Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like a lot of healthy, able bodied women

37 replies

isitjusthumannature · 18/04/2023 18:36

Completely dismiss the experiences of disabled women, brush off the things we have to go through - but then once anything medical happens to the 'healthy' person they suddenly want empathy and act like they are the first person to have to deal with it?

My mate had to provide a urine sample at her gp and banged on for ages about how invasive she found it. She knows I have to do this at regular medical appointments as well as blood tests and other things I find upsetting. But said "it's ok for you as you're so used to doctors".

She honestly didn't mean anything bad by it and she's a great person, I love her, but it strikes me that for some reason I'm in a separate category to her that makes her dismiss my experiences.

Like no, it isn't and I hate all the medical interventions I have to have.

That's just one example, it's something I've noticed quite regularly. And it honestly isn't coming from a nasty place, but makes me sad that it's like certain women, disabled women, are seen as less important and our upset matters less?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Snoken · 18/04/2023 21:34

I don’t think we as humans need to get every situation or experience. I don’t get how it feels to be white, I don’t get how it feels to be a male, I don’t get how it feels to not have parents still alive etc. that doesn’t mean I can’t be sympathetic of course. But if my parents died tomorrow I would be desperately sad, but I wouldn’t be equally sad for my friend who lost her parents a decade ago. Not because I think her loss meant less, but because I couldn’t relate to it then and I am going through something today.

LuvSmallDogs · 18/04/2023 21:29

I think that with severe illness or disability, you can never KNOW until it happens to you.

I used to go a good couple years without seeing a Dr for myself, hated the smell of hospitals, would dig old antibiotics out the cupboard to save the faff of making a GP appt when I felt the signs of strep, and I was terrified of needles. I was arrogant enough to think that in my early 30s, I had years left of magical, fell into my hands by luck, health.

Now I inject myself in the stomach flab 3 times a week to try to mitigate the effects of my chemotherapy, have biopsy scars, and the way my veins are having to get dug at I'm probably going to get landed with a PICC soon.

I didn't know how many different cancers there were, or what went into staging them, and I didn't think of cancer patients having whole lives outside of cancer until I got it and started spending a lot of time talking to other patients while we do chemo.

Pulpfan78 · 18/04/2023 21:12

Yes, health was the thing I took most for granted until I lost it. It really is the biggest gift. But I don't think healthy people understand that - I certainly didn't.

littlefirecar · 18/04/2023 21:08

I voted YABU but only because I don't think it's so black and white. I have a hidden disability (autoimmune with periods of wellness and periods of relapse) and I have had a disabled friend (full time wheelchair user) make 'lighthearted' comments how easy it would be to fake my condition and also once seemed to think i have some sort of control over when i have relapses so told me to try not to have one when we had something planned🙄

She didnt mean to be offensive just as I'm sure I've probably said inappropriate things to friends with disabilities other than my own before (still cringe about the time I invited a friend with MD and a heavy AF powerchair to my house and forgot to factor the stairs)

It's always harder for people to fully understand something that's outside of their lived experience but some people (disabled or not) try harder to be thoughtful to others.

Having an open dialogue is the best thing you can do about this as 99% of the time people don't mean to be cruel and if you let them know they will hopefully be more empathetic in the future

Mercedes45 · 18/04/2023 20:40

ALongHardWinter · 18/04/2023 18:39

I'm baffled that she found a urine test invasive! Did she have to do it in public?!

Ha ha,made me laugh

Dymaxion · 18/04/2023 20:26

It doesn't just happen to disabled people, I am really fat and very rarely ill, my friend is slim, fit and is poorly a lot more often, I am always really sympathetic when she is ill, if I am ill, I never seem to be allowed to be as ill as her and I get the distinct impression she thinks its because of my 'lifestyle' as opposed to the random lurgies that effect her.

Galatine · 18/04/2023 20:14

Starhead69 · 18/04/2023 18:40

I’m confused, how were they extracting the urine?

Pee in a bottle I imagine😀

elliejjtiny · 18/04/2023 20:00

Yanbu. I find this a lot with my 9 year old who has had 23 operations. People tell me that I should be used to it by now or that it's not a big deal but the only thing that's easier now is that I know where the toilet/vending machine etc are.

maddening · 18/04/2023 19:52

I don't think your friend represents a lot of women though- and I don't think her comment means that she dismisses your experiences based on the example you have given.

I do think it is absolutely fine for people to be mainly concerned with their own experiences and situations- whilst it is good to have empathy and consideration for other people I don't think it is possible for us all to hold in our minds all other peoples' experiences and worries or to ruminate on all possible problems - it would be mentally damaging even if you could.

queenMab99 · 18/04/2023 19:42

I think we are all the centre of our own universe, and think like this, if nothing has happened to make us aware. I remember thinking when my son died, how many women in poor countries or in the past had had to bear this often, and we in our ignorance just think that the fact that it is a common occurrence makes it less painful for them. It is not just that we are ableist, we are 'otherist' and imagine that people, who by their circumstances have to put up with horrible experiences, get used to it and do not feel it as we would.

drawingmaps · 18/04/2023 19:30

I get what you mean OP. Yes there's a certain amount of getting used to it, as a chronically ill disabled person. But that doesn't really make it any easier. If anything it makes it harder in some ways. For example, I've always been pretty chilled and open about my body, now I hate getting my tits out for the doctors to stick their tests on because it all feels so intrusive and medicalised. Another example, nobody really likes hospitals, but after a few bad experiences lots of us end up feeling panicked just going through the door. I hate seeing hospital trolleys because it reminds me of some traumatic experiences. And in my experience, we get a worse standard of care because we're "in all the time" and "must be used to it".
I don't think non-disabled non-sick people are ever really going to understand all that though. Best I can hope for is that they stop making insensitive comments in the meantime.
Disabled people are often seen as less than human. That's an extreme viewpoint for someone to explicitly express, but the way in which we are generally dehumanised, in so many different ways, contributes to ideas like this.

DelphiniumsBlueWildRose · 18/04/2023 19:22

Presume she's never given birth or had a smear test then?!

JudgeRudy · 18/04/2023 19:14

I think you have unrealistic expectations. In some ways you are 'in a separate category ' as in you're an experienced hardened urine giver! That doesn't mean she's invalidating your feelings but clearly you don't feel the same as her and probably have become desensitised to some degree.
Imagine a teen girl telling her best friend "and we were just looking at each other and then he kissed me. O M G I thought I was floating!" It's her first kiss, so in this case something nice, but its new. She won't be saying that in a years time.
Why can't you use it as a bonding experience instead of being angry at her. I have friends that care for elderly relatives. I don't but when my mum had a hip replacement I had a glimpse into their world ferry mum back n forth n pulling up knickers. I bet there's things going on in her life that you're not aware of.
Did you explain to her that although the initial shock has worn off you still feel humiliated/embarrassed/violated etc when you have to go through health checks/clinical procedures? Allow your friend to voice her feelings in real time, but re visit at a later date.

User2538309 · 18/04/2023 19:14

I would not call myself disabled, but I am managing a number of chronic conditions which flare up and disrupt things. I profoundly hate feeling like an “ill person”. My DC also has complex health needs. It has been absolutely eye opening to me how people just don’t really know what to do with chronic illness. They want you to be better. They want you to be positive. They want your kid to be fixed now. And yes, when they have a brief issue, they tend not to realise how it’s not easier for us to do, we just have to.

I agree it comes from just not seeing, and the huge amount of structural ableism. When other parents have to take their kids to A&E, it genuinely is probably the most stressful bit of their week. For us, if it doesn’t end up with DC spending 2 weeks in hospital then we are actually counting blessings. Our normal is not their normal. But it’s bloody hard. Hats off to you OP and everyone else doing their fucking best to live the best possible life despite a whole pile of unfair crap!

isitjusthumannature · 18/04/2023 19:12

ErrolTheDragon · 18/04/2023 18:54

Is this specific to able bodied women vs disabled women or more generally able bodied people vs disabled people?

Of course there is a huge problem with ableism in general. And a huge problem with women's healthcare being more unsatisfactory, and men being seen as the 'default' in healthcare research.

However, I am a woman in a romantic relationship with a woman, who primarily discusses any kind of personal medical stuff with other women - so this observation was more about how able bodied women can be inclined to brush off the experiences of disabled women.

OP posts:
Horsedoglover59 · 18/04/2023 19:04

isitjusthumannature · 18/04/2023 18:53

Yes agree with everything you say and it totally does fit in with the point I was making.

I most likely can't have children either and I've been there with some very thoughtless remarks too, it can be so hurtful I'm sorry Flowers

I've also been there, and gad that said to me. I found it very hurtful, as the person concerned who had known me for a long time, didn't know if I hadn't had children because I'd chosen not to have children, or was unable to have them. I'd expected better of her, and it put me off someone I had previously liked.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 18/04/2023 19:03

You know when athletes win at the Olympics. And they are all happy and celebrating etc and then they disappear for a while.

Do you know what they do in that time? A urine sample. A fully witnessed urine sample.

Kind of ruins the glamour of the occasion!

(Sorry - totally off topic - and you have a very good point Op - but it just blows my mind a bit.)

Horsedoglover59 · 18/04/2023 18:59

Hope your friend never needs a colonoscopy either!!

ErrolTheDragon · 18/04/2023 18:54

Is this specific to able bodied women vs disabled women or more generally able bodied people vs disabled people?

isitjusthumannature · 18/04/2023 18:53

Mycathatesmecuddling · 18/04/2023 18:45

Ive found my experiences as a disabled women quite easily dismissed as well

I was talking to a female friend about how I wasnt looking forward to my smear test because i find it so painful to get into the position. Im sometimes in a wheelchair, have mobility issues and getting into the right position is physically quite painful for me

She scoffed at me and told me 'when you have had a baby like me you can go through all sorts of gynae procedures without blinking. I don't find smear tests uncomfortable any more'

Well sure but my point wasnt that I found the actual test uncomfortable, although im not a fan. My point was it takes me forever to get into position and my body struggles to stay there. But that apparently is irrelevant.

Also I cant have kids and she knew it at the time but I was glossing over the 'when you have had a baby like me' part 🙄

Its only one example I have more but i totally recognise that attitude of dismissing the disabled persons experience, although I appreciate thats not the full point you were making

Yes agree with everything you say and it totally does fit in with the point I was making.

I most likely can't have children either and I've been there with some very thoughtless remarks too, it can be so hurtful I'm sorry Flowers

OP posts:
Smartiepants79 · 18/04/2023 18:51

Lapland123 · 18/04/2023 18:42

Totally hear you. Some people are just meant to put up with things as they have always had it rough. It’s just sooooo much worse for someone who is new to this minor experience. Comes from a narcissistic place

Narcissistic!?? There’s some arm chair psychology for you!
People ( understandably) find it hard to understand or appreciate the difficult parts of somebody else’s life until it happens to them. That’s human nature. It does not mean that it’s ok to dismiss or devalue that other person’s experiences and I think your friend was extremely thoughtless and insensitive and I’m not surprised it’s annoyed you.

isitjusthumannature · 18/04/2023 18:50

Lapland123 · 18/04/2023 18:42

Totally hear you. Some people are just meant to put up with things as they have always had it rough. It’s just sooooo much worse for someone who is new to this minor experience. Comes from a narcissistic place

Yes exactly, about how some people are just meant to put up and shut up.

But in fairness, I don't think it is always narcissistic.

I think sometimes it can just be from a place of innocence? Maybe that's not the right word exactly, but where they have never really realised how they would feel if certain things happened, and there was no other choice but to do them?

OP posts:
Quveas · 18/04/2023 18:50

I think your friend is insane. But (apart from on this site) I find most people try not to assume that my disability is something they understand, becuse they know they don't. Generally "society" can be awful at dealing with disability, but individually I think most people try. To be fair, I get it. Until I became disabled myself I thought that society had progressed. It hasn't.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/04/2023 18:47

doadeer · 18/04/2023 18:45

Sadly I think this is part of human nature... We often lack empathy until we have personal experience. I agree it's super frustrating and I can see why you would feel annoyed. It's tone deaf of your friend. If she had the humility to say "gosh, I had no idea how hard this must be for you, I'm so sorry I never realised." That would be better.

Absolutely

I think that's what separates out people who can only ever centre themselves and never stop to consider how others cope

TheYearOfSmallThings · 18/04/2023 18:47

I think you are right, mainly because I am guilty of it myself. When I have trivial health problems I find them so unpleasant...I can't even comprehend what it must be like to live with a serious health condition. I wouldn't deal with it gracefully.

Swipe left for the next trending thread