Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stressed about rehoming dog as GF is allergic

785 replies

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 03:40

This is likely to be long so apologies in advance. I’d like my DP to move in with me and we said we’d do it around June. Only issue is I have a dog and we’ve recently discovered she’s allergic. She’s also mildly ocd and struggles with the dog hair/smells. I suspected she was allergic but didn’t want to admit it to myself. We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

only thing is I’m understandably quite upset at the thought of rehoming my dog. I’ve agreed to do it as I love her and want to marry and start a family with her. I’ve said I could potentially ask family or a friend to take him as then I could visit. I will struggle to rehome him with strangers and this way I can ensure he is ok. The issue is June is basically around the corner and she is frustrated with my lack of progress on the matter.

I haven’t mentioned any of this to family/my friend yet so as it stands we have no idea if they would even be willing to take the dog. They are all animal lovers so I’m sure at least one of them will say yes. I haven’t mentioned it to them as it’s hard for me to think about. My DP understands it’s difficult with me but sees this as me not being proactive as we aren’t really able to plan her moving in until the dog is rehomed. We’ve discussed it many times but end up going In circles and she gets teary as I haven’t really put a plan in place. She suggested rehoming him by the end of May as she will be moving in the following month.

Every time she brings it up I say there’s still things I need to put in place but I struggle to articulate exactly what these things are. The conversation goes the same way each time and nothing is really resolved. She thinks I’m not prioritising her needs/health as I said I’d move forward with rehoming him but I haven’t actually done anything yet despite me saying I would rehome him a couple of months ago. If I’m being honest I’m afraid of family and friends judging me even though I know they’ll likely understand as she’s allergic. What would you do In this situation? Breaking up isn’t an option as she’s the person I want to be with but I’m struggling with the whole thing if im being honest. Thank you.

OP posts:
Waterbottleallthetime · 21/04/2023 17:46

mybeautifuloak · Yesterday 22:41

@Fuctifin0 I'm actually outraged at your ignorance. People die from asthma. They die. Animal allergies can trigger asthma. Why are you so belligerently restating your ignorant point?
Yes it’s a serious condition and many people don’t understand this. But to give up a beloved pet for someone you’ve known less than a year is crazy imo. Whichever way this goes there will be a risk of resentment. There’s two obviously live very different lives with one not prioritising cleaning and house work and the other being very ocd about it. Not the best combination. Best keep the dog and wait and see if it’s still something that they both want in a couple of years time.

Curlyfluff · 21/04/2023 17:27

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 05:14

I love my dog dearly but it is in no way comparable to a child. And he would never end up in a shelter as my family wouldn’t let that happen. I’m trying to figure out where I go from here. I love my partner and want this to work

You think you love your dog, but obviously you don't, to even THINK of rehoming him after 4 years together, for someone you know for less than a year just leaves me speechless.

eastegg · 21/04/2023 17:23

AlexisR · 19/04/2023 07:08

They will only treat you for things like severe nut allergy or very severe hayfever that means you can't go outside and severaly impact your life/ put you at risk of dying or a severe attack.

They wouldn't treat you on the NHS for a normal pet allergy, because the solution is to not have animals in your home.

You might be able to get it privately but it would cost an absolute fortune.

This! Some people on here talking as if you could get treatment on the NHS for a pet allergy on the basis that you might want to shack up with someone who has a dog!

CleverLilViper · 21/04/2023 14:41

I'm going to answer what I would do in this situation. If I had a partner who was allergic to my dogs, and he wanted to move in and requested that I rehome my dogs so he can do that, I'd break up with him.

It's not that his request is wholly unreasonable. If someone has a severe allergy that cannot be managed, it's reasonable to expect that the cause of the allergy be removed from living space.

It's just it's not something I'd ever be prepared to do. I do not care one inch that I'm happy to prioritise my dogs over humans because I absolutely am. I made a lifetime commitment to them for the duration of their lives, and I will see that through.

What have you both tried before deciding to rehome your dog? Has she been to a doctor or pharmacist for advice about managing her allergy? I understand this isn't always feasible or possible in some cases-but I think it's worth a try before moving straight to rehoming.

Have you tried having a good deep clean of your home? Regular grooms of your dog using deshedding shampoo? Limiting the places in your home where your dog can go-i.e. the bedroom is a no-go area.

It seems that all avenues to resolving this have not been explored. You're digging in your heels because, deep down, you don't want to do it. That's understandable. She's pushing for a resolution because she doesn't have the same emotional attachment to the dog as you do. It's also, in a way, understandable.

