my partner and I want to get a dog but cannot decide between trying to get a rescue or a puppy. Pls can people offer advice/opinions?
we have thought long and hard about the pros and cons of each…
Rescue pros

  • helping a dog in need
  • helping a charity
  • Dog may be less needy than a puppy
  • can get clearer idea of dogs character
  • cheaper
Rescue cons
  • don’t know genetic/health/physical history of dog
  • Potentially harder to train than a puppy
  • Would be from abroad so (low) risk of parasitic disease (would be tested for these)
Puppy pros
  • more choice over what we get and when we get it
  • more knowledge of puppies past and parents health etc
  • potentially easier to train as stating from young
Puppy cons
  • not helping a rescue
  • cost is higher
  • potentially more needy at beginning

we have given it a lot of thought, but cannot decide what option is best for us (and the potential dog). We are definitely in favour of rescues but want to make sure we get the right dog for us.

for context, we are first time dog owners who have no children or other pets. We have a large garden and live in a town. We enjoy longer walks, paddle boarding, beer gardens etc. We would want a dog to come out and do things with us. We would want a small dog as our car is small.

if we got a rescue it would be from Romania but from a charity with a UK presence and support system. If we got a puppy it would be from a licensed breeder with lots of research into them etc.

Sorry that’s long but didn’t want to drip feed.
all opinions gladly received!!

Where are you based?

Carouselfish · 19/04/2023 19:15

But...you DON'T know the personality of a rescue. You wont know what has happened to them previously. You wont know what triggers they havent encountered at the rescue centre.
And more importantly, as a first time owner, you simply wont be clued in enough to their 'language' to always react appropriately.

moveoverye · 19/04/2023 19:09

Haven’t read the whole thread, but have you considered rescuing from Takis Shelter in Crete? They will never “ship” a dog, you have to go there to choose and collect the dog in person, and arrange your own way home (usually by train/ferry/car). Takis will not let you take a dog if you are not a good match for them.

Spend some time following his Facebook page, he is a very ethical rescue, I am considering rescuing from there.

One pro, for me, of rescuing from abroad, is I think mongrel breeds are far healthier than pure-breeds or crossbreeds, which is what you will get in the UK, even in rescues.

Rhondaa · 19/04/2023 19:06

steppemum · 19/04/2023 18:56

They are kept in kennels in rescues

they really aren't.
Many small rescues use foster homes.
I would wnat to knwo how the dog is in a home

Many are kept in kennels. Whether indoor with heating or whatever the point is it is impossible to know if you'll get a nighttime howler or not. Unless they are one of the very few in foster homes.

MiniTheMinx · 19/04/2023 19:05

A dog from a UK rescue is probably more likely to have behaviour issues than many dogs from abroad. People give up on dogs that have behaviour problems!

I have a rescue from Spain who has absolutely no behaviour issues. He was two when he came to us. When we are ready (hoping to move) we will adopt again from the same rescue.

Offthexmaslist · 19/04/2023 19:04

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/04/2023 19:02

Ah @Offthexmaslist - I'm afraid ours wasn't ideal with cats! He did actually kill ours. He was as thoroughly cat tested as possible but she ran and I think he finally caught what he'd been chasing for years!

That is so sad.. I take my advice back BlushFlowers

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/04/2023 19:02

Ah @Offthexmaslist - I'm afraid ours wasn't ideal with cats! He did actually kill ours. He was as thoroughly cat tested as possible but she ran and I think he finally caught what he'd been chasing for years!

Annfr · 19/04/2023 19:01

ThereIsNoSuchThingAsRoadTax · 19/04/2023 12:54

I'm uneasy about the ethics of rehoming Romanian dogs. As other posters have said, they are generally street dogs 'rescued' to order to supply the demand here. But what makes us think that street dogs need to be rescued? They are quite distinct from pet dogs. They aren't simply dogs that have strayed from their homes, they are an independent population that lives alongside humans rather than with them. What are we rescuing them from? Why do we assume that transporting them hundreds of miles to a completely alien lifestyle is better for them? How is it different to rounding up squirrels from the local park and keeping them as pets (apart from that being illegal)?

This is utter trash.

I have a Romanian dog and involved in several charities. They are caught by dog catchers and aren't allowed to just live peacefully on the streets. They are then thrown into disgusting public shelters without their basic needs being met before being killed cruelly unless a rescue takes them to a private shelter and then rehomed.

steppemum · 19/04/2023 18:56

They are kept in kennels in rescues

they really aren't.
Many small rescues use foster homes.
I would wnat to knwo how the dog is in a home

Rhondaa · 19/04/2023 18:52

'find it very distressing to watch Sophie from Romania, she is not a happy dog'

I do too. She clearly is happier outside and instead of trying to domesticate her the best thing they could do is get her an outdoor kennel and let her have her solitude.

Rockbird · 19/04/2023 18:51

We rescued from abroad (N Macedonia). We tried so hard to rescue from the UK but with 2 cats and children we were turned down every time. Added to that, they always wanted a resident dog to teach the rescue.

We went with a UK based charity Paw Project UK who work with rescues in Eastern Europe. Our girl was dumped outside their door in a bag with her sister at a few hours old. We've had her 6 months now and she's a beauty. She's a pain in the arse puppy but no issues so far outside of just being a puppy.

Offthexmaslist · 19/04/2023 18:51

OrlandointheWilderness · 19/04/2023 09:17

Uk rescue dog with no previous behavioural issues. I think something like greyhounds are a fab choice for first time owners providing you use your brain and you don't own a cat..!
Taking on a Romanian rescue is a very tricky thing - I know several and none are easy dogs. They need experience. They are often abused street dogs.

Yes !, Greyhounds are fab... never met a tricky one ... also great with cats which is an added bonus

Secretvet · 19/04/2023 18:45

I’ve name changed for this, I’m a vet. I’m adding my voice to the don’t get a rescue from abroad crew. Some of the rescues are very good, but many are making money from this, and some of the dogs come here and are frankly totally terrified of life/people/living in a house. (I find it very distressing to watch Sophie from Romania, she is not a happy dog). Street dogs are not always happy living such a different life. In addition, some of these rescues can be economical with the truth when it comes to testing for diseases, leishmaniasis can cause kidney failure, even when it has been dormant for some time. Brucellosis can pass to humans and be life changing. In a recent vet survey close to 99% of practicing vets would never get an imported rescue.

I’ve been a vet for close on 40 years and this has been such a sea change, we sometimes can really struggle to get some of these dogs in the surgery, never mind lay a hand on them. Yes some are fine but they are the exceptions.

I would recommend looking at uk breed specific rescues. I have a rescue Border Terrier, I got her under a year after spending her first few months shut in a tiny cage. She still has some trust issues with new people but is a joy. And the greyhound/whippet recommendations are spot on, kind gentle dogs who will fit into a home so well as long as they have a comfy sofa to recline on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread