Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers?

215 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:29

The 8 month sleep regression is hitting us hard, so I might be more sensitive than usual as I’m exhausted.

However, as I try and resettle my baby, I can’t help but question how women are expected to do it all. How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home. The maths doesn’t add up and I feel like along the way of empowering women, things have changed but to just expecting women to do more than what’s actually manageable.

I think the first issue is the length of maternity leave and how long it’s financially supported (plus the ridiculously little amount maternity pay actually is).
Why can women take up to 12 months off, but only paid for 9 months? One of my arguments for a longer, financially supported maternity leave is that our babies need to get their main source of nutrition from milk for the first 12 months, so why doesn’t society support women being off for that long? There’s probably more arguments in the emotional support of babies being raised by their parents, instead of childcare, but too tired to look into this.
Luckily, we saved enough before having our baby to support me being off for 12 months, but baby needs me right now at 8 months and I can’t imagine putting them into childcare at 9 months, or even earlier.

The other issue I’m struggling to wrap my head around is how I’m expected to go back to work and give 100% whilst trying to be a mother. Parenting is exhausting, relentless and I can’t picture my life where I’m meant to give my all to work whilst trying to give my best to my child. Surely something will have to give, but with the cost of living my career can’t slip as we need me working, so naturally it’s seeing less of my child by working full time and having them be raised and looked after by nursery.

So, AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers? Surely there’s a better compromise than the current set up of maternity leave and more support from employers towards parents?

OP posts:
Katypp · 18/04/2023 18:18

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 14:59

@traytablestowed I think as we’ve gone from a unicorn babe who has slept 11 hours straight for nearly two months, to waking every 3 hours and fighting naps, it’s definitely hitting hard.
This whole thought process is probably due to muddled clarity of panic that things will never return to normal.

@freyamay74 I appreciate hearing so many different opinions, but I’m now wondering if maybe the modern set up isn’t working for parenting overall? Long days of commuting and working whilst juggling childcare, school holidays and the inevitable sickness that comes with having a child? I definitely not expecting things to go backwards, but to go forward to having a world with maybe a better work/life balance?

I honestly don’t know the answer or what I’m expecting, but maybe I’d love to have a culture that’s more flexible towards families and the hardship of raising children.

Did you feel like this before you had children?

reluctantbrit · 18/04/2023 17:49

WoefulLackOfEverything · 18/04/2023 15:15

Yes. It’s scary that women want to go backwards and yearn for an age where men dominated the workplace. Simpler times! 😫

We have far to go, but goodness don’t we want woman MPs, chief execs and judges? And making up a representative proportion of the workforce at every level? We need more men in caring professions. So much imbalance to correct still.

Having young kids is hard. It’s even hard when you don’t work. But that doesn’t mean women should step back from the workforce 🤯

Exactly. We need to evolve as a society where it is the norm for dads taking time off to be there for their children. Be it paternity leave, taking annual leave during school holidays, leaving work early for appointments etc.

It needs to be the norm that childraising is the job for both parents, not the dad doing mum a favour by babysitting.

And, mums need to realise that just because they gave birth the baby doesn't belongs solely to them. I don't think I had a bigger or better bond just because I gave birth and bf DD. I think it would have been great for DH to have some time with DD as well when she I stopped bf and she wasn't in nursery yet.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 18/04/2023 17:25

inamarina · 18/04/2023 16:24

I agree with you, particularly with this:

Even if you work in a way that enables two parents to work full-time and effectively play 'tag team' - what kind of life is that? Couples become like ships in the night and to be honest, it sounds absolutely shite. What is 'ideal' about that?

I know that some couples might not have a choice and other don’t mind a setup like this, but is it a viable option for the majority of people?

It was an option for us, and we seized it with both hands. It enabled both of us to have lots of time with dd and to minimise our use of paid childcare etc. And yes, we saw each other a bit less in those years but we still had plenty of family time all together, and it was only a few years which is really nothing in the grand scheme of things.

Not saying that it would work for everyone but it certainly worked for us.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 18/04/2023 17:22

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 17:04

@DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon

I'm glad you've found a balance that works for you, but some of the claims you make on a wider scale just can't be backed up by evidence. Why are you blaming marriage breakdowns on women being expected to 'keep up?' Why are you ignoring the fact that 50/60 years ago huge numbers of women were depressed and unfulfilled precisely because they couldn't work and were expected to stay at home? And as for saying no one values SAHM... surely it's valued by the SAHM herself and her partner? If it's a decision you make because you feel it benefits your family, surely that's what matters?

I agree. My mum was utterly miserable as a SAHP and it is her single biggest regret.

I am hugely grateful for having been able to balance my career and my family life effectively, and while it has involved some juggling at times, it has been well worth it.

And yes, if you and your family value what you do as a SAHP, then surely that's enough...it doesn't really make any difference to the rest of us.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 17:04

@DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon

I'm glad you've found a balance that works for you, but some of the claims you make on a wider scale just can't be backed up by evidence. Why are you blaming marriage breakdowns on women being expected to 'keep up?' Why are you ignoring the fact that 50/60 years ago huge numbers of women were depressed and unfulfilled precisely because they couldn't work and were expected to stay at home? And as for saying no one values SAHM... surely it's valued by the SAHM herself and her partner? If it's a decision you make because you feel it benefits your family, surely that's what matters?

DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon · 18/04/2023 16:52

It's precisely why women have never been so depressed and miserarable and so many marriages and relationships are failing.
Women are just expected to keep up no matter what, and are quite heavily frowned upon if the dont. Nobody applauds SAHMs, because apparently they don't work. Housework and childcare is unpaid work so not deemed valuable.
I had to go back to work part time when my son was only 17 weeks old, ( this was over 20 yrs ago) was still breastfeeding him and had to rush home in my breaks. It was so stressful and l hated it.
We have been fed such rubbish over the years, success now is solely measured on where you work , how much you earn, the size of your house, how many holidays you have, but the reality is a simpler slower way of life is much more enjoyable and meaningful.
I refuse to play along with it anymore, l work the minimum hours l can and happily manage on a small wage as my out goings are low. My wellbeing and MH has never been better.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 16:27

@maya48

It's ideal because it means both parents are equally responsible for childcare. And you generally don't need outside help

It was def worth it for us

inamarina · 18/04/2023 16:24

maya48 · 18/04/2023 15:18

Yes all societies expect too much of mothers, but particularly working ones. Few women really want to put their babies in full-time childcare, but too often, they are forced to these days and even told they should be grateful! Even if you work in a way that enables two parents to work full-time and effectively play 'tag team' - what kind of life is that? Couples become like ships in the night and to be honest, it sounds absolutely shite. What is 'ideal' about that? Also, that kind of set up probably leads to both parents just treading water, career-wise, as they're always rushing home to relieve the other one so they can get to work! Not to mention the tiredness and how that impacts your health and well-being and energy for the children.

There is always a compromise - whether it's being separated from your child too much and / or too soon; a toll on your marital relationship because you burn opposite ends of the candle; or you take a career hit (although most families these days can't afford to do that unfortunately). But apparently, this is all 'progress.' YANBU OP.

I agree with you, particularly with this:

Even if you work in a way that enables two parents to work full-time and effectively play 'tag team' - what kind of life is that? Couples become like ships in the night and to be honest, it sounds absolutely shite. What is 'ideal' about that?

I know that some couples might not have a choice and other don’t mind a setup like this, but is it a viable option for the majority of people?

Aphrathestorm · 18/04/2023 16:18

So true.

Women are ordered to do it all. But no one wants to help.

We should all the the right to universal free childcare on demand.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 16:17

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting

Society doesn't expect women to work full time.

It expects women to give up work and 'raise their babies' or at the very least go part time

Because society is sexist

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 16:02

*"the fact that there are many more women who desperately want kids than men who do, as opposed to those who just want to make their wives happy", that should say.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 16:00

Where I work (massive organisation), we have policies allowing men to take generous paternity leave - though of course this is shared with mum, not in addition to. Maternity leave also generous, pay is generally good. Take up in the last five years has been less than 2%. In my department there have been 50-odd babies born to mums in that time. Guess how many mums reduced their leave so that their partner could take some? Zero.

Anecdotal but the women in my team have been horrified at the idea of reducing their "time with baby".

You can lead a horse to water etc...

Add in the fact that there are many more women who desperately want kids than men who just want to make their wives happy, and it's not really surprising that we end up where we are.

Equalbutdifferent · 18/04/2023 15:57

NeIIie · 18/04/2023 06:41

There can't just be endless pots of money for supporting people to be at home for longer though, surely that responsibility is on the parents to save and be able to afford to be off with the baby (like you have).

People can ask for reduced hours when they go back off maternity leave if they can afford it. It is hard work whichever way you look at it. But apart from getting financially in a position where you don't need to work until your child goes to school then I don't see what the answer is. Work places need the job doing, same as they did before the baby came along. So it's not the responsibility of the work place.

Society relies on their being a next generation of people. The economy relies on it. We all individually rely on it (there are no pensions or hospitals or roads without tax receipts). If you want a workforce you need social policies and workplace policies that support families.

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 15:38

@mondaytosunday I think I’ll probably enjoy going back to work as I do love my team and the company I work for and can see it benefitting me being ‘me’ again, but when you are in the depth of sleepless nights again, it’s hard to imagine how I can be my old work self after such a massive life adjusting change?

@freyamay74 you are right, from an employers point of view it’s difficult. I think maybe my issue is with the modern world and how everyone is expected to work full time with children in tow.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 18/04/2023 15:30

When I was at work k didn't think about my kids. I was focussed and it was a nice break from the drudgery.
Frankly it will always be something of a compromise in terms of time, but you have to be sure that when you are with your kids you are present, not thinking about an upcoming work meeting or project. And the same when you are at work.
Plus get your partner to take some of the life admin off your hands - you should only have to do 50% of that and 50% of childcare when both at home (bf only takes up a small amount of time for a very short part of a child's life).
I think many women don't want to give up the control though.

maya48 · 18/04/2023 15:18

Yes all societies expect too much of mothers, but particularly working ones. Few women really want to put their babies in full-time childcare, but too often, they are forced to these days and even told they should be grateful! Even if you work in a way that enables two parents to work full-time and effectively play 'tag team' - what kind of life is that? Couples become like ships in the night and to be honest, it sounds absolutely shite. What is 'ideal' about that? Also, that kind of set up probably leads to both parents just treading water, career-wise, as they're always rushing home to relieve the other one so they can get to work! Not to mention the tiredness and how that impacts your health and well-being and energy for the children.

There is always a compromise - whether it's being separated from your child too much and / or too soon; a toll on your marital relationship because you burn opposite ends of the candle; or you take a career hit (although most families these days can't afford to do that unfortunately). But apparently, this is all 'progress.' YANBU OP.

WoefulLackOfEverything · 18/04/2023 15:15

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 14:52

@WoefulLackOfEverything I agree with you.

Let's face it, none of it is easy! Parenting is hard work and continues for years and years... it's not all about the baby bit. I don't think men and women are vastly different in their aspirations and what they want in life... I know my dh and I both wanted to be parents, we both have jobs we're good at and ambitions we wanted to achieve. We were going through the baby years when things were vastly more difficult than now (short ML, no paternity/transferable leave) and it does seem strange now things are so much better that some women still seem to want to go backwards in terms of equal opportunities

Yes. It’s scary that women want to go backwards and yearn for an age where men dominated the workplace. Simpler times! 😫

We have far to go, but goodness don’t we want woman MPs, chief execs and judges? And making up a representative proportion of the workforce at every level? We need more men in caring professions. So much imbalance to correct still.

Having young kids is hard. It’s even hard when you don’t work. But that doesn’t mean women should step back from the workforce 🤯

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 15:12

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting

Things are moving in that direction though. I think it's always difficult to see it when you're in the thick of it though. I remember when I was expressing milk, still doing night feeds and psyching up to leave our 12 week old with a childminder, thinking how much easier it must have been for my mother who was a SAHM. But of course that's completely overlooking the fact that she had no choice. She was just as capable as my father but the lack of regulated childcare in the 1960s meant opportunities for women were far more limited.

When you're going through a tough patch it's easy to think the past was easier or better but from my perspective as a woman in her late 50s, things are way better now, there have been huge leaps in maternity entitlement and things like flexi working and transferable leave. I also believe the balance now is about right. If women were expected and paid to be off work for more than a year, it could easily act as a disincentive for employers to take on women of child bearing age. It's an issue that needs to be looked at in the round... from all angles. I can see that if you're a mum struggling on maternity leave it might be tempting to wish for another paid year before the challenge of returning to work. But if you're running a business, or managing a team, you'd probably find it a nightmare having employees out of the workplace for over a year, with your hands tied so you can't appoint anyone else on a secure contract.

readingbluecat32 · 18/04/2023 15:04

OP! Please don’t think you are alone in these thoughts / feelings!

there are some amazing accounts to follow on insta and Facebook - Pregnant then screwed, A mothers place, Motherkind (motherkind has a podcast which is amazing also). They frequently say that sadly something will have to give - if you are smashing it at work, you are prob not at home and vice versa. Also Zoe blaskey from podcast I mentioned had a post natal specialist on that said it’s the hardest time to be a parent since the Second World War as many people don’t live near family, don’t have a village to keep cost of childcare down, nursery and mortgages are the highest they have been in generations (certainly since our parents and our working managers had their kids). It’s hard!

if you do read up on pregnant then screwed - we are pretty low on the maternity leave support in the western world - the Scandinavian countries give 1 year for mother and 1 year for father to take until child is 2 to help with bonding and cost! There nursery is also subsidised by the government because they make back around £3 for every £1 they invest in childcare off the salaries of the mothers returning to work / not on benefits/ also it means that all their children start primary school on level playing field for learning - which then requires less support from
government for struggling learning areas.

I went back to work with my son after 10.5m and he went into a few days at nursery and a few days with me whilst working from home. He didn’t sleep through the night and I was breastfeeding until 12 months - it was hard, but work were surprisingly kind and I had to accept that my productivity wouldn’t be back to normal for some time- but not forever as when he gets 30free hours or school I can ramp up again!

I am currently 6 weeks into mat leave with second one!

it sounds silly - but you will find a way to make it work and every day will get slightly easier with the juggle! Hang in there and sending solidarity

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 14:59

@traytablestowed I think as we’ve gone from a unicorn babe who has slept 11 hours straight for nearly two months, to waking every 3 hours and fighting naps, it’s definitely hitting hard.
This whole thought process is probably due to muddled clarity of panic that things will never return to normal.

@freyamay74 I appreciate hearing so many different opinions, but I’m now wondering if maybe the modern set up isn’t working for parenting overall? Long days of commuting and working whilst juggling childcare, school holidays and the inevitable sickness that comes with having a child? I definitely not expecting things to go backwards, but to go forward to having a world with maybe a better work/life balance?

I honestly don’t know the answer or what I’m expecting, but maybe I’d love to have a culture that’s more flexible towards families and the hardship of raising children.

OP posts:
freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 14:52

@WoefulLackOfEverything I agree with you.

Let's face it, none of it is easy! Parenting is hard work and continues for years and years... it's not all about the baby bit. I don't think men and women are vastly different in their aspirations and what they want in life... I know my dh and I both wanted to be parents, we both have jobs we're good at and ambitions we wanted to achieve. We were going through the baby years when things were vastly more difficult than now (short ML, no paternity/transferable leave) and it does seem strange now things are so much better that some women still seem to want to go backwards in terms of equal opportunities

WoefulLackOfEverything · 18/04/2023 14:14

Vivalaive · 18/04/2023 13:27

I do and i will. I think it’s a load of rubbish. Just look at the threads on here! Women ask for help from family/ grandparents and get shot down that ‘they had the children they should look after them.’ Women try to return to work after having said children and face being overlooked for promotions, looking unreliable when having to take time off to look after children etc. Women often have to straddle both motherhood, work, childcare, house etc and the struggle is real.

I believe it’s been a struggle for you. And some other women.

It was tough for us too. But I had a decent husband. I knew the baby days wouldn’t be forever. I am a great mum and great at my career. I am proud of my adult kids and they are of me.

It has worked out fine and my profession has not lost another woman to motherhood. My friends never gave up either and we are all glad we worked.

What’s the alternative? A workforce with no women? Especially at senior levels.

Work is tough but also good for mental health overall. I think people forget that.

You do not speak for all women and neither do I.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 13:57

ilovesooty · 18/04/2023 13:38

She doesn't seem to think childless people should retire earlier - only grandparents so they can provide childcare.

I read it as lowering the universal age to allow grandparents to help, but actually it makes much more sense to only apply that to grandparents. Someone has to be working to pay for this, after all!

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 13:47

@Vivalaive but so long as it carries on being framed as a women's problem then nothing will change! The solution isn't to expect women to take more time out of the workplace, to fall even further behind in earnings and in achieving ambitions, while in inverse proportion, men do less and less in the home and with the kids.

Surely life is about both women and men achieving a healthy life balance.

ilovesooty · 18/04/2023 13:38

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 13:11

Your solution is to give mums more time off work, fund childcare until the kids go to school and lower the pension age.

That’ll require some big tax rises, which - shocker - will be paid by childless people, as always.

She doesn't seem to think childless people should retire earlier - only grandparents so they can provide childcare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread