Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling yourself a creative professional if you don't make any money from it

205 replies

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 17:20

Through my work (hence NCed for this) I come across a number of people who will say they are in a creative profession, but who don't actually earn any money from it (or extremely little, say a few hundred a year). They are unpublished writers, artists who virtually never sell anything, musicians who put tracks online that no-one really listens to and actors who only do unpaid roles.

They do however invest a lot of time in their chosen activity and don't have another job. All are financially supported by their partners. They don't have young children or clean their own houses (this may be where I come in...) so couldn't be described as SAHPs or even housewives/husbands (as to me that implies looking after the home most of the time, not hiring a cleaner). They aren't retirement age either.

Should they be saying they are an xyz if they don't financially support themselves with it, or is that a money centric view and if it's how they spend their time then they are an xyz? At what point do they earn enough money from it to say they are one? Is earning any money OK or does it have to be at least min wage (for example)?

I don't have a horse in this race, I don't think I would say I was an xyz unless I made money from it but I also don't like that we define people so much by how they get their money.

IANBU = they shouldn't say they are an artist/writer/musician etc unless they make money from it
IABU = it's how you spend your time that matters, even if you earn nothing from it

OP posts:
Dithyramb · 18/04/2023 23:02

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 18/04/2023 18:24

My friend is a literary agent and represents lots of authors making actual money.

They are successful authors. Their works sell many, many copies & they are popular and widely sold.

I think a huge number of people are vain and cannot see past their love of the activity to the fact that they are not good enough at it to earn money doing it.

I’d be very surprised if your friend represents only writers who make a living solely from their sales. My agent, and the other agents at her big agency, tend to have a range of writers who sell varying amounts, but certainly of all the literary fiction writers I know, even the most successful (well-known name, has done author chats on here, Orange Prize-shortlisted) needs a day job. And it’s currently a crappy time to sell anything — I can think of three or four novelists with three or four novels to their name, reasonable sales, and their agents can’t sell the new one.

LolaSmiles · 18/04/2023 21:34

The part that's potentially misleading to me is the 'professional' part of 'creative professional'.

If someone said to me they were a creative professional, I would assume they were either experienced in their chosen field and setting up working freelance as a viable line of work, or they had an established business with a decent track record. Whether they had another income stream wouldn't come into it as having multiple income streams is common.

Hobby creatives who rely on their living costs funded by their partner whilst they earn very little and do little to develop their own business skills wouldn't be a "creative professional" to me. They're unemployed and doing stuff they enjoy.

hilariousnamehere · 18/04/2023 21:26

This whole thread is a beautiful example of why I rarely ask new people I meet what they do and instead always say what do you enjoy, what lights you up.

Most of my (creative professional 😂) peers, including me, have had a period of time where they worked a day job as well while building their creative practice/business, and quite a lot of us do multiple things and freelance bits because that's the nature of the creative brain too.

I get frustrated that as a society we put so much emphasis on success equalling earning money from something - my own
is divided very firmly into creative work (for clients, I love it but it's always to a brief and it pays well because I'm very good at it) and creative practice, which is what I make for my own joy. Prints etc are available for sale but I have no attachment to whether or not they sell because I create them for me, not for a market or audience.

Before I established the creative work side of what I do, I had a day job because I'm single and bills don't pay themselves. I can't really see why you'd say you were an xyz based what you do between 9 and 5, when what you actually do with your life and free time is what you choose what to spend your time on.

But regardless of whether you think you're a creative or not, or a professional or not, who wants to talk about work unless it's something you love? So asking what people enjoy gets a very different and much more interesting response.

LondonSE19 · 18/04/2023 20:46

If they make no money from it, then they maybe creative but professional they are not.

TedMullins · 18/04/2023 20:45

I’m with you OP. I used to be a music journalist (an actual, professional paid one) and the amount of hobbyists calling themselves music journalists was infuriating, because they’d happily offer to work for free just to get their names out there and in turn make it harder for actual professionals to get paid. I’ve no problem with someone pursuing a creative interest and I know that often you do have to start by doing unpaid work to build a portfolio - I’d have no issue if these people called themselves music bloggers or even writers, but they weren’t journalists or professionals.

Im surprised you know so many with partners happy to bankroll them tbh. My boyfriend is a musician and he does make a living from it but if he didn’t I sure wouldn’t be funding him!

BirdChirp · 18/04/2023 20:40

The phrase 'everyone is an artist' gets on my nerves a bit. If I read a science text book will they make me a scientist, or if I go for a run am I an athlete, as another PP said?

I was in art school for 6 years, worked as a professional artist for a couple of years. I made just about enough money to survive on but it was uncomfortable, so I do office work now as sole income and art as a hobby. I don't ever call myself an artist, as that is not now my profession. In fact I never called myself an artist, I said I was a painter as did most of my peer group.

To OPs point - one of my art school peers is married to a hedge fund manager. She is as you describe - has been an artist for many years as she doesn't have to make much / any money from it. I don't begrudge her though, she is very good.

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 20:25

Londre · 18/04/2023 20:10

That’s what I’m thinking… OP why do you care so much? Is your partner pursuing to do something like this?

No he's not thank fuck!

It honestly just began as a wondering thought whilst cleaning a bathroom 😂

It's not really about specific people so much but more about how we define ourselves/each other in society - people put a lot of emphasis on how you make a living but maybe we should be defining people more by what they enjoy doing?

I will freely admit I am quite insecure though and pretty jealous of those who are bankrolled to persue hobbies all day!

And then it's about hobbies vs work too, isn't it? As PPs have said, if you don't make any money from something are you "just" a hobbyist/amateur? What if you've had a lot of training? What if you've had no training but make big money? Does that mean Van Gogh was a hobbyist?

OP posts:
Londre · 18/04/2023 20:10

Dithyramb · 18/04/2023 17:26

I’m more intrigued as to why it bothers you so much? Calling yourself a writer or a painter or whatever isn’t a protected characteristic.

How much would they need to earn pa in order to make it ok? And is it the fact that they don’t have another job to pay the bills that bothers you? Because I hate to break it to you, but even published mid-list novelists need a day job. I write novels ‘for a living’, but the majority of my income comes from my university job. Every other fiction writer I know has a job.

That’s what I’m thinking… OP why do you care so much? Is your partner pursuing to do something like this?

NalafromtheLionKing · 18/04/2023 20:08

I agree OP. I could be the “managing director and sole shareholder of my own business” tomorrow, simply by incorporating a company which doesn’t actually do anything or make any money, which is kinda the same thing.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/04/2023 20:06

Sociologically speaking, professional artist us a bit of an oxymoron. Professions have set training, cides of ethics, gatekeeping practices etc which are pretty much the exact opposite of how the art / creative world works, at least in the post-Romantic West.

Trixibella · 18/04/2023 20:05

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 18/04/2023 19:40

There's even a bit of a divide in the 'author' world (although most will deny it exists) between the 'full time author' (therefore seen as the very successful one) and the 'author who also has a day job' ('trying...bless'). Although often the only difference between the two isn't sales or the quality of the prose, but the marital or relationship status.

This would do my nut if I were a published author and single and I was perceived as less-than in the field where ALMOST NO ONE EARNS EVEN MINMUM WAGE because I didn’t have a man to ponce off. Bugger that!

not much you can do about it I suppose but grim.

Mephisneon · 18/04/2023 19:56

I work in the cultural sector. I can't get worked up about this. You can make lots of art in whatever form and not make money from it and art be what you do. Feels like you're insecure which is why you're bothered about it.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 18/04/2023 19:55

They don't have young children or clean their own houses (this may be where I come in...) so couldn't be described as SAHPs or even housewives/husbands (as to me that implies looking after the home most of the time, not hiring a cleaner).

If they cleaned their own houses, you would be out of a job.

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 19:55

NoSquirrels · 18/04/2023 17:43

I’m mostly intrigued by how you managed to specialise your client base to be lots of struggling creatives with high-earning partners, tbh.

One came to me by chance, they then recommended me to a friend. Both of them have had friends round when I've been working who I've heard them talking to (and then later looked at on SM out of nosiness!). I haven't met heaps of them tbh but I guess they congregate so once I met one I found some others!

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 18/04/2023 19:54

NoSquirrels · 18/04/2023 17:44

If you write, you are a writer.

You might not be a writer who can make their living from it. But you can certainly claim to write if you spend at least some of your time doing it.

Ok, well I go running sometimes so next time someone asks what I do I’ll tell them I’m an athlete.

That’s the problem really. If you’re saying ‘I write/paint/sculpt in my spare time too’ that’s absolutely fine! If you’re replying to ‘what do you do’ with ‘I’m an author’ when in fact you’ve never had so much as a short story published, then that’s misleading.

Yazo · 18/04/2023 19:53

Almost no creative professionals make an average wage from it. So by your reasoning they wouldn't really exist

GeriKellmansUpdo · 18/04/2023 19:51

Noticed a lot of posts lately where a cleaner/tutor/babysitter is super miffed about their employers not living their lives in the appropriate way. Appropriate as defined by the employee.

minipie · 18/04/2023 19:49

If they’re doing it for free I think they can call themselves an artist, singer etc but not a “professional” as to me that implies doing it as a job.

However if they do get paid - albeit badly/rarely - I think they can still call themselves a professional whatever. They’re just not very successful.

WitcheryDivine · 18/04/2023 19:48

Yeah good points.

My mum is a really good writer and makes regular money from it, she was also self-employed in an unrelated field which - you know -pays the mortgage. The level of snobbery she's been subject to by other writers she knows who consider her a sellout - rather than surviving on family money, benefits or a partner like they do - is horrible to behold.

Scarfweather · 18/04/2023 19:48

Having read other responses on this thread, I’m thinking there’s a large difference between people who have spent years of training, degrees, performances etc…(good actors, singers, musicians) and people who decide they’re quite good at choosing curtains and take a three month interior design course and are supported by a partner and get an article in Vogue due to ‘connections’.
They aren’t the same thing.

Kanaloa · 18/04/2023 19:45

Hmm, it’s a weird one. I write but I wouldn’t say I’m a ‘writer’ because I’ve not been published. I’m no more of a writer than my DD who writes little stories. But if someone asked about me I’d say ‘oh I like to write.’ If I asked what someone did and they said ‘I’m a writer’ and it turned out they meant they didn’t work and would like to be a writer then I’d be a bit eh.

Mochinated · 18/04/2023 19:42

I think I know the kind of women you mean OP. There is one in particular who I had to cut contact with because she became insufferable. Gave up work entirely due to "stress" - DH working FT in a genuinely stressful job, she did very few hours as admin asst with little responsibility. Last I saw on her Instagram, she was showing off the custom made "workshop" aka spare bedroom her poor DH had spent a number of weekends and £000s building bespoke furniture and fancy lighting etc into (plus the costs of the materials) .. all while making precisely 0 sales on Etsy 🤔

What really wound me up was the incessant complaints and begging posts about childcare for the 2 DC under 4 .. all so she could twat around make stock and prep for craft fairs. Just ridiculously entitled.

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 18/04/2023 19:41

Why isn't it good enough to have these things as a hobby?

If like most people you aren't good enough to earn a living from it then its your hobby.

I play two instruments to a high standard & sing. I'm not talented enough to earn a living doing it, its a hobby.

Honestly? It's vanity. People want to believe they are more talented than they are. Talent is by its nature defined by rarity, few people truly have it.

What most people have is a hobby level of skill.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 18/04/2023 19:40

There's even a bit of a divide in the 'author' world (although most will deny it exists) between the 'full time author' (therefore seen as the very successful one) and the 'author who also has a day job' ('trying...bless'). Although often the only difference between the two isn't sales or the quality of the prose, but the marital or relationship status.

WitcheryDivine · 18/04/2023 19:34

It's a funny one isn't it, and I think it can rile us because of the reactions they hope to get by announcing "I am an author" or "I am an artist" when what they mean is I have another large income and spend my entirely free time drawing or writing - often with no success or even expectation of selling anything they make. The number of people in my old job I'd meet who would say "I'm an artist" and expect you to be in awe was truly hilarious.

You're right OP that for people who need to make a living i.e. most of us, we sort of have to be known by the thing we do for pay. Unless in the context of a talent show or something you wouldn't get many people who work in Next introducing themselves saying "I am a singer" as if others knew about their day job they'd probably say "er no you work in a shop". But if people have financial freedom so only do the hobby, they are free to announce that as if it's their real job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread