Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stressed about rehoming dog as GF is allergic

785 replies

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 03:40

This is likely to be long so apologies in advance. I’d like my DP to move in with me and we said we’d do it around June. Only issue is I have a dog and we’ve recently discovered she’s allergic. She’s also mildly ocd and struggles with the dog hair/smells. I suspected she was allergic but didn’t want to admit it to myself. We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

only thing is I’m understandably quite upset at the thought of rehoming my dog. I’ve agreed to do it as I love her and want to marry and start a family with her. I’ve said I could potentially ask family or a friend to take him as then I could visit. I will struggle to rehome him with strangers and this way I can ensure he is ok. The issue is June is basically around the corner and she is frustrated with my lack of progress on the matter.

I haven’t mentioned any of this to family/my friend yet so as it stands we have no idea if they would even be willing to take the dog. They are all animal lovers so I’m sure at least one of them will say yes. I haven’t mentioned it to them as it’s hard for me to think about. My DP understands it’s difficult with me but sees this as me not being proactive as we aren’t really able to plan her moving in until the dog is rehomed. We’ve discussed it many times but end up going In circles and she gets teary as I haven’t really put a plan in place. She suggested rehoming him by the end of May as she will be moving in the following month.

Every time she brings it up I say there’s still things I need to put in place but I struggle to articulate exactly what these things are. The conversation goes the same way each time and nothing is really resolved. She thinks I’m not prioritising her needs/health as I said I’d move forward with rehoming him but I haven’t actually done anything yet despite me saying I would rehome him a couple of months ago. If I’m being honest I’m afraid of family and friends judging me even though I know they’ll likely understand as she’s allergic. What would you do In this situation? Breaking up isn’t an option as she’s the person I want to be with but I’m struggling with the whole thing if im being honest. Thank you.

OP posts:
Peapodburgundybouquet · 19/04/2023 12:09

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 12:01

A lot to consider here although I will say some people are being a little nasty. She pops anti histamines constantly when she’s here. They don’t help. She didn’t know she was allergic beforehand as she is never around dogs and doesn’t know anyone who has one. I understand the length of our relationship is cause for concern but we are both genuinely so happy together apart from this one issue. They say when you know you really know and I do but this situation is quite difficult and I’m trying to do right by everyone involved. I also don’t think it’s insane to want to prioritise a potential life partner over a (beloved) pet. She can’t help being allergic so I’m trying to be sympathetic

Better hurry up and bin off your poor dog, then.

Poor thing.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/04/2023 12:08

Ok well if antihistamines don’t work, she can pay for injections or therapy to reduce the allergy. If she loved you that much she would do anything to help you keep the dog.

What she shouldn’t be doing is telling you to get rid of your pet that you love.

As you love her, you can also do a lot to mitigate the allergy:

  • install hard flooring
  • deep clean the house
  • train the dog not to go in the bedroom or sofa / have a blanket for the dog on a specific chair
  • even changing your dog’s diet could make a difference
CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 12:01

And yes I’ve seen the test result

OP posts:
CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 12:01

A lot to consider here although I will say some people are being a little nasty. She pops anti histamines constantly when she’s here. They don’t help. She didn’t know she was allergic beforehand as she is never around dogs and doesn’t know anyone who has one. I understand the length of our relationship is cause for concern but we are both genuinely so happy together apart from this one issue. They say when you know you really know and I do but this situation is quite difficult and I’m trying to do right by everyone involved. I also don’t think it’s insane to want to prioritise a potential life partner over a (beloved) pet. She can’t help being allergic so I’m trying to be sympathetic

OP posts:
Malificent1 · 19/04/2023 12:00

Handy that your self proclaimed OCD girlfriend has suddenly decided that she’s allergic to dogs and dust.

Where did she go for the tests? Did you see the results yourself?

ZiriForEver · 19/04/2023 11:57

Yes, it would sound as going back on your word as that is exactly what it would be.

That said, you can still do it, and how both of you will handle that discussion will tell you a lot.

I don't see how generic "waiting another half a year" would help - the dog causes her huge discomfort and health issues with every visit.

How i understand your posts, the allergy is quite obvious, but she took up an extra assessment to rule out other explanations. You have all information now and need to decide.

I won't be willing to have to take regular medication for the sake of an animal. One of the risks is, that it would work partially, I would still be uncomfortable, but there would be the pressure to try more, wait longer, getting familiar with the pet in the meantime.

This is either or kind of decision. It is absurd how many people would willingly compromise health of their human partner. If you are one of them, tell her.

Noodlehen · 19/04/2023 11:53

OP you seem very concerned on partners reactions, are you sure this is the right thing to do? If she was your person surely she’d understand and be a bit more patient.

Tinkerbyebye · 19/04/2023 11:53

Afraid I would be telling her she can’t move in and continue as you are. Has she actually done anything to see if her allergy can be controlled?

the dog was here first and would always take priority for me

Spanielsarepainless · 19/04/2023 11:52

GF is being unreasonable and demanding. Why did she get involved with someone with a dog? I couldn't live with myself if I had to rehome my dogs.

StillWantingADog · 19/04/2023 11:50

I would not rehome a dog of 4 years for a gf of less than a year.
You don't necessarily have to split up with the gf do you?

However the gf is right to be annoyed if you committed to 'June' and have not had conversations with family members yet.
I'm not sure why you haven't had non-committal conversations with family members about this yet if you think its a real option. If it turned out that a family member you really trusted was very enthusiastic about having the dog things could be a lot more straightforward. And if none of them wanted the dog a whole lot more complicated.

MystyLuna · 19/04/2023 11:42

I am sorry but expecting you to rehome your dog that you have had for 4 years is completely unreasonable. You and the dog come as a package deal and it is up to your girlfriend to accept that. If she is allergic to dogs then she should either not get into a relationship with someone who owns a dog or she should see a doctor to find out what steps she can take to manage her allergies. She shouldn't be asking you to get rid of the dog when you had him long before you got into a relationship with her. If she can't manage her allergy then it is up to her to find somewhere else to live.

Newpeep · 19/04/2023 11:41

I am not making light of allergies btw. Just alarm bells as I'd not ask someone I love to give up something they love without exhausting all avenues first and that includes a less traditional set up.

Newpeep · 19/04/2023 11:39

There are things you can do to lessen the allergies. I'd personally be exploring that rather than ask someone I loved to give up a much loved pet. It's very different to someone who has bought/adopted then found out they had allergies IMO.

My husband is allergic to cats and had lived with dogs but never a cat. I love cats. He spent time with them to see how bad things were before we committed to one. He was fine after a while. He's not had any problems for the 20 years we've had cats or dogs but if he had I know he would have been trying everything to mitigate it so we could enjoy the company of cats as well as dogs.

breakingintopieces · 19/04/2023 11:38

I'm very allergic to dogs, and some of the suggestions from other posters are ridiculous. Don't you think if there was a magic cure for serious allergies, no one would have any allergies? I actually love dogs, and I find it heartbreaking that I can't have one as a pet. I don't choose to stay allergic!

If she's allergic, she's allergic. Fact. She cannot live with your dog. You have to accept that point and move forward.

What does that leave? Well, either 1) you rehome the dog, or 2) you don't live together.

Let's be honest: you don't want to rehome the dog. You've done naff all on this front because you don't want to do it. Even if you're unwilling to admit that out loud, your subconscious knows it. What you've done wrong here is not failing to make arrangements to find a new home for your dog; it's having agreed to do that in the first place. You shouldn't commit to doing things you won't follow through on.

OK, so that leaves not living together.

Why is not living together a dealbreaker? If you are truly each other's forever people, you can adapt to a less traditional way of being in a relationship. Not living together is not the same thing as being long-distance: you can both live near each other. You can get a dogsitter and spend quality time together at her house - and you can contribute to her bills to cover that.

Being blunt, if all goes well, she's going to outlive your dog. You're not saying never, you're just saying not right now, for reasons. It's like a single parent who doesn't want their partner to move in because their child isn't cool with it. If you truly love the other person, you understand they made commitments before they met you, and they have to honour those commitments and find a compromise.

Personally, I think the fact you are terrified of losing her if you don't rehome your dog and move in quickly shows that you know she isn't your forever person. A forever person wouldn't expect you to get rid of a loved one to make space for them.

5mummy87 · 19/04/2023 11:37

Dear OP, ditch that inconsiderate person, she clearly cares only about herself, you've been with her for only UNDER a year, your dog been with you for 4 yrs. She also gets frustrated with your 'lack of progress' ? She can't wait to move ?? Wtf, you're looking to rehome your dog of 4 yrs who been with you through good and bad, to accommodate a selfish person who clearly doesn't even think about your feelings of giving up your dog, do you really want a life with someone like that ??? Seriously? She's been with you under year she knew what she's going for, she knew you've got a dog and now she's having a hissy fit because you're not getting rid of dog soon enough !!
Seriously you need to rethink your values, you sound like genuine good person whilst she sounds very self entitled selfish person who doesn't consider anyone or anything else other than herself and her new found allergies. Wonder what she will be like after marriage...

My brother in law and my sister both got kids and cats, when they got together he knew her love for pets, he knew she had one pet already, only later they found out he's very allergic, BUT, he's constantly on antihistamines, and they since got 2 more cats, it's their family, them both, 3 children and cats ...

Also, sometimes ago I was in relationship, he visited, but we didn't intend to move in together yet, I got myself a cat, I loved the cat so much, but then he decided he's allergic, sadly he made me give my cat away, I was heartbroken, he wasn't visiting very often to suffer allergy even at the start, but I cared, and I didn't have enough backbone to stand up for what right for me, So that was one of my BIGGEST mistakes, I gave my cat up, I broke my heart for person who didn't even consider my feelings, most probably cat cared about me more than that person.. Thankfully we split up few months after !

Seriously, think properly about what important to you ! And don't let someone that just entered your life to manipulate you into giving away what you care about!!!

vilepig · 19/04/2023 11:31

Do not rehome the dog. You will regret it.
You don't want to - that much is clear in your posts.
It's got red flags all over it to be honest.
I think you aren't compatible.
Tell her you want to delay moving in and spend time thinking about what you really want. I think you aren't sure about the relationship.
However, she does need a clear answer fairly soon because if you feel you will never be able to rehome the dog she needs to be free to move on and meet someone else. who doesn't have a dog and has a squeaky clean home which suits her needs better

ElizabethBest · 19/04/2023 11:29

I can't believe you'd consider rehoming your dog for someone you've known less than a year. God I hope you are a troll.

Pandorapitstop · 19/04/2023 11:22

Couldn’t rehome my dog.

SorePaw · 19/04/2023 11:22

Why is she in such a rush to move in?

get your house deep cleaned by professionals, properly cleaned, walls & carpets washed etc then invest in a GOOD hoover & steam mop. train your dog not to get on the soft furnishings (sofas, bed etc) and buy it a lovely dog bed which can be washed (laundromat if you need a big bed)

keep on top of keeping your dog clean & free of loose hair (brush daily outside).

you may find it's the residual stuff bothering her, not your fresh dog!

Then she can stay long weekends, for a week etc & build up resistance. I'm allergic to both cats & dogs, but have always had one or the other (& both) and pet sit for many people & it's fine unless I rub my eyes.

obviously some people are more severely allergic, but not necessarily.

she can take antihistamine while she sees how a much cleaner house & dog helps.

She sounds insecure & bossy though. You need to open your eyes, you cannot know if she's 'your person' it's been less than a year & you haven't lived together . I hope you're as young as you sound, else it's even more worrying.

what compromises is she making?

she WFH, but that doesn't mean she has to work from your actual home library/cafe etc. or maybe she can work from one room the dog doesn't go in.

GooglyEyeballs · 19/04/2023 11:22

I think you just need to make a decision either way and be upfront with her. I don't particularly love the idea of getting rid of a dog to make way for a new girlfriend but you are stringing her along right now so I can understand her frustration. Either tell her you're keeping the dog and it's over or that you're rehoming the dog and she can move in.

bd67thSaysReinstateLangCleg · 19/04/2023 11:08

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 04:23

I’m not sure if she’d be happy/willing to wait another 6 months after we agreed June. She’s already frustrated by the lack of progress. Her allergies are quite bad so managing the symptoms isn’t a possibility as I think the irritant would need to be completely removed unfortunately. She works from home so being around the dog constantly is a lot to ask when it causes an allergic reaction

She’s already frustrated by the lack of progress.

Alarm bells ringing here. I can't put my finger on why, but they are. Why is she so desperate to move in?

TedMullins · 19/04/2023 11:05

Even if you don’t like dogs or don’t understand why someone isn’t binning off their much loved pet for a girlfriend of a year, surely you can understand that it’s not on for a relatively new partner to start making demands and ultimatums? This could be about anything. It’s me or your football, it’s me or your vegetarianism, it’s me or staying in a location I don’t like, it’s me or your children.

yes, the allergies are unavoidable but she went into a relationship with a dog owner and rather than being understanding about what a difficult position OP is in and being accommodating of that and why moving in maybe can’t meet her ideal deadline, she’s apparently doubled down and started with the emotional manipulation. If she loves him then she’d want him to be happy and for them to work through this together which may look like living apart for longer or trying other solutions to mitigate her allergies before resorting to rehoming, and being understanding that this isn’t easy. I’m allergic to cats but if I dated someone with a cat I wouldn’t dream of demanding they rehome it! Similarly I’m a vegetarian, but if I embarked on a relationship with a butcher I wouldn’t start demanding they find a new career. She doesn’t seem to be making any compromises or allowances here.

NotMyFinestMoment · 19/04/2023 11:02

Personally I'd keep the dog and get rid of the girlfriend. Even if you get rid of the dog, she still has dust and other allergies, so to some extent getting rid of the dog will be for nothing.

Your dog is for life and with the greatest of respect, I doubt the relationship will last that long.

Thoughtful2355 · 19/04/2023 11:01

I wouldnt be having my gf of under a year move in if it meant having to rehome my dog and never getting a dog again unless we broke up.
I would be waiting for at least the 3 or 4 year mark

Tophy124 · 19/04/2023 11:01

I’m also pretty disgusted at your attitude towards your dog. How can you just not care? My dog is bonded so tightly with me that sending her to family permanently would put her in extreme distress. For those saying well what if I had a partner with allergies, well I do have allergies myself but I manage them. I wouldn’t pursue a relationship with anyone not wanting to one day live with my dog. We are a package deal. Anyone I’ve known with a true pet allergy knows about it instantly. I find so many red flags are popping up in ops story. I have a cat allergy and always have, so I wouldn’t date someone that has cats unless I was willing to take medicine. You were both selfish for pursuing this.