Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling yourself a creative professional if you don't make any money from it

205 replies

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 17:20

Through my work (hence NCed for this) I come across a number of people who will say they are in a creative profession, but who don't actually earn any money from it (or extremely little, say a few hundred a year). They are unpublished writers, artists who virtually never sell anything, musicians who put tracks online that no-one really listens to and actors who only do unpaid roles.

They do however invest a lot of time in their chosen activity and don't have another job. All are financially supported by their partners. They don't have young children or clean their own houses (this may be where I come in...) so couldn't be described as SAHPs or even housewives/husbands (as to me that implies looking after the home most of the time, not hiring a cleaner). They aren't retirement age either.

Should they be saying they are an xyz if they don't financially support themselves with it, or is that a money centric view and if it's how they spend their time then they are an xyz? At what point do they earn enough money from it to say they are one? Is earning any money OK or does it have to be at least min wage (for example)?

I don't have a horse in this race, I don't think I would say I was an xyz unless I made money from it but I also don't like that we define people so much by how they get their money.

IANBU = they shouldn't say they are an artist/writer/musician etc unless they make money from it
IABU = it's how you spend your time that matters, even if you earn nothing from it

OP posts:
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 18/04/2023 17:35

Battygirll · 18/04/2023 17:30

I am a published author. I make very little money. I get paid for performing my poetry - again, little money.

I am also a professional artist and I sell my work.

I have a day job to make ends meet.

I fund myself - don't rely on parents.

To be fair, most published authors make very little money. I am multi-published, award winning and have both a traditional publisher and an agent. I am single, so other income to fall back on, so I also work outside the home.

I don't know many creative people who make a living wage out of it, to be honest.

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 17:34

It doesn't really bother me, as I said in the OP I don't have a horse in the race. I just wondered what others think.

I suppose I think about it because I do one of the above things in my spare time but people still see me as a cleaner because that's how I make my money. And the people I'm talking about don't make any more money from it than I do but as they say that they are an xyz it seems more respected somehow? Maybe I just need to say I am an xyz instead of a cleaner! (I don't want this to get derailed into something about how I feel about my job though)

I definitely think it's OK to say you are an xyz if you still have another job too, but if you never make any money from the creative thing and no one really knows cares about your creative work, are you really an xyz? Maybe so and in which case it's just about how you spend your time.

OP posts:
InDubiousBattle · 18/04/2023 17:32

How on earth does it concern you what they call themselves? If they sell a couple of pieces of art for a few hundred quid and don't have another job then they are an artist, surely? Not sure what else they'd say!

Battygirll · 18/04/2023 17:30

I am a published author. I make very little money. I get paid for performing my poetry - again, little money.

I am also a professional artist and I sell my work.

I have a day job to make ends meet.

I fund myself - don't rely on parents.

Dithyramb · 18/04/2023 17:26

I’m more intrigued as to why it bothers you so much? Calling yourself a writer or a painter or whatever isn’t a protected characteristic.

How much would they need to earn pa in order to make it ok? And is it the fact that they don’t have another job to pay the bills that bothers you? Because I hate to break it to you, but even published mid-list novelists need a day job. I write novels ‘for a living’, but the majority of my income comes from my university job. Every other fiction writer I know has a job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread