Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:43

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:41

Oh I’m sorry, you seem to find it unacceptable for someone to express their horror and disgust at people’s commissioning of infant human beings to suit their own agenda?
Please excuse me if I don’t give a toss.

I think we are in a world where ‘backstory’ is everything, justifies everything.

That is not how justice words.

Sad and desperate people can to bad, wrong, even evil things.

Understanding what drove them to do the bad thing doesn’t turn the bad thing into a good thing. It’s still bad.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:43

Mojoj · 18/04/2023 17:38

Surrogacy is not illegal. Fact. It brings hope to many infertile couples. Love all these posts about how "sad" it is that some women can't have kids and how being a parent is not a "right". I bet they were written by parents. I mind my own business and try hard not to judge other people's decisions as I have no idea what led them down that path.

Suggest you actually read the thread.

Quite a number of those posters are those who have stated they do not have children for any number of reasons.

Milksheikha · 18/04/2023 17:43

"Surrogacy is not illegal"
but it is unethical .
The world is bursting , there are many many children in need but Mr& Mrs, Mr& Mr with money can buy themselves their REAL baby.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:41

I am actually pretty comfortable with the view that no surrogacy arrangement is without exploitable elements and without ethical dilemmas. I am also very comfortable in having laws that protect children from being exploited and that protect women from being exploited.

It is an interesting discussion to have views that are hardline on these protections challenged as being unreasonable or from groups other than feminists. I don't think I have read many feminists that agree with any kind of surrogacy because they recognise the exploitative nature towards the child and the potential exploitation of the women providing eggs and carrying the child.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:41

herlightmaterials · 18/04/2023 17:21

Can you hear yourself. Such vitriol.

Oh I’m sorry, you seem to find it unacceptable for someone to express their horror and disgust at people’s commissioning of infant human beings to suit their own agenda?
Please excuse me if I don’t give a toss.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:40

I actually feel pathos for those women who kidnap babies from hospitals.

Doesn’t mean I don’t think they are doing something wrong.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 17:40

Mojoj · 18/04/2023 17:38

Surrogacy is not illegal. Fact. It brings hope to many infertile couples. Love all these posts about how "sad" it is that some women can't have kids and how being a parent is not a "right". I bet they were written by parents. I mind my own business and try hard not to judge other people's decisions as I have no idea what led them down that path.

Did yuo forget half your first sentence? Surrogacy IS illegal in many countries, and that will hopefully spread.

I don't care what led people down the path of buying womens eggs and bodies,it doesn't matter. It's wrong whatever their reasons are.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:39

There are a lot of utilitarians about “the ends justifies the means”.

Mojoj · 18/04/2023 17:38

Surrogacy is not illegal. Fact. It brings hope to many infertile couples. Love all these posts about how "sad" it is that some women can't have kids and how being a parent is not a "right". I bet they were written by parents. I mind my own business and try hard not to judge other people's decisions as I have no idea what led them down that path.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:36

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:32

By saying sometimes it’s ok it’s basically endorsing that practice on some level.

you either think surrogacy is ok or you don’t. I could be you and know those people and I would still condemn surrogacy and not agree with what they did. There aren’t “shades” of procuring a child via another woman’s body for fuck’s sake.

I disagree.

I think there are situations where it is hugely exploitative and situations where it makes a lot of people very happy and allows someone life who would otherwise never had the chance to exist.

It would be so much easier if life were black and white, but it seldom is and antagonising increased polarisation just causes difficulty.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:35

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:32

So in this situation you’re saying a happy family should actually feel bad because there is a theoretical structure that means despite all being happy, they are actually all exploited?

You are the one here that is trying to say that a positive outcome means there is no 'exploitation' or ethical dilemma.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 17:34

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:32

So in this situation you’re saying a happy family should actually feel bad because there is a theoretical structure that means despite all being happy, they are actually all exploited?

They aren't all exploited. Some of them are the exploitors. They should feel shitty about that. The child is going to have issues regarding their creation, at some level.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:32

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:23

If you’d read my post, you’d have seen I have been very clear that I am not saying my story suggests surrogacy in general is ethically ok. I am simply pointing out that there are situations where it works well, and it is dangerous to blanket condemn it.

By saying sometimes it’s ok it’s basically endorsing that practice on some level.

you either think surrogacy is ok or you don’t. I could be you and know those people and I would still condemn surrogacy and not agree with what they did. There aren’t “shades” of procuring a child via another woman’s body for fuck’s sake.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:32

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:31

And even if my mother gave me to the richest and most loving parents in the world and I was very happy, if I was deliberately created and she carried me as part of some kind of transaction where I was then handed over to people, it doesn't remove the exploitative aspect of her pregnancy experience.

The positive emotions don't remove the ethical dilemma.

So in this situation you’re saying a happy family should actually feel bad because there is a theoretical structure that means despite all being happy, they are actually all exploited?

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:32

I agree with you OP. The women who gave birth is the mother and if a different woman supplied the egg, then she is more akin to a father of the child, who also only supplied a gamete.

The mother - is who gestated and grew the baby from her body, who the baby will feel that deep mother-baby connection to.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:31

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:28

My mother did not give me away as an infant after she had the 'experience' she wanted.

is it the giving away that bothers you?
they have been very present through the child’s life and the child is very content with their mum and their surrogate mum in their lives. I think you are being a little closed minded.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:31

And even if my mother gave me to the richest and most loving parents in the world and I was very happy, if I was deliberately created and she carried me as part of some kind of transaction where I was then handed over to people, it doesn't remove the exploitative aspect of her pregnancy experience.

The positive emotions don't remove the ethical dilemma.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:29

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:27

Actually, it is probably a case of commodification and commoditisation with the 'value' being non-fiscal but still of very high perceived value. Happy to use 'dehumanised for the purpose of a transaction' if that makes it clearer.

So you’re saying what, the child should stop enjoying life & their family (in which they include their surrogate) and start to feel dehumanised just because you refuse to believe there could be a happy outcome through surrogacy?

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 17:28

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 14:40

Is this the best response you have for the thoughtful responses and evidence supplied by posters in this thread?

"Hate"

Pot kettle 🤣

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:28

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:27

But if the child is happy, why does it matter?

again, specifically discussing this story.

to follow your line of argument: How are you not a commodity of your parents’ desire to gain something through the experience of becoming parents?

My mother did not give me away as an infant after she had the 'experience' she wanted.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:27

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:19

I’m confused who, in the situation I have recounted, is being commoditised?

Surrogate mother = chosen to help & still close to the child
child = happy adult glad to have been born
genetic parents = happy to be parents

to make someone into a commodity suggests an exchange of money or some kind of fiscal gain, which was not the case here.

To me, it sounds rather like you are saying the child in question, now an adult, shouldn’t exist.

To me that is a very dangerous thing to say.

Again, I am discussing this situation not all surrogacy.

Actually, it is probably a case of commodification and commoditisation with the 'value' being non-fiscal but still of very high perceived value. Happy to use 'dehumanised for the purpose of a transaction' if that makes it clearer.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:27

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:23

The child has been commoditised.

Just because they are happy, doesn't make them not have been commoditised. And it doesn't need to be fiscal gain. It can be any 'gain'.

The 'experience of pregnancy without the responsibility of the child created' is the 'gain' in this case.

But if the child is happy, why does it matter?

again, specifically discussing this story.

to follow your line of argument: How are you not a commodity of your parents’ desire to gain something through the experience of becoming parents?

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 17:24

EasyPeelersAreNotSatsumas · 18/04/2023 17:16

Over ten years ago I joined Mumsnet and enjoyed the healthy debates that it held.

Those respectful disagreements are no more. Now it's more like reading a transcript of PMs Question Time.

I for one find it really sad that this bunch of intelligent caring women are unable to debate such an emotive subject without insults, badgering and bullying.

As for surrogacy, I find the idea abhorrent. I do though admit to wondering how the surrogate twins born in the nineties are now. Never personally knew them, but worked with the adopted mother's sister.

yes yes we get it, it was all fields then, you were superstars.

In actuality, I was here ten years ago too, it was exactly the same. People like complained about "bullying" as if thats a thing you can even do on a discussion thread on the fucking internet, and loftily telling us that we're not doing it properly.

I'm pretty sure you recall what they were told to do then if they didn't like it?

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:23

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:19

I’m confused who, in the situation I have recounted, is being commoditised?

Surrogate mother = chosen to help & still close to the child
child = happy adult glad to have been born
genetic parents = happy to be parents

to make someone into a commodity suggests an exchange of money or some kind of fiscal gain, which was not the case here.

To me, it sounds rather like you are saying the child in question, now an adult, shouldn’t exist.

To me that is a very dangerous thing to say.

Again, I am discussing this situation not all surrogacy.

The child has been commoditised.

Just because they are happy, doesn't make them not have been commoditised. And it doesn't need to be fiscal gain. It can be any 'gain'.

The 'experience of pregnancy without the responsibility of the child created' is the 'gain' in this case.

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 17:23

User1990C · 18/04/2023 16:49

Ah, the close minded nature of Mumsnet. I've an adopted sibling whose biological mother was abusive. I'm sure the last twenty odd years pale in comparison to her "real" mother.

Surrogacy is a fine way for those unable to have children to become parents. Only the narrow minded martyr mums think otherwise.

Not true. Have you actually read the thread? P.entry of people who can’t have children, myself included, have expressed their opposition to and distaste for surrogacy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread