Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was my sister out of line? Or am I really too sensitive?

83 replies

blahblahsensitive · 18/04/2023 19:06

Since I’ve been young, my older sister has always put me down. Everytime I’ve expressed an interest, it’s been “since when do you like that?” “Are you only listening to that band because of me?” So I’ve always grown up sheltering myself from her.
A few years ago she told me I have no personality, but I honestly believe that’s because I have never felt confident enough and have always hidden any interests from her, for example growing up listening to music in earphones rather than out loud.

I thought now we’re older (26 and 29) it would have changed slightly but it hasn’t.

I’ve always not minded watching darts on tv, with my family, often it is her being loudly excited about it and showing interest, and I’ll watch in the background. I now have a boyfriend who also loves darts, so I took him to go and watch a premier league darts game about 2 hours away and stayed the night. I enjoyed it too. I put a picture on my Instagram story and sent one to our family group chat, saying my dad’s favourite player with heart eye emojis.

On both instagram and in the group chat, my sister had to make a point of messaging me “since when do you like darts
/when have you ever watched darts 😂😂😂”. The laughing faces seriously pissed me off and I got so upset, it ruined my night and I got really teary. I haven’t lived with her for years either.

I basically told her I was sick of being judged and here’s how the convo went roughly:

Sister: I’m not putting you down I’ve just never seen you watch darts or take an interest”
Me: ”why even ask then, why not just leave me to it without judging. Why the laughing faces”
S: “because it’s funny”
Me: “I don’t even feel like I can be here because I’m being judged again”
S: ”well that’s your problem. I find you don’t show an interest in lots of things at home and suddenly turn up at them. I’m not judging it’s just confusing, that’s why it’s funny”
Me: “okay well I mainly went for DP, but so what if I was suddenly interested?”
S: ”because you’re banging on with heart eyes as if you’re the darts fan, NOT that you’re there for DP. You’ve made your way all the way there, that’s what a darts fan would do. And I’ve never seen you watch it or take an interest 😂😂”

Pretty much sums it up. Like it honestly brings me down so much. I can’t do a single thing without being judged or interrogated, and she always has to be the “biggest fan” because she’s loud and brash and makes a bigger deal of them.

AIBU??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TeaAndTattoos · 24/04/2023 18:19

Do we share a sister because my sister has always been a nasty bitch to me ever since we where kids she loved telling me I was adopted etc now I barely speak to her unless I really have to I don’t even tell her about tattoos that I’m getting because she will say she wants the same thing so I wait until they are done before I say anything. I hide everything from her because anything I say she has same problem and hers is always way worse than anyone else. It’s very exhausting having a simple conversation with her because she makes everything about her. Sorry I have no advice but I know how you feel.

1930toEdinburgh · 24/04/2023 18:10

blahblahsensitive · 24/04/2023 16:28

Thank you all! I do wish I’d taken the higher ground but I was clearly feeling extra sensitive that day 😂. Just felt so annoyed that it ruined a perfectly reasonable night out with DP.

I’ll try not to let it get me down next time! She’s done it ever since I can remember…

You have sympathy from me. Shes obviously insecure and jealous of you. The bit about laughing emojis made me really cross for you!

This grew up this with this shite.
Sibling now lives in NZ and thinks their bullying of me is funny and tells anecdotes of things they did to their kids as funny stories.

Can remain in New Zealand as I'm concerned.

Rinkydinkydoodle · 24/04/2023 18:10

Is she a bit insecure, OP? Because the need to trim other people down to size and undermine their happiness and enthusiasm does pretty much always seem to be fed by some form of insecurity.

I’ve got a family member who is many years older than me and well old enough to know better but has this fairly childlike competitive side. More than once I’ll have been listening to a song or reading a book they’d never heard about, but felt they ‘should have,’ and they’d ask ‘when did you hear that? who told you about that?’ Clearly, the only way I could know about something they don’t is by having been recently educated on it by someone better informed 🤪

Some years ago for Christmas I bought them the first book in what went onto be a well-regarded series of literary novels. They gave me it back, unread, on my birthday ‘as a little extra’ and when I asked if they’d read it themselves they screwed up their face and said it really wasn’t their sort of thing. A couple of years ago I noticed on a visit they now had the whole sequence on their shelves, in a newer edition; a well-read friend had finished with them and passed them on, what a great find of hers, such fantastic writing, I should give them a go! In the intervening years the author’s career had gone stratospheric, so hardly a find, but it just showed me, with this person in my life, it’s not the recommendation that counts, it’s the person who makes it 🫣

These are just a couple of examples but it’s been pretty wearing and fairly consistent over the last two decades. It’s pointless and tiring being in this sort of competition when you never asked to be, and being repeatedly undermined doesn’t do much for your confidence or patience. I just don’t speak about anything interesting anymore, just the most run-of -the-mill stuff. The less I say, the less ammo, you know?

However, you two are still young, and sisters are sisters, so hopefully there’s a chance to tackle this. Do you get on well apart from this undermining side of her? Would she be likely to listen to you telling her honestly what you feel? If she would, it might be worth trying to find a way to raise it. Do your parents notice it?

Ihavehadenoughalready · 24/04/2023 17:47

Block her on Facebook. Tell her (if she asks why) that you block all people who write negative comments as you don't allow it.

She sounds like a narcissist, and is acting like a 13 yr old, not someone in their twenties.

Beautiful3 · 24/04/2023 17:46

I think your sister is being unkind and belittling you. Its something my sister did too. I've gone no contact.

MiddleParking · 24/04/2023 17:39

I wouldn’t text her back at all. I would literally pretend she hadn’t spoken. Pathetic behaviour.

Whochangedmynamec · 24/04/2023 17:37

I remember one time (not with family I might add) I was doing the box of chocolates thing and the person hit the fifth totally annoying comment and I started laughing. They demanded to know what was so funnny and I just said “Thank you! For being you”

SuffolkUnicorn · 24/04/2023 17:35

I have a sister like this I keep at arms length

Whochangedmynamec · 24/04/2023 17:35

If you expect put downs, they won’t annoy you. Make a list of her most annoying traits and promise yourself a box of chocolates on the way home if she does five of them 😁

Alternatively, amuse yourself with a series of witty sarcastic retorts or one liners- I’ve never seen you take an interest in darts- well thank God you are here to share your thoughts on that with the world. Anyway…..

Or sooo obssessed with me. I’ll take that as a compliment….

Yet again the wit and belly laughs are off the scale 🙄 thanks Sis!

etc. You can make a real art form out of ripping the piss the whole time if you do it with lots of smiles she can’t get too angry without looking bad.

If she does get angry “Oh I’m sorry, is me treating you how you’ve treated me all this time annoying? Now you know how I feel…

etc.

Don’t explain, don’t back down

WhoSaidWhat123 · 24/04/2023 17:28

Family!

I have a brother that is similar. However he likes to tease, name call, very childish stuff, just to get a reaction out of me. I do react, but it’s only to stick up for myself, however this just makes him name-call, tease even further for a bigger reaction. He’s 34, I’m 32, both are married and have kids, this shouldn’t even be happening! Anyway, I rarely talk to him these days because it’s just tiring, and every phone call would end abruptly because he’d say something petty and I just don’t have time for it so I don’t pick the phone up anymore! I’ll occasionally talk to him nicely to ask how his family is but I’ll make an excuse after a while to end the call before it ends badly! I think you need to cut contact with your toxic sibling also, believe me you will feel better for it!

Teapotmonkey · 24/04/2023 17:27

I'd ask her to explain the joke - it's very effective. Be completely dumb and keep poker-facedly not getting it until she's really backed herself into a corner of how nasty she's being. "I'm only joking / having a laugh" is the bully's defence.

LimeCheesecake · 24/04/2023 17:20

Your sister doesn’t know you.

I think if she says something again I might have a reply prepped like “you mean like you didn’t think I liked darts even though I’d sat with you and dad for years watching it? Maybe it’s time for you to accept you’ve not got a clue what I like!”

Butchyrestingface · 24/04/2023 17:07

The example you gave does make me think you're a bit over sensitive, especially since you let it ruin your night.

That said, quickest way to deal with this is block her off your social media or at least change the settings so she can't see any updates.

She may feel that you're prickly and oversensitive but if the result of that is her concluding she needs to mind her manners more around you, that will be no bad thing.

GooglyEyeballs · 24/04/2023 17:01

She sounds really unnecessarily combative and you have to wonder why she goes out of her way to shade you. Usually it comes down to insecurity. I have a sister like that who constantly takes every conversation I have with her to a passive aggressive place where the motive is always to make me uncomfortable. Ultimately the only way I can manage to have a relationship with her is in small doses. It's too emotionally tiring otherwise.

Secondwindplease · 24/04/2023 16:33

Some people are loudly insecure and your sister is one of them. Be grateful that, in contrast, you are quietly confident.

Well done on pulling sister up on things, but maybe think about how much energy you’re going to expend in future if she can’t/won’t reflect.

blahblahsensitive · 24/04/2023 16:28

Thank you all! I do wish I’d taken the higher ground but I was clearly feeling extra sensitive that day 😂. Just felt so annoyed that it ruined a perfectly reasonable night out with DP.

I’ll try not to let it get me down next time! She’s done it ever since I can remember…

OP posts:
Sicario · 19/04/2023 13:16

Toxic sibling relationships are more common than you might think, so it's good to know that you are not alone.

There is nothing you can do about your sister's behaviour. It's not your fault, and it's okay to be upset.

Having strong boundaries and refusing to "take the bait" will help you to step back from her.

You can choose not to respond to her goady texts, or to reply with something totally innocuous like, "okay", or "whatever".

There's probably no point in your trying to explain how she makes you feel, as this will just give her more ammunition to poke at you. She will probably respond with things like, "you're too sensitive", "I was only joking", to minimise her behaviour and negate your feelings. So I really wouldn't bother.

Start trying to care less about what she thinks. Ignore her sniping. Step away from the toxic behaviour. You're not kids any more. You are free to be whoever you want and you're not answerable to her (or anyone else for that matter).

You might want to look up Dr Ramani on YouTube and check out some of her comments about toxic siblings.

Just4ThisThread · 19/04/2023 13:10

Even if you’re not that arsed about darts it’s a great night out.

She’s jealous OP. Don’t rise to it.

Softoprider · 19/04/2023 13:05

@Icepinkeskimo · Yesterday 19:27
She sounds jealous and a bully.
Go low or no contact, and be yourself without the nasty little jibes and digs.
🌸

This

AspiringMermaid · 19/04/2023 13:02

I don't think you're being oversensitive, like others have said please block her from all forms of social media.
I think would write a long message to her, for your sake, get everything off your chest and explain why now you are going low contact and blocking her social media. She can send emojis she can laugh, she can call you x,y and z, she can try cause drama with your family... I think you should expect that and try to ignore it, grey rock method going forward.
You deserve better op!! Sounds like for your whole life been bullied by your sis

ExpatInSlavikLand · 19/04/2023 12:37

Icepinkeskimo · 18/04/2023 19:27

She sounds jealous and a bully.
Go low or no contact, and be yourself without the nasty little jibes and digs.
🌸

This.

Season0fTheWitch · 19/04/2023 11:30

It does sound like you're very sensitive about it because it keeps happening. A one off, I'd think you were silly for crying but repetitive put downs isn't nice. Tell her a few occasions where she's done this, tell her it's not funny and there's no need for it. If it happens again, ask her why she's saying it. Often unkind people realise they're wrong when they're questioned.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/04/2023 09:57

I think possibly a bit of both. It wasnt a nice comment and was designed to wind you up / imply you don't really have your own interests. All with laughing emojis so she can claim it was 'lighthearted'.

But you did rise to it and try and justify yourself to her. Ask yourself why you feel you need to justify such a juvenile thing to her, why you even give a shit about how much of a darts/ music etc fan that she judges you to be? Youre unlikely to be able to change her opinion of you. You can control how you react though.

I'd grey rock in the first instance. The less she knows about your life, the less she can pick it apart. And then try not to rise to it. Don't argue, don't justify - you cant ever win with someone like this. Just make some jokey comment back or put some laughing emojis. Or like other people have said said, make a comment like 'well I'm a dark horse / full of surprises' etc and then if she pushes it say she seems very invested in your hobbies and interests with a few laughing emojis

Honeyroar · 19/04/2023 09:39

You should have just ignored her and said “you’d have loved it dad, we’ll take you sometime” If she’d asked why she wasn’t invited you could have said “I think you’d be a bit too hard work”

LookItsMeAgain · 19/04/2023 08:47

I read on a website some time ago that you can't change other people, you can only change how you react to these other people. I think it is valid whether these other people are family or are friends or even strangers.

Use this as an opportunity to change how you react to her.

Perhaps go grey rock - don't react at all or very minimally to her questions/comments.

I don't think she is a positive influence in your life and hasn't been for quite some time. You've been conditioned almost to react in a certain way to her and her comments towards you. Time to break that habit.

It isn't going to be easy but you sound like a woman who has inner strength that hasn't been tapped yet. Time to release that stronger inner woman in you and take back control.

Swipe left for the next trending thread