Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stressed about rehoming dog as GF is allergic

785 replies

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 03:40

This is likely to be long so apologies in advance. I’d like my DP to move in with me and we said we’d do it around June. Only issue is I have a dog and we’ve recently discovered she’s allergic. She’s also mildly ocd and struggles with the dog hair/smells. I suspected she was allergic but didn’t want to admit it to myself. We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

only thing is I’m understandably quite upset at the thought of rehoming my dog. I’ve agreed to do it as I love her and want to marry and start a family with her. I’ve said I could potentially ask family or a friend to take him as then I could visit. I will struggle to rehome him with strangers and this way I can ensure he is ok. The issue is June is basically around the corner and she is frustrated with my lack of progress on the matter.

I haven’t mentioned any of this to family/my friend yet so as it stands we have no idea if they would even be willing to take the dog. They are all animal lovers so I’m sure at least one of them will say yes. I haven’t mentioned it to them as it’s hard for me to think about. My DP understands it’s difficult with me but sees this as me not being proactive as we aren’t really able to plan her moving in until the dog is rehomed. We’ve discussed it many times but end up going In circles and she gets teary as I haven’t really put a plan in place. She suggested rehoming him by the end of May as she will be moving in the following month.

Every time she brings it up I say there’s still things I need to put in place but I struggle to articulate exactly what these things are. The conversation goes the same way each time and nothing is really resolved. She thinks I’m not prioritising her needs/health as I said I’d move forward with rehoming him but I haven’t actually done anything yet despite me saying I would rehome him a couple of months ago. If I’m being honest I’m afraid of family and friends judging me even though I know they’ll likely understand as she’s allergic. What would you do In this situation? Breaking up isn’t an option as she’s the person I want to be with but I’m struggling with the whole thing if im being honest. Thank you.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/04/2023 14:52

A little reading will confirm we build up a natural tolerance to allergens, and we can work around them...so a period of managing the symptoms, and regudog grooming with anti allergan product

This just doesn’t happen. I’ve tried petalcleanse and all the rest. My allergies have got worse as l’ve got older.

Ponderingwindow · 19/04/2023 14:43

Gemmanorthdevon · 19/04/2023 13:21

Please do rehome the dog, but independently and with a family who won't ditch it when something better comes along!

Your plan of " rehoming with family" to mitigate the risk of loss to yourself incase you don't work out is awfully selfish. To unsettle a member of your immediate family ( Loving homes treat pets as family? ) who relies on you for their everything, and has done nothing but give you loyalty and unconditional love, perfectly prepared to do it again should life with Cruella not work out, begs belief.

Not to mention somebody that claims to love you, allowing you too! A little reading will confirm we build up a natural tolerance to allergens, and we can work around them...so a period of managing the symptoms, and regudog grooming with anti allergan product..will sort her issue. However the suggestion that she may also not do well with dog related smells etc, does very clearly illustrate that some of this is her personal preference.

OCD Is a very serious and debilitating mental health issue. If she is diagnosed then dog smells are the least of her worries. If not she is just being precious!

Either find someone who is prepared to work at being in your life as you like your life, or as I said, rehome the dog somewhere it won't be messed around again.

That isn’t how actual allergies work, not at all. Typically every exposure increases the reaction.

Wexone · 19/04/2023 14:40

am sorry no way could i do this. I would be dumping the GF before give up the dog, you are not compatible. Dog 4 years GF 1years and all ready moving in no fecking way

Offensiveapprently · 19/04/2023 14:36

I had similar situation only my prospective house partner was not a dog lover, nice guy but there was nothing that could have made me give up my dog so we didn't last.
I chose to have my dog and that for me was a lifetime commitment partner or not. For me I wouldn't break my dogs heart or my own.

Ponderingwindow · 19/04/2023 14:30

If she is wheezing when she visits, then this isn’t just about cohabitation. She needs to stop visiting your home entirely.

If she lives with family, the two of you spending time at her place probably doesn’t work. If she goes and buys her own place as she had planned, she isn’t going to want to move again any time soon, so I can see why the question of living arrangements arose.

if you really aren’t ready to take the step of re-homing your dog, you need to be honest with her. She can make her choices from there, but I would hope she stops putting her body through stress.

AppallinglyReheated · 19/04/2023 14:30

Kittycash · 19/04/2023 06:45

A friend of our always claimed he was allergic to our dog, this was highly unlikely as she is double coated and her fur is more like wool.
Last year his adult dd got a dog who is a wiry breed so much more likely to cause an allergy, friend is always posting photos of him and the dog.
It's not just about your dog op, it's control and this is only the beginning imo.

You really have that arse about there, wire coats are LESS likely to trigger allergy, double coats shed a lot and are much more likely to be an issue with allergy sufferers (though as PP have pointed out its generally the dander and saliva, not the hair, that causes the issue).

OP - I would be prioritising vacuuming, sorting out flooring (hard floors are better) seating (leather better than fabric), air filtration, grooming and washing the dog and anti-histamines before I considered rehoming the dog.

What if you rehome then find shes actually allergic to something else in your home, without doing much of the above, you won't find out the truth.

Onegingerhead · 19/04/2023 14:17

CatNamedBob · 19/04/2023 14:04

My DH was allergic to cats before he moved in with me, would get hives etc when he visited. He knew I would never rehome my cat. He took antihistamines every day to start with when he moved in but fairly quickly he got over the allergy and didn't need them any more. He now happily lives with the cat.

Having to rehome a pet for a new partner would be a total dealbreaker for me.

Absolutely the same story, but with a dog. DH has asthma, not extremely severe admittedly, and he knew about the dog from the day we met and also knew he had two options a) find another lady or b) make it work with the dog. He chose b) and his asthma had to agree with the decision. I think he stopped having flare ups within 2 or 3 months of moving in.
Dog person can only be with another dog person, imo.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 19/04/2023 14:12

I would never rehome my 4 year old dog for a partner of a year to move in, and I don't know anyone who would
Your GF knew you had a dog when you got together and I suggest you live separately.
If she wants to move out of her relatives house, she will have to find a place to rent
As you say she's " OCD" about dog hair She wouldn't be able to visit you either
A dog is for life, a GF may not be

impz · 19/04/2023 14:08

Dump the GF, keep the dog. I couldn't be dealing with someone who insists I rehome my beloved pet. He was there first and he isn't a sofa, he is a living being who loves you and depends on you.

2Rebecca · 19/04/2023 14:05

If I was allergic to a dog I wouldn't share a house with one. You don't normally need a test as it's fairly obvious by the symptoms. Pet allergies can be severe

Witchcraftandhokum · 19/04/2023 14:05

we both know we are each others person for life I'm sure your dog thinks that's his home for life.

You've been with her under a year, how could you?

CatNamedBob · 19/04/2023 14:04

My DH was allergic to cats before he moved in with me, would get hives etc when he visited. He knew I would never rehome my cat. He took antihistamines every day to start with when he moved in but fairly quickly he got over the allergy and didn't need them any more. He now happily lives with the cat.

Having to rehome a pet for a new partner would be a total dealbreaker for me.

Thelnebriati · 19/04/2023 14:03

Is she prepared to compromise? Deep clean your house, groom your dog every day and ask her to take an antihistamine. See if anything changes.
IMO its too soon to think about rehoming your dog.

Testina · 19/04/2023 14:02

“They say when you know you really know and I do but”

I posted earlier that talking about your “person for life” made you sound 13. That doesn’t change my opinion.

Don’t be silly. How many people on this site who are divorced now stood there on there wedding day “really knowing” 🤣

Modaboutyou · 19/04/2023 13:56

Your poor dog. No way would I rehome my dog for a new live in boyfriend/girlfriend. Whilst I feel sorry for your GF, allergy isn't her fault, my dog and me are a pair, you get both of us.

WisherWood · 19/04/2023 13:39

I understand the length of our relationship is cause for concern but we are both genuinely so happy together apart from this one issue. They say when you know you really know and I do

And yet you've mentioned at least twice that you want your dog to go to family in case it doesn't work out with your GF. You seem to think that if you ask her to wait six months she might end things with you. And despite this apparently absolute belief that you really know she's the one for you, you haven't approached family members to explain the situation to them and ask about the dog.

I've been in a similar situation OP, except in my case the problem wasn't a dog but a job. I gave up the chance of a good job at the other end of the country to remain with my partner, who I knew was the one for me. Except within weeks of me turning down the job, he'd dumped me. So I had no job and no partner. I thought I really knew he was the one for me but once he'd dumped me, I realised there were signs, but I'd been blind to them.

I think you might find, if you take the rose-tinted specs off, that there are signs that you're wishing she's the one, but are worried that she might not be. That's why you're dragging your feet about your dog. On some level, you're not actually quite that sure.

gettingoldisshit · 19/04/2023 13:25

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 03:40

This is likely to be long so apologies in advance. I’d like my DP to move in with me and we said we’d do it around June. Only issue is I have a dog and we’ve recently discovered she’s allergic. She’s also mildly ocd and struggles with the dog hair/smells. I suspected she was allergic but didn’t want to admit it to myself. We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

only thing is I’m understandably quite upset at the thought of rehoming my dog. I’ve agreed to do it as I love her and want to marry and start a family with her. I’ve said I could potentially ask family or a friend to take him as then I could visit. I will struggle to rehome him with strangers and this way I can ensure he is ok. The issue is June is basically around the corner and she is frustrated with my lack of progress on the matter.

I haven’t mentioned any of this to family/my friend yet so as it stands we have no idea if they would even be willing to take the dog. They are all animal lovers so I’m sure at least one of them will say yes. I haven’t mentioned it to them as it’s hard for me to think about. My DP understands it’s difficult with me but sees this as me not being proactive as we aren’t really able to plan her moving in until the dog is rehomed. We’ve discussed it many times but end up going In circles and she gets teary as I haven’t really put a plan in place. She suggested rehoming him by the end of May as she will be moving in the following month.

Every time she brings it up I say there’s still things I need to put in place but I struggle to articulate exactly what these things are. The conversation goes the same way each time and nothing is really resolved. She thinks I’m not prioritising her needs/health as I said I’d move forward with rehoming him but I haven’t actually done anything yet despite me saying I would rehome him a couple of months ago. If I’m being honest I’m afraid of family and friends judging me even though I know they’ll likely understand as she’s allergic. What would you do In this situation? Breaking up isn’t an option as she’s the person I want to be with but I’m struggling with the whole thing if im being honest. Thank you.

Op your partner sounds like a selfish control freak tbh! I would lose the partner not the dog!

Badbadtromance · 19/04/2023 13:21

Poor 🐕
No way would I part with mine

Gemmanorthdevon · 19/04/2023 13:21

Please do rehome the dog, but independently and with a family who won't ditch it when something better comes along!

Your plan of " rehoming with family" to mitigate the risk of loss to yourself incase you don't work out is awfully selfish. To unsettle a member of your immediate family ( Loving homes treat pets as family? ) who relies on you for their everything, and has done nothing but give you loyalty and unconditional love, perfectly prepared to do it again should life with Cruella not work out, begs belief.

Not to mention somebody that claims to love you, allowing you too! A little reading will confirm we build up a natural tolerance to allergens, and we can work around them...so a period of managing the symptoms, and regudog grooming with anti allergan product..will sort her issue. However the suggestion that she may also not do well with dog related smells etc, does very clearly illustrate that some of this is her personal preference.

OCD Is a very serious and debilitating mental health issue. If she is diagnosed then dog smells are the least of her worries. If not she is just being precious!

Either find someone who is prepared to work at being in your life as you like your life, or as I said, rehome the dog somewhere it won't be messed around again.

MegaClutterSlut · 19/04/2023 13:16

You would be an arsehole to rehome the dog...just saying. You haven't even been with her a year yet, poor dog is going to have its life turned upside down for someone you've known 5 minutes ffs

longtompot · 19/04/2023 13:13

I would not rehome my 4 year old dog for a 1 year relationship. You mentioned she was considering buying a house before meeting you, so maybe she could do this option, and if another year or so down the line things are still looking good, then maybe rent that out and move in together?

My dd is very allergic to pet dander, which was confirmed by a test at the hospital. She takes antihistamines which help a good amount. She has a cat which sleeps in her room and she would not even consider having her rehomed, nor our dog. We just make sure her bedding is changed weekly and the plan will be to eventually not have any carpets downstairs and have easily cleanable hard floor so some sort, probably cork.

I suspect the ocd has a larger part to play in why your gf wants you to rehome your dog. She presumably knew about your dog when you starting seeing each other. Is she like this about anything else in your home?

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 19/04/2023 13:05

At this stage, I think rehoming the dog would probably be the kindest thing for it - dogs deserve to be owned by someone who takes the commitment they made when making the decision to get one seriously.

Good luck!

bettybadger · 19/04/2023 13:05

What antihistamines has she tried? And does she take them before visiting? I have a cat allergy that produces the same symptoms. If I visit someone with a cat, I have to take the AHs in advance, then I'm fine. It's too late once symptoms start.
An OTC AH is enough for me but DH and DS take prescription strength Fexofenadine for theirs - has she tried speaking to GP?
Like PPs, I also know of someone whose allergy improved over time with living with a dog. (He now lives away and has a flare-up for a few days each time he visits - definitely seems to be a 'getting used to it' thing for him).
As regards your GF, she's entitled to be frustrated if you're promising one thing but doing another. Time to be honest with her and say you're having doubts about getting rid of the dog and would she be willing to try out different solutions.
Might also be an idea to ask your family to have the dog for a week or two (or put him in kennels) to see how she is without the dog there.
Definitely worth testing a few different options before making a firm decision. If she's not willing to try anything, that will tell you a lot. But you do need to ask her!

oldtree54 · 19/04/2023 13:04

I would never, ever, ever give up a pet for a partner. You made a commitment to that pet long before the partner was ever on the scene. There are so many options for treating allergies that don't involving getting rid of your pet.

It's a massive red flag if someone wants their partner to give up a pet, IMO.