Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely heartbroken by this comment made by a 5 year old

291 replies

dreamer998 · 18/04/2023 19:15

My job involves working with kids. Today, a teary eyed little girl told me this: "I don't see my daddy because mummy said that he doesn't care about me and doesn't want to bother with me"

Why on earth would you tell this to your 5 year old child?! Haven't stopped thinking about it all day. Made me want to cry 😢

OP posts:
Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 22:24

Bambooflowers · 18/04/2023 22:18

op, there is no test to make sure you’re an intelligent decent person capable of parenting before you are able to conceive. Which means small children are sometimes treated like this, and those parents can’t grasp why it’s wrong. This thread shows it. Speaking to the mother is pointless. She lacks the ability to understand why this is very wrong.

Just like some lack the ability to understand they haven’t got all the info needed. Like if it was said directly or if the child overheard a conversation.

If your child heard a conversation like this wouldn’t you want to know?

Don’t schools let parents know anymore if their child was upset in school? Even more so if it was all day?

Ineedahappyjob · 18/04/2023 22:23

Actually, @Bambooflowers, many parents can be helped to understand how their actions and words impact their children.

Bambooflowers · 18/04/2023 22:18

op, there is no test to make sure you’re an intelligent decent person capable of parenting before you are able to conceive. Which means small children are sometimes treated like this, and those parents can’t grasp why it’s wrong. This thread shows it. Speaking to the mother is pointless. She lacks the ability to understand why this is very wrong.

Echobelly · 18/04/2023 22:18

Honestly if I were to speak to the mum I might report what you said and say 'I understand you might have said that when you were feeling low and frustrated, but I wanted to let you know it's had an impact on her'. I'm not judging the mum - we can't know if she said it because she's an insensitive cow, or because she's been pushed to the limit by a shitty ex partner and blurted out the wrong thing in a moment of utter frustration. Or indeed if the little girl somehow misunderstood something?

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 22:14

saraclara · 18/04/2023 22:05

I would too. There is absolutely no justification for deliberately causing one's child psychological harm.

Go onto the stately homes thread to discover just how damaged adults can be by the actions of their parent when they were small.

But OP doesn’t know the mum TOLD her. She’s jumped to conclusions. 🤯

HolyMolyGuacamole222 · 18/04/2023 22:12

The best explanation is to tell a child that the absent parent is sick/mean/not very responsible. This sends the message that the problem is with the absent parent and not the child.

This little girl has been made to feel that she isn't good enough for the dad to be interested in her from the sounds of things, so mum has got the explanation wrong even if she did want to tell the child the truth.

Op if a child said this to me my response would be something like "well I don't understand that at all because you are so lovely and so much fun." And speak to the mother later on.

Really sad.

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 22:11

@BadNomad I don't disagree, I think he could have done more. I think it would have been different if it happened today, I think back then he was a bit clueless. But we were for example told things like 'well I told him you were ill last weekend he could have come round to try and see you but he didn't bother' when in fact mums boyfriend had threatened to batter him if he turned up at the door and he didn't want to have it out with him on the doorstep. So from our perspective we thought he chose not to see us as much as we 'chose' not to see him.
So there we didn't see him for long periods and he was trying and failing to be an active parent.

I'm not assuming this is the case here, just that the OP doesn't have the info to go on to know the context (and aware that it may not be ops role to ask those questions)

Ineedahappyjob · 18/04/2023 22:09

Different thing telling the child directly or a child over hearing something mum said to another person don’t you think?
Very very different.

Kvetching · 18/04/2023 22:08

They fuck you up, your mum and dad…

Some parents don’t deserve to be parents. No 5 year old needs to hear an adult narrative from a bitter parent. Decent people would put the child first and protect them from this sort of spite.

saraclara · 18/04/2023 22:05

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:53

fully wearing her judge pants

I would too. There is absolutely no justification for deliberately causing one's child psychological harm.

Go onto the stately homes thread to discover just how damaged adults can be by the actions of their parent when they were small.

WingingItSince1973 · 18/04/2023 22:04

user1473878824 · 18/04/2023 19:46

There are some truly awful parents on this thread, clearly.

It shocking isn't it 😢

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 22:01

JupiterFortified · 18/04/2023 21:58

I can’t believe some people are defending the mother here. Insane.

Cannot believe some are judging without knowing the context of the conversation. Different thing telling the child directly or a child over hearing something mum said to another person don’t you think?

JupiterFortified · 18/04/2023 21:58

I can’t believe some people are defending the mother here. Insane.

Roundandnour · 18/04/2023 21:58

afaloren · 18/04/2023 21:50

I don’t know. In my case that was true and the adults in my life lied to me to make me feel better but all it did was kick the can down the road until I figured it out for myself.

. I wonder how some would have responded with child logic - well if he cared why isn’t he here and list names of people who cared enough.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:58

that he was not a good man, and that she'd been doing all the heavy lifting our entire young lives

Great, and you knew it was about HIM and not about YOU. Which this poor child will not given the language that was used to her.

Lifeomars · 18/04/2023 21:56

oakleaffy · 18/04/2023 20:42

@Lifeomars ..Edit..Wanted to say that my DC used to be sick sometimes, with the stress of it all.

So sorry to hear that, this is one of the things that makes me so sad for the children of these parents who do not reflect on how much it hurts and disappoints a child when they are often let down. I remember my son pacing the street looking for his dad and crying when he didn't show, I just cannot fathom letting down any child in this way, let alone my own flesh and blood, My ex is on to partner number 4 after leaving me, he did have a vasectomy thank heavens!

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:53

fully wearing her judge pants

OatMilkLattes · 18/04/2023 21:53

This sounds like something my mum would have said to me in an effort to turn me against my dad. It is so sad. I don’t know how a grown adult than think it’s ok.

BadNomad · 18/04/2023 21:53

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:27

I think you've misunderstood, or not read my post properly.
Id shared this in response to you saying that if the child had an 'active and engaged dad' this wouldn't be a problem.
My point was I had an 'active and engaged' dad, and we did have this problem. One who tried to fight for us, was repeatedly threatened (including my mum threatening to hurt us - which he felt was credible given her behaviour) He didn't walk away but it did mean he couldn't see us as often, and due to the lies we were told, we 'decided' very early on not to see him. He tried, but how exactly do you fight to see a child when the child doesn't want to see you? As a child I hated him. I thought he was to blame for everything that was bad in our lives because that's what we'd been told.

There isn't enough information in this case to know if dad is deadbeat, or being blocked from being involved.

I did misunderstand. I assumed you meant absent fathers can be good fathers.

The child in the OP is thinking her father doesn't see her because he doesn't care about her. Whereas your father was seeing you, but you chose (I use that loosely because I know it isn't really a choice when you've been manipulated into it) to stop seeing him. That's not the same thing. My point was active and engaged fathers are not absent fathers.

It's all shit though. It is messed up that your father let you be raised by someone who was clearly dangerous and emotionally damaging. You were let down by them both. I really do think he could have done more.

MusicDreamer · 18/04/2023 21:52

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:46

For those people who keep commenting that the OP is judging mum and doesn't understand safeguarding -

The point of safeguarding is not that the OP is blaming mum, comparing mum to dad or trying to spite mum.

The point is that the child has been harmed, regardless of intention, and the OP is worried that if no one intervenes the child will suffer more harm.

Whether it was overhead, an accident or intentional isn't really relevant to the OP - the child has been affected and that's the OPs responsibility to flag up.

Yes. I have no issue with her flagging it in the correct way. I’m sure no one else does either.

They do have an issue with the judgement. OP doesn’t know the circumstances yet is fully wearing her judges osnts and jumping to conclusions. That’s not a good trait in a safeguarding job. She does seem to understand not judging when you don’t know the full story though, as she’s said she wouldn’t do they about dad.

OP is clueless.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 18/04/2023 21:51

BabyofMine · 18/04/2023 19:42

Why though? If it’s true? Why should a Mother cover up for an indifferent neglectful father? It’s hurtful but life hurts. What lie would they tell instead of the truth?

Because as a staff member you don't know if it's true or not so you just report it as it was said. No judgement. There could be other stuff going on that you may not be aware of and that statement could be pivotal.

afaloren · 18/04/2023 21:50

I don’t know. In my case that was true and the adults in my life lied to me to make me feel better but all it did was kick the can down the road until I figured it out for myself.

EarringsandLipstick · 18/04/2023 21:50

Brieandme · 18/04/2023 21:46

For those people who keep commenting that the OP is judging mum and doesn't understand safeguarding -

The point of safeguarding is not that the OP is blaming mum, comparing mum to dad or trying to spite mum.

The point is that the child has been harmed, regardless of intention, and the OP is worried that if no one intervenes the child will suffer more harm.

Whether it was overhead, an accident or intentional isn't really relevant to the OP - the child has been affected and that's the OPs responsibility to flag up.

But OP's posts completely indicate that she's made a judgment about the mother. A very negative one.

Based on what she's disclosed here, she simply doesn't have enough context to know if this represents a pattern of harmful behaviour.

Even if what was said was indeed said to the child, the wider context could be an engaged supportive mum overall. (OP later drip feeds she had other concerns but she didn't, predictably, start with this)

I am in Ireland and safeguarding doesn't operate this way - a chat with mum would be the starting point.

I really can't get over OP's judgment given her apparent professional experience.

ThisNameIsNotAvailable · 18/04/2023 21:50

Ketzele · 18/04/2023 21:03

People are talking about whether the choice is to lie or tell the truth, but isn't the challenge always about how to be honest while also protecting our children? Ask an adoptive parent (I am one, as well as being a single parent and the daughter of a man who pissed off and never looked back). Our children have real horrors in their backgrounds that we have to help them come to terms with, not once but over a lifetime.

We have to raise our children with no secrets, while keeping the information age appropriate (some things can never be age appropriate). We have to not demonise the birth parents, because adopted children feel so much inherited shame. But also we can't lie and say there were no problems, because then how can the child understand why they had to be taken away? It is hugely challenging and it never stops. It is a million miles beyond 'what lie would you prefer?'.

100% this

AllOfThemWitches · 18/04/2023 21:47

Dottymug · 18/04/2023 20:59

@AllOfThemWitches it is both parent's duty, but if the father is a terrible parent, surely it is even more important after divorce that the mother does everything she can to protect her child's mental health and well-being? She is all the child has.

And what about her? Is she not allowed to be imperfect occasionally without being harshly judged?