Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely heartbroken by this comment made by a 5 year old

291 replies

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 19:15

My job involves working with kids. Today, a teary eyed little girl told me this: "I don't see my daddy because mummy said that he doesn't care about me and doesn't want to bother with me"

Why on earth would you tell this to your 5 year old child?! Haven't stopped thinking about it all day. Made me want to cry 😢

OP posts:
icanneverthinkofnc · 18/04/2023 21:47

saraclara · 18/04/2023 21:37

Well I told my dd6 that her dad just wasn't very good at being a dad and that's why he doesn't see her, no lie is needed. There is no need to be cruel and hurt/upset the child because of bitterness!!!

I think that's perfect.

I'm absolutely appalled by some of the other posts on this thread. That any parent would think it okay to cause their small child psychological harm to somehow avenge their ex, is almost impossible to believe. Yet here they are, on this very thread.

Same..I'm appalled too, but I'm not surprised. It does rather blow out the water, the idea that all mothers are saints and want the best for their children. They are perfectly happy to use the children as weapons if it suits their agenda.
Yes, there will be men that shouldn't ever be fathers, but there are ways and means to minimise the stress and unhappiness in children. Quite frankly, some mothers shouldn't be parents either.
Parental alienation is a problem that gets ignored and causes so much harm.

UpsyDaisy352 · 18/04/2023 21:46

In my place of work (nursery), this comment would be addressed with the mother in a private meeting, and links to family support (counselors, etc) would be offered. Safe-guarding protocol might also be looked at.

This is horrific for a child to hear

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:46

For those people who keep commenting that the OP is judging mum and doesn't understand safeguarding -

The point of safeguarding is not that the OP is blaming mum, comparing mum to dad or trying to spite mum.

The point is that the child has been harmed, regardless of intention, and the OP is worried that if no one intervenes the child will suffer more harm.

Whether it was overhead, an accident or intentional isn't really relevant to the OP - the child has been affected and that's the OPs responsibility to flag up.

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 18/04/2023 21:45

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:41

I'd have just felt that was honest.

That is an adult evaluation of what a child would feel. But young children feel that everything that happens is their fault. So you have to be careful to be clear it is not. This mother was not. There are lots of examples on here of parents who were careful of their children's feelings while telling the truth - there is no need to lie, but you tell the truth in a careful way. That is why good parents are supposed to be able to put their children's needs ahead of their own. This mother seems to see no need for that - it may be a one off frustration (still damaging but no one is perfect) - except that there is form. As for being judgemental - there is nothing wrong with being judgemental about poor behaviour. Which this is, there is no excuse for this.

I actually remember feeling it as a child. My mother was always so kind and diplomatic about him, and I just couldn't understand why she was bothering - my siblings and I knew full well, even at 6, 8, 10, that he was not a good man, and that she'd been doing all the heavy lifting our entire young lives. Actually, i remember thinking I wish she'd just call it what it was, not sugarcoat him. He didn't deserve that.

jannier · 18/04/2023 21:45

Beachbreak2411 · 18/04/2023 20:59

Ah so a scum bag father can abandon his child… but the mother gets reported? How about you offer some help to the mum?

There is a legal duty on practitioner's to report all incidents they do not investigate or act on it that decision is made higher up.....but there are plenty of abused and dead children because a child's words or actions were not treated properly. The investigators are the people who support the parents hopefully by intervention before the pattern is established. ....so yes the op is helping the child and the mum....who I'm sure doesn't want to be dealing with issues like a self harming child.

PlantKi1ler · 18/04/2023 21:43

Poor little girl :( I remember being told things like this by my mum when I was a child and they still pop into my thoughts sometimes. It's a horrible thing to say to a child, whether it's true or not.

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:42

@Roundandnour yes.
This might be outing, but basically mum threatened to kill herself and take us with her if he continued to fight for custody. She also started spreading rumours in the community that he'd been abusive in the relationship. She'd made serious attempts on her life previously and he felt it was credible.

He backed down in the sense of agreeing to all her demands for the arrangements (eg level of contact, dates and times, limitations about holidays etc) in return for being able to see us. Bear in mind this was many years ago when dads were rarely afforded much in court.

I later found out that it was common knowledge that my mum was known to have 'issues' ie assumed to have some kind of mental health problem (again, long before there was much support for that kind of thing) My mum lived in a small town and overshared a remarkable amount of info about our lives, so as an adult returning to my home town it was quite easy to find stuff out. I also have several older half siblings on my mum's side who were more aware of what was going on who provided some context.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:41

I'd have just felt that was honest.

That is an adult evaluation of what a child would feel. But young children feel that everything that happens is their fault. So you have to be careful to be clear it is not. This mother was not. There are lots of examples on here of parents who were careful of their children's feelings while telling the truth - there is no need to lie, but you tell the truth in a careful way. That is why good parents are supposed to be able to put their children's needs ahead of their own. This mother seems to see no need for that - it may be a one off frustration (still damaging but no one is perfect) - except that there is form. As for being judgemental - there is nothing wrong with being judgemental about poor behaviour. Which this is, there is no excuse for this.

jannier · 18/04/2023 21:41

oakleaffy · 18/04/2023 20:48

''But at the end of the day, this wouldn't be an issue if she had an active and engaged father. A good father that wants to see his child will make sure he does''.
@BadNomad

If I could put this quote in capitals a mile high , I would.

So many dads are absolutely hopeless.

Really good fathers who put their child/ren above a new partner are worth the title of 'Dad'.

But that's irrelevant you don't emotionally abuse your child because the dad has been a shit dad

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 18/04/2023 21:40

Why on Earth would you abandon a 5yo? And why should mothers make bullshit excuses for useless exes?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 18/04/2023 21:38

If you're in a safeguarding role, you really need to ask for more training. Putting something like this on the internet is not a good move.

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:38

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:28

@MusicDreamer well yes, you could be right. It might not have been said directly to her, but if it was a case of her overhearing a conversation, then surely her mum should be more careful when discussing the fact that her child's dad "doesn't care" about her when said child is in the house.

I know I am coming across as judgy to some people, but stuff like this is really damaging for young kids. I've witnessed it first hand.

It’s possible that mum believed the child was asleep. If mum works when is she supposed to talk about stuff? It could have been mum and step dad talking about how to explain to her that her dad didn’t give a shit now she’s pregnant, or once the baby is born and his absence is more obvious.

saraclara · 18/04/2023 21:37

Well I told my dd6 that her dad just wasn't very good at being a dad and that's why he doesn't see her, no lie is needed. There is no need to be cruel and hurt/upset the child because of bitterness!!!

I think that's perfect.

I'm absolutely appalled by some of the other posts on this thread. That any parent would think it okay to cause their small child psychological harm to somehow avenge their ex, is almost impossible to believe. Yet here they are, on this very thread.

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:35

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:28

@MusicDreamer well yes, you could be right. It might not have been said directly to her, but if it was a case of her overhearing a conversation, then surely her mum should be more careful when discussing the fact that her child's dad "doesn't care" about her when said child is in the house.

I know I am coming across as judgy to some people, but stuff like this is really damaging for young kids. I've witnessed it first hand.

Of course people should be careful as to what their children hear.

But that’s not what you were judging. You were judging mum for telling her child yet you don’t know that she did.

As the pp said, ‘You are happy to judge mum as being bad yet you don’t know exactly what happened. Yet you say you can’t judge dad as you don’t know the circumstances.’ You need to sort your logic out.

You jumped to conclusions and that isn’t your job. It’s actually very bad to do this if you work in safeguarding. You were wrong.

SnarkyBag · 18/04/2023 21:35

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:03

@Beachbreak2411 a very big part of my job is to protect and safeguard children. A five year old was very upset today because of comments made by her mother, so yes it needed reporting, especially as this is not the first incident involving this child. My job is not to give parenting lessons

If this is true then a very big part of your job should also be not posting about it on the internet. Very unprofessional

PicturesOfDogs · 18/04/2023 21:33

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:28

@MusicDreamer well yes, you could be right. It might not have been said directly to her, but if it was a case of her overhearing a conversation, then surely her mum should be more careful when discussing the fact that her child's dad "doesn't care" about her when said child is in the house.

I know I am coming across as judgy to some people, but stuff like this is really damaging for young kids. I've witnessed it first hand.

So surely you bring it up to mum, so she can be more careful?

I said it earlier, but you’ve already reported her, so if it was said directly to the child, you’ve done your bit anyway. But I think if it was a genuine case of overhearing, you’re also letting the child down by not making mum aware

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 18/04/2023 21:32

Hm. My father was a useless, neglectful, horrible man. My mother was diplomatic about him, but my siblings wouldn't have taken it personally had she merely verbalised what we actually already knew. I'd have just felt that was honest. And she loved us enough for two parents. We were 6, 8 and 10 when they split, and he barely bothered with us.

Obviously the 5yo got upset, but maybe the mother felt the truth was important, and is parent enough to make up for the lacking father.

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:31

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:27

I think you've misunderstood, or not read my post properly.
Id shared this in response to you saying that if the child had an 'active and engaged dad' this wouldn't be a problem.
My point was I had an 'active and engaged' dad, and we did have this problem. One who tried to fight for us, was repeatedly threatened (including my mum threatening to hurt us - which he felt was credible given her behaviour) He didn't walk away but it did mean he couldn't see us as often, and due to the lies we were told, we 'decided' very early on not to see him. He tried, but how exactly do you fight to see a child when the child doesn't want to see you? As a child I hated him. I thought he was to blame for everything that was bad in our lives because that's what we'd been told.

There isn't enough information in this case to know if dad is deadbeat, or being blocked from being involved.

So your dad left you with someone who had threatened to harm you and had reason to believe this?

Stressfordays · 18/04/2023 21:31

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:28

@MusicDreamer well yes, you could be right. It might not have been said directly to her, but if it was a case of her overhearing a conversation, then surely her mum should be more careful when discussing the fact that her child's dad "doesn't care" about her when said child is in the house.

I know I am coming across as judgy to some people, but stuff like this is really damaging for young kids. I've witnessed it first hand.

You seem to really dislike this Mum. Your professionalism is really questionable here.

Badtasteflump · 18/04/2023 21:30

OP I'm not sure what you're hoping to get from this thread. Clearly it's an inappropriate thing to say to a child, and upsetting for you to hear.

But if your work role involves safeguarding children I am shocked you think it's ok to post about it on an internet forum and start a public debate on the issue.

Ted27 · 18/04/2023 21:30

@dreamer998
So you may have changed a few details, but if you have a role in safeguarding or have any ethics at all, why on earth do you think its acceptable to put this on a public forum knowing that a whole heap of judgement would descend on this mother.
What do you hope to achieve by reporting her - social services involvement?

madroid · 18/04/2023 21:29

I think you sound a bit naive OP.

My friend was in this situation with an extremely flaky father who messed about their kids then basically stopped bothering.

I don't know where her 4 year old daughter heard it, but she was convinced it her mum (my friend) that was stopping her seeing her dad.

My friend had to say in the end that no, it was his choice because she didn't want her daughter thinking the only parent she had left in her life was evilly stopping her seeing her dad. She had to put the blame squarely where it lay to preserve the trust with her daughter and to protect their relationship.

It wasn't an easy decision, but after very much agonising this was what she decided to say to her dd, out of the very best intentions.

Some family situations are just hard. There is no easy way to deal with them. You just have to try to minimise the hurt and damage.

I think your pupil and her mother need your compassion and understanding, not reporting. This isn't a safeguarding issue.

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 21:28

@MusicDreamer well yes, you could be right. It might not have been said directly to her, but if it was a case of her overhearing a conversation, then surely her mum should be more careful when discussing the fact that her child's dad "doesn't care" about her when said child is in the house.

I know I am coming across as judgy to some people, but stuff like this is really damaging for young kids. I've witnessed it first hand.

OP posts:
Stressfordays · 18/04/2023 21:28

I tell my kids the truth about their Dad 'he's a nasty man and does bad things, the police have said he can't see you anymore'. Mainly because I was sick of making excuses for the idiot. My eldest is 10 now and will say himself his Dad doesn't care about him and my reply is always 'I don't know about that but I do know that you are my entire world'. Lying doesn't help anyone, chances are the kid heard it from Mum ranting to someone about it. I know my kids have overheard things they shouldn't.

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:27

BadNomad · 18/04/2023 20:55

Yes, and my father made no effort to stop my mother taking me out of the country because, I later learned, she threatened to have him killed by the IRA. She actually did the whole "your father doesn't care about you" thing with me too. But he still found a way to keep in touch until I was old enough to make choices. At no point did he just shrug and say "Welp. That's that then." and walk away. Even in your situation, your father could have found a way to keep in touch even if he didn't want to pursue custody. Or contacted you as a teen/adult. No doubt your mother did a bad thing, but I don't think your father comes out of this blameless.

Either way, I don't think our situations are the norm in absent father cases.

I think you've misunderstood, or not read my post properly.
Id shared this in response to you saying that if the child had an 'active and engaged dad' this wouldn't be a problem.
My point was I had an 'active and engaged' dad, and we did have this problem. One who tried to fight for us, was repeatedly threatened (including my mum threatening to hurt us - which he felt was credible given her behaviour) He didn't walk away but it did mean he couldn't see us as often, and due to the lies we were told, we 'decided' very early on not to see him. He tried, but how exactly do you fight to see a child when the child doesn't want to see you? As a child I hated him. I thought he was to blame for everything that was bad in our lives because that's what we'd been told.

There isn't enough information in this case to know if dad is deadbeat, or being blocked from being involved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread