Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers?

215 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:29

The 8 month sleep regression is hitting us hard, so I might be more sensitive than usual as I’m exhausted.

However, as I try and resettle my baby, I can’t help but question how women are expected to do it all. How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home. The maths doesn’t add up and I feel like along the way of empowering women, things have changed but to just expecting women to do more than what’s actually manageable.

I think the first issue is the length of maternity leave and how long it’s financially supported (plus the ridiculously little amount maternity pay actually is).
Why can women take up to 12 months off, but only paid for 9 months? One of my arguments for a longer, financially supported maternity leave is that our babies need to get their main source of nutrition from milk for the first 12 months, so why doesn’t society support women being off for that long? There’s probably more arguments in the emotional support of babies being raised by their parents, instead of childcare, but too tired to look into this.
Luckily, we saved enough before having our baby to support me being off for 12 months, but baby needs me right now at 8 months and I can’t imagine putting them into childcare at 9 months, or even earlier.

The other issue I’m struggling to wrap my head around is how I’m expected to go back to work and give 100% whilst trying to be a mother. Parenting is exhausting, relentless and I can’t picture my life where I’m meant to give my all to work whilst trying to give my best to my child. Surely something will have to give, but with the cost of living my career can’t slip as we need me working, so naturally it’s seeing less of my child by working full time and having them be raised and looked after by nursery.

So, AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers? Surely there’s a better compromise than the current set up of maternity leave and more support from employers towards parents?

OP posts:
Botw1 · 18/04/2023 13:37

@Vivalaive

🤷‍♀️

It can be a struggle. It's not always easy but it is doable.

As I said, we have a great work life balance

Vivalaive · 18/04/2023 13:27

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 13:20

@Vivalaive

Speak for yourself

I do and i will. I think it’s a load of rubbish. Just look at the threads on here! Women ask for help from family/ grandparents and get shot down that ‘they had the children they should look after them.’ Women try to return to work after having said children and face being overlooked for promotions, looking unreliable when having to take time off to look after children etc. Women often have to straddle both motherhood, work, childcare, house etc and the struggle is real.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 13:20

@Vivalaive

Speak for yourself

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 13:18

Of course it's a myth that women can 'have it all.' But I do believe that it's possible for women and men to have a good balance in life whereby both can earn, both can have responsibility for caring, both can cook, shop, do housework....

Surely that's a positive model to aim for? Not just expecting mums to have longer and longer leave which places responsibility firmly on them for everything child-related, and also has the knock on of making women of child-bearing age a less attractive proposition for employment.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 13:11

Your solution is to give mums more time off work, fund childcare until the kids go to school and lower the pension age.

That’ll require some big tax rises, which - shocker - will be paid by childless people, as always.

Coffeeandbourbons · 18/04/2023 13:11

Vivalaive · 18/04/2023 13:08

100% agree. The big myth that women could have it all the home the family the career. What a load of bull. We just run ourselves into the ground trying to achieve the impossible. You can’t convince me otherwise and I say this as a woman/ mother/ worker etc.

Yes, me too.

What use is having all this stuff on paper if the day to day is miserable.

Vivalaive · 18/04/2023 13:08

100% agree. The big myth that women could have it all the home the family the career. What a load of bull. We just run ourselves into the ground trying to achieve the impossible. You can’t convince me otherwise and I say this as a woman/ mother/ worker etc.

diflasu · 18/04/2023 13:04

Women are expected to parent as if they don't work, work as if they don't have kids.

A good summary.

I think it one of many factors in why we have a rapidly falling birth rate.

lower pension age so grandparents can help out (a lot of my friends all have the same issue as our parents are still working FT

We lived in an area where most people had extended family help with childcare and emergencies - we didn't and I found it made parenting harder as so many services expected that support - even when I was a SAHM they'd expect another adult to have the other kids or would refuse to work appointments round school/nursery times.

When DGP did retire - they were long distance way because we moved from work and one set had health issues other no interest in helping - they'd be working since 15 and hadn't enjoyed parenthood though are good GP.

At population level they need more people working for longer to fund aging population anything getting in the way of that won't go though - plus some especially women need to work longer if they took time our for their kids to build up pensions. The government may do something about childcare costs but that will be so more mothers can remain in the workforce paying tax in.

Kolakalia · 18/04/2023 12:59

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 18/04/2023 12:52

I agree with your title… not at all with your conclusions!
IMO if women were taking short mat leaves it would be easier to go back to work and as a result not being « just mum ». Also easier to share the parenting with the dad when the mum hasn’t spent a full year doing most of it while on mat leave.
In France women often go to work after 3
months, or 6 months, but the 1y+ you have here in the UK are not the norm.

I think this is definitely one of the downsides of extended mat leaves. A whole year at home with the baby means that often by the time mum returns to work the family dynamic has entrenched into her being the 'main' parent and dad being supplementary 'help'. And it's hard to shift that upon returning to work. I often see mums say stuff like 'no point in me working, my entire wage would go to childcare' as if it's her responsibility alone, when in reality it's the responsibility of both parents or the family as a whole to pay for childcare.

traytablestowed · 18/04/2023 12:55

You have my sympathy, sleep regressions are horrible!!
I think most people on mat leave probably go through this in their head at some point, I know I did to a certain extent. Honestly all parents are just winging it the best they can - nobody really expects 100% from parents of young children in any part of life. You just find a way to get by at eg. 80% of your actual potential for a few years. And then it gets easier (so I'm told - my DD is 2 and it's still hectic 😂).
I agree with most PPs that you might need to reflect on the expectations you have of yourself, and your partner. Mostly doing ok is good enough!

Snaaaaacks · 18/04/2023 12:52

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:48

@Mutabiliss I'm extremely lucky that my husband pulls his weight, but he’s a teacher and it’s a lot harder to hide when you are exhausted than my office job. He can’t turn off and have an easier day like I can when I’ll be WFH.

My husband is a teacher too, our kids have all been awful sleepers, but it doesn't mean he doesn't do his share because he can't have an easy day. It's teaching not brain surgery or driving a HGV!

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 18/04/2023 12:52

I agree with your title… not at all with your conclusions!
IMO if women were taking short mat leaves it would be easier to go back to work and as a result not being « just mum ». Also easier to share the parenting with the dad when the mum hasn’t spent a full year doing most of it while on mat leave.
In France women often go to work after 3
months, or 6 months, but the 1y+ you have here in the UK are not the norm.

WinterDeWinter · 18/04/2023 12:51

It was never about 'empowering women' op - that's just how they sold it to us.

Snaaaaacks · 18/04/2023 12:44

We have 3 young children, we both work ft, I still bf the youngest. Your focus is all on mums in this, dad's exist too and bar breastfeeding can and do as much as mums. Yes I took the mat leave as my husband doesn't lactate or do the giving birth bit, but from me returning to work when my children were between 9 and 12 months my husband and I have been equals when it comes to parenting. I do think men should have longer paid paternity leave, where I work men get 6 weeks fully paid which is great but my husband only got 2 weeks statutory paternity pay (peanuts). There aren't endless pots of money though so unfortunately men and women can't be off together for a year having a baby, it just can't happen.

Both men and women juggle working and trying to raise children, I don't personally feel that it all falls on me, but I have a good husband and I work in the public sector where they are flexible towards people with children whether you are male or female.

Dilemma19 · 18/04/2023 12:40

You'll find that these expectations and the least amount of support come from women themselves. Women are their own worst enemies.

UndertheCedartree · 18/04/2023 12:38

Yes. Mothers are expected to just 'get on with it'. When my ex-DH was mentally unwell I was expected to just carry on with everything. When I became mentally unwell (partly due to that experience) there was help from everywhere for my ex-DH. Even though I was still carrying most of the mental load and organising everything for the DC when I was sectioned in a psychiatric hospital. There was so much praise for the DC's dad for looking after them, none for me when I was doing it all plus looking after a very unwell husband and none for me when I was keeping so much going for the DC while in hospital. It was a very stark reminder that a mum is expected to get on with it at all times and a dad is a hero for doing anything to care for his own children.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2023 12:32

My friend's daughter and her husband both work 3 days to bring nursery costs down. Their second child has high needs and even with that working pattern they've had significant amounts of time off work recently. Her parents usually end up picking up the slack and they weren't utterly delighted when they announced her third pregnancy. They aren't without their own health conditions and already find childcare as grandparents difficult at times.

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 12:30

reluctantbrit · 18/04/2023 12:21

From all my family and friends I know exactly two families who have grandparents nearby (and I mean nearby as in 1 1/2 hour drive). Everyone else lives far away as they moved for jobs after university/training/posted with army.

My mum and my PIL also have health issues which means they aren't able to run after a toddler for a whole day.

Also, my mum rightly so told my sister who expected childcare, that she had raised her children without help and if my sister wants 3 children in 6 years than that's her choice. My mum loves her grandchildren and did happily jump in in emergencies but it's hardly fair to expect people to change their lives and dreams to provide childcare.

It is obviously just another choice, it’s possible if it’s something everyone is happy with. It’s there if you want it. If not you just stay at home yourself, also fully paid.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 12:30

@HoppingPavlova

I said 'full time' because of course most parents are full time parents whether they work or not.

I mean no one says parents are part time parents to school age kids do they?

It's just a dig at working mums.

Wp may do a bit less physical parenting, meaning they aren't technically a full time parent but so what

I had no intention of ever being a full time patent anyway.

We did the same as you.

HoppingPavlova · 18/04/2023 12:25

@Botw1 And, no. No one can be a 'full time' worker and a 'full time' parent

Thats not true. DH and I were both full time workers and full time parents. Often we literally tag teamed, one out the door, one in. Also had to allow for the fact my shifts generally ran over/went into doubles etc so factored that in with his. We worked opposite days and/or shifts to make it work. Yes, it was hard and yes, it was shit, and it often involved little to no sleep but we made it work between us without outside help apart from a carer for one disabled baby/toddler/child who was provided for a few hours each day for a period of time but only to provide direct care for that particular child, nothing else.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 12:25

@Satsumastocking

What does working have to do with 'bringing up children or being in families and communities'

reluctantbrit · 18/04/2023 12:21

Neandertallica · 18/04/2023 11:37

lower pension age so grandparents can help out (a lot of my friends all have the same issue as our parents are still working FT

One more example, here gp’s who work can stay at home with sick gc instead of the parents, fully paid. My colleague is currently at home with one of her gc.

From all my family and friends I know exactly two families who have grandparents nearby (and I mean nearby as in 1 1/2 hour drive). Everyone else lives far away as they moved for jobs after university/training/posted with army.

My mum and my PIL also have health issues which means they aren't able to run after a toddler for a whole day.

Also, my mum rightly so told my sister who expected childcare, that she had raised her children without help and if my sister wants 3 children in 6 years than that's her choice. My mum loves her grandchildren and did happily jump in in emergencies but it's hardly fair to expect people to change their lives and dreams to provide childcare.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 18/04/2023 12:19

inamarina · 18/04/2023 11:23

And honestly, why are you only now thinking about this?
It hasn’t been a secret in years/decades how things are.
Why now demand more leave?
Why didn’t you think this before choosing to have a kid?

I really don’t get this attitude. So it’s unreasonable to want change? How do other (European) countries manage? Germany offers 12 months paid maternity leave after birth plus 6 before birth if I remember correctly, Sweden is similar. So it is possible.
All this “well, it’s always been this way/ USA is even worse/ you should have known better/ why did you chose to have a child?” is so depressing.

Because it so selfish, lazy and entitled, that’s why.

Had to go and have a child, and then whine how unfair it all is.
Like I said, nothing op complain about is new.

Change IS possible, but you gotta demand it BEFORE. If you do what society wants, in this case, birth a child, why would anything change. When enough women are going to do it anyway.

The only real power women have is saying no.
Saying no until change is made. Iceland did that back in the day. It worked.

And about how other countries do it.
I live in said country, and that means fucking high taxes - on everything and they come up with more taxes all the time.
Many over there wouldn’t be so happy about it.
It also means that it can take a while to get a permanent job, so could get all those benefits.
Cost of living has always been crazy high, salary not so much, so many end up needing both parents full time working so they can pay bills and morgage.
Stay at home moms or parents are pretty much unkown concept here, I’ve never knew one parent who did that when I was a kid (born in the 80’s) and don’t know anyone who is now or know anyone who knows someone who is.
That’s how unusual it is. It’s not a thing here.
I’ve gathered that it’s much more common over there, how many would like to make change like it is here?

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 12:16

@Whataretheyfeedingyou

The more it's asked for the more it's done

And, no. No one can be a 'full time' worker and a 'full time' parent

But I dont see why anyone needs to.

(And tbh I don't really see what sahps do that wps don't but thats a different story)

Kolakalia · 18/04/2023 11:59

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 11:03

@Kolakalia as a FTM who is BFing, I do think there’s lots of pressure to ‘do it all’ and be baby led. I’ve been blessed with an easy baby who only woke up once, maybe twice for a 5 min feed between 4-6 months and then slept 11 hours straight from 7 until now.

Maybe I’ve been going wrong by being baby led, but you see so much advice on the potential negatives of not being baby led and trying to make a new baby fit into todays society (for example sleep training, wasn’t a thing years ago when you had more SAHM).

Sleep training has always been a thing, even if it wasn't really called that! I remember a friend's mum mentioning casually how she 'had to' put my friend in the garage as a baby because she just wouldn't sleep. There was no guilt or shame in it, simply a 'but you wouldn't sleep! Of course we had to, how else could the rest of the house sleep?' lol. The term 'cry it out' was first introduced in the late 1800s but of course parents throughout history have not always managed to respond to every cry from their child during the night. The upside of bedsharing and EBF can be that babies sleep a bit better attached to the breast all night, the downside of course being increased mortality from bedsharing deaths.

I think it's really tricky to know what's best when you're a new parent honestly. My biggest piece of advice to new parents is to look into evidence based parenting information, for example the books Expecting Better and Crib Sheet, so that you can make your own decisions based on the current research. Safe sleep, feeding, weaning, etc., as long as you know the research you can make your own decisions. A lot of online spaces/groups are just full of wild misinformation about so many different aspects of parenting and lots of shaming. I think mothers are expected to allow their baby to lead everything when that isn't always desirable, practical, or even possible. I know some toddlers still waking every hour in the night needing to be fed back to sleep for example, because they've only ever fallen asleep while being fed. Fine if that works for a family but not many people hope for that as an outcome!