Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Illegal chinese "police stations"

38 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 18/04/2023 11:36

Who does this? Tries to set up secret police stations in other countries to try and control ex pats? This is insanity. How does anyone think they will get away with it? These links are for information of such "police stations" in USA and Netherlands, but I wonder how many others are yet to be uncovered

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-65305415

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0d9p822

Lu Jianwang attends a Brooklyn courthouse

FBI makes arrests over alleged secret Chinese 'police stations' in New York

China has previously denied running secret police stations overseas, calling them "service centres".

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-65305415

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
1dayatatime · 18/04/2023 22:15

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

"Remind me how many people did the US help kill in their various "operations" across the world? How many were dissappear to black sites and "interrogated" or held for years without charge?"

++++

This comment really intrigued me. You see most people around the world want to think well of themselves and of the country they live in. Except that is in the West where there is a behaviour of self criticism, self distrust and effectively self abuse that is only made possible through liberal political values that allow freedom of speech.

A behaviour that countries outside the West (in particular China) are happy to encourage for their own benefit.

Returning to your post, you are of course through the freedom of speech in a western society allowed to criticise actions taken by western governments. A freedom of speech that incidentally doesn't exist in China.

In any event the numbers of detainees that the US may or may not have killed in their "black ops" certainly pales into insignificance compared to the 30 million deaths in the Chinese cultural revolution under Mao, which is more than Hitler or Stalin.

1dayatatime · 18/04/2023 21:50

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

"Nimbostratus100
yes, I really think they don't!

Well that's naive. The UK has extradition treaties with over 100 countries, as do the US. If you do something the US/UK don't like, even if living overseas/a foreign national, they can (and do) come after you"

+++

Well that's just factually incorrect.

An extradition treaty requires that a country seeking extradition has to be able to show that: The relevant crime is sufficiently serious. There exists a prima facie case against the individual sought. The event in question qualifies as a crime in both countries.

Crimes that are exceptions to extradition are pure political offences include crimes such as treason, espionage, and sedition. In most cases, there is no duty to extradite for pure political offences, and there is agreement that the political offence exception applies to these offences.

Username84 · 18/04/2023 20:34

It's also worth having a look into the belt and road policy which is designed to basically make china a soft power all round the world. Once they control huge amounts of the infrastructure worldwide through things like loans to build it they'll have a lot more influence to do things like this. Pick a place that's tactically important and look at the developments recently. Where has the money come from? For instance they own a huge amount of the places mining the key ingredients for batteries and they have a huge amount of influence over the Panama canal that huge amounts of imports worldwide go through now the US have stepped back. The more you look the worse it gets.

Since we're on the topic of what the Chinese government do with this power, the same CCP in charge now where responsible for things like the great leap forward which killed over 45million of their own people (conservative estimate, likely to be much higher). They cut back on the number of concentration camps a couple of decades ago to about 10% of the original number of camps but we've all seen the expansion work to those so I've no idea if the number of people reduced. Where do you think the cheap Chinese labour comes from? Who do you think was making the made in china things like masks and COVID tests when their citizens were locked down?

It's terrifying to see the growth of this. I wouldn't be surprised if the boundary pushing like this doesn't lead to WW3.

Nimbostratus100 · 18/04/2023 19:44

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/04/2023 12:31

Well that's naive. The UK has extradition treaties with over 100 countries, as do the US. If you do something the US/UK don't like, even if living overseas/a foreign national, they can (and do) come after you.

there is a huge difference between going through formal, legal channels, and setting up your own illegal police station! and trying to impose your own laws secretly in another state

OP posts:
cosmiccosmos · 18/04/2023 16:50

It isn't just the Chinese though is it, a number of religions seem to think they can just impose their own 'laws'. The UK is a soft touch, its under the guise of inclusion and cultural acceptance.

PollyPeptide · 18/04/2023 16:26

I want to minimise it because its a non-story. There's been a notable increase in the amount of anti China rhetoric coming out of the West recently, and most of it is solely designed to stir up division and distract people from western governments failure.

If you travelled round the world and saw their influence and how they are building up military bases, I hope you'd be less quick to minimise stories of Chinese control and brutality spreading outside the PRC. If the Chinese themselves actually had full rights, they'd be at the forefront of speaking about Chinese govt failure. Instead, critics are just hauled away to gaol.
But yes, let's keep quiet about all that so we can talk about Sunak's wife's investment in Koru Kids.

notimagain · 18/04/2023 16:23

@greenteafiend

The British Embassy where I live couldn't be more oblivious to Brits overseas. I have yet to work out what they actually DO, because you can't actually go in in person and speak to them about anything whatsoever, they don't answer the phone, don't hold events or get involved in Brits' stuff in any way whatsoever,

Very very much our experience as well, they seem to exist pretty much exclusively to try and facilitate diplomatic, business and trade links...they don't give a stuff about Brits in country outside of that.

The only embassy staff get close to anything that could be described as policing is if they get called in because somebody has fallen foul of the local cops...

The Chinese system sounds like something much more intrusive and sinister.

CalistoNoSolo · 18/04/2023 16:18

The Chinese govts actions abroad and at home are indefensible. They really are vile :(

SerendipityJane · 18/04/2023 16:07

On a global scale, if we (i.e. the UK and other supposed democracies) don't ensure the bully boy tactics of the Chinese fail at every step, then in the long run our own leaders will think that's alright then.

CuriousMoo · 18/04/2023 15:31

Did you know that the CCP forces women in Xinjiang to live with and sometimes sleep with Han Chinese civil servants, after their own husbands have been taken to concentration camps? It's a public government programme.

That they have QR codes on their front doors so any government official can check immediately who they are, when they pray, whether they drink alcohol and more.

That the kids have been kidnapped and put in government run boarding schools where they are forced to study propaganda and banned from speaking their own language.

That Muslims in Xinjiang must install spyware on their phones so the CCP can track them at all times.

That the Chinese government has developed racially profiling facial recognition software and installed checkpoints to track their movements.

Women have been forcibly sterilised.

People who've escaped have been kidnapped aboard and taken to China and put into camps.

It's a living nightmare for the Uyghur people right now.

CuriousMoo · 18/04/2023 15:24

CalistoNoSolo · 18/04/2023 15:15

The anti-china rhetoric is because Xi and the CCP are violent thugs who have a frightening amount of control over way too many countries finances. Because they steal from, spy on and attempt to destabilise the west. Because they have designs on other sovereign nations that they think should be theirs. Because they are allies of such delightful people as Putin and Kim Jong Un. Is that enough for your genocide-apologist mind?

Yeah there's always one who defends brutal dictators and actually thinks they are right to do so. Weird really.

CalistoNoSolo · 18/04/2023 15:15

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/04/2023 12:31

I didn't say all citizens, I highly doubt the Chinese government have trackers on the 5.4million Chinese diaspora in the US but they'll no doubt be scanning and surveying for individuals who pique their intrest. The same way SIS, SS, GCHQ, DI, NCA, etc, all work together to keep tabs on what British nationals of intrest are up to whether home or abroad.

Remind me how many people did the US help kill in their various "operations" across the world? How many were dissappear to black sites and "interrogated" or held for years without charge?

I want to minimise it because its a non-story. There's been a notable increase in the amount of anti China rhetoric coming out of the West recently, and most of it is solely designed to stir up division and distract people from western governments failure.

The anti-china rhetoric is because Xi and the CCP are violent thugs who have a frightening amount of control over way too many countries finances. Because they steal from, spy on and attempt to destabilise the west. Because they have designs on other sovereign nations that they think should be theirs. Because they are allies of such delightful people as Putin and Kim Jong Un. Is that enough for your genocide-apologist mind?

SerendipityJane · 18/04/2023 15:10

I doubt a judge is going to sign an extradition warrant and it'll be upheld just because the uk govt doesn't like something.

Have you seen the US-UK extradition treaty ? All we need is a nod from a US judge and that's it. You is off to the land of the free my friend.

The treaty has been claimed to be one-sided[3] because it allows the US to demand extradition of British citizens and other nationals for offences committed against US law, even though the alleged offence may have been committed in the UK by a person living and working in the UK (see for example the NatWest Three), and there being no reciprocal right; and issues about the level of proof required to extradite from the UK to the US versus from the US to the UK.[4]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK%E2%80%93US_extradition_treaty_of_2003

NatWest Three - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NatWest_Three

PollyPeptide · 18/04/2023 14:55

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/04/2023 12:31

Well that's naive. The UK has extradition treaties with over 100 countries, as do the US. If you do something the US/UK don't like, even if living overseas/a foreign national, they can (and do) come after you.

If you break a uk law, surely they should come after you. I doubt a judge is going to sign an extradition warrant and it'll be upheld just because the uk govt doesn't like something.

greenteafiend · 18/04/2023 13:06

Nimbostratus100 · 18/04/2023 11:47

yes, I really think they don't!

Ha. The British Embassy where I live couldn't be more oblivious to Brits overseas. I have yet to work out what they actually DO, because you can't actually go in in person and speak to them about anything whatsoever, they don't answer the phone, don't hold events or get involved in Brits' stuff in any way whatsoever, and emailing them just results in getting a standard copy-and-paste reply saying "We don't handle [insert literally every service an Embassy could be expected to provide]. Please take care of it yourself/read our website again/fuck off and die." Things like passports you do yourself with online forms and posting stuff to the relevant offices in the UK.

CuriousMoo · 18/04/2023 12:49

Why is this thread already degenerating into whateraboutery?

("Never mind this terrible thing that you started a thread about, what about this other (hypothetical, unproven) terrible thing??")

If you want to discuss UK authoritarianism, maybe start another thread about that.

This one is about the abuse of Chinese people by their government.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/04/2023 12:31

CalistoNoSolo · 18/04/2023 11:54

The UK govt and border forces have zero clue who is currently in the UK so I highly doubt that they have any clue what most of their citizens are doing while abroad. The US undoubtedly has the ability but I highly doubt they monitor all of their citizens abroad. The Chinese govt on the other hand, is secretive, authoritarian and happy to use torture and genocide on its own citizens. Why do you want to minimise this news story?

I didn't say all citizens, I highly doubt the Chinese government have trackers on the 5.4million Chinese diaspora in the US but they'll no doubt be scanning and surveying for individuals who pique their intrest. The same way SIS, SS, GCHQ, DI, NCA, etc, all work together to keep tabs on what British nationals of intrest are up to whether home or abroad.

Remind me how many people did the US help kill in their various "operations" across the world? How many were dissappear to black sites and "interrogated" or held for years without charge?

I want to minimise it because its a non-story. There's been a notable increase in the amount of anti China rhetoric coming out of the West recently, and most of it is solely designed to stir up division and distract people from western governments failure.

SerendipityJane · 18/04/2023 12:31

It's already happened, hasn't it ? The Chinese consulate in Manchester tried to kidnap a protestor and it was only the fact that the idiots at GMP hadn't got the memo (I bet they have now) that meant their officers went and rescued him.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clash_at_the_Consulate_General_of_China,_Manchester

Given how needy the UK has become of late and the lack of any moral compass in our own leaders, I have zero confidence that we will be able to resist this innovation. Which given we are dealing with a country whose leader is upset at being compared to Winnie the Pooh, isn't a great feeling.

Incidentally I notice the US acted as they have laws against this sort of thing. I wonder if the UK does ? I mean proper laws that can be quoted, not some flimflam from whoever is on press duty today.

Clash at the Consulate General of China, Manchester - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clash_at_the_Consulate_General_of_China,_Manchester

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/04/2023 12:31

Nimbostratus100 · 18/04/2023 11:47

yes, I really think they don't!

Well that's naive. The UK has extradition treaties with over 100 countries, as do the US. If you do something the US/UK don't like, even if living overseas/a foreign national, they can (and do) come after you.

ComtesseDeSpair · 18/04/2023 12:20

The USA is similarly laid back about their citizens except trying to tax them overseas!

It may sound a bit tinfoil hat, but a lot of Americans believe that this has a lot less to do with actual tax receipts as it does enabling the US government to monitor its citizens overseas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread