Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not trust DH to not shout at me again

108 replies

LaMaG · 18/04/2023 23:29

My DH is a bit stressed these days (as am I) for a million reasons but particularly cos of some behaviour problems with our teenage son. I could write a book about it but let's just say he is extremely argumentative. I have many times begged DH to not shout back or engage in aggressive talk, partly cos I can see it makes everything worse but also on advice of a number of psychologists. Yet he always shouts back and has to have the final word. If I intervene the anger can turn towards me. Recently we had a family dinner at in laws and my son started rising my DH, bringing up something he was asked to not mention in front of gran. This was done intentionally to cause a stir, this is what he does. Anyhow shortly after I unintentionally cut across DH, and he let rip, shouting at me in front of everyone saying how dare i interrupt, I have no respect etc. I was in shock and then told him to get over himself and then just sat there while he yelled again. Everyone was mortified and I left shortly after. DH apologised shortly after and now acts like all is OK. I am so angry. Less than 24 hours later when I told him how upset I was he said I was trying to drag it out again so I feel like I can't talk to him or he will shout again. I don't want to see my inlaws again and am afraid of a dinner we are throwing for some friends in a few weeks, I just feel like it's all going to happen again and I will not set myself up for humiliation again. I have no idea how to let it go or do I try to talk it through and risk another tantrum.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
billy1966 · 21/04/2023 15:34

OP,

You are in a very difficult stressful situation.

You are not your husbands emotional punching bag.

Far better he leaves than continues to bully you and escalate an already difficult situation.

Your upset all week is clearly telling you that your health is also now at risk.

Remain calm.

If he becomes aggressive, ring the police.

Your husband is an out of control bully and you do not have to accept this.

I really wish you well.

LaMaG · 21/04/2023 15:27

Thanks all. Just to answer a few questions - DS was offered meds 4 yrs ago when diagnosed with ADHD but DH really strongly felt it was a bad move. I disagreed as we had a prof recommendation but then DS said he would refuse to take it and then his teachers said they didn't think it was necessary, so we put it off. Then puberty and covid hit and it all escalated. We have gone back to ask for meds but have to be reassessed so thats where we are now.

Thanks for the ODD book recommendation. I am v familiar with the condition since teachers and minders have used the oppositional word his whole life. I have been on so many parenting courses and read so many books but mostly based on children not teenagers. DS is a serious athlete, it's his life and lockdowns were horrific for him. I think we chose our battles carefully at that time and possibly lost a lot of parental control just trying to get through the day.

I intend to sit down and have a very honest talk this weekend with DH. It probably won't end well but I have been so stressed and have a tummy ache and head ache all week so I know I have to do it now for my own sake. Dreading it

OP posts:
Irritateandunreasonable · 20/04/2023 13:40

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 22:12

@Irritateandunreasonable and I was careful to not say it was abusive. I have used the word unacceptable in all my posts. I agree that it is sometimes used too quickly as is LTB. And having 3 children I would agree sometimes you're frustrations on your children's behaviour can project to your partner, but not shouting and humiliating them. Not in my world, anyway.

Yes but my point exactly was that OP wasn’t in an abusive relationship (from what was written about said relationship) and you were responding to me.

Glad we agree on everything else.

billy1966 · 20/04/2023 09:34

@DeeCeeCherry completely agree.

I would be absolutely appalled if anyone connected to us behaved as her husband did.

I certainly wouldn't remain sitting by and allow him to think it was acceptable.

I would be cancelling all future social dinners and meet ups.
I would tell friends/family that his behaviour is completely unacceptable.

I would be telling him that you have cancelled all future socialising with him and explained that his verbal abuse of you is the reason.

This bullshit continues because people accept it.

Shine a light on it and let him deal with the fact his wife refuses to socialise with him and why.

If you socialise with him again, the message is clear, that you accept this behaviour and its okay with you.

I'm so sorry.

DeeCeeCherry · 19/04/2023 23:03

Your husband is scolding you in public. It's designed to humiliate and embarass you in front of others, cause stress and anxiety re upcoming occasions, and there is absolutely no justification for doing that to anybody. He lacks control. If I was at a table and witnessed something like that I'd get up and walk out.

The teenage son issue must be addressed seperately, he is way out of order. There needs to be consequences. However you are not to be scapegoated for your son's behaviour. & his dad is no role model, clearly.

Ignore the 'yeah buts' on this thread, they have no standards. You do not have to accept or put up with this. & you should tell him so, and mean it.

Once unkindness becomes a norm, your relationship is dead in the water anyway. So thats also something to think about. Alongside the fact he doesnt respect you and wants others to see and know it.

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 22:12

@Irritateandunreasonable and I was careful to not say it was abusive. I have used the word unacceptable in all my posts. I agree that it is sometimes used too quickly as is LTB. And having 3 children I would agree sometimes you're frustrations on your children's behaviour can project to your partner, but not shouting and humiliating them. Not in my world, anyway.

Tigofigo · 19/04/2023 21:57

This is toxic masculinity in action. Men unable to express themselves through anything other than shouting as they're told crying and talking about their feelings are signs of weakness. Passed on through the generations.

Your DH shouting is really unacceptable and unhelpful but equally it sounds like he's really struggling. Your son also is really struggling which you recognise.

Not that it makes their behaviour ok. Your DH is massively out of order, but also needs empathy. Both things can be true at the same time.

I suggest before you walk out that DH gets counselling, and joins a men's talking club, and you both attend a teen parenting course for neurodivergent children. Look at trauma informed parenting or explosive child parenting.

You also need to take care of yourself. Find an outlet to vent and explore your own feelings. You are currently doing a huge job holding this all down.

Both you and DH need to work on your triggers and find inner calm. I know you're not shouting which is harmful to everyone, but hyperventilating in the bathroom isn't good for you either. It's tough but you're the parents and you're the ones that need to be cool, calm and in control here. Good luck.

billy1966 · 19/04/2023 21:42

Regularly screaming at your wife, even in public, your younger children wanting to ask Santa to stop Daddy shouting, absolutely indicates a highly dysfunctional environment that I would describe as abusive.

It's hardly a happy home or anything resembling one.

Her husband may indeed be struggling with their son, but that doesn't mean he gets to terrorise the house with his shouting and temper.

ToWhitToWhoo · 19/04/2023 21:37

Could your dh also have ASD- given that at least two of the children do, and there is a big genetic component to the condition? Even if he does, it does not excuse his obviously quite frequent shouting; but could explain some of his stressed behaviour and lack of tolerance.

Whether this is the case or not, it is certainly not your fault.

billy1966 · 19/04/2023 21:35

You poor woman.

How dreadful.

You have a lot going on.

Your son has issues but he is a child still.

Personally I wouldn't know how to move forward with someone who would humiliate me like that and behave so badly.

I certainly wouldn't be sharing a bed with them.

His behaviour is nasty and abusive and your younger children are feeling it too.

Do you want to remain married is the question?

He really made a complete show of himself didn't he!

I'm so sorry.

This must be very tough to live with.

User1990C · 19/04/2023 21:34

To the usual nonsense, i.e. ultimatums etc, get over yourselves.

Your husband has been horrible to you. This is not excusable. It is understandable. He needs to reflect on his source of anger.

He's likely struggling with realising that his son is going to have a far worse sort of life than he'd hoped for him. He likely thinks that your son can be either reasoned with or bullied into proper conduct; he can't.

I'm sorry your family are dealing with such a tough situation.

mainsfed · 19/04/2023 21:27

Dilemma19 · 19/04/2023 14:09

There's no doubt DH behaviour is linked to deterioration in DS behaviour in the past few years. The day before this incident they stopped to get an energy drink for DS on the way home from a match and he called DH a "stupid fggot" for tapping the wrong button on the self service machine - loudly inside in Tesco. DH was so upset.*

And posters still think the dh is at fault? Your d
S sounds horrible and gets off on gaslighting your dh and others. No one can keep their tolerance with a child like that.

Of course the dickhead H is still at fault for shouting at his wife in front of his whole family.

Why is the son’s ADHD and behaviour OP’s fault?

Itwasnaeme · 19/04/2023 21:23

OP have you ever read about Oppositional Defiant Disorder? Trying to wind others up is part of this, and it's more likely in someone with adhd than someone without.
Your dh may be experiencing stress from the situation with his son, but he also may have a similar condition yourself.
Whether it's ODD or not, I found the book 10 days to a less defiant child really helpful - I haven't shouted at my dc since and I'd say his behaviour is improving (slowly!) as a result.

LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 20:58

With your updates, your DH's behaviour is a bigger problem.

Whilst it's unacceptable for him to have shouted in your first post, it could be understandable that someone could lost their temper after an ongoing situation is bubbling for ages and they're being endlessly goaded.

The fact that your DH seems to react with shouting with such regularity that children have asked Santa for him to stop suggests a worrying pattern of behaviour on his part.

You and him still need to get on the same page to address your teen's behaviour, but he also either needs to change his behaviour and possibly go to therapy himself so he can address the root cause of why he is that badly triggered by the behaviour on such a regular basis.

