Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should nanny tidy up toys before going home

117 replies

treeliver · 18/04/2023 18:38

And in general during the day ? I had a nanny before and she kind of automatically did this...

However she did only look after 1 child. New nanny is looking after my two.

But I felt a bit miffed when I had welcomed her in this morning to quite a tidy house and obviously it got completely trashed and she just left, without lifting a finger.

I get that it gets messy, but the last 30 minutes she was just chatting to me anyway, whilst the older one was watching cartoons and younger one was just hanging out.

I don't know if she would have tried to tidy up, had I not come in and had a chat with her. Does it send mixed signals ?

She hasn't really tidied up much otherwise either to be honest. But I noticed it more today because I left the house especially tidy this morning for her.

Also, random question, but emptying the bin is not part of what the nanny should do right ? Previous one used to do it, if I hadn't got to it on the odd occasion ( maybe 3 times in a year ) she also used to occasionally hoover up after the my son, if he'd made a mess on the floor with play doh. Current nanny just leaves the play doh on the floor ( well she did today ) and didn't tell older child to tidy it away and close the pots. So basically the house was trashed and play doh everywhere.

I feel a bit miffed but perhaps it was caused by me being there for the last 30 minutes ? We were just catching up on the day and I started prepping dinner.

I'm not sure if it's me or her and how to say it to her in a nice way.

OP posts:
DorisParchment · 19/04/2023 05:37

She should tidy away toys and do any child related cleaning - if they have been painting, the kitchen table should not be covered with paint. Play doh should be hoovered up or swept up before it treads through the house. Sort this out now or she will get lazier and lazier (voice of bitter experience).

EllandRd · 19/04/2023 05:32

RobinHobb · 18/04/2023 18:41

Yes, the nanny should tidy up the toys in the same way you would after your kids.

Ignore PP: maybe her babies and toddlers and preschoolers pick up after themselves?

For older kids, the nanny can encourage the kids to pick up after themselves - the same way you would

At nursery the children are not allowed out until they have put all their toys away.

EllandRd · 19/04/2023 05:30

treeliver · 18/04/2023 18:38

And in general during the day ? I had a nanny before and she kind of automatically did this...

However she did only look after 1 child. New nanny is looking after my two.

But I felt a bit miffed when I had welcomed her in this morning to quite a tidy house and obviously it got completely trashed and she just left, without lifting a finger.

I get that it gets messy, but the last 30 minutes she was just chatting to me anyway, whilst the older one was watching cartoons and younger one was just hanging out.

I don't know if she would have tried to tidy up, had I not come in and had a chat with her. Does it send mixed signals ?

She hasn't really tidied up much otherwise either to be honest. But I noticed it more today because I left the house especially tidy this morning for her.

Also, random question, but emptying the bin is not part of what the nanny should do right ? Previous one used to do it, if I hadn't got to it on the odd occasion ( maybe 3 times in a year ) she also used to occasionally hoover up after the my son, if he'd made a mess on the floor with play doh. Current nanny just leaves the play doh on the floor ( well she did today ) and didn't tell older child to tidy it away and close the pots. So basically the house was trashed and play doh everywhere.

I feel a bit miffed but perhaps it was caused by me being there for the last 30 minutes ? We were just catching up on the day and I started prepping dinner.

I'm not sure if it's me or her and how to say it to her in a nice way.

She is a nanny not a cleaner

webuiltthiscityonrockandwheat · 19/04/2023 05:09

I used to tidy up as a nanny as well as do laundry, ironing, vacuum any kids mess etc. it did annoy me with one family though when I would turn up on a Monday morning and clearly the playroom hadn't been tidied all weekend and I was expected to tidy it before the kids could play. But in general I would leave the house tidy

pepperminticecream · 19/04/2023 05:02

Yes, she should tidy up any mess made while she is with the children that day. Our nanny does the following: children's laundry (wash, fold and put away), change their bedding once per week, their dishes from the day, works with them to put toys/books, etc away before she leaves. I also expect that the kitchen counters/table/high chairs are wiped down after lunch and the floor swept.

We do not expect her to clean up after us, and as a rule, we make sure that when she arrives our house is tidy, dishwasher unloaded, etc. She should have a clean work place & this set the standard for how we want the house to look at the end of the day.

Willmafrockfit · 19/04/2023 04:52

surely it is the nanny's job to tidy up toys

Mischance · 19/04/2023 04:50

Mess like spills ... yes she should clear up.
General toys etc around and about ... no, not really. The children are still awake and will not suddenly vanish ... when they have finished with them later then you should supervise a tidy up. What are the children supposed to do when you come home ... just stand around with nothing to do ?

Phoebo · 19/04/2023 04:44

I don't bother tidying toys until kids are asleep as it's pointless

SkyandSurf · 19/04/2023 04:41

Most nannies would tidy up after the children and themselves as a minimum.

That said, you have to look at the whole person and her performance as a whole.

Our current nanny is really messy. Absolutely trashes the house. BUT the children have a ball with her, she does lots of educational (albeit messy) activities and crafts, she has so much energy and positivity.

My children are happy and safe - I happily take the trashed house.

My previous nanny was wonderful as well, very tidy and would leave the house tidier than she found it. It was bliss to come home to the laundry folded and the dishwasher empty.

Both wonderful.

I think if the tidying is important to you say something, but no nanny will be perfect so be conscious of all her good traits before you push too hard about this one aspect.

Riverlee · 19/04/2023 04:07

Yes, she should tidy up and put toys away, clear up messy play doh etc.

Softsoftsleep · 19/04/2023 03:51

Of course she should be tidying the kids mess before she leaves. That's such a no brainer. When I was maternity leave (with a baby and 2 school aged kids) I made sure the place was tidy before their dad came home. That way we could get straight onto dinner and spending family time together before bed. I wouldn't want a nanny who didn't get that or chose not to. I think it's a really basic thing to clear your work space before you go home, whatever you Job is. It's just basic manners to not be handing over a big mess that occurred on your watch and skipping away from it like its not your responsibility. Its not good enough. 'I'd appreciate it if you can have the place tidied tidied by the time I get back'. It doesn't require an explanation surely! I would not be happy about this.

Theoldwoman · 19/04/2023 03:23

All chores related to her charges should be carried out by the Nanny. Maybe she was embarrassed to be cleaning while you were there for fear of being judged?

Suzi888 · 19/04/2023 03:04

“She also thought it was important to teach the kids how to tidy, and so they were involved in the process every day as part of their winding down routine.”

Indeed.

Murdoch1949 · 19/04/2023 02:51

You need to have a review with her and discuss your expectations and hers. I agree with you that she should tidy away the toys, with older child's help. Also the children's meal debris, cooking utensils etc, but she obviously needs to be told what you expect. Get her opinions to, as to whether there are things she wants to happen.

Chamomileteaplease · 18/04/2023 22:41

I am getting the rage just reading about the mess she made! No wonder you are cross.

Next time you see her, have your sentence ready - something like, "Yesterday the house was really messy when I got home. I really need you to have cleared up the kids' toys and to keep the kitchen clean and tidy. We did talk about this in your interview so could you please keep on top of it from now on?"

And don't start any sentence with " Sorry, but ...."

I am sure you can say it nicely but firmly. Is she young and thoughtless or older and cheeky? Either way, knock it on the head 🙂.

EconomyClassRockstar · 18/04/2023 22:39

As long as they arrive to a tidy house, it's ok to expect them to clear up before you get home. However, if they arrive to a mess, then no they shouldn't be expected to clear up stuff that happened when they weren't there.

determinedtomakethiswork · 18/04/2023 22:31

I think it's quite good that she left it in such a mess, including her own mess, today because it gives you huge advantage. I would say to her tomorrow that you can't come home to a mess like that again. It's her responsibility to tidy up after the children before you come home and to leave it in the same condition that she found it in the morning. She is at work. Can you imagine if any of us did that at work and just left it for someone else to clear it up?

determinedtomakethiswork · 18/04/2023 22:27

TwilightSkies · 18/04/2023 18:39

So your kids trash the house and the nanny has to tidy it all up?

Don't be ridiculous.

GatherlyGal · 18/04/2023 21:24

I agree OP. We had a few nannies over the years and I don't think it's unreasonable to want to come home to a reasonably tidy house and not need to be cleaning up after her. When our kids got a bit older we had a nanny-housekeeper because our nanny didn't want to do cleaning and I drew the line at paying for 2 people to be in my house while the kids were at school!

Tidying away kids toys and a cleanish kitchen are pretty basic nanny duties I would say.

LavenderOlive21 · 18/04/2023 21:09

Yes your nanny should tidy up the toys and children’s meals and any other child related mess from the day. Particularly if you’d left the house tidy this morning, ideally you should be coming home to the house in the same condition.

I don’t think nannies should be expected to do any housework not relating to the children however ie emptying the bin. Our wonderful nanny used to kindly unload and reload the dishwasher and occasionally unpack the food shop, which we were very grateful for. But it wasn’t at all expected nor was it in her contract.

strawberry2017 · 18/04/2023 21:06

I think it depends on what you discussed with the nanny when she started. At her old job tidying up might not have been a requirement.
Ultimately she's there to look after the children.
I would say bins is not the nanny's job. She may choose to do them but it's not her role.

treeliver · 18/04/2023 20:54

PegasusReturns · 18/04/2023 20:49

I’ve had a number of nannies over the years and they always cleared up after the DC as well as other child related chores.

toys should be put away, if there’s play doh on the floor it needs to be swept/hoovered.

DCs beds should be changed once a week, towels hung up after bath time, pans washed up after their dinner is cooked.

I’ve had nannies that have been more rigid than others but generally I think flexibility in the relationship works better. It does have to be both ways though.

I'm flexible and I was actually tidying away the nannies stuff too whilst cooking and chatting. She was just sitting down whilst I was moving around, cleaning the table / cooking..

I've just found a cup she's used on the side and it's given me the rage, as I also cleared some wrappers off the table that she'd left there and I also did some of the washing up after the kids lunch that she had not done..I have been doing stuff like that since she started. Nothing is ever done 100 percent. The house is a constant tip.

I will need to do something about this because I shouldn't have to tidy up after her, as well as my kids. She's supposed to make my life a bit easier.

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 18/04/2023 20:49

I’ve had a number of nannies over the years and they always cleared up after the DC as well as other child related chores.

toys should be put away, if there’s play doh on the floor it needs to be swept/hoovered.

DCs beds should be changed once a week, towels hung up after bath time, pans washed up after their dinner is cooked.

I’ve had nannies that have been more rigid than others but generally I think flexibility in the relationship works better. It does have to be both ways though.

ToEllewithIt · 18/04/2023 20:48

I think you sent mixed messages with the chit chat.
I would definitely expect the toys to be tidied away either by the children with encouragement or by the nanny depending on age, apart from those in use.
On the bin I think common sense applies. My husband would generally bring ours out at night so it would be rare that she would need to do anything,but if the kitchen bin / recycling became full during the day I would expect that she'd put in in the wheelie bin.

Thinkbiglittleone · 18/04/2023 20:39

Yes, she is responsible for the mess on her watch.
Although I would also expect that she shows/encourages the children to tidy up after themselves.