Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely heartbroken by this comment made by a 5 year old

291 replies

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 19:15

My job involves working with kids. Today, a teary eyed little girl told me this: "I don't see my daddy because mummy said that he doesn't care about me and doesn't want to bother with me"

Why on earth would you tell this to your 5 year old child?! Haven't stopped thinking about it all day. Made me want to cry 😢

OP posts:
jannier · 18/04/2023 21:26

If it continues it is emotional abuse telling a child someone doesn't love them is cruel

To be absolutely heartbroken by this comment made by a 5 year old
Ineedahappyjob · 18/04/2023 21:26

My first thought on reading was that she had overheard a conversation between adults. It's really easy to think children are busy and not listening.

Or maybe the mum has let her own feelings get in the way, or maybe she doesn't understand how damaging such a message can be. All of which she can be helped with. And it's in the little girls great interests to try understand where the mum has come from and help her with parenting. Intentionally hurting her little girl is possible but probably low down the list of possibilities.

And people involved in safeguarding are usually very careful about confidentiality.

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:23

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:17

I am not worried about the post being outing or it putting my job at risk. The child is not identifiable and I have changed a few details. The main point I was trying to get across was that I don't think this should be said to a child under any circumstances.

But you don’t know it was said to the child.

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:22

fridaytwattery · 18/04/2023 21:10

That is your adult interpretation of what has been said, not a five year old's.

How old was your child when another child told them that dad doesn't care about you (I'm guessing older than 10 years old)?

Parents (whether mum or dad, because some mums do walk out too), need to be thinking how to support their child, how to explain it in an age appropriate way, so the child won't feel it's their fault.
[This might mean parents not answering the question straight away in order to think about the best way to respond. So empathising with the emotion, distraction to buy time, then answer.]

You would be guessing wrong. They was 7 the other child was 8. This happened in the school after the lesson was about families.

It wasn’t my interpretation. It was said to one of mine. My dad is away a lot and when he can he calls and writes. Does you dad do this? No? He mustn’t love you.

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:21

ChienChatCheval · 18/04/2023 21:13

You do NOT know the mum has TOLD her child this. The child may have overheard her mum saying it or heard mum had said it from someone else.

You are happy to judge mum as being bad yet you don’t know exactly what happened. Yet you say you can’t judge dad as you don’t know the circumstances.

This.

You’ve jumped to conclusions and you should know better if you deal with this in your job.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/04/2023 21:21

@ItsThePlayBusDingDing

That's a very good, thoughtful post.

auberJohn · 18/04/2023 21:19

As a father, I have been on the other side. The mother of my children would bad mouth me to my eldest who was at the time 7. He would come to me crying saying "why do you hate mummy, she told me that you don't like her" or "in our religion, mummy told me that I have to love her more than you". I would try to rationally explain that neither was the case.

After a year of this manipulation, I noticed my child consciously chose to believe his mother but unconsciously show me love through his actions like instinctively playing with my hair, holding my hand etc. It killed me to know that he was conflicted. I can see that this has damaged him, as he is growing up to be negative and paranoid, despite my best efforts to always be positive around him. I have tried to lead by example, never saying anything negative about his mother and even speaking positively about the time he lives with her. Thankfully he has found some independence and our relationship is strong again, but it was a horrible time for us both.

Children are impressionable, sensitive to their environment and never want to hurt the parent that is caring and providing for them.

What the mother said to the child in the OP was emotional abuse.

ItsThePlayBusDingDing · 18/04/2023 21:19

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 20:55

I'm pretty sure your young children would not have wanted you to tell them that their dad didn't give a shit about them. It's easy for them to say that now because they are emotionally mature enough to process that information, but I guarantee if you would have said that when they were five it would have been very upsetting for them.

It would have been/was upsetting for them.

However it was more upsetting having a Mum who was saying one thing when they could clearly see another. Even if I was doing it for the 'right' reasons.

My 12yo is far more easy going about the situation than my 21yo because she knew that her dad didn't give a shit from a fairly young age, unlike my oldest and the middle 2 who I fucked up the most with by stringing things out, my oldest was the one who told dd that I was just being nice and her dad didn't give a shit,and she could see that so accepted it quickly.

So you can't guarantee me anything.

I get you're upset as you've been dealing with an upset 5yo, but you're clearly no expert in this at all.

Most of us are just trying to do our best, and sometimes we are faced with 2 impossible choices, and just get slated for choosing the least worse choice at the time.

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:17

I am not worried about the post being outing or it putting my job at risk. The child is not identifiable and I have changed a few details. The main point I was trying to get across was that I don't think this should be said to a child under any circumstances.

OP posts:
jannier · 18/04/2023 21:16

Mum2jenny · 18/04/2023 20:21

I think that it happens and that’s the way it is. What is the point of the mum giving false hope to her little girl?

I think you should read up on the long term damage of Adverse Childhood experiences

DarkDarkNight · 18/04/2023 21:16

herlightmaterials · 18/04/2023 19:41

Mum is obviously heartbroken. A gentle word might help her see the damage her words are causing. Perhaps you could suggest another way of putting it. "You're sad you don't see daddy anymore and I am too. There's nothing I can do to change this but I love you and will always be here for you."

Not necessarily. Maybe mum is spiteful and is taking the end of a relationship out on the dad by cutting contact. Even if it is true that the dad just can’t be arsed that is not the way to tell a 5 year old.

Thedoctorswife1 · 18/04/2023 21:14

BabyofMine · 18/04/2023 19:42

Why though? If it’s true? Why should a Mother cover up for an indifferent neglectful father? It’s hurtful but life hurts. What lie would they tell instead of the truth?

Because this is incredibly damaging and tantamount to emotional abuse.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/04/2023 21:13

I believe that the child was actually told this by mum as there have been issues similar to this previously.

Nice drip feed OP

anyolddinosaur · 18/04/2023 21:13

"Mummy said" doesnt mean it was said direct to the child. it could have been overheard. I wouldnt judge a single parent who had got tired of trying to think up new lies, especially when that parent may be exhausted from a new baby,

A child said something similar to me, but they were 10 at the time. She was quite mature for her age so I said that some men are just not very good with young children. He might be better when she was older but some men never grow up enough to be good parents. She seemed content with that.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:13

*Teder · Today 21:07
MissTrip82 · Today 21:04

Your code of conduct permits you to post details of a conversation you’ve raised as a safeguarding issue on the internet? Really?

I’d really consider whether this post fits with your professional ethics.
Particularly the level of judgment the OP has demonstrated towards the mother. She’s taken the child’s word and made assumptions based on this about the mother but has been kind enough not to make assumptions about the father.
If any mother did this, it is categorically wrong but the father is absent and that is abusive and harmful too. Poor child.*

Poor children than there are people on here excusing the mother and presumably doing shit like this themselves. But hey, easier to pile on the OP and criticize her. OP, I hope you are ignoring this nonsense.

ChienChatCheval · 18/04/2023 21:13

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 20:00

@SittingNextToIt I can't judge the father because I don't know anything about him... he could be an absolute waste of space or he could be actually trying to see his child and mum is making it difficult. Who knows. What I do know is that this mother has told her 5 year old something that has completely broken her heart and will possibly impact her for the rest of her life.

You do NOT know the mum has TOLD her child this. The child may have overheard her mum saying it or heard mum had said it from someone else.

You are happy to judge mum as being bad yet you don’t know exactly what happened. Yet you say you can’t judge dad as you don’t know the circumstances.

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:13

WavingAtTheClouds · 18/04/2023 21:08

It sounds like it's an unusual thing to come across in your job, you've given details about mums personal life, I'd be careful about that in case it puts your job at risk,

It's probably total coincidence but my five year old niece overheard her Mum talking to me on the phone after a very hard emotional day with her kids. She's never once told her children their father doesn't care, she's lied for him ever since they've split, she needed some emotional support late last night and was telling me she wishes she could make their Dad care and was upset that he doesn't seem to love his children, because it's heartbreaking for her seeing how hurt their children are and my 5 year old niece has overheard that. She's also in a new relationship.

My sister feels like shit and is beating herself up for it, my niece came home from school and told my sister she had cuddles off her teacher and also her lunchtime supervised because she was sad that daddy don't care, she said her lunchtime superviser said daddy does love her.

I really hope her teacher/lunchtime supervisor isn't making assumptions and starting threads about her, she feels like like utter shit as it is. My niece would be telling the truth when she said "mummy said" but it's not accurate that she told her in the way you're presenting it, she overheard after waking up sneaking downstairs for Easter Eggs she'd been told no for earlier.

My sil is also in a new relationship but doesn't mean she's not upset seeing her children's feelings trampled all over time and time again by their father. I worked with children for a long time and would be I trouble posting about individual children and their families like this.

I’m now waiting for the message - the op has asked for this to be deleted because they’ve realised how outing it is to them.

Srin · 18/04/2023 21:12

Who knows which is worse? Being told the truth age 5, or the gradual realisation throughout her childhood that her dad doesn’t care about her. Ultimately it is the dad’s lack of love that will damage her, not the mum’s honesty.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/04/2023 21:11

IAgreeWithHim · 18/04/2023 20:37

I recall years ago going to a holiday park holiday for 4 -5 days and my older DS was playing with a little boy who lived on the campsite basically as a perm resident. I asked the biy his name and he replied; 'My name is Brendan but you have to call me Reece because my daddy can't know where we live'.

There could be a very valid reason for this, you do realise that?

fridaytwattery · 18/04/2023 21:10

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:02

The message is still the same. Dad doesn’t care enough to make time for you.

Would it have been easier for another child to say it? Doesnt your dad care enough about you? Mine does and he’s away a lot… or something of those lines.

How would you deal with your child coming home upset at that response?

One of mine was told this after I told mine dad was away, wasn’t sure where. Which was true didn’t know where he was. He just decided to drive away one day and wasn’t heard of for about 10 years.

That is your adult interpretation of what has been said, not a five year old's.

How old was your child when another child told them that dad doesn't care about you (I'm guessing older than 10 years old)?

Parents (whether mum or dad, because some mums do walk out too), need to be thinking how to support their child, how to explain it in an age appropriate way, so the child won't feel it's their fault.
[This might mean parents not answering the question straight away in order to think about the best way to respond. So empathising with the emotion, distraction to buy time, then answer.]

EarringsandLipstick · 18/04/2023 21:10

But the mother is happily in a new relationship with a baby on the way, so definitely not 'upset'

🙄

Your posts are laced in judgment of the mother, OP.

I do not agree that those exact words are reasonable or fair to say to a 5 yo, of course not.

However, one statement cannot be taken as a true indication of how this mother parents, or as PPs have said, whether the mum said this or in fact the child had picked it up indirectly or overheard, for example.

I do not agree with lying to children - my own DC have sadly had to deal with a highly emotionally abusive father. No, I wouldn't say this exactly, but I've been honest about his lack of capacity as a parent, that this doesn't reflect on them & they need to trust their own judgment & believe in themselves 💯 (I also did everything I could to support any element of their relationship, regardless of my feelings towards their father.).

The idea that a parent shoud directly lie as suggested by a PP ('That she's the apple of her dads eye, but he can't see her at the moment because he's working away.') I think is really wrong. I can honestly say I've never lied to them in these matters, but of course that doesn't mean telling them everything at an age when they are too young either.

PicturesOfDogs · 18/04/2023 21:09

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:05

Why am I getting comments asking if I have reported the father? Report him for what? I know absolutely nothing about him or the situation. I can only report on what I have seen and heard.

Did you mention it to the mother?

Id give her the benefit of the doubt, that the child has overheard her talking to someone else, and she can talk with her.

If she said it to be spiteful to her daughter, well, you’ve already reported it, but it could have been a genuine mistake, speaking to her and letting her know would give her the opportunity to discuss with her daughter, as she might not know her daughter knows

Unsure33 · 18/04/2023 21:08

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 19:55

I'm absolutely shocked that some of you on here would find no issue with telling your child this!

I totally agree . I know two families where this was said and it causes long term damage . And in one case it was not true and the child found out when they were older . Most of the time problems are between the parents and then the children get dragged in . Those words are awful . If the father is that bad let the child learn as they grow up .

WavingAtTheClouds · 18/04/2023 21:08

It sounds like it's an unusual thing to come across in your job, you've given details about mums personal life, I'd be careful about that in case it puts your job at risk,

It's probably total coincidence but my five year old niece overheard her Mum talking to me on the phone after a very hard emotional day with her kids. She's never once told her children their father doesn't care, she's lied for him ever since they've split, she needed some emotional support late last night and was telling me she wishes she could make their Dad care and was upset that he doesn't seem to love his children, because it's heartbreaking for her seeing how hurt their children are and my 5 year old niece has overheard that. She's also in a new relationship.

My sister feels like shit and is beating herself up for it, my niece came home from school and told my sister she had cuddles off her teacher and also her lunchtime supervised because she was sad that daddy don't care, she said her lunchtime superviser said daddy does love her.

I really hope her teacher/lunchtime supervisor isn't making assumptions and starting threads about her, she feels like like utter shit as it is. My niece would be telling the truth when she said "mummy said" but it's not accurate that she told her in the way you're presenting it, she overheard after waking up sneaking downstairs for Easter Eggs she'd been told no for earlier.

My sil is also in a new relationship but doesn't mean she's not upset seeing her children's feelings trampled all over time and time again by their father. I worked with children for a long time and would be I trouble posting about individual children and their families like this.

Teder · 18/04/2023 21:07

MissTrip82 · 18/04/2023 21:04

Your code of conduct permits you to post details of a conversation you’ve raised as a safeguarding issue on the internet? Really?

I’d really consider whether this post fits with your professional ethics.

Particularly the level of judgment the OP has demonstrated towards the mother. She’s taken the child’s word and made assumptions based on this about the mother but has been kind enough not to make assumptions about the father.
If any mother did this, it is categorically wrong but the father is absent and that is abusive and harmful too. Poor child.