Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can we muzzle all dogs in public yet (warning, graphic image of mauled hand)

478 replies

lfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 18/04/2023 22:25

“Whilst out walking a route that Tom has been on numerous times, he was the victim of an unprovoked attack by an unleashed dog. The dog attacked Tom multiple times as he tried to protect his puppy from being mauled by the dog and was left with horrific injuries. What is more horrifying, however, is that the owners of the dog didn’t try to help and fled the scene leaving Tom bleeding from his artery on his wrist.

Wife Katy recalls the moment that she opened the door to find her husband standing there after the attack: ‘‘Tom managed to get home where I had to tourniquet, to try to stem the bleeding, while waiting for 999. He lost several litres of blood in the short time until the ambulance arrived. Our two children were at home at the time and were woken up by the commotion. My 7-year-old was terrified and thought that her dad was doing to die from the blood loss.’’

https://www.familiesonline.co.uk/news/dad-of-2-viciously-mauled-by-dog-trying-to-protect-family-puppy

Imagine it had been a child’s face, or neck, or little body, instead of an adult’s hand.

Absolutely sick of nothing being done to protect the public.

YABU - dogs are man’s best friend
YANBU - something needs to be done

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
hiredandsqueak · 20/04/2023 16:09

My old dog walks off lead she will never be muzzled. She bothers nobody she's not interested in the majority of dogs or anyone outside of her family. She's old now so doesn't stray far from my side but she has reliable recall anyway. There would be no benefit to anyone if she was forced to be on a lead and muzzled but it would impact her happiness considerably. Ive lost count of the number of people, both adults and children though who have stroked her, tried to pick her up without asking first. Not a problem as she wouldn't hurt anybody but only I know that at the time.

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2023 15:52

There's billions of knives and only 282 were used for murder so why bother restricting their sale etc, everyone should be able to wander the streets with a carving knife... You'd think that pretty silly though..
That's exactly the point. Do you think anyone carrying any sort of knife, to a barbecue or a picnic should have licence and a double lock just in case you suddenly decided to go and murder someone because there are a few who uses them to do so?

Actually, make it forks too because I'm sure there are up to 9000 people going to A&E to A&E with forks injuries so let's make sure everyone having a nice picnic in the park put all forks in a lock container and never use them if there are people around you just in case they have an accident with a fork.

The dog thing is a complete overreaction. Doesn't mean you shouldn't be careful but no, danger doesn't lurk at any corner of local parks.

Maverickess · 20/04/2023 14:26

24KaratCucumber · 20/04/2023 14:03

Totally reasonable response to people that don't like dogs.

Completely rational and normal.

Not to mention completely wrong...... I have two dogs so I do actually like them. And my main issue is uncontrolled dogs coming at mine and the owners either don't or can't call them away, and some also fail to recognise aggressive behaviour from their own dog when approaching, leading to the possibility of a fight. If your dog doesn't do that then what's the issue with what I've said?

I was saying that if a dog is under control and reliably ignores others, then there's no reason to put it on a lead because the objective is still achieved - the dog doesn't bother anyone else or cause any issues - in answer to people saying all dogs should be on a lead everywhere, all the time. Makes no difference if the dog is on or off the lead if it doesn't run up to you, there isn't an issue.

Yet I'm another poster you've decided to have a go at? You're on all these threads about dogs throwing around suggestions of anxiety and MH issues when people don't want to be jumped at, pawed at, have food nicked or have their own dogs accosted, but honestly you're coming across like you could start a fight in an empty room because you're just going at anyone that posts anything.

MintsPi · 20/04/2023 14:26

I will never understand why dog owners who describe themselves as good owners are so desperate to defend bad owners. I have a child. I don't defend everything single thing another parent does and don't take moans at children as being against my child.

I don't know statistics but I would imagine most people who are attacked by dogs are dog owners (attacked by own dog or hurt defending their own dogs). If someone allows their dog off lead without good recall it could easily be both humans and other dogs at risk from them. Why would you not want other dogs on leads and certain breeds muzzled if they are a risk to your own dog?

My mum has a terrier. It stays on a lead during walks but if an off lead xl bully type decide to attack it I can't see a situation where neither my mum or dog escape unhurt. YOUR dog might have great recall but it doesn't mean ALL dogs do.

24KaratCucumber · 20/04/2023 14:03

VincentVaguer · 20/04/2023 13:56

That's fine, you can ignore him, he won't care and neither will I. Neither of us need the approval of miserable fuckers to have a nice day.

Totally reasonable response to people that don't like dogs.

Completely rational and normal.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 20/04/2023 13:57

ZellyFitzgerald · 18/04/2023 22:29

Putting all dogs on leads in public places would be a good start.

I don't agree with muzzling dogs unless they have shown previous signs of aggression towards people or other dogs.

But leads in public places? Absolutely. This dog should have been on one.

This

VincentVaguer · 20/04/2023 13:56

Maverickess · 20/04/2023 11:29

An off lead dog isn't a problem unless it's also not under control - I have no issues with dogs not being on leads unless the are approaching people/dogs/other animals and are not recalled or do not respond to the recall.

It's of no concequence if the dog is on or off lead as long as it's not allowed to accost other people, in a friendly way or not. If a dog leaves you alone then it doesn't matter if it does so because it's trained to do so or physically restrained from doing so, the results are the same - you don't get bothered by a dog you don't want to interact with.

The issue is that a rising number of owners don't like having their dog on a lead, but also have little to no control meaning the dog does accost others in the area, and then try to defend that saying that the dog is friendly and that dogs need off lead time and everyone should fall in line with that.

It's your dog, and therefore your responsibility to entertain it, not mine.

That's fine, you can ignore him, he won't care and neither will I. Neither of us need the approval of miserable fuckers to have a nice day.

VincentVaguer · 20/04/2023 13:54

@Ersorrywhatnow I was quoting @SnapCracklePopBang ,upthread

VincentVaguer · 20/04/2023 13:53

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 11:01

@VincentVaguer hold on, how am I a ‘bad dog own er’ ??? You’re basing that on the fact I don’t think there should be a blanket law muzzling all dogs? Wise up.

Hey! Not me mate, I'm on your side.

Feelinadequate23 · 20/04/2023 13:50

all the “irresponsible people won’t comply anyway” responses are just like the arguments against gun control in the US. No! Take away most dogs and dog attacks will decrease!

also it’s not just violent men with violent breed dogs that do damage. My idiot ditsy sister who doesn’t have a violent bone or bad intention in her body has a completely out of control “loveable” golden retriever, who is not at all aggressive, but is huge and totally out of control due to lack of training. The dog knocked over an elderly lady and hurt her quite badly, and my sister just looked on dumbly saying “she’s just energetic, she didn’t mean it!” with zero idea it was her fault!

Controls such as licenses and mandatory training would weed out the many idiotic owners who just don’t think ownership through or don’t understand what’s needed and cause many lower level, unreported issues and attacks which cause the majority of the problems.

nomoredriving · 20/04/2023 13:46

Crocodilekneecaps · 20/04/2023 12:41

My dog is not being muzzled

Neither is mine

Verv · 20/04/2023 12:56

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 10:59

‘Appalling reckless and stupid post.’ @Verv

Reckless? To say men commit most violet. Crime? Mmm
no more batshit than most of the posts in here - the link to the church/dog fucker might be my ‘favourite’ so far…

Sorry, NO!
I was directing my comment at screenshot of the woman who slept with a dog and responding to that, but didnt want to quote it as it was vile.
I was agreeing with you. Apologies for the miscommunication..

24KaratCucumber · 20/04/2023 12:55

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2023 12:33

And 13 milion dogs in the UK so 0.6% bitting or less if you consider that one dog bit more than once.

Any kids are more likely to end up in hospital being accidentally injured by a sibling or friend!
Y
People really need to adjust their views on the basis of facts rather than emotional response or worse sadly, sensational news on media.

You're going to have to explain that to me I'm afraid.

13 million dogs, a small percentage hurt people, so.... Never mind.. is that what you're saying?

Is it just dogs that applies too?
There's billions of knives and only 282 were used for murder so why bother restricting their sale etc, everyone should be able to wander the streets with a carving knife... You'd think that pretty silly though..

If I said:
Responsible knife owners wouldn't let their knives near kids and people that don't want knives near them.
And someone said,
"But my knife is very safe, why can't a kid play with it?.. it's got a green collar on it after all.."

You'd call me names I'm sure...

Crocodilekneecaps · 20/04/2023 12:41

My dog is not being muzzled

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2023 12:33

And 13 milion dogs in the UK so 0.6% bitting or less if you consider that one dog bit more than once.

Any kids are more likely to end up in hospital being accidentally injured by a sibling or friend!
Y
People really need to adjust their views on the basis of facts rather than emotional response or worse sadly, sensational news on media.

vivainsomnia · 20/04/2023 12:29

A quick google shows 9000 people a year go to hospital with dog related injuries
That sounds high isn't it? Until you also read that there are 43,000 attendances to A&E DAILY! That's over 17 million. Suddenly, it doesn't feel high at all, certainly not high enough to justify the extreme measures suggested here!

24KaratCucumber · 20/04/2023 11:59

and then try to defend that saying that the dog is friendly and that dogs need off lead time and everyone should fall in line with that.

All too often a dog will approach people and other dogs whilst the owner yells it or yells not too worry that it's friendly.

A quick google shows 9000 people a year go to hospital with dog related injuries. In a Europe wide study, UK was 4th for fatalities from dogs.

How many of those happened just after an owner yelled,
"Don't worry, they're friendly"

How many owners of those dogs that caused those injuries blamed themselves? Their dog? Or the victims?
'well they should have stayed home, they should have had a picnic elsewhere or had a picnic on table. They should have made alterations to their lives and their plans to accommodate my friendly dog.'

Maverickess · 20/04/2023 11:29

An off lead dog isn't a problem unless it's also not under control - I have no issues with dogs not being on leads unless the are approaching people/dogs/other animals and are not recalled or do not respond to the recall.

It's of no concequence if the dog is on or off lead as long as it's not allowed to accost other people, in a friendly way or not. If a dog leaves you alone then it doesn't matter if it does so because it's trained to do so or physically restrained from doing so, the results are the same - you don't get bothered by a dog you don't want to interact with.

The issue is that a rising number of owners don't like having their dog on a lead, but also have little to no control meaning the dog does accost others in the area, and then try to defend that saying that the dog is friendly and that dogs need off lead time and everyone should fall in line with that.

It's your dog, and therefore your responsibility to entertain it, not mine.

Anyotherdude · 20/04/2023 11:29

Sorry - meant to add:
If dog owners adhere to the points I made in the PP, and their dog is not prone to lunging and/or biting, then why should they muzzle their dog?

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 11:21

My dog is licensed, insured, chipped and trained. She has faultless recall, is socialised and friendly, doesn’t jump up on anyone but isn’t allowed off the lead where I think it might be inconvenient to anyone else. She’s walked 2/3 times a day, fed well
treated well, but as an animal, not a human child.

So which part of that makes me a ‘bad’ dog owner? My opinion that dogs shouldn’t have to wear muzzles in public or be on the lead all the time doesn’t make me a bad anything. It’s just an opinion.

Anyotherdude · 20/04/2023 11:03

A bad dog owner is:
Someone who doesn’t get their dog regular vet treatment (E.g. minimum worming/flea treatment and check-ups)
Someone who mis-treats their dog
Someone who does not provide adequate nutrition for their dog
Someone who does not offer their dog the opportunity for regular exercise
Someone who does not adhere to the dog-walkers code(picking up after them Etc.)
Someone who allows their dog off-lead in public places, when their dog does not display adequate recall
Someone who allows their dog off-lead in public places, when their dog is likely to attack other dogs or people
Unfortunately, I see people who fit one or more of these descriptions every day, when walking my dog.

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 11:01

@VincentVaguer hold on, how am I a ‘bad dog own er’ ??? You’re basing that on the fact I don’t think there should be a blanket law muzzling all dogs? Wise up.

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 10:59

‘Appalling reckless and stupid post.’ @Verv

Reckless? To say men commit most violet. Crime? Mmm
no more batshit than most of the posts in here - the link to the church/dog fucker might be my ‘favourite’ so far…

VincentVaguer · 20/04/2023 10:47

I feel sorry for the dogs of the bad dog owners on this thread like @VincentVaguerand@Ersorrywhatnow. I wish dogs no ill and abhor animal cruelty

Out of interest, what makes you think I'm a bad dog owner? I mean, I know I'm not, but presumably you mean I'm not spending every waking moment worrying about whether someone with a dog phobia is going to have to walk past my labrador/terriers? So what you really mean is that I don't make your life easier for you, rather than my dogs. My dogs are very well trained and behaved by the way and would never jump up at anyone.

Verv · 20/04/2023 10:35

Ersorrywhatnow · 20/04/2023 09:57

I mean, I could back up an argument that men are a public safety hazards d should be escorted at all times and given curfews at night by linking to stories about violent crime, child abuse and sexual assault etc but What would be the point?

If you want to play with extremes im pretty sure that you could link all sorts of horror that mothers and parents inflict upon their children, and use it to make the indirect claim that all mothers are somehow sexually involved with their kids.
That is abhorrent and utterly unacceptable, and yet do it in a post regarding dog ownership.. fair game.

Appalling reckless and stupid post.

Swipe left for the next trending thread