Irritateandunreasonable · 19/04/2023 20:56

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 20:40

Well the other children have asked santa to take daddy's shouting away as their Christmas present and a phycologist has told him to not shout as a way of Communication and his wife is serious going to cancel a dinner party because she is scared he will kick off and shout at her.
And that's all we have read about. They have a significant parenting challenge but shouting and humiliating his wife at home that scares the other children and in front of family so they leave, is a problem.

A psychologist is hardly going to say ‘yes, shout back, that will make it better’ but the fact psychologists are involved indicates the immense stress this family are under.

Who said it wasn’t a problem? Because that wasn’t me. I said OP was not in an abusive relationship because her DH shouted at her.

Honestly MN are so quick to jump to ‘abuse’ if it was the Mother acting like this she’d get sympathy.

Many, if not most MN users massively struggle to see any view point other than their own. There are real people involved here all with their own thoughts, feelings and processes. Making dangerous assumptions and jumping to conclusion from extremely limited information can leads to misguided advice, conflicts and conclusions.

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 20:41

A one off it ain't

ClareBlue · 19/04/2023 20:40

Irritateandunreasonable · 19/04/2023 16:38

Oh for goodness sake. DH has been arguing with DS and shouted at his wife once and now she’s being abused.

If you’re arguing with your DS or DD and snap at your DH because of the stress of it all are you an abuser?

We all get angry, we all have very stressful times in our lives and occasionally we take it out on someone who doesn’t deserve it, it’s human, it doesn’t make use abusive.

Well the other children have asked santa to take daddy's shouting away as their Christmas present and a phycologist has told him to not shout as a way of Communication and his wife is serious going to cancel a dinner party because she is scared he will kick off and shout at her.
And that's all we have read about. They have a significant parenting challenge but shouting and humiliating his wife at home that scares the other children and in front of family so they leave, is a problem.

pickledandpuzzled · 19/04/2023 16:39

How does your son behave when his dad isn't around? Is it mainly him that he targets?

I wonder whether he's reacting to your husband's control- it often happens.

Irritateandunreasonable · 19/04/2023 16:38

Oh for goodness sake. DH has been arguing with DS and shouted at his wife once and now she’s being abused.

If you’re arguing with your DS or DD and snap at your DH because of the stress of it all are you an abuser?

We all get angry, we all have very stressful times in our lives and occasionally we take it out on someone who doesn’t deserve it, it’s human, it doesn’t make use abusive.

Devoutspoken · 19/04/2023 16:35

Agree with onions, humour is a better tool than shouting, when dealing with provocative kids

Devoutspoken · 19/04/2023 16:34

I think it's very easy to ignore a child on the wind up, in the same way I can ignore a buzzing insect, ignoring a fully grown man shouting, is not so easy

AxolotlOnions · 19/04/2023 16:28

I am autistic and I grew up with a shouty autistic father too. Has DH always been like this or is it a recent thing?

If he's always been shouty then your son is pushing his buttons as he has become immune to the shouting. If you're going to get shouted at no matter what you do you may as well get a few jabs in to the person you despise before all hell breaks loose. DH is then directing his anger at you as you don't fight back, he still has power over you.

If this is just since DS started pushing his buttons then DH needs to grow up a bit. I know it's hard but it's best to ignore teens when they are like this. I usually walk away or tell them how lovely teenagers are at this age or something else to diffuse the situation. Don't lose you sense of humour, adapt it to the hell that is raising autistic teens! It's not forever, they'll be human again in another couple of years. 10 at the most!

Nowvoyager99 · 19/04/2023 16:27

Given your updates, the problem is clearly your DH.

It is heartbreaking to hear your little ones are asking for Santas help to make daddy stop shouting.

What eldest DS said really doesn’t sound that bad to me. Certainly not enough for the full scale shouting from DH that followed. Does he have no SOH? I would think it rather funny (as would my siblings) if our DC were talking about us like that. We would probably respond with “yeah, but at at least I don’t have his stinky feet” or similar.

Would DH consider anger management? Is he eldest DS father?

Royalbloo · 19/04/2023 16:19

He sounds like a horrible bully. Next time I'd film him and tell him that's why he's now single.

TuesdayJulyNever · 19/04/2023 16:18

I’m also going to add that one of the greatest failings of the support for ND dc is the assumption that the dps and siblings are NT when the balance of probability is that we’re not.

Most behaviour management relies on parents being consistent and paragons of emotional regulation.

The reasons for that are about economics and convenience rather than best practice or psychology.

It is worth taking a look at everyone involved to figure out 1) whether you have traits or an undiagnosed condition; and 2) what your needs and triggers are.

You cannot focus everything on the needs of one child - it’s about balancing a system. Once you get clear on when, where and why you each need support it becomes easier to find it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread