Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should nanny tidy up toys before going home

117 replies

treeliver · 18/04/2023 18:38

And in general during the day ? I had a nanny before and she kind of automatically did this...

However she did only look after 1 child. New nanny is looking after my two.

But I felt a bit miffed when I had welcomed her in this morning to quite a tidy house and obviously it got completely trashed and she just left, without lifting a finger.

I get that it gets messy, but the last 30 minutes she was just chatting to me anyway, whilst the older one was watching cartoons and younger one was just hanging out.

I don't know if she would have tried to tidy up, had I not come in and had a chat with her. Does it send mixed signals ?

She hasn't really tidied up much otherwise either to be honest. But I noticed it more today because I left the house especially tidy this morning for her.

Also, random question, but emptying the bin is not part of what the nanny should do right ? Previous one used to do it, if I hadn't got to it on the odd occasion ( maybe 3 times in a year ) she also used to occasionally hoover up after the my son, if he'd made a mess on the floor with play doh. Current nanny just leaves the play doh on the floor ( well she did today ) and didn't tell older child to tidy it away and close the pots. So basically the house was trashed and play doh everywhere.

I feel a bit miffed but perhaps it was caused by me being there for the last 30 minutes ? We were just catching up on the day and I started prepping dinner.

I'm not sure if it's me or her and how to say it to her in a nice way.

OP posts:
user1496146479 · 18/04/2023 19:34

TwilightSkies · 18/04/2023 18:39

So your kids trash the house and the nanny has to tidy it all up?

Well the nanny is supposed to be supervising the kids and not letting them trash the house!!

LisaD1 · 18/04/2023 19:34

Bud expect a nanny to clear up after the children and not leave my house messier than she found it. We only ever had one nanny and she was a god send. She would often do our laundry as well as our dd’s and many a time we walked into a dinner already made. None of that was expected but it was massively appreciated.

LittleMie · 18/04/2023 19:34

Surely both you and her should be teaching the older one to put toys away?

herlightmaterials · 18/04/2023 19:32

Yes I expected my nanny to leave things roughly as she found them unless of course it would have caused major upset to an ongoing game. You can't look after children and ignore the state of the house or you need a helper for that person too.

Kanaloa · 18/04/2023 19:32

whatapfaff · 18/04/2023 19:28

My experience of nannies (I was friends with several when my DC were small) is that they acted like SAHMs, only even more so, in that they had everything tidied up (with the DC assisting), floors mopped/swept, bins dealt with, shopping put away, etc and the DC fed and bathed and in their pyjamas. All the parents had to do was stories, cuddles and bed. I was always more than happy for my DC to go for after-school playdates with children who had nannies because I knew I wouldn't end up with over-excited, tearful children. That would be my expectation of a nanny. A lot of it is, as a pp says, common sense. You see a job that needs doing, and you do it.

This isn’t my experience of nannying (or most nanny job descriptions) at all. Nannies don’t generally do your housework and sort your shopping! They provide childcare and nursery duties. That means dealing with children’s laundry and cooking etc.

Kanaloa · 18/04/2023 19:31

I wouldn’t expect a nanny to be emptying bins really, but I would expect them to be teaching the children to tidy up/keep toys neat. It may be if she is new she isn’t comfortable doing so, but she needs to be in charge of the children and ensuring they aren’t allowed to trash the house.

whatapfaff · 18/04/2023 19:28

My experience of nannies (I was friends with several when my DC were small) is that they acted like SAHMs, only even more so, in that they had everything tidied up (with the DC assisting), floors mopped/swept, bins dealt with, shopping put away, etc and the DC fed and bathed and in their pyjamas. All the parents had to do was stories, cuddles and bed. I was always more than happy for my DC to go for after-school playdates with children who had nannies because I knew I wouldn't end up with over-excited, tearful children. That would be my expectation of a nanny. A lot of it is, as a pp says, common sense. You see a job that needs doing, and you do it.

Blondeshavemorefun · 18/04/2023 19:09

Yes the nanny should make sure all tidy at end of day /maybe one activity still out

Perhaps you being there stopped her thought process esp if was chatting

Bins. No.

Used to drive me mad to get to work and bin totally full /pushed down

As then splits when try and pull out

melj1213 · 18/04/2023 19:08

TBF to her she may have earmarked the last 30 mins as time to tidy up but when you came in and started chatting she didn't think she could just walk away from her employer mid conversation. If it's a one off then I'd let it slide this time but be prepared to ask her directly to tidy up if it happens again.

I think if you had important things to talk about it would have been better to say "Since the kids are occupied, I'll let you finish tidying up the toys but if it isn't done by 5.20pm then it's fine to leave it, I'll finish it later, as I need to have a quick catch up with you before you leave at 5.30pm" but if it was just chit chat then I would have stayed out of the way until her finish time, or asked "Hey can you please tidy up the toys while I'm prepping dinner, it would be a real help for me not to have to do it later in the middle of dinner/bath/bed, thanks"

I have certain "close down" tasks at the end of my shifts to get done, but if my boss came to talk to me before I got to them then none of the tasks individually are important enough for me to say "Sorry boss I have to do XYZ instead of talking to you" and they all just take a few minutes but collectively if I don't get them done then either the person coming in to take over from me comes into disarray with things half finished/not put away as opposed to an organised handover, but if I can't stay late then unfortunately sometimes those jobs just don't get done.

treeliver · 18/04/2023 19:02

HaggisBurger · 18/04/2023 18:57

Surely you’ve outlined this in her contract and at interview ? I always discussed the fact that nanny duties included tidying up the kids toys and anything she’d been doing with them, wiping down the kitchen after they’ve had their tea, stacking dishwasher and keeping their bedrooms tidy, drawers organised, laundry done etc. Only stuff directly related to the kids tho. They allowed time for that when the kids were napping and playing. It’s standard and I think I often mentioned at interview that I like quite a tidy house.

Like you, my house would be tidy at the start of the day and I’d expect it like that at the end.

I wouldn’t expect a nanny to empty bins etc. That’s a nanny housekeeper type thing.

Yes

OP posts:
GatherlyGal · 18/04/2023 19:00

TwilightSkies · 18/04/2023 18:39

So your kids trash the house and the nanny has to tidy it all up?

That made me laugh. Clearing up after children is a fairly standard nanny duty I believe.

HaggisBurger · 18/04/2023 18:57

Surely you’ve outlined this in her contract and at interview ? I always discussed the fact that nanny duties included tidying up the kids toys and anything she’d been doing with them, wiping down the kitchen after they’ve had their tea, stacking dishwasher and keeping their bedrooms tidy, drawers organised, laundry done etc. Only stuff directly related to the kids tho. They allowed time for that when the kids were napping and playing. It’s standard and I think I often mentioned at interview that I like quite a tidy house.

Like you, my house would be tidy at the start of the day and I’d expect it like that at the end.

I wouldn’t expect a nanny to empty bins etc. That’s a nanny housekeeper type thing.

dinkybella77 · 18/04/2023 18:57

You need to talk to her about your expectations and nip it in the bud. Your perspective of the situation is based on what your previous nanny did, but your new nanny's experience might be that she hasn't been expected to tidy in previous roles. It is a case of communication as you get to know one another. Every nanny will have different strengths, perhaps she is great with the children but a bit on the messy side.
I would be more worried if it were the other way around.
I would approach it that you would like the children to learn to be responsible from an early age and you want her to teach them how to tidy. If you don't show them what to do they will always expect adults to tidy up after them! There is a lot of learning in tidying- sorting, classifying , making decisions and developing a sense of responsibility. So you would like her to focus on this as part of your routine

treeliver · 18/04/2023 18:54

YoDood · 18/04/2023 18:50

Also she did empty the bins when needed. Basically just used her common sense.

Yeah i can live with her not doing that tbh. But she's not even doing the basics and we did specify all stuff to do with the kids.

OP posts:
alyceflowers · 18/04/2023 18:51

Normal for nanny to tidy up, but if you spent the last 30 minutes there and chatting then expectations were a bit blurred.

Just say to her, 'hi nanny, at the end of the day you can pop the kids in the playpen/in front of the TV for 30 minutes so you can put toys away and make sure there's nothing left out from lunch or craft activities.'

YoDood · 18/04/2023 18:50

Also she did empty the bins when needed. Basically just used her common sense.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 18:49

I wouldnt expect a nanny to let kids tash the house

I wouldnt.

What did you tell her were your expectations when you hired her. What's in the contract?

YoDood · 18/04/2023 18:48

Our fabulous nanny always tidied everything away.

She used to say that her job really was about keeping her employers happy. It was all part of the service she provided: when we came back from work, the house would be immaculate, the kids would be bathed and fed and in their pyjamas. A bit like Mary Poppins.

She also thought it was important to teach the kids how to tidy, and so they were involved in the process every day as part of their winding down routine.

Nordicrain · 18/04/2023 18:48

Yes, she should tidy up the mess your kids make during the day as part of looking after then. I wouldn't expect her to clear away anything already there or do anything additional though.

Isthisexpected · 18/04/2023 18:47

Is she a nanny or a babysitter?

A professional nanny would have clarified your expectations at least.

DrWhoNowww · 18/04/2023 18:47

I would assume if this is a one off that if you hadn’t gone to chat to her she would have used the last half hour to tidy a bit?

If my boss wanted to talk to me for the last half hour I wouldn’t get any of my last minute tasks done either - some nights I might stay to do them, some nights I’ve got other places to be.

JudgeRudy · 18/04/2023 18:47

I've never been or employed a nanny but I would think there's a middle ground. I'd pick the playdoh up, same with a sandwich and I'd sweep up but not sure I'd get carpet cleaner out. If the children were playing with the toys I'd leave them out till I was 'relieved' by a parent however if they were young children and example it was tea at 5pm then an hour play before getting ready for bed, I'd pack toys away with them as part of their routine.
I think what you need to do is say what you expect and see if it works for you both.

Iheartsummertime · 18/04/2023 18:46

Yes, she (with the dc) should tidy up after each activity. Good habits. Some creches have a tidy up song and when it comes on, everyone tidies.

DHsPoorBack · 18/04/2023 18:46

Yanbu.

A nanny should be doing, essentially, all things related to the children.

Most will do the children's lunch, and certainly tidy up after them. She's not there to play. She's there in professional capacity. And being paid that rate. All the nannies I know do the children's laundry as well. Basically, if it relates to the child (with some common sense exceptions) she should be doing it. That's kind of the point of her.

General household tasks, no. She shouldn't be touching the bins.

Nanny0gg · 18/04/2023 18:46

TwilightSkies · 18/04/2023 18:39

So your kids trash the house and the nanny has to tidy it all up?

Surely it's the nanny's responsibility to engage with the children and play with them? And even if left to their own devices for a time they don't need to trash the place. I would have thought it's part of her job as it's child-related