Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know what to do - dog related

181 replies

Dogconfused · 19/04/2023 08:40

my partner and I want to get a dog but cannot decide between trying to get a rescue or a puppy. Pls can people offer advice/opinions?
we have thought long and hard about the pros and cons of each…
Rescue pros

  • helping a dog in need
  • helping a charity
  • Dog may be less needy than a puppy
  • can get clearer idea of dogs character
  • cheaper
Rescue cons
  • don’t know genetic/health/physical history of dog
  • Potentially harder to train than a puppy
  • Would be from abroad so (low) risk of parasitic disease (would be tested for these)
Puppy pros
  • more choice over what we get and when we get it
  • more knowledge of puppies past and parents health etc
  • potentially easier to train as stating from young
Puppy cons
  • not helping a rescue
  • cost is higher
  • potentially more needy at beginning

we have given it a lot of thought, but cannot decide what option is best for us (and the potential dog). We are definitely in favour of rescues but want to make sure we get the right dog for us.

for context, we are first time dog owners who have no children or other pets. We have a large garden and live in a town. We enjoy longer walks, paddle boarding, beer gardens etc. We would want a dog to come out and do things with us. We would want a small dog as our car is small.

if we got a rescue it would be from Romania but from a charity with a UK presence and support system. If we got a puppy it would be from a licensed breeder with lots of research into them etc.

Sorry that’s long but didn’t want to drip feed.
all opinions gladly received!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
lljkk · 20/04/2023 22:43

is anyone following SophieFromRomania on Twitter?
It's sad story because she's taking so long to adapt and become a pet.
She is progressing, but so so so slowly.
Not a difficult dog but seemingly very timid.

The journalist who got her had a placid family dog (also Romie rescue) previously, but Sophie is a much harder nut to crack.

There have been a few stories on here of nightmare dogs acquired as puppies but hugely problematic after years of trying to resolve their issues, even well bred cared for puppies aren't guaranteed to become nice pets.

Noodles1234 · 20/04/2023 21:16

Battersea Dogs Home say from PoG Love of Dogs (and I’m sure others) check personalities of their animals and check for any medical issues. You get advised of any issues and they will recommend what age range of children etc. They spend weeks assessing things like can they be with cats, what makes them happy or annoyed.

for the money they are castrated, have a health check (and possible operations), and a microchip.

just check the breeds, as sadly there are a lot of the same few types of breeds in rescue places.

phlebasconsidered · 20/04/2023 20:34

Ok. I have 2 uk rescues. Both got when my kids were little and I was a stay at home mum. Tried to get another rescue when I went back to work. Flat no from over 15 rescues. Because I am working with 2 teens. Despite the fact that my in laws are in my house with my dogs walking them. We tried and tried again but because I worked it was a no. Despite having 2 happy rescues.

So my rommie rescue arrived 2 years ago and she is a joy. There are no issues, follow up was great, uk support has been great and we love her. It was a minimum payment and no more than I paid for uk rescues. My vet (who is himself from europe) says she is fit as anything and no problems. He says even a nuclear war may not kill her she is so healthy! She has far less problems than the uk rescues I had because she was so socialised with other dogs. she's a real social butterfly.

So now she has a quick walk at 5am with me, then a snooze, then a good walk with my in laws at 10 with my old dogs They stay till 2, then the dogs snooze, then I get back at 5 This is the hideous life no uk rescue would let me add a dog to.

I don't say a rescue or a romie rescue is for everyone but my goodness the thought that my lovely dog could have ended up euthanized in a cruel way there but now she is 100% one of the kindest most intelligent dogs i've owned in 50 years. People are very prejudiced.

Floralnomad · 20/04/2023 19:44

There are enough unwanted dogs in this country and personally I think the importing of rescue animals should be banned in its current form . Get a uk rescue .

Buildingthefuture · 20/04/2023 19:40

@FurAndFeathers I am fully up to date with all leishmaniasis research and I’ve obviously seen those articles before, they aren’t recent (2016 and 2019). In the case from Germany BOTH dogs had travelled abroad. In the UK case it is equally possible that the infected dog had contracted Leish from its mother.
And, if you know anything about Leish, you know that tests before travel are largely immaterial. Even with a negative test prior to transport, a dog can go on to develop Leish at any time, due to the ability of the parasite to lay dormant. Given the sheer number of dogs imported into the UK from Leish endemic countries, the fact that a large percentage of those will be carriers but will never be symptomatic or diagnosed, plus the number of dogs that are knowingly imported with Leish, if it was zoonotic, we’d be seeing it. It’s hard to prove a negative, but we simply aren’t seeing transmission in the UK. And, given the prejudice to “Trojan” dogs in the UK, if it was there, various agencies would be shouting it from the rooftops.
As the climate in the UK changes, we may well become a habitat for the sandfly and things might change, but for now, Leish dogs pose no risk to animals or humans in the UK.

ItsCalledAConversation · 20/04/2023 17:08

I wouldn’t get a Romanian rescue, one of my (very horsey, experienced dog owner, totally responsible owner/animal trainer) got one and it was off its rocker, she couldn’t do anything with it or take it anywhere, it was crap with children, incredibly anxious and reactive, it took a good year to sort it out, she wasn’t working and didn’t have kids so had every second of the day to spend with it. Steer well clear.

ByTheSea · 20/04/2023 16:54

We got a rescue, originally from abroad (not Romania) but already in a foster home in the UK. We are first time dog owners with a cat and one adult dog-loving DC still with us. I researched very carefully and narrowed the selection down. There were no UK rescues that would have us for the reasons stated. She does have a dormant health issues unfortunately but is truly the most perfect dog for us. She was quite shy at first but is a real sweetheart and after six months I cannot imagine life without her.

FranksOcean · 20/04/2023 16:04

Adopt don’t shop

dimpleton · 20/04/2023 15:52

Dogsandchocolaterule · 19/04/2023 09:35

My friend got a Romanian rescue dog and it was probably the worst thing she ever did. It is 4 now and is terrified if everything, goes for other dogs, won't let you stroke it etc. it had clearly been abused or something before it came to the UK as a vetted puppy at 12 weeks, it's not a normal or happy dog despite the love it's now given.

There are rescue centres in the UK with dogs and puppies that are DESPERATE for homes and they are the most gorgeous dogs, you could visit a few times to see which works for you.

www.manytearsrescue.org/. Is a lovely one they have every type of breed possible, they have a TikTock page where you can see videos of them and they are adorable. 🥰

When my son has moved out I'm going there to adopt a several!!

Nearly all of many tears rescue dogs say "needs another friendly dog in the household" which OP doesn't have.

Allthemissingsocks · 20/04/2023 15:24

There is a lot of puppy-bashing on here. If you are prepared to do your research, be patient and be consistent with training, puppies are incredibly rewarding. They are sweet, bonkers and frustrating in equal measures, but the puppy stage doesn’t last forever. You just need to have the right home situation, have properly researched what breed (and breeder) is right for you, be committed, be willing to learn and accept that you are not always right and to want it above everything else. I have never had a rescue, so I can’t speak with authority on the subject, but anecdotally, of the people I know who’ve had rescues, just as much work is required to be put in (albeit maybe differently).

I’m aware of 2 Romanian rescues who were PTS because the family who “rescued” them didn’t compute that they wouldn’t just slot into their family and how much investment they would need. Getting any dog requires a significant lifestyle change. You should also think about when in the year you get the dog. From experience, toilet training in winter is pretty miserable!

AuroraForever · 20/04/2023 15:14

We took in a Rommie rescue about ten years ago. He wasn’t brought in to order, we took him in from a fosterer whose circumstances had changed. He was a sweet little boy but had issues with other dogs and some people (particularly anyone wearing a hoodie or work boots). We just adapted to his needs and never forced him to do, be or go anywhere he wasn’t comfortable. We didn’t take him anywhere where he would come into contact with other dogs and we kept him away from anyone who visited. It took him about three years to settle in and feel safe and be less jumpy. It took a bit longer for him to sit next to one of us on the sofa. He was with us around seven years before he fell ill and passed away. We were glad to have given him some peace and comfort for the time we had him. So I think I’d say if going for a rommie rescue be patient, you won’t have a full history for them or know what they’ve been through (or even know their actual age- we didn’t!), but also don’t try and mould them into some idyllic version of the dog you imagine in your head because you probably won’t get that at all!

DogInATent · 20/04/2023 14:43

if we got a rescue it would be from Romania
No. Just no. There's no need to import a rescue.

ILikePizzas · 20/04/2023 14:36

Rescuing dogs from abroad?

Sounds more like a convenient and profitable business model than charity. Certainly easier than hoping locals bring dogs to you. I expect the charity keeps some people in well paid jobs.

FurAndFeathers · 20/04/2023 13:40

Buildingthefuture · 20/04/2023 10:24

@FurAndFeathers Please do you research. Leishmaniasis is NOT zoonotic. The only vector for transmission is the sandfly, which we do not have here in the UK. Pointless scaremongering helps no one.

And yet dog-dog transmission in the absence of sandflies has been reported in the UK.
https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/first-reported-uk-case-of-likely-dog-to-dog-transmission-of-leishmaniosis/

which indicates that sandflies are NOT the only route of transmission @Buildingthefuture

diseases have this funny habit of evolving.
It helps to keep abreast of the research. Ignoring emerging risks helps no one 😊

First reported UK case of likely dog to dog transmission of leishmaniosis | BMJ

Not usual route for this potentially fatal infection, which can also be passed on to people Veterinary professionals have sounded the alarm in this week’s Vet Record after treating the first UK case of a dog with the potentially fatal infection, leishm...

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/first-reported-uk-case-of-likely-dog-to-dog-transmission-of-leishmaniosis/

charliegirl86 · 20/04/2023 12:58

I’ve had experience of both. Our dog was from rescue, 6 months old was picked up by them as a stray. He was challenging when he was young (biting/nipping, destructive) but he mellowed out and became the worlds best dog and we miss him so much since he got poorly and pts age 14💔
my sister has a dog from Romania. She’s a good dog, daft as a brush as they say. She had to be trained to walk nicely on a lead and not bark madly at other dogs (cured now) she also has a health condition and almost died, she’s on medication and special food for life for it (I believe it’s to do with her home country the disease) but apart from that she’s a lovely 5 year old dog who wouldn’t hurt a fly.

i haven’t had a puppy so can’t say much apart from what I’ve learnt from friends who say it’s like having a newborn. Being up in the night with the dog crying etc . Our dog was nippy and destructive at 6 months old so imagine a full year or more of this puppy behaviour

AVoiceofSense · 20/04/2023 12:30

You state con of puppy " possibly more needy at the beginning". You are wrong. Puppies are exceptionally hard work. Not only are they needy for say the first 6-9 months, training is almost a full time job incl toilet training getting up every hour every day/night to let them out, the tidying up when they have inevitable accidents, destructive and biting phases, adolescence. The list is endless. Do not underestimate! I speak from recent experience

Nordicrain · 20/04/2023 11:17

Dogsandchocolaterule · 19/04/2023 09:37

Just look at the gorgeous little faces wanting a cuddle! Breaks my heart!

People always say this, but when our first dog died we searched rescues for another as we didn't fancy the puppy phase again and there were never any suitable dogs. Almost all of them require adult only homes, many require another dog in the household (e.g. from breeders) and normally there are only a couple. I searched the link you sent and there were only 10 dogs available within a 50 mile radius to me and over half had special requirements like those mentioned above. Our local dog charity only ever seem to have bit bull type breeds which is not one we would consider.

Anyway, OP - if you can find a suitable rescue then I'd go for that. Youngish, but trained to some extent would be great! However if you aren't an experienced dog owner I wouldn't go for a potentially problematic dog because some behaviours and traits can't be fixed and it's unfair on both you and the dog to get a dog you will struggle to manage. Shelters seem to be quite upfront about these things, so I think the main thing is just to be realistic about what you can handle.

steppemum · 20/04/2023 10:52

OK I am going to say something and then put on my hard hat and run.

personally I think the world would be better off if we actively culled a lot of dogs.

I would be quite ruthless. Any dog with aggression towards people. Any dog that has such bad behaviour issues so they are left in a rescue for years. (where are all these mythical homes of people who are home all day and experts in difficult dogs?) Any dog that has not been socialized properly.
We should not be trying to rehome dogs who have never lived in a house etc etc.

People constantly say that it is the worst thing that a shelter does to kill a dog. I think that often the best thing for the dog might be a quiet, kind end.

I am an animal lover, I have a dog (a rescue) and a cat.
I just don't have such a horror of death as most and don't think is it always the worst thing.

Buildingthefuture · 20/04/2023 10:24

@FurAndFeathers Please do you research. Leishmaniasis is NOT zoonotic. The only vector for transmission is the sandfly, which we do not have here in the UK. Pointless scaremongering helps no one.

beguilingeyes · 20/04/2023 10:20

I do think that with the cost of living how it is, a lot more people will be giving up their pets as they won't be able to afford them.
Rescues are probably going to be overwhelmed with much loved family pets.

SweepTheHalls · 20/04/2023 10:04

Have a look at Many Tears on social media for a UK rescue.

redboxer321 · 20/04/2023 10:03

FurAndFeathers · 20/04/2023 08:58

And now just unpleasantness 🙄

i haven’t claimed any expertise and you’re perfectly free to sneer at ‘facts and figures’ if evidence makes you uncomfortable.

it’s a shame though as I find informed discussion is usually more helpful than uniformed opinions and unpleasantness.

I think you need to look at your own posts before calling me unpleasant.
And I think stating that you have "years of experience" suggests you think of yourself as a bit of an expert.
You also neglect to back up your facts and figures in any way.
But we agree on one thing, informed discussion is definitely the way to go.
We actually agree on more than that and if you bothered to read my posts properly you'd see that I am cautious about adopting from overseas, or am at least suggesting people do proper research, so as to avoid the problems you mention.

Jollyatricfirsttimer · 20/04/2023 09:27

Hi there

Definitely team rescue for me, but I just wanted to add that there are lots of benefits with going with a smaller local foster based rescue. When visiting a dog in their foster home you get a much truer picture of their personality than in kennels. I got to see my dog with children, when the door bell rang, around meal times etc etc. His family had fostered him for 3 months so had an insight into his quirks. As a first time dog owner this really helped me.

Good luck and enjoy your new dog.

bamboonights · 20/04/2023 09:12

I've had experience of all options that you mention. If you are considering children in the future, I would NOT rescue, or I'd avoid a foreign rescue. A puppy is a far safer bet.
A good UK rescue with support would be the best option for rescue (Dogs Trust, Blue Cross, Battersea etc) as you need a charity with money behind it and BACKUP if things go wrong. Many of the foreign charities mean well not simply don't have the resources or money to help if things go wrong, which they frequently do. (I've had two fosters that were meant to be dog friendly, child friendly and cat friendly-neither were any of these things).
A decent breed charity in this country is also an option but check their credentials (ie are they registered via Companies House in charity sector-are their financials healthy) etc.. they will often pay for any pre existing conditions the dog may have and will provide lifelong backup.
If you do go down the puppy route, make sure you do your research, ie avoid any Facebook, Pets4Homes (online) sales and source a breeder who health tests both mum and dad, and ask to see the paperwork for said sire and dam. Good breeders often have waiting lists.

www.champdogs.co.uk/

is an excellent source for breeders who health test. Simply being registered with the Kennel Club means nothing in the way of health guarantees. Good luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread