Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was my sister out of line? Or am I really too sensitive?

83 replies

blahblahsensitive · 18/04/2023 19:06

Since I’ve been young, my older sister has always put me down. Everytime I’ve expressed an interest, it’s been “since when do you like that?” “Are you only listening to that band because of me?” So I’ve always grown up sheltering myself from her.
A few years ago she told me I have no personality, but I honestly believe that’s because I have never felt confident enough and have always hidden any interests from her, for example growing up listening to music in earphones rather than out loud.

I thought now we’re older (26 and 29) it would have changed slightly but it hasn’t.

I’ve always not minded watching darts on tv, with my family, often it is her being loudly excited about it and showing interest, and I’ll watch in the background. I now have a boyfriend who also loves darts, so I took him to go and watch a premier league darts game about 2 hours away and stayed the night. I enjoyed it too. I put a picture on my Instagram story and sent one to our family group chat, saying my dad’s favourite player with heart eye emojis.

On both instagram and in the group chat, my sister had to make a point of messaging me “since when do you like darts
/when have you ever watched darts 😂😂😂”. The laughing faces seriously pissed me off and I got so upset, it ruined my night and I got really teary. I haven’t lived with her for years either.

I basically told her I was sick of being judged and here’s how the convo went roughly:

Sister: I’m not putting you down I’ve just never seen you watch darts or take an interest”
Me: ”why even ask then, why not just leave me to it without judging. Why the laughing faces”
S: “because it’s funny”
Me: “I don’t even feel like I can be here because I’m being judged again”
S: ”well that’s your problem. I find you don’t show an interest in lots of things at home and suddenly turn up at them. I’m not judging it’s just confusing, that’s why it’s funny”
Me: “okay well I mainly went for DP, but so what if I was suddenly interested?”
S: ”because you’re banging on with heart eyes as if you’re the darts fan, NOT that you’re there for DP. You’ve made your way all the way there, that’s what a darts fan would do. And I’ve never seen you watch it or take an interest 😂😂”

Pretty much sums it up. Like it honestly brings me down so much. I can’t do a single thing without being judged or interrogated, and she always has to be the “biggest fan” because she’s loud and brash and makes a bigger deal of them.

AIBU??

OP posts:
BeachHat · 19/04/2023 08:01

I don’t think you are being over sensitive.
Your sister sounds abit…jealous or competitive/controlling & is looking for a reaction, in the nicest way possible, you are giving her one.
As other posters have said, for people like her, it’s best to disengage.
Don’t ask her ‘why did you say that’ etc she will always turn it around on you/say things like ‘you’re being over sensitive’ & you end up more frustrated.
The best thing to do is give short witty or matter of fact responses. Things like ‘I’m full of surprises!😉or ‘darts is great, really enjoyed it!’ There’s not much she can really say after that.

If she’s been doing this for years, she’s not going to change, but you can change how you react & hopefully in turn, how it makes you feel. Once she sees you are not responding how she wants, she will most likely stop bothering ( it will probably frustrate her at first)

One of my older sisters used to be like this - very similar, although not as bad as your sister sounds. I used the about tactics & eventually she got the message & stopped saying crap. We get on much better now she knows I don’t take any of her nonsense!

Excellentbex · 18/04/2023 22:24

Ugh I know this dynamic deep in my soul…

my sister and I have a decade on you two, and I’ve made progress! I don’t interact with her on social media. At all. No family group text - if I want to share something with my parents I do. I only see her at their home and I act completely non-plussed by her competitive digs. And, since I haven’t opened myself up to her in years the digs are getting very weak and stale.

S: since when have you cared about x?
me: oh jeez, a few years at least
s: random passive aggressive statement
me: ok (smile)
s: you always / you never x
me: ok (smile)
s: I’ve never seen you y
me: huh, yeah I guess you haven’t

then I ask superficial questions about the weather or her dog until she gets bored and wanders off

ProtestantsHateAbba · 18/04/2023 21:59

She sounds insecure and she takes it out on you because she’s learnt you’re an easy target because of how you react- she can make you feel small and stupid with a bit of needling. The trick is to not show she’s getting to you. The more she goes on and the less you react the more of a bitch she looks and in my family at least, she’d soon be told to shut up and stop being a boring twat.

Gatekeeping the of watching darts ffs. She needs to get a life.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:48

Ps, also second the use of humour - taking the piss like asking if you like something, commenting on the amount of time it took her to make a nasty comment, or even just saying something like, 'hm, interesting', or 'I will make a note of that'. If part of what she is doing is trying to get a rise out of you, the best thing you can do is not give it to her, either ignore her when she is negative, or laugh at her.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:45

I get it and there's no comeback that doesn't sound pathetic!

What about commenting on her thinking rather than the content, which can sound defensive which I think you may be seeing as pathetic. So 'what an interesting comment, what motivated you to say that?' or 'what are you hoping to achieve with a statement like that?'.

Fuerza · 18/04/2023 21:42

Jeez, she owns darts 😑
I'd have been annoyed too. It's like she's accusing you of being fake.

Her telling you that you have no personality says more about her than it does about you.

It's a horrible thing to say and it's no wonder you're wary expressing yourself around he'd.

If you don't block her id rake the piss out of her in the future. "Oh sorry, I forgot you own Darts'. Or 'I don't know sis, am I hungry?". "Am I allowed to like this band?". "So what's your dismissive reaction to my reading this best seller, let's get it over with!".

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 21:26

Faradalla · 18/04/2023 19:57

Gah!!! One of my relatives always used to say 'who are you copying?' any time I took an interest in something or acted a certain way. It used to drive me up the wall. One of my children has a really bubbly, eccentric personality and this same relative always says that my child has copied her personality from the tv/is copying children in her class. I get it and there's no comeback that doesn't sound pathetic!

I find F off works quite well

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/04/2023 21:24

'When you post laughing emojis or comment since when...., you are clearly mocking me and it is not ok.' If she does it again, dont engage. Praise positive comments, if there are any, and ignore negative ones.

Mingeater · 18/04/2023 21:21

She sounds like aright old cow. Sisters are either the best or the worst and sometimes both. Block her- that will learn her and then you can post what you want.

pictoosh · 18/04/2023 21:03

She's horrible. Stop justifying yourself and tell her to fuck off.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/04/2023 21:03

I'd say that just because she likes to scream and broadcast her interests doesn't mean the rest of us do.

You've watched darts alongside her for X years you just manage to do it quietly because you're not a performative drama Queen.

I'd then tell her you have lots of interests you just don't share them with her bc she's always a nasty bitch about anything you like.

--- it will make the situation worse but tbf she needs to hear it and needs to know you're not actually a boring doormat but that you just don't care about her opinion.

But then I find the only way me and my sister ever sorted things out was with a massive bust up followed by going for a pint. Make it worse to get better kind of thing.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 18/04/2023 20:54

She sounds so petty and bitter and insecure in herself and jealous of you. Don't bother so much with her and tell her nothing. Don't let her see you upset or that she gets to you at all. I have a brother who does this to me but he is really ill now so cannot say anything. He tells me I am past it, my hair is too dark (even though I have naturally black hair, just do the grey roots). I read up on this and it can stem from childhood on their behalf if they felt you got more attention than they did. Either confront or ignore. Do not let her upset you as she sounds awful, vile even. Be happy and cheery around her as that will piss her off more.

DeadbeatYoda · 18/04/2023 20:40

Octonaut4Life · 18/04/2023 20:17

I'm going to go against the grain here. Honestly from the darts thing I don't think she's done anything wrong. You say yourself in your own post you "don't mind" darts and you basically went for your DP - so it's hardly unreasonable that she was a bit surprised and asked about it. And you got so upset that it ruined your night? Seems like a complete overreaction. Just say "yes, I like darts" and leave it there? Really you're the one turning a throwaway comment from her into a massive drama?

Do you have a younger sister by any chance @Octonaut4Life?

Elvis1956 · 18/04/2023 20:31

She sounds so very similar to my wife's sister. One example of her behaviour...my wife is a cleaner and she cleans a sports club. For the last year sister had been talking about taking up that sport. My wife has no interest in the sport, but sister wants to out do her! Wife is 50s sister late 60s.
it's always been like that. Sister is actually the golden child, yet feels threaten by my wife!

BellePeppa · 18/04/2023 20:28

blahblahsensitive · 18/04/2023 19:17

Actually did tell her that in the end, I just feel like there must be a reason and I must be in the wrong ☹️

My (older) sister used to be a bit like this, putting me down and criticising my style/taste in everything but I never got upset about it and just ignored her. I always, even as a child, had the mindset that it was her issue not mine. Thankfully she is no longer like it but it took a good thirty odd years for her to stop. Just ignore her, you don’t need to defend yourself. If she says something just say ‘whatever’ and walk away.

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 20:28

Octonaut4Life · 18/04/2023 20:17

I'm going to go against the grain here. Honestly from the darts thing I don't think she's done anything wrong. You say yourself in your own post you "don't mind" darts and you basically went for your DP - so it's hardly unreasonable that she was a bit surprised and asked about it. And you got so upset that it ruined your night? Seems like a complete overreaction. Just say "yes, I like darts" and leave it there? Really you're the one turning a throwaway comment from her into a massive drama?

Yeah I agree with this, and the heart emoji was a bit over the top in that case tbh. A bit funny. I would not have said anything if I were her though, it’s good to find new interests op!

PippaF2 · 18/04/2023 20:25

Block her from your social media or limit your posts (you can do that on fb, not sure about instagram).

But also have something in your arsenal to throw back at her on social media - make her think twice about publicly embarrassing you.

E.g since when have you been into darts 😂

You: 'oh sorry, you upset this post is not all about you?'
'Since forever, not that you'd know - do you want to talk about you again?'
'wow - not spoken to you in ages, how are you?'
'Since you used to sing Kylie Minogue with your hairbrush'
'Oh, it's you again.....'

Throw something back at her on social media!

She does sound jealous.

honeylulu · 18/04/2023 20:24

I would just say "bore off Doris" to all her little jabs.

BasiliskStare · 18/04/2023 20:22

Honestly - I think you need to stop worrying about what she thinks - so yes too sensitive - but I do know easier said than felt.

I would have been happy to reply - well I don't much like darts but I went because my boyfriend does. & we had a nice time.

I do realise these things are not as easy as that but just don't rise to things & she is not the boss of you ( is that an actual phrase )

Others have sound advice - just ignore stuff when you feel she is telling you things which aren't how you want to go about things.

MattDamon · 18/04/2023 20:18

This really resonated with me, OP. I completely get it. I've had to 'hide' things about myself - including partners - because of family members like your sister.

The consequence of her behaviour is that you do not have to share your life with her. Block her from posts. Ignore her comments full stop. Be vague if she starts fishing for details. Being related does not entitle her to be awful to you.

You are in control, don't give her that power anymore.

Octonaut4Life · 18/04/2023 20:17

I'm going to go against the grain here. Honestly from the darts thing I don't think she's done anything wrong. You say yourself in your own post you "don't mind" darts and you basically went for your DP - so it's hardly unreasonable that she was a bit surprised and asked about it. And you got so upset that it ruined your night? Seems like a complete overreaction. Just say "yes, I like darts" and leave it there? Really you're the one turning a throwaway comment from her into a massive drama?

Peapodburgundybouquet · 18/04/2023 20:17

Your sister is a nasty little bitch. Truly. I’d go low contact with her. Ignore her jibes, it’s the only way to cope with it.

Dontbelieveaword · 18/04/2023 20:14

She sounds jealous, goady snd if she had to shout snd scream about everything she likes, she's also an attention seeker.
She is bu however, you're giving her ammunition by showing her that you get upset by her judgement and opinions, which will just encourage her more. Please don't go through rest of your life seeking approval from someone who enjoys withholding it.

2Hot2Handle · 18/04/2023 20:13

Your sister sounds incredibly threatened by you, to behave this way. Only unhappy people feel the need to make others feel bad. Perhaps it’s because you keep yourself to yourself and she feels shut out.

Regardless of the reason, if you can look at her comments and behaviour as a reflection of her feelings, this works to your advantage. Rather than getting upset, give her a carefree smile and either don’t engage, or say something along the lines of “why does it matter?” Or “is it that important?” If she says it’s odd, or funny, you could say, “that’s interesting” then refuse to elaborate. She’ll start getting the message that her put downs no longer have the desired effect.

And ultimately, if she keeps pushing or it’s too much, physically remove yourself from the room she’s in, so that she can’t see your reaction.

PuddlesPityParty · 18/04/2023 20:13

Also block her from viewing your stories etc