Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers?

215 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:29

The 8 month sleep regression is hitting us hard, so I might be more sensitive than usual as I’m exhausted.

However, as I try and resettle my baby, I can’t help but question how women are expected to do it all. How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home. The maths doesn’t add up and I feel like along the way of empowering women, things have changed but to just expecting women to do more than what’s actually manageable.

I think the first issue is the length of maternity leave and how long it’s financially supported (plus the ridiculously little amount maternity pay actually is).
Why can women take up to 12 months off, but only paid for 9 months? One of my arguments for a longer, financially supported maternity leave is that our babies need to get their main source of nutrition from milk for the first 12 months, so why doesn’t society support women being off for that long? There’s probably more arguments in the emotional support of babies being raised by their parents, instead of childcare, but too tired to look into this.
Luckily, we saved enough before having our baby to support me being off for 12 months, but baby needs me right now at 8 months and I can’t imagine putting them into childcare at 9 months, or even earlier.

The other issue I’m struggling to wrap my head around is how I’m expected to go back to work and give 100% whilst trying to be a mother. Parenting is exhausting, relentless and I can’t picture my life where I’m meant to give my all to work whilst trying to give my best to my child. Surely something will have to give, but with the cost of living my career can’t slip as we need me working, so naturally it’s seeing less of my child by working full time and having them be raised and looked after by nursery.

So, AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers? Surely there’s a better compromise than the current set up of maternity leave and more support from employers towards parents?

OP posts:
Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 10:03

Where I live parents are entitled to 480 days of paid parental leave when a child is born or adopted. Each parent is entitled to 240 of those days. Fathers average at least around 30 per cent of all paid parental leave. Works well. If need to take days off to care for a sick child, there is compensation and the days are basically unlimited but a doctor’s certificate is required after one week. So there are ways for society to do it, but it’s based on taxes which is absolutely fine.

Triffid1 · 18/04/2023 10:00

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 07:48

A lot of posts are mentioning my lack of me talking about my husband, but he does fairly split things. Our responsibilities in the home are often split, encourages me to meet up with friends without the baby and he steps up, so I can’t complain but I do still think there’s an expectation for mums to have it all together and do it all.

But you specifically said he can't be tired because he's a teacher!?

Honestly, I think you might be sleepwalking into a situation where he's great at "helping" but you're the one taking on all the actual responsibility and mental load and you'll get more and more stressed as a result.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 10:00

Tbh, I think the 'shared parental leave doesn't always work out the best financially' is sometimes used as an excuse by mums who simply don't want to hand over any of the leave to the other parent. There have been comments from some posters on other threads actually being quite up front and saying 'no way am I sharing any of my leave.'

Even if financially it might mean a little less money for a few months, tbh, some things are more important than cash. Imagine a scenario where the mum transfers the last 3 months of ML to the dad. Dad gets to fully experience being the sole carer. Mum is eased back into work with the other parent at home, which is undoubtedly easier than getting everyone out the house and starting nursery drop offs at the same time as starting back at work. And, most importantly imo, I suspect that there are long lasting advantages to the family when the dad has had a period of time as the sole carer. When he's had a few months of doing all the caring, making meals, changing nappies, playing, doing to baby classes, he's going to have real insight into the role and is far less likely to slip back into just seeing himself as the 'earner.' It's a win win for the whole family. If transferable leave had been an option when we had kids, we'd have jumped at it, as even if there was a very short term financial downside, I believe the benefits I've described far outweigh any downsides

ilovesooty · 18/04/2023 09:43

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 08:27

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I’ve no idea what the solution is. If I did, I’d run for PM and maybe, hopefully make the UK a better place.

I think if I had to take a punt it would be to introduce better maternity pay so parents can take off longer if they wanted, childcare that doesn’t cost as much or more than a mortgage (£1,300 here and our mortgage is £1,100 but we can’t move away due to work), lower pension age so grandparents can help out (a lot of my friends all have the same issue as our parents are still working FT), longer paternity because 2 weeks is a joke.

Yes, there’s shared parental leave but it doesn’t always work out the best solution financially.

The childcare is a fair point, but how do you finance the rest? And do childless / free people have to retire later?
And it's not anyone else's concern how shared parental leave works out financially.

Catspyjamas17 · 18/04/2023 09:35

Yes, I agree on the whole. I think the issue is that some/a lot of men haven't stepped up in the home to make things more equal, and also arguably employers still make it harder for men to be part time or to work flexibly around kids. There is still an expectation that it will be the woman doing this. Which is also rather heteronormative too. Partly it's because of biology and who becomes the primary carer to start with. But we should really be working towards a society where everyone can do paid work for fewer hours for a good salary and make ends meet. This would allow more people to be economically active whether they are parents, carers, or have disabilities and health conditions. At the moment due to the cost of living crisis, and crisis after crisis meaning the super rich acquire more wealth and everyone else has to make do with less, society is going the wrong way and people are having to do two or three jobs to make ends meet. And what should be good professional jobs such as nursing or teaching have fallen way behind in terms of salaries.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 09:34

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting it's interesting that the solution you suggest is to make paid ML even longer. In other words, you want to place responsibility for children even more on the mother rather than both parents.

Even with the advances over recent decades, women still lag behind men in earnings, despite the fact that at all levels of education, females outperform males. Suggesting that women have even longer out of the work place would be a retrograde step. It will make things worse for women in the long run.

As I said, I think the balance now is about right. Up to a year's leave is available, childcare is heavily subsidised from age 3 with plans in place to subsidise it from even younger. Mums can transfer leave to the child's father. If you made ML any longer, you'd probably have a situation where women were taking full leave, returning to work for a month or so and then embarking on another ML for child number 2. Businesses can't sustain that. It's not about saying business is more important than children; it's about understanding that for society to function effectively, all aspects need to be considered.

I also think the bf is a red herring, particularly with the length ML is now. Even if you only take the paid 9 months, the child will be on solid food too, not totally dependent on bm. And thousands of women continue bf long term after returning to work anyway. The correlation between education/ social status of the mother and bf is far more significant than whether the mum works. I'm not saying that in a judgemental way, it's just a fact. I worked in a professional role and continued bf when I returned to work with a 12 week old baby, as did many of my colleagues. Conversely, there were women in my hospital ante natal group who didn't return to work and didn't bf. It's disingenuous to use the bf argument as a reason for women not to return to work.

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting it does sound like you're feeling overwhelmed right now and god knows, the baby years are tough, but the solution is not to try to heap even more responsibility onto mums. It's to acknowledge that every child has two parents and if you want an equal relationship where earning/caring/housework/cooking is shared, then it's up to you as a couple to make that happen.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 09:24

I never expected to parent 100%.

I'm not a single parent.

I also don't think parents have to do everything themselves. Takes a village and all that.

I think a years mat leave is excessive and would much rather there was better paternity leave

I absolutely don't agree with the parent as if you dont work thing.

It is possible to do both.

I have a great work life balance with time for everything

Ingrowncrotchhair · 18/04/2023 09:21

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 07:11

@Hedwigharlot he doesn’t do the night wakes as I BF and that’s the quickest and easiest thing to our baby back to sleep.

from your logic, women shouldn’t do the most natural thing and breastfeed to try and get more sleep? That’s a strange opinion.

Not strange at all. We certainly planned on mixed feeding so I would be more than source of food and sustenance for baby, be able to rest and so my partner could experience feeding/baby experience father feeding him and their bond benefit from that.

as it was, I didn’t produce any milk so FF but that was the plan

NoSquirrels · 18/04/2023 09:15

But honestly, if you took 1000 mothers with 12 month old babies and told them they and dad had the same salary and progression opportunities, and 150% earnings was enough - and they could choose to be full time, the only part time 50% parent, or 75% each… how many do you think would choose each?

Oh, interesting. I would think choosing anything but 75% each would be weird in this scenario. Neither of the other options are better, after all?

Testina · 18/04/2023 09:11

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/04/2023 08:54

It’s also expected by “society” these days that fathers pull their weight

No one ever asks fathers if they are planning to return to work full time after their baby arrives.

A minimal amount of fathers (I'd love to see actual stats on this) put their careers on hold/slow down when kids arrive as they need to do more on the home front.

How many men do you know who work part time so they can do childcare? As in actually part time. And how many women?

No one asks dads how they plan to cover childcare during school holidays. A vanishingly small number of men take annual leave while their wife works full time to cover the kids being off school.

Men aren't told to keep their hand in at work in case their wives leave them to parent alone.

Mumsnet is not a reflective cross section of society.

All fair points.

BUT…

When women say, or post on here, that they need more from their baby’s father how many of them mean that they want him to stop work, or take a long leave? How many of them want the father to go part time or not further their career (by which we all just mean: earn more money)?

How many women actually want a SAHD or for dad to be the one that does all of the above, instead of them?

Definitely some! But honestly, if you took 1000 mothers with 12 month old babies and told them they and dad had the same salary and progression opportunities, and 150% earnings was enough - and they could choose to be full time, the only part time 50% parent, or 75% each… how many do you think would choose each?

Personally: we both chose 100% long term and banked the cash, and used childcare.

Interestingly, I work in a European team. Whilst no-one asks the dads if they’re coming back, they don’t ask that of the mums either. They do ask what parental leave they’ll take - when they are German and Swedish. (that’s not a full survey, but from my team, that’s male colleagues who have been off for 2-6 months)

BitOutOfPractice · 18/04/2023 09:09

Oh I dunno @NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting ! Because women have been talking about this for generations? Because you’ve met another mother before? Because you don’t go around with your head up your arse completely unaware and unempathetic of what other people’s lives are like? 😂

Katypp · 18/04/2023 09:05

While I agree largely with the OP, I do think there has been a large switch in expectations since maternity leave was extended in the UK. I also think the current baby-led trope is somewhat the blame too.
I posted on another thread yesterday about how young mothers are running themselves into the ground to accommodate a baby instead of taking control and trying to get things to work for them. The whole ethos needs to change back to what's best for the mother, not what's best for the baby or we are heading IMO for a mental health crisis. This post sort of illustrates the issues.
The long maternity leave makes things worse, because there is now no hurry to deal with sleep etc as there used to be.
Although the emphasis is on the baby not the mum, new mums are so revered now, as if they have done something special and amazing, that they lose sight that there are many babies born every year. To the family, a new baby is amazing and a joy but to an employer, not so much. They see the new family as one of many.
It is absolutely not the employer's responsibility to fund more time off so women are paid to do the job they are not doing. That's ridiculous.
Social media is also to blame for feeding the line is all about milky cuddles, making memories and mumma bear. It's not.
Women are putting ridiculous expectation upon themselves. Based on social media (including MN) it is implied that it is possible to be a CEO, have a perfect home, be the best mother ever and always be immaculately groomed. It's crazy

2muchtimeonline · 18/04/2023 09:03

Honestly you probably feel like people are hopping on you, and I know you are exhausted. But most of us are a little further down the journey. You can't change teh world but you can change you. And the main thing is make him do half. Even if you don't want to go back to work full time or WFh, do not become the parent who knows everything because you'll be stuck like that. It creeps up on you - you finally send him to the doctor with the kid and he still rings and says 'does she have all her jabs' because you 'know' stuff like that. And so it continues. You are at the very start, you can make that change now! Your OH is a teacher, wonderful. That's all your school holidays sorted. Many women opt for teaching specifically so they can cover the school hols. So tell him to step up. Do not WFH during the school holidays, go into the office footloose and fancy free knowing there is a primary parent in the house. For all those weeks a year you can be the employee who doesn't have to rush off, what freedom! Make sure he does some of the doctor visits, the getting up at night sick, the reading the back of the Calpol box. Hey, even the surfing mumsnet to see what car seat to move up to. If enough people did that then we'd see a change. Good luck. The baby years are horrendous but they pass. And kids are great ;)

Testina · 18/04/2023 09:01

As for part time work and the impact on pensions / career.

I became a mother in my 30s. My child is now 15, and has a local group of friends I’ve know all through the primary years - and their parents.

Out of 8 mothers, I am the only one who works full time. These kids are 15 - this is not a childcare issue 🤣 We all went back to work, I was 4 days for a year then up to full time again. They all kept their 2,3,4 day contracts permanently. Most are in well paid jobs, two of them are quite senior. Several have been promoted. Several were previously the higher earner. All have husbands (first or second) so have some protection in case of divorce. There is no SEN - they’re all still part time because as a family they can afford it, and they simply bloody love it!

That is only one (very lucky) section of society.
But don’t go around thinking that all women are forced into career-wrecking pension-decimating part time roles because of childcare costs or sleep deprivation. Or because “society” told them to. Some of them are happy as a pig in shit!

Whatafustercluck · 18/04/2023 08:59

Do you have a dp/ dh, op? I'm not asking to be provocative and I do understand much of what you're saying. But women who 'want it all' need partners who will support them to achieve that. The daily grind of work, childcare and housework takes two. Before women get involved with and eventually marry someone, they should be having open conversations about children. If their ambitions and aspirations are incompatible, then one partner inevitably ends up 'settling' or otherwise getting burned out from trying to do it all.

But yes, even if you do have a partner who shoulders much of the burden, there are still many challenges for women. I truly believe that it isn't possible to have it all, every day and every week is about trying to achieve as much balance as possible but it is always an imperfect fit. The choices you make personally can make that easier of course. And things do get easier again once the children are older, the key is to keep your career from stagnating while they're little.

In the UK we're actually pretty fortunate - paid mat leave, shared parental leave, flexible working arrangements, 30 hours of free childcare etc. Compare this to the US.

Women who want to have it all need to make the right personal choices first and foremost. And accept that for a while at least, there is no perfect fit, only best fit.

LotsofVikings · 18/04/2023 08:59

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/04/2023 08:54

It’s also expected by “society” these days that fathers pull their weight

No one ever asks fathers if they are planning to return to work full time after their baby arrives.

A minimal amount of fathers (I'd love to see actual stats on this) put their careers on hold/slow down when kids arrive as they need to do more on the home front.

How many men do you know who work part time so they can do childcare? As in actually part time. And how many women?

No one asks dads how they plan to cover childcare during school holidays. A vanishingly small number of men take annual leave while their wife works full time to cover the kids being off school.

Men aren't told to keep their hand in at work in case their wives leave them to parent alone.

Mumsnet is not a reflective cross section of society.

Spot on.

ShivRoy2nd · 18/04/2023 08:58

I don’t think women need more maternity I think men need more paternity / flexibility. It’s a cultural thing. My DH works for a small company. He is entitled to 7 weeks paternity leave (unpaid) but he said no men in his company had ever taken it including a colleague who had a baby a year before us and how there would be no one to cover work if a long period of time was taken off. I encouraged DH to bring this up with the owner. He ended up taking 8 weeks off when baby arrived - half annual leave, half paternity. Lo and behold the other colleague is now expecting a baby again and he told DH he plans to ask for the same time off a DH had. It took DH being brave enough (yes brave -culture in these companies around men taking time off is poor despite being permitted legally) to ask to change his colleagues views. I presume now any other men who are expecting babies will do same. This will help the mothers. DH next step is to ask for a 4 day week to help share the load when I go back to work. Again he is nervous but going to do it.

however these are men who step up and actually parent. More paternity is no good if fathers are how I sometimes see on mumsnet and think it’s time off to repaint the garden shed.

PretzelBite · 18/04/2023 08:56

Yes, a lot is expected of women who are mothers and as we gain more equality and independence we access more opportunities. Taking all these opportunities means spreading ourselves thinner and thinner which takes its toll if we get no respite and have young children at home. We are also increasingly widespread, away from family support or parents are still working so cannot provide as much help. This will only continue to get harder. I think we will see a lot more childfree by choice women or one child families in the next few decades.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/04/2023 08:54

It’s also expected by “society” these days that fathers pull their weight

No one ever asks fathers if they are planning to return to work full time after their baby arrives.

A minimal amount of fathers (I'd love to see actual stats on this) put their careers on hold/slow down when kids arrive as they need to do more on the home front.

How many men do you know who work part time so they can do childcare? As in actually part time. And how many women?

No one asks dads how they plan to cover childcare during school holidays. A vanishingly small number of men take annual leave while their wife works full time to cover the kids being off school.

Men aren't told to keep their hand in at work in case their wives leave them to parent alone.

Mumsnet is not a reflective cross section of society.

AncientToaster · 18/04/2023 08:51

I BF but it’s the only thing they can’t do, they can change the nappy and resettle. Be careful you don’t become subsumed by motherhood. Most of my friends and I all now have kids teens to early twenties. One let that happen to her and her partner was rubbish. The youngest is about to go off to University and she is a totally lost empty nester who said I don’t know who I am to me recently, it was incredibly sad.

Sounds like your partner isn’t pulling their weight. It’s either because he is crap or you just feel compelled to do it all.

Morningdewy · 18/04/2023 08:51

Men as a class need to step up. None of this refusing to get up in they night because they might be tired at work, none of this dumping the domestic load on their wives/partners, more men need to be doing their fair share of household jobs, their fair share of childcare, sharing parental leave, going part time.

As soon as more men have to start doing their fair share, things will start to change, but any progress will be at snail pace because as you can see from lots of MN threads, too many men think it's not their problem

This I think is borne out of women generally driving the wish to have children. I accept there are men who actively want to have kids but I think the reality is many are ambivalent about it. Love them when they arrive of course but see it more as the woman’s domain. It’s not right, they shouldn’t have kids just to indulge their partner’s desire but I think it’s what happens.

The older I get, the more I realise the inherent nature of men is unchangeable

NoSquirrels · 18/04/2023 08:51

But poor sleeping 8 month old babies are a PITA, so I’m not surprised you’re looking at the idea of going back to work and thinking Bloody hell, how? But you’ll get through it when it happens, honestly.

LolaSmiles · 18/04/2023 08:50

Haha. Best for the baby? No - Best for they employer and capitalism? Yes.
Lol at them thinking about the baby.
Agreed. A country that cares so much about children they think the solution to the mass shooting of children is more guns and expects mothers to leave their newborn at a few weeks old isn't a country that cares about children at a policy level

Testina · 18/04/2023 08:49

“How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home.”

This is just martyred nonsense though, not “society” forcing this on you.

No, you’re not expected to give 100% of yourself to a new mothering role. It’s perfectly socially acceptable to combine it with work (yes, you’re 100% still a mother, but you’re not putting 100% of your time into it). It’s also totally acceptable socially to get a babysitter or leave your baby with their father or other relatives to go out with friends. It’s also expected by “society” these days that fathers pull their weight. Not by all individuals and I’m not saying it happens -but generally, that is the societal expectation. As for “running a home” - if you want to see a reflection of the general view in society, then post on here that you can’t keep up with dusting because your baby song sleep, and society will tell you to fuck the fucking housework 🤷🏻‍♀️

These are your choices.

Does having a baby mean you have to compromise on time available to clean or party? Well yeah - no shit Sherlock! Babies are a choice. You don’t get a dog then acted surprised when you have to walk it and still do your food shop.

Society is not telling you to give 100% of you to each of motherhood, social life and running a house. That’s on you if you feel that. I certainly never did.

As for work… well, they’re paying you so yes, you should give 100% during that paid time. And that isn’t always easy. But how can you say society just expects that?
There’s maternity leave (much of it paid) with employment protection as well as money.
There’s the right to make flexible working requests.
It’s very common for returners to choose to work part time.
There is emergency parental leave.

Now I’m not saying that means every woman’s experience is perfect, there’s still a ridiculous amount of discrimination. But you can’t say that “society” demands 100% for work when society (in the form of what the state will champion and pay for) provides all those things.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 08:49

@BitOutOfPractice please tell me how you can experience the true exhaustion and relentless of parenthood before becoming a parent?

Obviously I considered what life would be like once I would be going to work, but I don’t think you ever understand what having a baby is like without having a baby.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread