Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers?

215 replies

NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting · 18/04/2023 06:29

The 8 month sleep regression is hitting us hard, so I might be more sensitive than usual as I’m exhausted.

However, as I try and resettle my baby, I can’t help but question how women are expected to do it all. How are women expected to give 100% of themselves to motherhood, 100% in their careers, 100% to trying to maintain a social life/being a person outside of motherhood and 100% of themselves to help running the home. The maths doesn’t add up and I feel like along the way of empowering women, things have changed but to just expecting women to do more than what’s actually manageable.

I think the first issue is the length of maternity leave and how long it’s financially supported (plus the ridiculously little amount maternity pay actually is).
Why can women take up to 12 months off, but only paid for 9 months? One of my arguments for a longer, financially supported maternity leave is that our babies need to get their main source of nutrition from milk for the first 12 months, so why doesn’t society support women being off for that long? There’s probably more arguments in the emotional support of babies being raised by their parents, instead of childcare, but too tired to look into this.
Luckily, we saved enough before having our baby to support me being off for 12 months, but baby needs me right now at 8 months and I can’t imagine putting them into childcare at 9 months, or even earlier.

The other issue I’m struggling to wrap my head around is how I’m expected to go back to work and give 100% whilst trying to be a mother. Parenting is exhausting, relentless and I can’t picture my life where I’m meant to give my all to work whilst trying to give my best to my child. Surely something will have to give, but with the cost of living my career can’t slip as we need me working, so naturally it’s seeing less of my child by working full time and having them be raised and looked after by nursery.

So, AIBU to think that as a society we expect too much from mothers? Surely there’s a better compromise than the current set up of maternity leave and more support from employers towards parents?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Oioicaptain · 30/06/2023 21:27

I think that you should raise the question with ITV, OP. I'm sure that their resident 'mother' will be able to explain to you exactly how difficult it is to be a mother (whilst putting three items of laundry into the machine).

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 18/04/2023 21:56

Nounoufgs · 18/04/2023 06:47

Absolutely. The bit I still don’t get is that the man can do nothing at all and be viewed as a good father but if a woman doesn’t manage to work full time, do everything for her kids, attend all appointments, have a clean house, turn out perfectly behaved clean kids then she is seen as lacking. The only solution is clearly to gain superpowers.

This isn't true IMO. Many women never return to full time work and don't get the stigma a man would in this situation.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 21:45

I don't think anyone should quash their feelings. That's not healthy. But neither is it necessarily healthy to always just go with how you feel.

The father (or mother) who doesn't want any disruption to their career and wants their life to continue exactly as it was pre-children isn't necessarily considering what's best overall for their family (ie their partner and child) and many people would think they should be prepared to flex, to compromise.

Likewise, the mother who doesn't want to return to work (or transfer parental leave) because that's just how they feel isn't necessarily considering what's best for their child and partner.

maya48 · 18/04/2023 21:35

freyamay74 - Well yes, but some women also might say that - they are clear they are going back to work at the earliest possible opportunity because they don't want any disruption to their career. They never want to be at home with the baby beyond the minimum possible.

People would say that sounds selfish but really, if that's how they feel it's probably better for them to be honest about it. If you force yourself to be at home with a baby and you're not cut out for it (as some women find) or you get very depressed or anxious, then it's no good for the baby or the mum. Similarly, if you are really struggling with returning to work and separation from a baby or child, you shouldn't feel like you need to quash that or pretend you are fine. I've seen how that can make some women mentally and physically unwell.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 21:05

@maya48 fair enough but turn the situation around. Imagine a man saying he wants to get straight back to work after having a child, for his priorities to remain the same and for his life not to change at all, because that's how he feels. I think most people would say that's selfish and unreasonable and that he should consider the child and the other parent, not just his own feelings.

maya48 · 18/04/2023 20:32

freyamay74 - I wasn't making a case for polarised roles. My point was more that if and when women really struggle emotionally with returning to work after a baby or child (whether they go back after one year, three years, ten years or whatever), there is a tendency for some people to be dismissive about this - "there is nothing special about mums / you can't really feel that because men don't etc etc."

LolaSmiles · 18/04/2023 20:03

I said earlier that I believe transferable leave is a really positive thing that probably has a long term impact far beyond the few months that dad might be on leave
I agree with this and anecdotally all the dads I know who have submitted flexible working requests for flexible starts, compressed hours, shorter lunches to be able to do one of the drop offs, or go part time have all been men who took shared parental leave.

It's also interesting that their wives/partners also say these men take a fair share of sick days with the children, do chores at home on their days off and domestic life seems much more balanced and equitable.

It's positive for children to grow up seeing that domestic responsibilities and load is not mums job because she's the default parent.

lljkk · 18/04/2023 19:49

imho, MNers as mothers expect too much of others. I don't think "society" expects too much, I perceive that "mothers" expect too much of other mothers.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 19:28

@maya48 it's interesting too that you frame things in terms of how the mother feels, as though that must always trump everything else.

What about the children? What if it's actually really beneficial for a child to be looked after by their dad, as well as by their mum? As in, proper time with dad as sole carer? Seeing their dad doing childcare and domestic jobs? Absorbing it all?

I said earlier that I believe transferable leave is a really positive thing that probably has a long term impact far beyond the few months that dad might be on leave.

Having a harmonious balanced family life isn't about any one member of the family- whether mum or dad - just doing what they feel like all the time.

Its about each member of the family sharing the joys and the tough bits surely.

Sleepygrumpyandnothappy · 18/04/2023 19:22

RollingInTheCreek · 18/04/2023 19:15

I agree to an extent but also I think some mothers do flog themselves. No one has ever asked how my ‘breaks’ were after Mat leave and almost everyone I know acknowledges how all consuming parenthood is. Work try to balance home life and work life but ultimately if you’re employed for X hours to do X job and are being paid as such there’s only so much ‘support’ possible.
I think you have to look at it as doing your best. I do my best at work, as a mum, as a friend and partner. Sometimes I have spells where I can juggle everything and feel great. Other times I feel crushed exhausted and overwhelmed and I give myself grace and cut back on non essentials.
I went back to work after 7 months and enjoyed it. I went back after 12 months and enjoyed it. I work part time and love being with the kids and work. Some days are shit and I’d love some proper ‘time off’ that isn’t just covering kids hols but that’s life! They’ll be grown up soon.

Very much agree with this.

Yes I think society doesn’t value motherhood and fathers need to do more. But women need to cut themselves some slack.

I’m about to go back to work and I won’t be giving 100% of what I gave before. My boss doesn’t expect me to give 100% either. And what the house gets is going to come courtesy of a cleaner. I don’t feel pressure to keep my social life at 100% as the majority of my friends have small children and arranging anything is a triumph in itself.

I feel lucky that I’ve waited until I’m established enough and senior enough to step back without it really knocking me. No, I want be surging ahead but I’m not going to get sacked or anything close to it. I’m lucky that I’m surrounded by senior woman all very visibly balancing work and parenthood. I really hope this is role modelling to younger women that if they decide to have kids then no, they don’t need to do everything at 100%.

Hazzamum · 18/04/2023 19:20

What do we count ourselves as “lucky” when our other halves split the chore’s equally with us. 🤷🏼‍♀️ we need to raise the bar here. Surely doing the fair share is the bare minimum requirement of a partnership?
i’d start with looking at your mindset here.

RollingInTheCreek · 18/04/2023 19:15

I agree to an extent but also I think some mothers do flog themselves. No one has ever asked how my ‘breaks’ were after Mat leave and almost everyone I know acknowledges how all consuming parenthood is. Work try to balance home life and work life but ultimately if you’re employed for X hours to do X job and are being paid as such there’s only so much ‘support’ possible.
I think you have to look at it as doing your best. I do my best at work, as a mum, as a friend and partner. Sometimes I have spells where I can juggle everything and feel great. Other times I feel crushed exhausted and overwhelmed and I give myself grace and cut back on non essentials.
I went back to work after 7 months and enjoyed it. I went back after 12 months and enjoyed it. I work part time and love being with the kids and work. Some days are shit and I’d love some proper ‘time off’ that isn’t just covering kids hols but that’s life! They’ll be grown up soon.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 19:12

But I don't think anyone is denying differences. Just pointing out that many men and women want similar things out of life and don't wish to end up in polarised roles as 'earner' or 'carer' when they're capable and interested in doing both

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 18/04/2023 19:10

maya48 · 18/04/2023 19:07

I'm not saying men don't love their children just as much and I'm certainly not saying women shouldn't have careers. But I think in finding meaningful solutions, it's best to admit differences than perpetually trying to deny them and then feeling permanently frustrated.

Well, that's very gracious that you think women should be allowed to have careers.

But what exactly are these differences that you have identified and how do you think they should impact on how society is organised?

BadNomad · 18/04/2023 19:09

I think men go through the same biological urges women do.

Nah. Men have the biological urge to mate. Yes, some men do want children, but for a many of those it doesn't mean they have an urge to raise them on a practical level and if they can get away with not having to they will.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 19:09

@maya48 I agree entirely.

maya48 · 18/04/2023 19:07

I'm not saying men don't love their children just as much and I'm certainly not saying women shouldn't have careers. But I think in finding meaningful solutions, it's best to admit differences than perpetually trying to deny them and then feeling permanently frustrated.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 19:05

Although I do agree it would be helpful if women stopped enabling it

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 19:05

@fitzwilliamdarcy

I dont think thats true

I think men go through the same biological urges women do.

They're just too often let off the hook when it comes to the practicalities because of sexism.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 18/04/2023 19:03

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 18:47

@maya48

I think men should be as capable nd as attached to their kids as women are

The problem with this is that on a societal level men aren’t desperate to have children in the way that women are. Sure, there are men who do really want kids but nowhere near as many as there are women who do.

Those men will never be as committed to 50/50 as the women are.

The best way for a woman to pursue equality is to pick one a man who is really keen to have kids as they’re more likely to actually take on the work. Some women prioritise the baby over the father of the baby, and they end up with one of the men that liked the idea of having kids or was ambivalent about it, but mainly signed up for it because his wife really wanted them. Getting equality out of that guy is next to impossible.

It’s all very well saying men should feel like women do about babies, but it doesn’t make it happen.

freyamay74 · 18/04/2023 18:54

I don't think parents need to have the exact same feelings as each other but I've no doubt my dh loves our children as much as I do. His relationship with them is just as meaningful and strong. And he's certainly been just as capable as I am at changing nappies, playing games, cooking dinner....
Just as I'm equally as capable as him at going to work.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 18/04/2023 18:53

maya48 · 18/04/2023 18:45

I think it's too easy to say "men should feel the same as women" when it comes to separating from children. Some may do, but the majority don't. A lot is due to societal expectations - nobody would deny that - but also, this is an area where men and women, as a general rule, are different (psychologically and biologically). I know some on here will disagree, but there it is. I think if you work on the premis that men and women should always feel / react the same, it usually does women a disservice and makes it more difficult for them to define their own terms to suit them.

But it also does women a massive disservice when people try to suggest that they are somehow the natural caregivers for children, and that finding a balance between career and family life is somehow a women's problem rather than a parents' problem.

If women want to have a career and enjoy a happy family life, then there is one simple thing that needs to happen. Men need to step up and do their fair share. Arguing that they shouldn't have to because somehow they're just not feeling it lets them off the hook and keeps women trapped in situations where they have to either choose between their own career progression and financial independence or sucking it up and doing the double shifts at work and at home.

Botw1 · 18/04/2023 18:47

@maya48

I think men should be as capable nd as attached to their kids as women are

maya48 · 18/04/2023 18:45

I think it's too easy to say "men should feel the same as women" when it comes to separating from children. Some may do, but the majority don't. A lot is due to societal expectations - nobody would deny that - but also, this is an area where men and women, as a general rule, are different (psychologically and biologically). I know some on here will disagree, but there it is. I think if you work on the premis that men and women should always feel / react the same, it usually does women a disservice and makes it more difficult for them to define their own terms to suit them.

CosieRotton · 18/04/2023 18:22

@NameChangeAsICouldBeOverReacting

💯

I’ve recently gone back to a 4 day per week job. But it could easily be full-time plus more.

Going back to work has been good for me in one sense. I found maternity leave quite bad for my mental health and I’m enjoying feeling good at something. However it’s still fucking tough and exhausting in a different way! I feel so stretched all the time. And that I’m letting everyone down because frankly I’m just not prepared to do the overtime I would have done pre child in order to get shit done, so I feel like I’m always having to say no to things.

And don’t even get me started on the state of the house!