Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stressed about rehoming dog as GF is allergic

785 replies

CanineConundrum · 19/04/2023 03:40

This is likely to be long so apologies in advance. I’d like my DP to move in with me and we said we’d do it around June. Only issue is I have a dog and we’ve recently discovered she’s allergic. She’s also mildly ocd and struggles with the dog hair/smells. I suspected she was allergic but didn’t want to admit it to myself. We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

only thing is I’m understandably quite upset at the thought of rehoming my dog. I’ve agreed to do it as I love her and want to marry and start a family with her. I’ve said I could potentially ask family or a friend to take him as then I could visit. I will struggle to rehome him with strangers and this way I can ensure he is ok. The issue is June is basically around the corner and she is frustrated with my lack of progress on the matter.

I haven’t mentioned any of this to family/my friend yet so as it stands we have no idea if they would even be willing to take the dog. They are all animal lovers so I’m sure at least one of them will say yes. I haven’t mentioned it to them as it’s hard for me to think about. My DP understands it’s difficult with me but sees this as me not being proactive as we aren’t really able to plan her moving in until the dog is rehomed. We’ve discussed it many times but end up going In circles and she gets teary as I haven’t really put a plan in place. She suggested rehoming him by the end of May as she will be moving in the following month.

Every time she brings it up I say there’s still things I need to put in place but I struggle to articulate exactly what these things are. The conversation goes the same way each time and nothing is really resolved. She thinks I’m not prioritising her needs/health as I said I’d move forward with rehoming him but I haven’t actually done anything yet despite me saying I would rehome him a couple of months ago. If I’m being honest I’m afraid of family and friends judging me even though I know they’ll likely understand as she’s allergic. What would you do In this situation? Breaking up isn’t an option as she’s the person I want to be with but I’m struggling with the whole thing if im being honest. Thank you.

OP posts:
uncomfortablydumb53 · 20/04/2023 02:24

Why agree to get rid so easily?
You haven't even tried thorough cleaning and dusting yet??
You'll regret it if you get rid of the dog

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/04/2023 02:21

Cross post @xxx82 I should have added no decent pet owner just relinquishes their pet without exploring all options either.

Money doesn’t seem to be an issue and op could spend the money from travelling on hard flooring and deep, deep cleaning the house. His house the dog’s home.

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/04/2023 02:17

Ninety nine percent you’ll regret this decision. So many posters have told you they managed to overcome the allergy issues. No decent person would make giving up your beloved pet their red line without even trying.

xxx82 · 20/04/2023 02:17

I don’t think that’s the case here though. They’ve been dating for a year and she only just got tested to confirm she’s allergic to dogs. he mentioned watery eyes, etc. but nothing so strong it means she can’t be around the dog without a visit to A&E. surely they’d have had to make a decision before now if it was that serious.

She’s also allergic to dust and the post made it clear their house is dusty. So it’s unclear if it’s entirely the dog that’s the problem.

So I wouldn’t go as far as suggesting he break up with her like some folks have. But if it was me, I’d be taking some steps first to minimise the pet dander as much as possible to see if that works. And getting the dust cleared too. Because there was no mention of them really trying anything yet to see if her allergies could be managed.

before you give up a pet that has been a part of your family for 4 years… or equally to be having it create an issue with your other half, I’d think you’d try anything and everything to make it work first.

DahliaRose3 · 20/04/2023 01:53

You have no idea if your relationship will go the distance if you haven’t even lived together yet. I would let her get her own place and see how it goes first before giving up your pet of 4 years.

Many people think their partner is it when they’re in the honeymoon phase, living together is completely different.

Anyway, I think your pet deserves a better home. It will break his heart - personally I couldn’t do that to my cat or dog. Trust me, you’ll regret that decision.

ChienChatCheval · 20/04/2023 01:40

🙄

CanineConundrum · 20/04/2023 01:28

Also the OCD comment was flippant and I apologise. I just meant she’s particular about keeping a clean and tidy home. Not showroom level but presentable. I admittedly haven’t been great at doing that and she emphasised the need for a clean space and I’ve been receptive to it as I know my standards could be higher

OP posts:
lemonchiffonpie · 20/04/2023 01:26

We’ve discussed rehoming my dog as her allergies are quite bad and she’s also very allergic to dust and my home is a little dusty as I’m more laid back about cleaning (she’s told me this needs to change and I’m actively working on this)

If she's that allergic, rehoming your dog will have minor impact as the house will remain full of his fur and other allergens long after he's left the house.

I'd stick with the dog.

CanineConundrum · 20/04/2023 01:22

Wow a lot of responses, thank you to everyone who has responded. Just to clarify a few things, she never demanded I get rid of the dog. She was honest about the fact she doesn’t think she can live with a dog and felt bad but didn’t know how difficult she’d find it as she’s never around them. It was me who chose to rehome him but I’m struggling with the thought of it.

to the person who asked about holidays, yes we’ve had a few trips together already as we love to travel. I saw her today and we had a heart to heart and aired everything out. She told me she doesn’t want me to do something if it will make me unhappy and suggested maybe I’d be happier with someone who is an animal lover. However I don’t want that as they wouldn’t be her. We’ve agreed a time frame and I will begin the conversations with family members soon. She was frustrated by the lack of conversation with others as she didn’t know where she stood but we’ve clarified everything now. Rehoming him will be the hardest thing I have ever had to do but I can’t imagine my life without my partner. Nobody has ever made me this happy. This is the only issue in our relationship even though it’s a big one but it’s a risk I have to take. At least this way my dog will be with people he already knows and I will be able to visit. I started this thread as I wanted advice on how to handle the situation and you all gave me a lot to think about

OP posts:
lfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 20/04/2023 00:36

ZiriForEver · 19/04/2023 23:30

Are you for real? Asking human being you supposedly care about to regularly medicate, inhale steroids, suffer from a year of exposure test...
And now let's imagine it doesn't help. Would it be enough of a sacrifice from that human, so you would rehome in the end, or would it be "well, it was nice to have you here, but I don't really care about your well-being that much"?

Exactly. Well said. Maddening that so many think the gf should just Medicate.

lfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 20/04/2023 00:35

ChrisTrepidation · 19/04/2023 05:06

Would you rehome a child for a new partner?

Dogs are family. Rehoming your dog for a woman you"ve known five minutes is just awful.

If I met someone and they were allergic to my pets their would be zero chance of my animals being shipped off to suit them.

She sounds cold and uncaring and you sound like a doormat!

dogs are not comparable to children.

and no one is allergic to children.

Ponderingwindow · 20/04/2023 00:29

Do none of you have family who have ended up in a&e after exposure to a beloved family pet? Have none of you been there yourselves? Have you experienced the joy of a 3 week course of steroids because of a bad exposure?

Try Hoovering, dusting, washing bedding, and washing the pet, and keeping the pet isolated, and then loading up the relative on antihistamines so they can come in for a brief visit where they stick to only hardwood areas and hard furniture only to end up in the hospital and you might start to understand pet allergies.

Agapornis · 20/04/2023 00:29

ZiriForEver · 20/04/2023 00:24

Ok, I admit you haven't actually asked it from (OP's) partner, others did so earlier. Sorry about that.
Anyway, the prolonged exposure sounds like a self-harm to me. I am wondering now how long term inflammation influences the body.

It's been 30 years and I'm alright so far :) Cats do wonders for my mental wellbeing and more than make up for the slight inconvenience of medication.

ZiriForEver · 20/04/2023 00:24

Agapornis · 20/04/2023 00:13

@ZiriForEver yep I'm for real - I love my cats and am willing to do that. I posted it to show there are options - whether the partner is willing to give it a go is another matter.

Ok, I admit you haven't actually asked it from (OP's) partner, others did so earlier. Sorry about that.
Anyway, the prolonged exposure sounds like a self-harm to me. I am wondering now how long term inflammation influences the body.

JMSA · 20/04/2023 00:20

Ditch the drama llama and keep the dog!

Agapornis · 20/04/2023 00:13

@ZiriForEver yep I'm for real - I love my cats and am willing to do that. I posted it to show there are options - whether the partner is willing to give it a go is another matter.

ZiriForEver · 19/04/2023 23:30

Agapornis · 19/04/2023 21:13

From experience:
A) Try different antihistamines. Some work, some don't. Cetirizine, loratadine, fexofenadine, any others - try them all, over the counter as well as prescription.
B) Exposure. It can take me 3-9 months of living with a new cat to get used to them. It's worked with 7 different cats so far for me.
C) Inhalers. They can take the edge off. Try a steroid inhaler e.g. beclometasone.
D) Flooring. Either hard flooring or regular hoovering with a good hair hoover - probably not a Henry, the bag should be filter not paper.

Are you for real? Asking human being you supposedly care about to regularly medicate, inhale steroids, suffer from a year of exposure test...
And now let's imagine it doesn't help. Would it be enough of a sacrifice from that human, so you would rehome in the end, or would it be "well, it was nice to have you here, but I don't really care about your well-being that much"?

xxx82 · 19/04/2023 23:29

I discovered I’m allergic to dogs after getting my first dog as an adult - although only mildly. I was already in love with him from the time we chose him so no way was I going to do without him. I just take steps to manage it.

I understand that a more severe allergy is harder to deal with. However, it does sound like your dog is only one cause of her allergic reaction. So I think it’s a bit soon to jump to rehoming your dog.

There are definitely things to try first to see what makes a difference.

— first, you could get a cleaning company in to do a real professional deep clean - get rid of all dust/dog dander/etc in your home

and get your dog groomed professionally too

Then you’d be starting from scratch with a fresh environment. from there:

— restrict the areas your dog goes in - that would be hard enough for both you and your dog and a huge compromise in itself

— wash the dog’s bedding regularly

— consider getting a regular cleaner - you will be sharing bills you’ve paying yourself up to now. So use some of the extra for professional cleaning, paying close attention to areas your dog is in most

— if your GF works from home then could you put your dog to a doggy daycare so he’s not home all day or could family or friends help out and have him at their house during the day

and then if your GF also tried some allergy remedies, all of that combined could make this totally manageable.

I definitely wouldn’t rehome til you’ve tried at least some of that. And if she isn’t willing to even try so that you don’t have to give up a pet that you love and are bonded to, then that’s honestly a big red flag

Catsmere · 19/04/2023 23:09

Allergic or not, the fact she wants OP to get rid of his dog so she can move in - the fact she even considers that a reasonable course of action if OP suggested it - says nothing good about either of them, imo.

Spambod · 19/04/2023 22:57

She is allergic to nothing. She doesn’t love you if she is putting pressure on you to do such an awful thing that will make you so unhappy. Run for the hills.

Testina · 19/04/2023 22:53

“I truly believe 'when you know, you know' too. I knew after 6 weeks with my hubbie, and 14 years later, we are very happily married. “

That isn’t proof of anything @Secretroses

Lots of people think they “know”. And yeah sure, some of them are right and their boyfriend doesn’t turn out to be an arsehole.
But that doesn’t mean that everyone can rely on a feeling of “just knowing” - because statistics clearly tell us that a huge amount of people are simply wrong.

And whilst I wish you love and luck in relationship for another 14 years and more, plenty of people are happily married after 14 years then post on here as a 29 year marriage implodes. So again, it doesn’t prove anything.

Lovely when it works but this idea that you “just know” makes a person sound childish or naïve.

Knockmealdowns · 19/04/2023 22:40

Could you have a delux doggie shed? Heated etc that doggie can sleep in? And just keep it in one room by day? We had farm dogs that lived outside, never saw a sofa and lived well up to 14 or 15 years..

Catsmere · 19/04/2023 22:39

This isn’t a family member being exposed to an incoming pet though. It’s a short-duration girlfriend demanding a pet be got rid of so she can move in.

Catsmere · 19/04/2023 22:36

Coffeetree · 19/04/2023 10:14

Well no, OP has said there are family members who can take the dog? Look, I won't argue about how a life partner differs from a pet. Just if the partner is being ducked around because OP would rather remain single with a dog, the the partner deserves to know that.

OP hasn’t even asked and this girlfriend isn’t a life partner, they have been together tless than a year and never lived together. The dog is OP’s responsibility and wholly dependent on him.

Treesoutsidemywindow · 19/04/2023 22:27

Because the thread is already so long, I'm afraid I haven't read all of it OP, but can I ask a couple of questions please?

  1. How old are you and your GF
  2. Have you had a holiday together yet, ideally at least 2 weeks?

The reasons I ask about the holiday situation, is that if you've only known each other less than a year, you may not have had the opportunity to spend 24/7 together for any length of time, and if this is the case, I would suggest at the very least, that you ask your parents or friends if they would consider looking after your dog for at least a fortnight so that you can see how well you get on when you're together all the time. It's very easy to think that you've found the love of your life, but in reality if you haven't spent full days and nights together for more than a few days, you may find that your girlfriend is even more picky than you think she is, ie, she might moan at you for leaving the top off the toothpaste, or not wiping round the washbasin after you've finished, leaving the loo seat or lid up, or not wiping down the worktop the minute you've made a sandwich. There could be hundreds of things about you that irritate her, and vice versa, so before you even think about rehoming your dog, please make sure that at a minimum you've at the very least got a clear idea of what living together day after day might be like.

Alternatively, you said that she was thinking of getting her own place soon, well why not let her do that, then maybe you can spend more time getting to know each other before taking such a big step as getting rid of your do.