I'm not going to say that she's a villain in this piece-if she's severely allergic and unable to manage her allergy through treatments etc, her position is logical and reasonable. It's possible that because she thinks the dog will get rehomed with a family member or friend that it's somehow less of a sacrifice on your part as you would still be allowed to see it.

If anything, I think you sound quite immature and naive. You are perhaps young and as you haven't been together that long-I'd suggest taking a deep breath and pause. If you are, indeed, partners for life, what is the hurry to move in together? If she doesn't have a lease that's due to expire, gets on with the relatives she's staying with, where's the fire? Why June?

I'm sorry, OP, I don't see this ending well. Even aside from the issues with the dog and allergies, it seems like you're quite nervous/scared of communicating with her.

It's clear from your hesitancy to act that you don't really want to do it. If you did, you'd have asked around friends and family by now. Yet, you don't want to say anything to her about this in case she views this as you "going back on your word." I'm sorry-but any partner that has empathy would be able to understand the difficult position that you are in.

I'm trying to think of what it is that you want from MN, OP, because many have given advice about things you could both try that don't involve rehoming the dog-but it seems you may want some handhold that lets you off the hook here. Please don't ever think of owning a dog or any animal again, if you treat them as disposable depending on the status of your love life.

horseyhorsey17 · 21/04/2023 14:31

She's not the girl for you. It shouldn't be this difficult. Move on.

theblackradiator · 21/04/2023 14:03

LoveSong · 19/04/2023 04:32

Very sus.

More about her OCD I think. I think you’ll be changing a lot to suit this woman, once the dogs gone, it’ll be something else. You’re being naive.

I agree with this she sounds like she could be very hard work.
I myself have always been allergic to cats but I have actually had cats for a lot of my life. I actually find the more time I am with cats my allergy gets much less and i kind of build up a resistance. I haven't had a cat for around 6 years now and if I do come into contact with one the itchy eyes,nose,throat and sneezing are back with a vengeance because I've lost that resistance after 6 years. I myself wouldn't be getting rid of my beloved dog. what breed of dog is it as many dogs are hypoallergenic and none shedding.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/04/2023 13:57

2bazookas · 21/04/2023 13:47

You know that if she'#s to move in, you have to act (rehome dog, dust and clean house) but you've done notheing and keep fobbing off her reasonable enquiries.

Very clearly, you're putting your feelings about a dog, and the dog's feelings, ahead of hers. She's a poor third.

Not surprisingly she probably interprets this as a lack of commitment on your part. Any woman would.

What? The dog has been around three years more than the girlfriend. They've been together a year. Not an animal lover are you? An animal is a lifelong (their life) commitment. If you're not prepared to put in that time, don't get an animal. Simple.

Helena91 · 21/04/2023 13:48

ScotsBluebell · 21/04/2023 11:08

Amazed by the unforgivable ignorance about allergic asthma on here and the casual dismissal of what can be a life threatening condition. And no, it doesn't have to cause anaphylaxis to be life threatening. I thought the days of people thinking that 'being allergic to dogs and cats' meant 'not liking dogs and cats' were long gone. Or the days of being 'embarrassed' to admit that you couldn't bloody breathe and consequently putting yourself at risk of hospitalisation. Serious allergic asthma is not something that can always be controlled by inhalers, strong antihistamines or injections although they can all help and some people manage fine. But they also have side effects. I've had all of these, take a steroid inhaler every day as a preventative, and there are still some houses and - worse - 'dog friendly' hotel rooms that trigger my asthma. I've had to go out and sleep in the car on more than one occasion. As for people telling people with allergies to 'make an effort' - would you tell a coeliac to 'make an effort' to cope with wheat?
It is true, OP, that doing a deep clean and - more importantly - getting rid of old carpets if possible, and making sure that you can mop floors, and have washable rugs, would definitely help. Also hypo allergenic bedding. Many allergies are to some combination of pet 'dander' and house dust mite, rather than hair, all of which can be addressed by fairly simple changes to housekeeping. I hope that works for you.
I've lived with dogs without too much trouble in the past, but they never went on the furniture or in the bedroom and we had rugs on hard floors rather than carpets. So it would be well worth while trying all these things first.
It's true that some people gradually get desensitised which is great - but it's also true that the reverse can happen. We had to rehome a much loved dog when I got pregnant and the pregnancy triggered serious allergic asthma. When push came to shove, the baby was more important than the dog. But we made sure she went to a very good home.

And I am amazed that you can even think about comparing a dear family member to wheat!! The bottom line is, the dog was there first. We found out I was allergic to cats when I was 8 after getting our first, but my mum never considered giving him up! Yes it's been hard, yes I ended up in A + E at times and started using an inhalor, but once we did things like removing carpet from my room, keeping the cat out of my room etc it was manageable. You make adjustments because they are family! Some people are willing to and some aren't. So yes it DOES come down to how much you love them and clearly you didn't love yours enough. Personally I think people who give up on their pets should be put on a 'no adopt' list. Gosh I feel enfuriated by some people. Angered and saddened by some of the comments on this thread, thankfully most see things my way which is comforting to know.

2bazookas · 21/04/2023 13:47

You know that if she'#s to move in, you have to act (rehome dog, dust and clean house) but you've done notheing and keep fobbing off her reasonable enquiries.

Very clearly, you're putting your feelings about a dog, and the dog's feelings, ahead of hers. She's a poor third.

Not surprisingly she probably interprets this as a lack of commitment on your part. Any woman would.

KarmaStar · 21/04/2023 13:19

Sorry but I wouldn't be moving her in.
Your dog was there first it's his home and the dog loves you,why should be be thrown out ?he isn't an old sock.
Why can't you have a relationship living in separate houses?you sound very young.
Ask her to speak to her Dr about anti allergens.
She sounds,to me,somewhat controlling .
🐕🐾🐾🐕🐾🐾

mybeautifuloak · 21/04/2023 13:04

Abouttimemum · 21/04/2023 10:20

I’m allergic to dogs and cats etc, it’s awful. I also just don’t like being in homes where they are as it’s just hair and smell everywhere and it’s not for me.

Not in a million years would I expect someone to give up their pet for me though. Absolutely not. If she really wants to be with you then she needs to make an effort to deal / ease her allergies and you need to make more effort to clean your home. Maybe there’s a compromise.

If with all the will in the world your allergy could not be treated sufficiently to prevent you suffering unbearably, would you break up with the love of your life ?

mybeautifuloak · 21/04/2023 13:02

Gingernan · 21/04/2023 09:57

Hmm well there is a saying,Love me,love my dog!

She shouldn't try to change you or how you live your life. She can get treatment for her allergy,as for the dust, she should put a mask on and do some of the dusting! Sounds a bit high maintenance.

Seriously people like you don't get it. I had a dc in my house who was allergic to cats. She had a massive and terrifying asthma attack. She had to be rushed to hospital. She was on treatment but for many people, treatment doesn't make the allergy disappear. It just makes it a little less severe. People saying she should 'just get treatment' dint have a frcking clue.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/04/2023 11:09

Can I suggest to you @CanineConundrum that there is a person out there for you, your person if you will, that will love you so very very deeply and will not make you sad by the requirement of rehoming your dog? That person is out there but you haven't met yet (or you might have already met but not realised that they were your person). They will love you and your dog.
This particular person, while not specifically stating that you can't have your dog around, is making you unhappy because in order for you to be around them, you can't be around a dog that you've had in your life for 4+ years.

Can I also ask you if you're planning on washing/dry cleaning every scrap of your clothing and bedding and soft furnishings before this person moves in? Because hair and dander from a pet can remain on surfaces long after the pet has gone and unless you're going to give your house a thorough deep clean and clean all of the soft furnishings and clothing that the pet may have come in contact with throughout their 4+ year stay in your home, it'll take months to clean everything to a level that this person doesn't have a reaction to.

ScotsBluebell · 21/04/2023 11:08

Amazed by the unforgivable ignorance about allergic asthma on here and the casual dismissal of what can be a life threatening condition. And no, it doesn't have to cause anaphylaxis to be life threatening. I thought the days of people thinking that 'being allergic to dogs and cats' meant 'not liking dogs and cats' were long gone. Or the days of being 'embarrassed' to admit that you couldn't bloody breathe and consequently putting yourself at risk of hospitalisation. Serious allergic asthma is not something that can always be controlled by inhalers, strong antihistamines or injections although they can all help and some people manage fine. But they also have side effects. I've had all of these, take a steroid inhaler every day as a preventative, and there are still some houses and - worse - 'dog friendly' hotel rooms that trigger my asthma. I've had to go out and sleep in the car on more than one occasion. As for people telling people with allergies to 'make an effort' - would you tell a coeliac to 'make an effort' to cope with wheat?
It is true, OP, that doing a deep clean and - more importantly - getting rid of old carpets if possible, and making sure that you can mop floors, and have washable rugs, would definitely help. Also hypo allergenic bedding. Many allergies are to some combination of pet 'dander' and house dust mite, rather than hair, all of which can be addressed by fairly simple changes to housekeeping. I hope that works for you.
I've lived with dogs without too much trouble in the past, but they never went on the furniture or in the bedroom and we had rugs on hard floors rather than carpets. So it would be well worth while trying all these things first.
It's true that some people gradually get desensitised which is great - but it's also true that the reverse can happen. We had to rehome a much loved dog when I got pregnant and the pregnancy triggered serious allergic asthma. When push came to shove, the baby was more important than the dog. But we made sure she went to a very good home.

Abouttimemum · 21/04/2023 10:20

I’m allergic to dogs and cats etc, it’s awful. I also just don’t like being in homes where they are as it’s just hair and smell everywhere and it’s not for me.

Not in a million years would I expect someone to give up their pet for me though. Absolutely not. If she really wants to be with you then she needs to make an effort to deal / ease her allergies and you need to make more effort to clean your home. Maybe there’s a compromise.

Jamjaris · 21/04/2023 10:00

Ask yourself if rehoming your dog will make you feel resentful? I think you are stalling because you do not want to and hope a relative can take your dog so if your relationship doesn’t work you can have dog back. I also think you haven’t asked them because if no one will have your dog you can’t bear the thought of your beloved pet being given to strangers and you never seeing your pet again.
A doctor will prescribe strong antihistamines for your gf if she is allergic so you won’t have to rehome your dog and tbh she isn’t sounding like she wants to even try and is just issuing an ultimatum.
It can take up to 6 months to completely remove all the pet dander from your home after a pet dies or gets rehomed.

Gingernan · 21/04/2023 09:57

Hmm well there is a saying,Love me,love my dog!

She shouldn't try to change you or how you live your life. She can get treatment for her allergy,as for the dust, she should put a mask on and do some of the dusting! Sounds a bit high maintenance.

LaDamaDeElche · 21/04/2023 09:25

CanineConundrum · 20/04/2023 21:42

For the last time she never demanded I give up my dog. The wording in my OP is clumsy. She said she was willing to separate even though she didn’t want to as she knew how much I loved my dog. I didn’t want to lose her so I compromised and said I’d rehome him with family. I came on here for advice on how to make the whole thing easier as I was sad about the whole thing but it’s descended into people making assumptions and calling her controlling. I don’t think wanting to live in a clean house with your spouse is asking for the world and I’ve told her she’s right and I’m taking the steps to be better at cleaning and tidying up. Nor does she control me seeing my friends as a few suggested. We aren’t in each others pockets and both see our friends regularly.

Separate or give up dog. That's what it boils down to though, so it's a her or your dog situation. A compromise would be that she tries to live with your dog for a month say. You deep clean the house and keep on top of the cleaning, have areas that are dog free (easy with baby gates), wash and brush your dog outside frequently, she speaks to a doctor about the best antihistamines to take for a pet allergy. You try. That's compromise. Otherwise you just bite the bullet and talk to your family, that's the other option. Procrastinating on MN and getting defensive when people say things you don't like isn't solving the situation one way or another.

Mummyoflittledragon · 21/04/2023 09:10

CanineConundrum · 20/04/2023 21:42

For the last time she never demanded I give up my dog. The wording in my OP is clumsy. She said she was willing to separate even though she didn’t want to as she knew how much I loved my dog. I didn’t want to lose her so I compromised and said I’d rehome him with family. I came on here for advice on how to make the whole thing easier as I was sad about the whole thing but it’s descended into people making assumptions and calling her controlling. I don’t think wanting to live in a clean house with your spouse is asking for the world and I’ve told her she’s right and I’m taking the steps to be better at cleaning and tidying up. Nor does she control me seeing my friends as a few suggested. We aren’t in each others pockets and both see our friends regularly.

I came on here on how to make the whole thing easier

You’ve had that advice, haven’t you? Advice to deep clean the house (which is not the same as being better at tidying up), wash your dog, look into getting hard flooring, explore whether your gf could take prescription medication or exposure therapy.

But I don’t think that’s what you’re after. I think you want a magic pill, where people say there, there, it’ll be ok. And with minimal effort on your part. It won’t. Almost everyone is telling you the same thing so that should be sending off massive alarm bells ringing, especially as many of us have a lot of life experience. I know you possibly don’t get that now, but you will, in time.

And she’s not a spouse. You’re mapping out a future, which hasn’t happened yet and you may find you’re massively incompatible. I have a spouse. I know what it is to have been with the same person for decades with all of the commitment, dedication and compromise, which goes with it.

She’s a girlfriend of less than a year, whom you’ve never lived with and is currently living with her parents, looking to improve her life by moving in with you whilst not trying to work with you to find a compromise. Giving your dog to someone else is not a compromise. It’s a decision to no longer want to take care of a sentient, living, loving being.

If your gf that easy to lose, is she really worthy of your love? Your dog otoh will love you til his dying breath.

mybeautifuloak · 21/04/2023 09:01

Peapodburgundybouquet · 21/04/2023 07:06

@mybeautifuloak my husband had severe asthma as a child, his family always had dogs. We have dogs. He has built up
a tolerance to them. He can get wheezy around other dogs but will adapt to it quickly. We have hard floors and keep them relatively clean, but his body has grown used to them. Two of them are huge, fluffy, double-coated giants, too. Who drool. A lot.

His asthma has randomly recurred badly in adulthood but his tolerance to the dogs means they are not a problem.

That's great but tolerance doesn't build for everyone. For some it will be completely debilitating and potentially life threatening. 'Allergy' covers a huge range of levels of affliction. Expecting people with severe allergies ti just suck it up and hope they build an immunity is no appropriate

WisherWood · 21/04/2023 08:37

I came on here for advice on how to make the whole thing easier

I don't think there's a way to make it easier. I think you can stop dragging it out. Start by having conversations with friends and family about your dog. You might be very lucky and find someone who's been thinking of getting a dog and who likes yours. You might find none of them are interested. But either way, if you have the conversations, at least you'll know.

And you'll also know a bit more from your reactions to those conversations about how you really feel. Relief that they can/ can't take the dog? Will their reactions confirm something you're thinking? Will they think your GF is amazing and good for you, and that you're right to rehome the dog? Or will they think you're making a big mistake for someone they don't like very much.

You need more information. And dragging your feet will not make this easier. Once you've got that information you can make more informed decisions. Meantime, get on top of the cleaning. She's asked you to do this anyway, so try, and see if ultimately that might be a dealbreaker between you. And even if it isn't, it might help with her reactions to the dog. It might not, if it's a serious allergy, but for many reasons it's worth a shot.

Novatherova · 21/04/2023 08:33

mrbreezeet1 · 21/04/2023 06:49

I would get rid of the girl before I got rid of my cat :-(

Same. Unless its my actual human child who's allergic there's no way I'd get rid of my cat. She's my best friend.

Catsmere · 21/04/2023 08:20

Mollymoostoo · 21/04/2023 07:33

If you are considering the possibility that your relationship might not work out and she is demanding and won't wait, you really need to question if this is the relationship for you.
OCD is hard to live with, the dog isn't the issue here, it is a block to you living together and you are reluctant to rehome your dog because you are not 100% convinced things are going to work out.
How old are you both? Less than a year is not a lot of time to see if this person is really the one for you.

OP is now saying GF isn’t “mildly OCD” at all but simply likes a neat and tidy house.

Mollymoostoo · 21/04/2023 07:33

If you are considering the possibility that your relationship might not work out and she is demanding and won't wait, you really need to question if this is the relationship for you.
OCD is hard to live with, the dog isn't the issue here, it is a block to you living together and you are reluctant to rehome your dog because you are not 100% convinced things are going to work out.
How old are you both? Less than a year is not a lot of time to see if this person is really the one for you.

Ukrainebaby23 · 21/04/2023 07:21

CanineConundrum · 20/04/2023 21:42

For the last time she never demanded I give up my dog. The wording in my OP is clumsy. She said she was willing to separate even though she didn’t want to as she knew how much I loved my dog. I didn’t want to lose her so I compromised and said I’d rehome him with family. I came on here for advice on how to make the whole thing easier as I was sad about the whole thing but it’s descended into people making assumptions and calling her controlling. I don’t think wanting to live in a clean house with your spouse is asking for the world and I’ve told her she’s right and I’m taking the steps to be better at cleaning and tidying up. Nor does she control me seeing my friends as a few suggested. We aren’t in each others pockets and both see our friends regularly.

Long time dog owner/dog lover, married to very allergic DH who is not anti-animal but can't tolerate hair/fur etc.

I would suggest you are not ready to remove your dog, if DP was to get her own place where you could visit etc, soend dog free time together, meanwhile making arrangements to ensure your pet is cared for then the relationship might survive.
If DP moves in and dog goes out, I think the changes in lifestyle might create you issues leading to resentment over loss of pet.
Also if she does live in, you have to get on the cleaning schedule quick to get rid of allergens.

Swipe left for the next trending thread