Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling yourself a creative professional if you don't make any money from it

205 replies

SwanPools · 18/04/2023 17:20

Through my work (hence NCed for this) I come across a number of people who will say they are in a creative profession, but who don't actually earn any money from it (or extremely little, say a few hundred a year). They are unpublished writers, artists who virtually never sell anything, musicians who put tracks online that no-one really listens to and actors who only do unpaid roles.

They do however invest a lot of time in their chosen activity and don't have another job. All are financially supported by their partners. They don't have young children or clean their own houses (this may be where I come in...) so couldn't be described as SAHPs or even housewives/husbands (as to me that implies looking after the home most of the time, not hiring a cleaner). They aren't retirement age either.

Should they be saying they are an xyz if they don't financially support themselves with it, or is that a money centric view and if it's how they spend their time then they are an xyz? At what point do they earn enough money from it to say they are one? Is earning any money OK or does it have to be at least min wage (for example)?

I don't have a horse in this race, I don't think I would say I was an xyz unless I made money from it but I also don't like that we define people so much by how they get their money.

IANBU = they shouldn't say they are an artist/writer/musician etc unless they make money from it
IABU = it's how you spend your time that matters, even if you earn nothing from it

OP posts:
Dithyramb · 19/04/2023 08:01

dimpleton · 19/04/2023 07:41

I know someone who calls himself a creative professional but refuses to get another job to supplement his income even though he lives hand to mouth on very meagre earnings. I find that more annoying than what he calls himself.

During the pandemic he didn't work at all and was moaning all over Facebook about lack of benefits support for people like him, even though he was fit and well enough to get a different job but chose not to as he felt it beneath him 🙄

Or you could see it as admirable? No one is paying for this man. He’s prepared to live very simply and sacrifice things in order to spend time on doing what he loves. Even if he is an annoying person, and even if

This thread is quite revealing of a mix of both a certain kind of snobbery, tall poppy syndrome, and ignorance of the realities of making a living as a writer, musician etc, from people who know very little about it. It is an incredibly difficult thing to do, and there’s a lot of luck involved. It’s absolutely not a matter of talent meaning you can make it pay enough to support you, or having to have a job meaning you’re no good.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 19/04/2023 08:01

The underlying issue can be summed up as 'life isn't fair' I suppose.

You have person A who is very talented creatively but has to pay the bills with a 'day job' and is often too tired or busy with life admin to do very much towards their creative goals in their very limited free time.

Then you have person B who has a more mediocre skill but who is supported financially by someone else so can spend all their time working creatively and developing what abilities they have. They have the time and money to go on courses and workshops, to pay for one-to-one professional support, have networking opportunities and so on.

Person B is the one more likely to get a book published or have paintings exhibited, because that's the way life works. Person A resents that.

Lookylookyy · 19/04/2023 08:01

I’m a published writer. I have another part time job though! I don’t earn enough from writing alone, plus I really like my PT job. Oddly, I describe myself as a [pt job titler]. I am shy about my writing.

Most of my author friends have other income streams: some teach creative writing, some are copywriters on the side.

I have come across people who call themselves writers and they aren’t published and don’t work in another field. So I see what you’re saying. But, as someone who is published and does have another job, I am not offended by it! I know how hard it is to get published and how much it means to writers to write.

I suppose the not-working part shows how unequal our society is, that some get that choice because of family or spousal money. But our vaguely broken society is hardly the fault of the person who is not suffering in it.

LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 07:59

You're right. Sorry if that was misleading, I just didn't want the title to be really long! One will say she is "a creative" but the others say "I'm a poet", "I'm an actor" etc..
I'd not say someone was a poet/actor/musician unless there actively making a living from it.

I've got friends who are musicians and they do some solo projects, play in ensembles, are session musicians and also teach. Some of them did other jobs alongside whilst they got their different income streams established but I'd say they were accurately describing themselves if they said they were a musician.

If someone wasn't earning much/anything and was choosing to spend their days playing their instrument and uploading stuff to social media of mixed quality, whilst their partner pays all the bills, I'd say they were unemployed and doing their hobby.

Same for people who say they're an entrepreneur when what they actually mean is unemployed and expecting their spouse to bankroll the next poorly considered idea.

Testina · 19/04/2023 07:53

“It doesn't really bother me, as I said in the OP I don't have a horse in the race. I just wondered what others think. “

I think you are bothered 🤣

SwanPools · 19/04/2023 07:50

I'm trying not to pick a side here, that's the point of the discussion. I guess I do find it odd to call yourself an xyz if you don't make £ from it, but then the whole point is it's making me question how we define ourselves. I am open to both POVs but had to set the vote one way.

OP posts:
gannett · 19/04/2023 07:50

Well, the joke is that being a freelance creative feels a bit like being self-unemployed sometimes.

The thing is when you introduce yourself as X it's in a social context. It's meant to open up an ongoing conversation. When I describe myself as X it means that I can talk about it enthusiastically, I have interesting thoughts about it and if the person I've just met feels the same, we can have a great chat.

And there's an element of selling yourself a bit too. Everyone who's ever been in a creative industry knows that the next opportunity can come from anywhere - a random interaction online, a random conversation at someone else's party. "I'm a writer and I'm interested in this field" is more likely to get you that break than "the bulk of my income actually comes from a data entry job that I do an autopilot with my brain turned off".

SwanPools · 19/04/2023 07:47

Dithyramb · 18/04/2023 23:21

But I don’t think the people the OP is talking about are using the phrase ‘creative professional’ — that’s her catch-all phrase for them. I imagine these people are saying ‘I’m a musician’ or ‘I’m a novelist’, not ‘I’m a creative professional’.

You're right. Sorry if that was misleading, I just didn't want the title to be really long! One will say she is "a creative" but the others say "I'm a poet", "I'm an actor" etc..

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 19/04/2023 07:43

And I’m not sneering - I’m one of the short story tinkerers! But if someone asked ‘oh and what do you do’ I wouldn’t answer ‘I’m a writer’ because that would give them a very misleading answer of what I do on a daily basis.

Kanaloa · 19/04/2023 07:42

KnittingNeedles · 19/04/2023 07:33

Gosh, so much sneering.

I am a freelance writer. That is what I do to earn cash, that is what does down on my tax return. I work part-time and always have done since my eldest was born - just as many other parents do. Probably about 12-15 hours a week. I don't "publish" anything, because it's not that sort of writing. People have a very narrow view that writing = novels and that's not the case, most of my income is from blog posts and I also have a gig creating multiple choice questions for quiz websites. I also volunteer regularly 4 hours a week, am just about to complete a MSc and am applying for a PhD, look after my kids and do loads of other things as well.

So let me get this straight, it's OK for someone who works 12 hours a week in Tesco to describe themselves as a checkout operator (even though that takes up a fraction of their working week), but someone who paints, makes jewellery, writes or similar is self-indulgent and deluded?

Well, no… you could be described as a part time freelance writer because you are a part time freelance writer. If someone asked ‘oh what do you do’ they want a basic idea of what your life is. So if you said ‘oh I’m a freelance writer plus I’m doing my PHD soon’ that wouldn’t be misleading. If you were on benefits and occasionally tinkered with a short story then it would be misleading to say ‘me? Oh I’m a writer.’ Because you know it would imply to the asker that you make your money through and spend most of your time on writing which is not correct.

LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 07:41

KnittingNeedles
So your writing is your part time job and you look after the children. Iknow people who work part time for education companies writing content and resources. It's flexible and works around their children.

I'd say you're both writers/content creators/copywriters/something else linked to your particular area of writing.

It's a bit different to someone wanting to do their hobby, not earning anything for it/a little bit here and there, and then trying to present themselves as a professional in that area whilst someone else covers all the living expenses. They're not a professional jewellery maker/writer/musician, they're unemployed and are lucky to have a partner who is happy to fund the household so they can devote time to their hobby.

dimpleton · 19/04/2023 07:41

I know someone who calls himself a creative professional but refuses to get another job to supplement his income even though he lives hand to mouth on very meagre earnings. I find that more annoying than what he calls himself.

During the pandemic he didn't work at all and was moaning all over Facebook about lack of benefits support for people like him, even though he was fit and well enough to get a different job but chose not to as he felt it beneath him 🙄

Kanaloa · 19/04/2023 07:40

Realistically Van Gogh was a massive outlier though. It’s a bit like when people go on about how ‘x entrepreneur dropped out of school!’ Well yes, but so did Donna down the road from me who is now on benefits, or Jacob who went to uni in my class and now lives at home smoking weed. The majority of people who paint aren’t going to be Van Gogh.

KnittingNeedles · 19/04/2023 07:33

Gosh, so much sneering.

I am a freelance writer. That is what I do to earn cash, that is what does down on my tax return. I work part-time and always have done since my eldest was born - just as many other parents do. Probably about 12-15 hours a week. I don't "publish" anything, because it's not that sort of writing. People have a very narrow view that writing = novels and that's not the case, most of my income is from blog posts and I also have a gig creating multiple choice questions for quiz websites. I also volunteer regularly 4 hours a week, am just about to complete a MSc and am applying for a PhD, look after my kids and do loads of other things as well.

So let me get this straight, it's OK for someone who works 12 hours a week in Tesco to describe themselves as a checkout operator (even though that takes up a fraction of their working week), but someone who paints, makes jewellery, writes or similar is self-indulgent and deluded?

Happyhappyeveryday · 19/04/2023 07:32

Furthermore, let’s be honest, the most creative and prolific authors and artists in history were often supported by family money.

Happyhappyeveryday · 19/04/2023 07:30

I think you can call yourself whatever you wish.

Coxspurplepippin · 19/04/2023 07:27

People who call themselves 'Creatives' usually aren't.

LolaSmiles · 19/04/2023 07:26

@LolaSmilesReplace partner with brother and you have just described Van Gogh
Yes, and?
Isn't it generally accepted he only sold one painting in his lifetime?

He was in a fortunate position where someone else funded his living costs so he could do something he enjoyed.

It's not a statement about the quality of the paintings.

He wasn't a professional artist in his lifetime.

MRex · 19/04/2023 07:26

"Creative" isn't an issue as they clearly but that brief, it's "professional" that implies they earn money. If they only earn £10, they are still "professional", just not very good at it. I used to know an artist who was mostly lazy or drunk, culminating in a few wild weeks of working where he'd create something (often commissioned) and sell it for £10k-£15k. He probably only did 3 pieces per year. I don't know how you know how much your clients earn, but while it might not be a lot it may be more than you think.

mudonmyslipers · 19/04/2023 07:18

I don't mind what people call themselves as long as it's not 'thought leader'. 🤮
I absolutely will judge you for that!

JackiePlace · 19/04/2023 07:18

LolaSmiles · 18/04/2023 21:34

The part that's potentially misleading to me is the 'professional' part of 'creative professional'.

If someone said to me they were a creative professional, I would assume they were either experienced in their chosen field and setting up working freelance as a viable line of work, or they had an established business with a decent track record. Whether they had another income stream wouldn't come into it as having multiple income streams is common.

Hobby creatives who rely on their living costs funded by their partner whilst they earn very little and do little to develop their own business skills wouldn't be a "creative professional" to me. They're unemployed and doing stuff they enjoy.

Hobby creatives who rely on their living costs funded by their partner whilst they earn very little and do little to develop their own business skills wouldn't be a "creative professional" to me. They're unemployed and doing stuff they enjoy.

@LolaSmiles Replace partner with brother and you have just described Van Gogh.

JackiePlace · 19/04/2023 07:15

By OP's definition Vincent Van Gogh was not a creative professional.

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 19/04/2023 07:12

The deeper question to ask ourselves is why do we care so much about what people do in exchange for money, and not so much what they do for hobbies.

Its because the willingness of other people to pay you for what you do is a clear indicator of your skill/talent level at it. Has been since the prehistoric social evolutions that enable human beings living in groups to develop specialist skills beyond simple survival (eg hunting/gathering food, finding shelter & water etc).

Also for me there's a thing about laziness. A lot of these people want paying to do their hobby rather than support themselves with an actual job that needs doing. Yes it would be fun to just play guitar and sing all day wouldnt it, but hard working people do a useful job besides like being a nurse or a fireman.

It gets more annoying when people self indulgently have a hobby profession earning the bare minimum and then survive topped up by benefits, rather than taking the hit like everyone else and getting a job. It's about sharing the social load & doing your bit to support yourself if you are able to.

Dithyramb · 18/04/2023 23:21

ModestMoon · 18/04/2023 23:11

Like others, I think that the "professional" bit is misleading. But whether it's ok to say "I'm an author" depends entirely on context. If someone asks you what you do and it's heavily implied that they mean for work, then it's misleading. If someone asks you what you like doing, then I think it's fine. Some things are obviously not someone's main source of income, and sound fine to state "I'm a Morris dancer", for example. Also if you're talking to people who know your job then of course it's fine, if a colleague said "I'm an artist" I wouldn't assume that she meant she made money from it.

The deeper question to ask ourselves is why do we care so much about what people do in exchange for money, and not so much what they do for hobbies. I think it's because on some level it's an indicator of their worth and wealth, and we're secretly trying to place people in a social hierarchy. That's why "creative professional" feels deceitful, because it makes you place them somewhere on the social hierarchy that they don't really belong to.

But I don’t think the people the OP is talking about are using the phrase ‘creative professional’ — that’s her catch-all phrase for them. I imagine these people are saying ‘I’m a musician’ or ‘I’m a novelist’, not ‘I’m a creative professional’.

ModestMoon · 18/04/2023 23:11

Like others, I think that the "professional" bit is misleading. But whether it's ok to say "I'm an author" depends entirely on context. If someone asks you what you do and it's heavily implied that they mean for work, then it's misleading. If someone asks you what you like doing, then I think it's fine. Some things are obviously not someone's main source of income, and sound fine to state "I'm a Morris dancer", for example. Also if you're talking to people who know your job then of course it's fine, if a colleague said "I'm an artist" I wouldn't assume that she meant she made money from it.

The deeper question to ask ourselves is why do we care so much about what people do in exchange for money, and not so much what they do for hobbies. I think it's because on some level it's an indicator of their worth and wealth, and we're secretly trying to place people in a social hierarchy. That's why "creative professional" feels deceitful, because it makes you place them somewhere on the social hierarchy that they don't really belong to.