Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should nanny tidy up toys before going home

117 replies

treeliver · 18/04/2023 18:38

And in general during the day ? I had a nanny before and she kind of automatically did this...

However she did only look after 1 child. New nanny is looking after my two.

But I felt a bit miffed when I had welcomed her in this morning to quite a tidy house and obviously it got completely trashed and she just left, without lifting a finger.

I get that it gets messy, but the last 30 minutes she was just chatting to me anyway, whilst the older one was watching cartoons and younger one was just hanging out.

I don't know if she would have tried to tidy up, had I not come in and had a chat with her. Does it send mixed signals ?

She hasn't really tidied up much otherwise either to be honest. But I noticed it more today because I left the house especially tidy this morning for her.

Also, random question, but emptying the bin is not part of what the nanny should do right ? Previous one used to do it, if I hadn't got to it on the odd occasion ( maybe 3 times in a year ) she also used to occasionally hoover up after the my son, if he'd made a mess on the floor with play doh. Current nanny just leaves the play doh on the floor ( well she did today ) and didn't tell older child to tidy it away and close the pots. So basically the house was trashed and play doh everywhere.

I feel a bit miffed but perhaps it was caused by me being there for the last 30 minutes ? We were just catching up on the day and I started prepping dinner.

I'm not sure if it's me or her and how to say it to her in a nice way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TomeTome · 20/04/2023 06:15

determinedtomakethiswork · 19/04/2023 11:04

One of them is a baby! The other is very young too.

I was responding to the pp who seemed to think tidying up at the end of the day was unusual. Of course the baby can’t tidy away toys but a 4 year old can. Most toddlers help.

Didimum · 19/04/2023 15:12

They do tidy their own mess but not all of it. They are four years old.

Blondeshavemorefun · 19/04/2023 15:04

Didimum · 19/04/2023 08:46

Do you have a formal contract outlining her duties? (You should …)

Our nanny (for two children) cleans and tidies all the downstairs communal areas (two living rooms, play room, kitchen), and children’s areas (bedrooms, children’s bathroom). She doesn’t do the bins but she cleans the kitchen and floors, does the shopping, some errands like post office and dry cleaners.

Housekeeping and nannying can be separate jobs. You won’t always find an amazing nanny is the best housekeeper and vice versa. For an amazing nanny when the kids are this little, I’d let housekeeping tasks slide a bit, as long as I could see they were generally conscientious of the home and gave things their best effort. However, doesn’t sound like your nanny is doing this whatsoever - I’d have an easygoing chat in the first instance and if you’re not getting anywhere, look for a new nanny.

For example our nanny left last night and the play room was a complete tip. She had, however, cleaned and tidied the kitchen, living room and bedrooms, taken them out to pick up new school shoes, and bathed them, and then told me she’d sort the play room the next morning. I think this was reasonable.

If old enough for school shoes then old enough to tidy up their own mess

So imo school age can start tidying while nanny or mummy does tea

GiltEdges · 19/04/2023 11:24

Hedwigharlot · 19/04/2023 09:31

I went for an interview for a nanny position once when I was in my early twenties. It was an absolute pisstake. She wanted all kid related stuff done plus 'light' housework, which turned out to be bins, cooking, the lot. All this for just below minimum wage. I was naive but not that naive! I decided I didn't want to be an underpaid skivvy. I think it's reasonable to expect the nanny to tidy up the toys but some of the other expectations on this thread are ridiculous.

In fairness, most nannies are paid a lot more than NMW.

WellTidy · 19/04/2023 11:19

We’ve employed nannies for 15 years. They’ve all been really good, some have been exceptional. But none of them have left a mess behind before they leave. The odd thing, maybe, but not as an everyday thing. I think you should raise this now as otherwise it will really jiggle at you and you will become resentful and it will really impact on your relationship with your nanny.

What does your contract say in relation to the job description? Is is something like ‘caring for x and y between an and b hours on days d, e and f’ or is it more specific like listing examples of what that care would involve?

If it is more general, and if things remain the same as they are once you’ve had a chat and made your feelings known, maybe you could consider adding an appendix to the contract with a job description that includes the tasks that you feel should be obvious but aren’t being done (and those which are being done, for completeness). You’d both need to agree that this becomes part of the contract.

Do you think she isn’t seeing the mess? A very basic checklist for the end of the day might help. I know it shouldn’t be necessary, but maybe it would help you both.

I appreciate that these conversations are hard to have, but I’ve had to have hard conversations in my workplace too. Sometimes they’re needed and things improve afterwards.

determinedtomakethiswork · 19/04/2023 11:04

TomeTome · 19/04/2023 09:48

its not about the kids sitting and doing nothing waiting for mum. It’s about teaching them how to manage their environment both by helping and by example. The children should be helping put the house to rights and then having telly or whatever

One of them is a baby! The other is very young too.

TomeTome · 19/04/2023 09:48

its not about the kids sitting and doing nothing waiting for mum. It’s about teaching them how to manage their environment both by helping and by example. The children should be helping put the house to rights and then having telly or whatever

Hedwigharlot · 19/04/2023 09:31

I went for an interview for a nanny position once when I was in my early twenties. It was an absolute pisstake. She wanted all kid related stuff done plus 'light' housework, which turned out to be bins, cooking, the lot. All this for just below minimum wage. I was naive but not that naive! I decided I didn't want to be an underpaid skivvy. I think it's reasonable to expect the nanny to tidy up the toys but some of the other expectations on this thread are ridiculous.

melj1213 · 19/04/2023 09:08

Mischance · 19/04/2023 04:50

Mess like spills ... yes she should clear up.
General toys etc around and about ... no, not really. The children are still awake and will not suddenly vanish ... when they have finished with them later then you should supervise a tidy up. What are the children supposed to do when you come home ... just stand around with nothing to do ?

Nobody is saying the children should be left with no toys out at all, or that they shouldn't be allowed to play in case they make a mess.

However, there's a massive difference between leaving out a train set which was the last toy they were playing with before they started watching TV and leaving out the train set, a pile of Lego, the car track and associated cars, pencils and colouring books all over the table, playdoh all over the floor, books strewn around the room and the dolls house is empty because all the furniture has been dumped out on the floor.

The former is perfectly acceptable and I would have no issue with a nanny leaving the current toy out for them to continue playing with after dinner but the latter is unacceptable - firstly because they're leaving all the tidying up for the parent to do and secondly because I have always preferred to clean as I go, so if DD was playing then we'd have a maximum of two activities out at once and if she wanted to do something new she had to help me tidy away something she wasn't playing with any more.

Didimum · 19/04/2023 08:49

socksaremyfriend · 19/04/2023 08:38

I'm not a nanny but if I was watching my nephews for a few hours I would definitely tidy up. I think it's a bit cheeky of her to let the kids trash the place and leave it for you to come home to. I would maybe politely say to her in a jokey way to not let the kids play with something until the previous toy/ game has been tidy

I even tidied up another school mum’s house when we were round for a play date and my son made a mess with the toys 😂

Didimum · 19/04/2023 08:46

Do you have a formal contract outlining her duties? (You should …)

Our nanny (for two children) cleans and tidies all the downstairs communal areas (two living rooms, play room, kitchen), and children’s areas (bedrooms, children’s bathroom). She doesn’t do the bins but she cleans the kitchen and floors, does the shopping, some errands like post office and dry cleaners.

Housekeeping and nannying can be separate jobs. You won’t always find an amazing nanny is the best housekeeper and vice versa. For an amazing nanny when the kids are this little, I’d let housekeeping tasks slide a bit, as long as I could see they were generally conscientious of the home and gave things their best effort. However, doesn’t sound like your nanny is doing this whatsoever - I’d have an easygoing chat in the first instance and if you’re not getting anywhere, look for a new nanny.

For example our nanny left last night and the play room was a complete tip. She had, however, cleaned and tidied the kitchen, living room and bedrooms, taken them out to pick up new school shoes, and bathed them, and then told me she’d sort the play room the next morning. I think this was reasonable.

Taq · 19/04/2023 08:46

Thehop · 19/04/2023 08:36

"Right, whilst I get dinner started, can you make a start on tidying up with Johnny please?"

This doesn’t work. You’re not asking a favour, they’re getting paid for it. I wouldn’t leave my workplace a shithole.
We've had lots of nannies over the years, and I’ve thing I’ve learnt is to be direct.

snitzelvoncrumb · 19/04/2023 08:42

I was a nanny. I always made sure the house was tidy before the end of the day. I planned meal times based on being able to clean kitchen before mum came home.

socksaremyfriend · 19/04/2023 08:38

I'm not a nanny but if I was watching my nephews for a few hours I would definitely tidy up. I think it's a bit cheeky of her to let the kids trash the place and leave it for you to come home to. I would maybe politely say to her in a jokey way to not let the kids play with something until the previous toy/ game has been tidy

Thehop · 19/04/2023 08:36

"Right, whilst I get dinner started, can you make a start on tidying up with Johnny please?"

TomeTome · 19/04/2023 08:35

She needs to clean up after herself and the children. Explain what you want it to be like and ask if she’s happy to do that. If not find someone that will.

ZenNudist · 19/04/2023 08:34

Of course the nanny should tidy as she goes. Just the mess she has made with the kids. I wouldn't get too hung up on how you approach this. Just ask outright and do it soon. Bins and stuff is not her job but what I'd say is if the bin is full empty it, don't just stack rubbish next to it. You will always try and empty it but if it's full on occasion then she should empty it. Ditto dishwasher being full /clean. Not always but occasionally. Expect her to treat the house like her own (but not routinely clean for you).

Yummymummy2020 · 19/04/2023 08:31

Ex nanny here and it was always in my contracts to leave the kids toys tidy before I went home. Easier said than done but I was paid to do it so I did it. I would be annoyed too. Do you have a proper job description in her contract?

Taq · 19/04/2023 08:27

And absolutely yes to writing an instruction sheet. In my experience ‘please leave kitchen tidy’ isn’t enough. But a checklist of ‘plates in dishwasher, surfaces wiped and clear, table clear and floor swept after meals’ does get results.
I always apologise with new nannies and say ‘obviously you know all this but it’s just the generic list I have.’

Taq · 19/04/2023 08:25

Yes she should and you need to tell her now. One difficult conversation and they don’t do it again.
‘I expect the house to be left in the same condition it was when you arrived. I respect that you are a nanny and not a cleaner, and I do not expect you to clean up after me. However I also do not expect to be cleaning up after you. Please don’t let it happen again.’

Then move onto a lighter subject and thank her for anything positive. Don’t do it over text.

SkyandSurf · 19/04/2023 08:20

OP if she is new, then now is the time to write a short instruction sheet. Include the children's schedules, likes/dislikes, allergies, important contacts and then a reasonable list of duties you'd like her to complete.

You can put 'tidy away toys' at the end of the day, 'stack dishwasher and wipe down kitchen' at lunch etc.

Remember she has two children to look after, not one so be realistic.

Personally I wouldn't expect a nanny to fold laundry etc if the children were awake, I'd rather them engage with the children. But that's a personal preference, it's fine to ask for light household chores that are related to the children. I wouldn't ask them to take the bin out, unless there was a dirty nappy or something that required it.

Also make sure her pay reflects her responsibilities. If you're paying her like a babysitter (not saying you are) then her job is just minding the children. A nanny is paid more but expected to do more.

maddiemookins16mum · 19/04/2023 07:26

Emptying the bin is part of someone being at home caring for children. Assuming nappies, food wrappers etc are going in there during the day. It takes two minutes. Hardly beneath a Nanny to do this surely (I was one btw and did all sort of stuff not in the job description (Nursery Duties). It’s part of being the only adult in the house all day.

lamaze1 · 19/04/2023 06:21

Have a chat and set out your expectations. Better to know sooner rather than later if the arrangement is going to work.

I would expect a nanny to tidy away toys with the children. Ours does with my 18month old. Also to tidy up after themselves add they go along.

MaverickSnoopy · 19/04/2023 06:08

Speaking as a former Childminder and parent, the Nanny should be teaching the children to tidy up, even the baby (depending on age).

I've always started with taking a basket to the baby and asking them to put the toy in the basket. Over time it progresses.

Playdoh etc should be hoovered but bin is your job. If it's not bed time I've always gone with a 90% tidy rule, leaving out anything they're likely to want to play with. Then if they go to get anything else out I say, don't forget anything you get out needs tidying up, which will stop them from getting lots out but also pre warn them that they'll need to tidy.

Kittylickingplate · 19/04/2023 05:56

Of course she should tidy up the children's mess that they made in her care. Just ask her too in future.