Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not trust DH to not shout at me again

108 replies

LaMaG · 18/04/2023 23:29

My DH is a bit stressed these days (as am I) for a million reasons but particularly cos of some behaviour problems with our teenage son. I could write a book about it but let's just say he is extremely argumentative. I have many times begged DH to not shout back or engage in aggressive talk, partly cos I can see it makes everything worse but also on advice of a number of psychologists. Yet he always shouts back and has to have the final word. If I intervene the anger can turn towards me. Recently we had a family dinner at in laws and my son started rising my DH, bringing up something he was asked to not mention in front of gran. This was done intentionally to cause a stir, this is what he does. Anyhow shortly after I unintentionally cut across DH, and he let rip, shouting at me in front of everyone saying how dare i interrupt, I have no respect etc. I was in shock and then told him to get over himself and then just sat there while he yelled again. Everyone was mortified and I left shortly after. DH apologised shortly after and now acts like all is OK. I am so angry. Less than 24 hours later when I told him how upset I was he said I was trying to drag it out again so I feel like I can't talk to him or he will shout again. I don't want to see my inlaws again and am afraid of a dinner we are throwing for some friends in a few weeks, I just feel like it's all going to happen again and I will not set myself up for humiliation again. I have no idea how to let it go or do I try to talk it through and risk another tantrum.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 09:38

Can not believe people saying it is the fault of the teen that an adult humiliated and embarrassed their partner in front of family to the extent people had to leave
The husband is 100% responsible for his behaviour. It was unpleasant and unacceptable.

The teen is responsible for his behaviour.

The OP and her husband are responsible for allowing a teenager to get to this position by not getting to grips with his behaviour.

Identifying that an ongoing situation can be a trigger for someone losing their temper doesn't excuse them losing their temper.

Nothing in their household is going to change until the OP and her husband address the issue of the teens behaviour in a way they're on the same page.

Sooner or later then teenager will become an adult and the big wide world isn't going to accept his shit, and there's a realising chance (based on how the OP describes his attitude and behaviour) that one day he'll pick a fight with the wrong person.

Devoutspoken · 19/04/2023 09:35

It's the response of the abuser that's the problem not the provocation

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 09:27

Gregorylass · 19/04/2023 09:19

So, a badly behaved teen is deliberately causing arguments and you really don't think he's the problem?

The behaviour of the teen needs to be addressed but the issue that the OP is discussing was her husbands' behaviour towards her. That lies completely with him irespective of what their teen is doing or has done. I genuinely can not understand posts saying the problem is the teen. The problem is that when the teen is challenging behaviour the husband thinks an acceptable reaction is to yell and humiliate his wife in front of his family and in front of the teen. That is the problem.

Devoutspoken · 19/04/2023 09:22

Maybe fil did nothing, because that's where your dh learned his behaviour

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 09:20

The teenager knows which buttons to push, no doubt about that. The teenager said his uncle is more successful than his dad. It might be nasty but the dad has to learn to deal with this. It's not acceptable to react by yelling at his partner who tried to intervene in the argument. Why is he so touchy about this anyway. Is he insecure or ultra competitive with his brother.
Why even engage when teen is being like this. Does he react like this when he is wound up at work or in other situations.
Can not believe people saying it is the fault of the teen that an adult humiliated and embarrassed their partner in front of family to the extent people had to leave. The responsibility for the husband's behaviour lies with him and on absolutely no level was it acceptable whatever the teen was doing. The reaction, of course, was exactly what the teen wanted so he will do it again.

Gregorylass · 19/04/2023 09:19

CleaningOutMyCloset · 19/04/2023 09:13

I couldn't disagree more! The son is NOT the problem here.

The parents need to find a way of parenting their son, does he have any mental health issues, has something happened, is he simply struggling with teenage hormones, is it just typical teenage angst? Whatever it is, his parents should be helping him to manage his behaviour, he needs to understand his behaviour isn't acceptable. But how on Earth they can do that whilst his father sets the example that it's ok to shout at people when he's annoyed. Maybe the ds is fed up with his DF being a bully and is trying to control the narrative with his behaviour.

As parents it's our job to ensure you try to bring up a good human, firstly by setting a good example

It's a bit like getting smacked by your parents for hitting.

So, a badly behaved teen is deliberately causing arguments and you really don't think he's the problem?

CleaningOutMyCloset · 19/04/2023 09:13

Gregorylass · 19/04/2023 08:55

Your son is the problem here. He is clearly manipulating the situation and deliberately causing tension and arguments. You both need to be on the same page regarding his unacceptable behaviour, and back each other up when dealing with him.
I don't believe that shouting is abuse when there is a stroppy teenager winding everyone up.

I couldn't disagree more! The son is NOT the problem here.

The parents need to find a way of parenting their son, does he have any mental health issues, has something happened, is he simply struggling with teenage hormones, is it just typical teenage angst? Whatever it is, his parents should be helping him to manage his behaviour, he needs to understand his behaviour isn't acceptable. But how on Earth they can do that whilst his father sets the example that it's ok to shout at people when he's annoyed. Maybe the ds is fed up with his DF being a bully and is trying to control the narrative with his behaviour.

As parents it's our job to ensure you try to bring up a good human, firstly by setting a good example

It's a bit like getting smacked by your parents for hitting.

LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 08:55

I HATE being shouted at. I never shout. Never ever so people can fuck of if they think they can shout at me.

I assume all the odd posts on this thread are from posters who can't control their tempers
I also don't like shouting, our house is a calm house where DH and I make a point of teaching our DC how to disagree whilst maintaining an appropriate tone of voice and volume, but can think of some situations where I have shouted because I'm human.

In this situation I can easily see how having a teenager displaying this sort of behaviour, with two parents on totally different pages on how to deal or not deal with it, is the sort of situation where someone is going to run out of fuse.

It doesn't excuse the shouting. It doesn't make it acceptable. It does acknowledge that there is a situation here that isn't being resolved and unless something drastically changes the whole household dynamic is going to be dictated by a teenager picking fights, the OP tiptoeing around so not to bother the fight picking teenager and a husband blowing his fuse.

It isn't a healthy situation so the OP and her husband need to be the adults in this situation and get to grips with DC.

Gregorylass · 19/04/2023 08:55

Your son is the problem here. He is clearly manipulating the situation and deliberately causing tension and arguments. You both need to be on the same page regarding his unacceptable behaviour, and back each other up when dealing with him.
I don't believe that shouting is abuse when there is a stroppy teenager winding everyone up.

Devoutspoken · 19/04/2023 08:51

Nice of the inlaws to do nothing about their sons behaviour

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 08:48

CleaningOutMyCloset · 19/04/2023 07:27

What teenager doesn't start arguments or isn't a knob. Sounds like he's extreme in comparison to some, but he's still just a teen. Rather than shouting and losing his temper, why isn't his DF finding ways to resolve the conflict without getting angry and shouting? Could the reason his DS is being a knob because he's seen his DF shout at all members of the household on a regular basis - monkey see, monkey do.

OP your DH needs to find a way of resolving conflict without getting angry and losing his temper. Regardless of what you or your teen did, his reaction to this was terrible and far too extreme. I'm not surprised you're struggling to get past it. Tbh I'd cancel the dinner with friends.

As for your teen, could he speak to someone? Maybe a councillor at school to get to the bottom of why he's deliberately annoying his DF? There might be an underlying issue (or he could just be being a twat)

This is it in a nutshell. However bad a child behaves there is never ever an excuse to shout at the other parent. Doing in front of others shows a serious lack of self control.
And it just reinforces the power the teenager has as he got exactly what he wanted and also sets an example that shouting at his mother is an acceptable way to take out your anger. He did it twice in front of the in laws over the same meal.
Humiliating, agressive, embarrassing. Everyone left. OP thinks same could happen again next week. There is no excuse, even if he was 'at the end of his tether' and people shouldn't be making them for him.
He needs to address this quickly

Comeohsavinglight · 19/04/2023 08:46

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/04/2023 00:56

Your son is an ass that intentionally riles everyone up. You seem to deflect or ignore it and your husband is fed up with the dynamic.

Good luck is all I have to say. Clearly you and DH aren’t on the same page and your son is taking full advantage of it. This will probably not end well.

I don’t normally agree with posts like this, but this time I do. After seeing what your son said, that just nasty. He was deliberately and calculatedly going for the jugular, and in public too.

it sounds like you and your H need to agree a strategy for how to deal with son’s behaviour. I’d suggest outside mediation / support to agree an approach.

piedbeauty · 19/04/2023 08:36

I wonder where your son learned this abusive behaviour from.

MagiMagic · 19/04/2023 08:29

Really odd replies on this thread.

I'd be devestated to be shouted at like that too. In some ways it's good there was an audience as it means it's harder to ignore and brush under the carpet.

The fact he is shutting you down talking about it makes it a lot worse.

How often does he shout at you? Do you even want to stay with him? What do you feel about your future? What about when the kids leave home and it's just you and him? Retirement is a long period of time and you need to be able to trust the other person.

Do you feel tense around your husband?

I would.

I HATE being shouted at. I never shout. Never ever so people can fuck of if they think they can shout at me.

I assume all the odd posts on this thread are from posters who can't control their tempers.

Good luck OP. I'd cancel the meal.

Daniella12 · 19/04/2023 08:28

Teenagers can be very testing and cruel. I know from experience. The husband was being riled and humiliated, and lost it. Forgive him.

CalistoNoSolo · 19/04/2023 08:24

CecilyP · 19/04/2023 07:58

Is he at the end if his tether? I bet he’s not unable sleep and asking for advice at midnight! As he is unwilling to even talk about it with OP, it sounds like he’s quite happy to get on with his day like nothing has happened.

I have no idea, OP hasn't given much background info. But why are you so invested in the husband being an abusive bastard?

CalistoNoSolo · 19/04/2023 08:24

CecilyP · 19/04/2023 07:58

Is he at the end if his tether? I bet he’s not unable sleep and asking for advice at midnight! As he is unwilling to even talk about it with OP, it sounds like he’s quite happy to get on with his day like nothing has happened.

I have no idea, OP hasn't given much background info. But why are you so invested in the husband being an abusive bastard?

Maray1967 · 19/04/2023 08:21

Cancel or at least postpone the dinner - you don’t need the stress of that right now.
No, your DH should not have behaved as he did, and I wouldn’t be rushing back to the in-laws any time soon, I must admit.
But - you need to get a grip on your son’s behaviour. What consequences does he face for behaving like this? You should not be intervening to pacify him, you should be warning him and then carrying out consequences. Mine would have been ordered to leave the table and head to the car and I would have driven him home. I would have warned the in-laws in advance so they did not intervene to try to stop me taking him away. Then I would make sure he respected what he receives from his dad’s work - does he fancy going without his phone for a month? I’m wondering why you ‘pacified’ a teenager who was basically humiliating his dad by belittling what he earns compared to his brother?

AP5Diva · 19/04/2023 08:08

If your DH were an abusive twat, shouting would have started long before there was a teenager in the mix deliberately pushing buttons to make his dad angry.

Your DH should not have shouted at you, but OMG I have shouted at my teens and my DN when the teens have egged me over the brink. I can count the number of times on one hand though, and I don’t think that is too terrible.

Obviously, I did start doing mindfulness and working on taking three deep breaths before responding to one of my teens being deliberately provocative towards me. Teens can be a whole new challenge.

Id punish the teen for being deliberately provocative and also tell DH he needs to find a solution to not shout- even if it means saying “I can’t deal with this right now” and walking away to cool down.

Cherry8809 · 19/04/2023 08:01

PottyMouthkaka · 19/04/2023 01:19

Your son sounds a knob. I'd cut your poor husband some slack it all got too much. I would look into why my son is such a shit stirrer instead of adding more grief to an already stressed out husband. I wouldn't be so dramatic as to not go see my in laws again.

This.

Sapphire387 · 19/04/2023 08:00

It's not fully clear to me from your post but... if you were interrupting while he was dealing with your and his (very rude) teenage son, then you are being unreasonable. It does sound like you are excusing poor behaviour on son's part and husband doesn't agree with you on how to tackle it. Neither of you is necessarily 'wrong'.

IF, however, he just took his anger out on you as part of an unrelated conversation because he was still annoyed from your son's behaviour, that is unacceptable and he is unreasonable.

It does sound like the root cause is son's poor behaviour- your husband is allowed to be angry at your son. And also neither you nor your husband seem to agree on how to tackle it, which sounds like it is creating tension.

Theunamedcat · 19/04/2023 08:00

Doesn't even sound like the son did anything wrong teasing someone for being jealous can and should be laughed off

CecilyP · 19/04/2023 07:58

CalistoNoSolo · 19/04/2023 07:46

Your son sounds like a complete nob and your husband sounds like he's at the end of his tether with it. It's an awful dynamic to live in and you and your husband really need to be on the same parenting page otherwise your marriage is pretty much over. Your H yelling isn't necessarily abusive, it depends if it was a one off during a high stress moment, or if its how he always is.

Is he at the end if his tether? I bet he’s not unable sleep and asking for advice at midnight! As he is unwilling to even talk about it with OP, it sounds like he’s quite happy to get on with his day like nothing has happened.

CecilyP · 19/04/2023 07:54

OP your DH needs to find a way of resolving conflict without getting angry and losing his temper. Regardless of what you or your teen did, his reaction to this was terrible and far too extreme. I'm not surprised you're struggling to get past it. Tbh I'd cancel the dinner with friends.

As for your teen, could he speak to someone. Maybe a councillor at school to get to the bottom of why he's deliberately annoying his DF? There might be an underlying issue (or he could just be being a twat)

OP mentioned advice of psychologists in her first post so it seems the son’s behaviour has already got passed the school councillor stage. My own feeling from the limited information given, is the underlying problem is his dad.

CalistoNoSolo · 19/04/2023 07:46

Your son sounds like a complete nob and your husband sounds like he's at the end of his tether with it. It's an awful dynamic to live in and you and your husband really need to be on the same parenting page otherwise your marriage is pretty much over. Your H yelling isn't necessarily abusive, it depends if it was a one off during a high stress moment, or if its how he always is.