Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers?

215 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:29

The 8 month sleep regression is hitting us hard, so I might be more sensitive than usual as I’m exhausted.

However, as I try and resettle my baby, I can’t help but question how women are expected to do it all. How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home. The maths doesn’t add up and I feel like along the way of empowering women, things have changed but to just expecting women to do more than what’s actually manageable.

I think the first issue is the length of maternity leave and how long it’s financially supported (plus the ridiculously little amount maternity pay actually is).
Why can women take up to 12 months off, but only paid for 9 months? One of my arguments for a longer, financially supported maternity leave is that our babies need to get their main source of nutrition from milk for the first 12 months, so why doesn’t society support women being off for that long? There’s probably more arguments in the emotional support of babies being raised by their parents, instead of childcare, but too tired to look into this.
Luckily, we saved enough before having our baby to support me being off for 12 months, but baby needs me right now at 8 months and I can’t imagine putting them into childcare at 9 months, or even earlier.

The other issue I’m struggling to wrap my head around is how I’m expected to go back to work and give 100% whilst trying to be a mother. Parenting is exhausting, relentless and I can’t picture my life where I’m meant to give my all to work whilst trying to give my best to my child. Surely something will have to give, but with the cost of living my career can’t slip as we need me working, so naturally it’s seeing less of my child by working full time and having them be raised and looked after by nursery.

So, AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers? Surely there’s a better compromise than the current set up of maternity leave and more support from employers towards parents?

OP posts:
Satsumastocking · 18/04/2023 11:52

It's appalling, but Mumsnet is very extremely right-wing and against people actually spending time bringing up children or being in families and communities, instead very pro capitalist.

Obviously a system where we expect mostly women to look after society's children in low paid jobs while parents go to work elsewhere is both sexist and divisive. Pretending having children is a "choice" rather than how humans, in fact all animals, exist, is disingenuous at best.

Whataretheyfeedingyou · 18/04/2023 11:46

No one can give 100% to a full time job and 100% to being a full time parent, at the same time. (Yet look at any thread where SAHMs are mentioned and there are always women who turn up saying "well don't you think working women do all that too?" in an attempt to put the SAHMs down..) No one person can honestly do it all on their own. In my opinion @Botw1 has the right idea in saying both work and childcare should be shared equally, but, in reality, how many men are there who are willing to do that? How many employers are willing to let people work as flexibly as that? How many jobs where you can? Yes OP too much is expected of women.

WandaWonder · 18/04/2023 11:38

Blaming society is lazy if you have problems with a partner blame the partner not 'society made them that way'

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 11:38

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 11:36

These threads are always full of people saying its ridiculous that both parents are expected to work or that 1 full time wage should be enough to support an entire family.

I just dont understand this thinking at all.

In a household of 2 adults, both should be working to support the family.

Reduced hours and flexible working, better paternity leave and childcare provision should also be standard

But not a whole family financed by 1 adult

100% this. And it’s quite possible too.

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 11:37

lower pension age so grandparents can help out (a lot of my friends all have the same issue as our parents are still working FT

One more example, here gp’s who work can stay at home with sick gc instead of the parents, fully paid. My colleague is currently at home with one of her gc.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 11:36

These threads are always full of people saying its ridiculous that both parents are expected to work or that 1 full time wage should be enough to support an entire family.

I just dont understand this thinking at all.

In a household of 2 adults, both should be working to support the family.

Reduced hours and flexible working, better paternity leave and childcare provision should also be standard

But not a whole family financed by 1 adult

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 11:33

It hasn’t been a secret in years/decades how things are. Why now demand more leave?.

Because it’s in the child’s best interest. Because society has changed since decades ago. Because it’s quite possible to better things, look at other models like Scandinavia.

There is no way I’d be made feeling guilty staying at home with a sick child, even if it’s 15 times a year. No way my dh would not share half of the care. Or domestic chores for that matter. It takes time, but it can be done even in a traditional country like the UK. Many of you seem to want a change, now you need to demand it not just want it.

HoppingPavlova · 18/04/2023 11:29

No idea what societal expectations you refer to, what you describe seem to be personal ones.

I think if I had to take a punt it would be to introduce better maternity pay so parents can take off longer if they wanted
Surely encouraging people to plan for children and not have them unless/until they could afford whatever maternity length they want would be best? Otherwise, where does this money come from?

childcare that doesn’t cost as much or more than a mortgage (£1,300 here and our mortgage is £1,100 but we can’t move away due to work
Surely encouraging people to plan for the cost of childcare if they wish/need to use it would be best? Surely it’s not a surprise to people. The only exception I can think of is multiples, if they are a genuine surprise. In that case I see an argument for high subsidy where you basically pay what you would have for one. Treatment where more than one embryo is transferred does not constitute a surprise, that’s a choice. Again, where would this money come from?

lower pension age so grandparents can help out (a lot of my friends all have the same issue as our parents are still working FT
This one’s a cracker. If my adult children planned badly and expected me to retire early so I could become a childminder instead, I’d think they had gone crackers. No thanks, I ‘retired’ from my job when the hours, physical effects became too much. Why would I want to give up my retirement age desk job to run around all day after a 3yo? Could have just kept the original job. Also not sure what ‘the issue’ is you refer too? Assuming obligatory childminding until school age and then before/after school and school holidays? Plus likely nights so parents can hit the town to ‘reconnect’.

longer paternity because 2 weeks is a joke
again, who pays for this? Generally all of this is just other colleagues covering, which people are always happy to do but there is a limit. Employing extra staff is rarely feasible or works as often there is no one to employ.

It’s really about personal choices and not having children until you are in the space to do so which is different for everyone, there is no standard. It’s not about expecting everyone else to fit around you.

I also debate that parenting is harder than work. Truthfully, I think I had a few of mine to score time off work which was way harder than any baby/child, and I say that as someone who has two with SN.

It’s also about expectation. We didn’t go off on jollies with friends, or date nights, with extremely infrequent family holidays. It was just a never ending grind, chore after chore but that’s okay if you accept that’s just what it is. I took 8 years out from friends and then rightly, some were not keen to reconnect whereas others gladly did so. Meanwhile I had colleagues for adult company at work and for some became genuine friends that have continued. It’s about recognising capacity and accepting things.

LolaSmiles · 18/04/2023 11:26

Maybe this is down to me taking on more load and I know people have said “well most teachers are women” and I think that’s not fair for them to be exhausted either. There’s some jobs you can definitely get away with being more tired with (I could nap on my lunch if I WFH if needed), but we shouldn’t just be expecting mums to be exhausted and get on with it because that’s just how it is.
But honestly, we just get on with it like any hands on parent. It's a fact of life when you choose to have children that you don't get the same amount of sleep.

As a teacher if you genuinely believe it's not possible for your husband to be a bit tired because his job is so important, he's taking you for a ride.

I can tell you that there's hands on parents in all lines of work who deal with the reality of having babies and young children, including teaching. The difference is that a bigger proportion of men seem to be able to convince their other halves that their big important man job means they need to have uninterrupted beauty sleep.

inamarina · 18/04/2023 11:23

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/04/2023 07:14

No one is giving 100% anything, to anything.
It’s your responsability figure how much you give to and to what with the choices you have made.

And honestly, why are you only now thinking about this?
It hasn’t been a secret in years/decades how things are.
Why now demand more leave?
Why didn’t you think this before choosing to have a kid?

And honestly, why are you only now thinking about this?
It hasn’t been a secret in years/decades how things are.
Why now demand more leave?
Why didn’t you think this before choosing to have a kid?

I really don’t get this attitude. So it’s unreasonable to want change? How do other (European) countries manage? Germany offers 12 months paid maternity leave after birth plus 6 before birth if I remember correctly, Sweden is similar. So it is possible.
All this “well, it’s always been this way/ USA is even worse/ you should have known better/ why did you chose to have a child?” is so depressing.

Coffeeandbourbons · 18/04/2023 11:18

As for maternity leave the U.K. is very generous compared to most other countries.

Coffeeandbourbons · 18/04/2023 11:17

Well this is the life we were told was better for us. But we don’t have it all we just do it all. A trick played on us by men frankly and we fell for it.

Albiboba · 18/04/2023 11:14

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting (for example sleep training, wasn’t a thing years ago when you had more SAHM).

You’re just making random claims and stating them as fact though. Arguably sleep training was more of a thing in the 80s and even earlier when leaving a baby down by themselves, feeding on a schedule etc were all much know common place.

You blaming “society” but it’s your own expectations. You are the one who thinks your husband’s big man job is more important and he can’t miss sleep atm. No doubt that thinking will carry on when you are at work. But you can’t blame society for your own relationship dynamic.

but we shouldn’t just be expecting mums to be exhausted and get on with it because that’s just how it is.
Are you actually reading any of the replies? Because that’s pretty much the exact opposite of what anyone is telling you.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 18/04/2023 11:13

If you compare with the US, we look ok. If you compare with most European countries, our leave isn't great, especially with those Nordic countries like Finland, Norway, even Eastern European countries like Bulgaria plus the pay is 80-90% of salary so staying off is feasible (unlike maternity allowance here).

Basically what I see day after day on mumsnet is exhausted overwhelmed mums possibly taking anti-depressants and feeling completely wrung out by the demands of commuting, f/t work, small kids, lack of family close by, older parents to care for and so on. This is the world of two parents full-time working for one mortgage instead of having a mortgage off one wage as my parents had in the 70's and 80's. Some throw money at it like having a cleaner. Some cut down their hours, nearly always the woman, affecting her pension and long-term career prospects. Some just quit. Some keep going and take the tablets. A few say they like it, and I believe them but for most, it's arduous which is a shame.

The general malaise and unhappiness in the population suggests something's going wrong with this model, and the happier countries of the world tend to have longer maternity or don't require two parents constantly working.

MissTrip82 · 18/04/2023 11:08

Childcare doesn’t raise children, any more than school does. Parents raise children. A key part of raising children is paying for them

Society isn’t expecting more
than it’s always expected from
working class women, who have always worked. The idea of staying at home is a couple of centuries old; it was invented alongside the concept of the middle class and was always entirely about the status of men.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 11:05

But longer leave comes with drawbacks. A pp mentioned her Czech friend who gets 5 years' leave with the right to return to her job. How on earth can society function if a women can take 5 years off, then return, then take another 5 years off for baby number 2....? And of course when a mother has the right to return to her job, it prevents the employer offering that role to someone else permanently. And of course that has implications for the person covering the role... how can they take out a mortgage if they don't have job security. Or consider starting a family of their own?

Systems have to work for all stakeholders in society. I wonder how those women who claim a year's leave isn't enough would feel if they were the one running a business, trying to recruit and retain the best possible workforce yet had a constant revolving door of women dipping in and out of the workplace on consecutive maternity leaves, and preventing anyone else from taking the role permanently? And of course the upshot of that scenario is that employers are put off hiring women of child bearing age so will favour men... oh hang on, we're going backwards to an era where women routinely didn't have the same opportunities.

It's about balance. Systems need to work for everyone. I'd say a year's leave with the option to transfer some to the other parent is a pretty good deal.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 11:03

@Kolakalia as a FTM who is BFing, I do think there’s lots of pressure to ‘do it all’ and be baby led. I’ve been blessed with an easy baby who only woke up once, maybe twice for a 5 min feed between 4-6 months and then slept 11 hours straight from 7 until now.

Maybe I’ve been going wrong by being baby led, but you see so much advice on the potential negatives of not being baby led and trying to make a new baby fit into todays society (for example sleep training, wasn’t a thing years ago when you had more SAHM).

OP posts:
NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 10:58

@Squamata that’s interesting about maternity leave in Czech Republic as I didn’t know they had so long off. I would agree with you that my idea is floored @CantAskAnyoneElse but if other counties are doing it, surely we can model our systems on something better.

nice to read lots of different input into this. I still think society and expectations unconsciously fall onto the mum from my experiences so far and I do think there’s room for improvement.

hopefully my baby will go back to sleeping through the night and I won’t have to even consider how tired I am when I do return to work!

OP posts:
Kolakalia · 18/04/2023 10:58

Katypp · 18/04/2023 09:05

While I agree largely with the OP, I do think there has been a large switch in expectations since maternity leave was extended in the UK. I also think the current baby-led trope is somewhat the blame too.
I posted on another thread yesterday about how young mothers are running themselves into the ground to accommodate a baby instead of taking control and trying to get things to work for them. The whole ethos needs to change back to what's best for the mother, not what's best for the baby or we are heading IMO for a mental health crisis. This post sort of illustrates the issues.
The long maternity leave makes things worse, because there is now no hurry to deal with sleep etc as there used to be.
Although the emphasis is on the baby not the mum, new mums are so revered now, as if they have done something special and amazing, that they lose sight that there are many babies born every year. To the family, a new baby is amazing and a joy but to an employer, not so much. They see the new family as one of many.
It is absolutely not the employer's responsibility to fund more time off so women are paid to do the job they are not doing. That's ridiculous.
Social media is also to blame for feeding the line is all about milky cuddles, making memories and mumma bear. It's not.
Women are putting ridiculous expectation upon themselves. Based on social media (including MN) it is implied that it is possible to be a CEO, have a perfect home, be the best mother ever and always be immaculately groomed. It's crazy

I think this is very insightful. It's lovely that we have such long mat leaves but there is definitely a huge pressure on mothers alone to do 'baby led' everything these days. Keep bf even if it's killing you. Keep getting up every hour through the night even though baby is 6m and perfectly capable of learning to sleep/connect longer stretches. I think there's a lot to be said for having a baby and finding ways to fit them into their new family rather than everything having to revolve around them for their entire infancy and beyond.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 10:53

@ilovesooty I’ve no idea what the percentage difference between our taxes and somewhere like Sweden, but if they are similar then surely we could model our society on theirs which seems to work quite well in offering cheap childcare (@Neandertallica mentioned it’s £80 per month there) and longer parental leave which would solve all these issues.

Maybe this is down to me taking on more load and I know people have said “well most teachers are women” and I think that’s not fair for them to be exhausted either. There’s some jobs you can definitely get away with being more tired with (I could nap on my lunch if I WFH if needed), but we shouldn’t just be expecting mums to be exhausted and get on with it because that’s just how it is.

I know I’ve mentioned mums in this post more, but maybe it’s just my experience so far as I’ve taken on the nights and broken sleep of parenthood so far because it’s my job atm. I’ve given up work to be home, but my husband will be taking over during the summer holidays and he will do any night wakes as he’s off work. Once we are both are work, we will definitely split this if it’s needed, but I know I can take on more tiredness with my job as I can turn off between meetings.

OP posts:
CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/04/2023 10:28

Albiboba · 18/04/2023 08:33

This reaffirms that you just actually want more paid time off.

The reality is longer maternity leave with more pay at the expense of introducing a decent parental leave policy doesn’t benefit women in the long run. It does more to place the burden of children on women alone. It reaffirms the idea that men don’t need to get involved in the early years.

Eventually I think paid leave should extend to about 12 months, but I think paternity needs to reach at least 3 first.

Not to mention that who’s gonna hire women anymore?
There would be fear of after being hired women would just get knocked up, take a long - fully paid leave, maybe come back, realize work is hard/moved on/lost talent, get knocked up again and again just go for a long paid leave.
Who would risk that?

Goldbar · 18/04/2023 10:25

I agree, OP, and it's part of the reason why women are increasingly voting with their feet when it comes to motherhood.

In the past, women had little control over either their economic situation or their fertility. But if you look at what happens when you give women this control but maintain sexist and outdated societal structures, the birth rate drops dramatically. South Korea, Japan and Italy are arguably even more pertinent examples of this than the UK, and it is viewed as a big problem in these cases with, surprise surprise, single women being condemned as "fussy" and "selfish", including by politicians.

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 10:13

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/04/2023 08:54

It’s also expected by “society” these days that fathers pull their weight

No one ever asks fathers if they are planning to return to work full time after their baby arrives.

A minimal amount of fathers (I'd love to see actual stats on this) put their careers on hold/slow down when kids arrive as they need to do more on the home front.

How many men do you know who work part time so they can do childcare? As in actually part time. And how many women?

No one asks dads how they plan to cover childcare during school holidays. A vanishingly small number of men take annual leave while their wife works full time to cover the kids being off school.

Men aren't told to keep their hand in at work in case their wives leave them to parent alone.

Mumsnet is not a reflective cross section of society.

That’s the UK though. It’s absolutely not the norm where I’m from. There are also not many SAHM and I don’t know anyone who would want to tbh, equality means equality both ways.

Squamata · 18/04/2023 10:10

Your mistake is to think someone designed this system. Women have found their way into work by claiming they can do it without detriment to the family unit. There was never a moment where women said 'we are dropping half the domestic load and demand men pick it up' - we said 'modern labour saving devices mean we can manage the house and have a job outside the home'.

No one ever sat and created a system that's best for women and babies as well as men. Men just said 'ok, give it your best shot' but most of them didn't say 'ok, I'll do half the laundry and cleaning then'.

I had a Czech friend who moved home and got a mat leave cover position. I said what would she do after and she said she didn't need to worry as mat leave lasts up to 5 years there and the woman has the right to return after that. You get the same amount of money however long you take off - but can spread it across up to 5 years.

If 5 years was the default then our 9/12 months would look puny, right?

If you're not keen on nursery, childminders can be a good option - home-based care that's more similar to you taking care of the baby.

I'm afraid the stinger comes with school hours which are 9-3.30 ish, it can be a shocker if you're used to wraparound nursery and there aren't enough school breakfast/afterschool club places.

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 10:05

And childcare/nurseries/schools are basically free as well, nurseries are £80 a month but with very good home cooked food and uni educated staff.